Yeah, but Bruce can have a conversation with Alfred without saying “No, Batman said that.”
Orion Fury
I wouldn’t be surprised if there’s a one-off where he did, though.
timemonkey
That’s because Alfred is aware there’s only one real identity. Bruce is a mask, nothing more.
Killian
That’s because Batman doesn’t disassociative identity disorder. (At least, I’m not aware of any evidence that he does.)
SgtWadeyWilson
No, he says: “Bruce Wayne said that. I didn’t” and even Alfred says things like: “Bruce Wayne has a party to attend, maybe you could learn more about this Cobblepot fellow there.”
AGV
But do they really mean it?
To me they were just playing roles
Deanatay
When Batman refers to Bruce Wayne in the third person, it’s more of a tongue-in-cheek, throwaway line, meant more for the audience than for himself. When Amber refers to AG in the third person, she’s serious.
I know, that’s subjective, but it’s how it seems to me.
thejeff
Depends on who’s writing it, of course, but I’ve always seen that take as being Batman is the real person, Bruce Wayne is just the mask. He refers to Bruce Wayne in the third person because Bruce Wayne is a role he plays.
Distinct from most superheroes, where the secret id is the real person and the mask is the hero, but also distinct from Amber because “Bruce Wayne” has no mind of his own.
It’s worth noting that those close to him, Dick & Tim in particular, often try not to let him make this distinction – calling him Bruce in private.
StClair
Different writers, and fans, have lots of different takes on this. Personally, I’m fond of the interpretation that the “real” Bruce is who we see sitting the cave in his “working clothes” but with the cowl off/down, showing his face, and with his family present. No masks, no secrets.
Eh, that was easy. “emo clown” just means a Sad Clown in an Iron Lung. From there, you just have to question whether a particular trait needs further on-screen representation. Given that they’re in an iron lung, we can safely say sexuality doesn’t need representation at this time (If you’re in an Iron Lung, I suspect you have other things on your mind.)
But what about the Nic Cage way? I bet bees would be involved.
SgtWadeyWilson
I said the fun Ghost Rider!
Wait… I also said not… so Nic Cage would be an alternative.
Orion Fury
Gotta say, always a bit weird when it comes to those reviled Marvel movies. I was a fan of both Nic Cage Ghost Riders films, and the Affleck Daredevil, though with that one the director’s cut. Fan4astic? Couldn’t even finish that one.
I enjoyed both Ghost Rider movies for reasons clearly not intended by their creators.
I was super made about the second Fantastic Four though. I was expecting a GIANT PURPLE MAN IN A HELMET BEING TREATED LIKE A SERIOUS GRITTY VILLAIN, DAMNIT
SgtWadeyWilson
I did enjoy the Ghost Rider movie as one does any bad movie. That doesn’t make him the fun Ghost Rider.
My main beef with F4 movies is that they try to cram origin stories and character delelopment for the team and Doom into one movie. Obviously each of those stories need more time to be done right.
…and this would be the second time I started my “Doom needs a solo film” rant on the internet, so I’ll quit while I still can.
The question is, is Amber lying to Ethan about how her and Danny broke up to cover up what really happened or does Amber actually believe that’s what happened?
See that’s the part that scares me. It would be better if Amber was just covering for what Amazi-Girl did, but if she truly believes it then Amazi-Girl might be hiding memories from Amber or at least part of a memory. Heck, it might have been Amazi-Girl posing as Amber who told Ethan that he was not to talk to Danny anymore after they broke up since Amber doesn’t jump on Ethan here for going against her request not to speak to Danny anymore.
(hmm, well I’m gonna have to look for the comic where she asks Ethan not to speak to Danny to see the tags, but from what I remember it said Amber so I dunno.)
I doubt Amazi-girl hid memories from Amber though. It’s very highly likely that Amber could access Amazi-girl’s memories(I know a few people who’re like that) since it seemed to be that way from the comic (I dunno, I could be reading it wrong).
But yeah, The both of them are kinda a mess right now in regard to that relationship… :\
Ethan mentioned being told that Danny was now “persona non grata”, though I don’t think that means she told Ethan not to talk to him, only that she’s not talking to him.
BBCC
Or even that she doesn’t want to talk ABOUT him or for Ethan to talk to her about him, which normally would be a reasonable request for a painful breakup. Considering how much she’s isolating herself, this concerns me though.
Bluewind
I looked up the definition
In non-diplomatic usage, referring to someone as persona non grata is to say that he or she is ostracized. Such a person is for all intents and purposes culturally shunned, so as to be figuratively non-existent.
BBCC
Yes, it does, but she could also be being colloquial – as in, referring to not wanting to bring him up. It could also mean she doesn’t want Ethan talking to him though, and he definitely seems like that might be the case, which is soooooo not okay I can’t even begin to describe it.
The Chosen One
cf Taboo, Ixnay. She’s trying not to think about it, is all.
Fart Captor
”This boyfriend is no more! He has ceased to be! He’s passed on! Bereft if life, he rests in peace! He’s shuffled off ‘is mortal coil, run down the curtain and joined the bleedin’ choir invisibile!!
THIS IS AN EX-BOYFRIEND!!”
Roborat
This thread is the last place I would expect a Monty Python reference.
Also, I’m honestly basing the memory hiding issue on what Cerberus has said on previous strips as she has personal experience with DID and all I have is a neighbor from many years ago who was not even close to integrated. From what I understand, when they are integrated they can talk to each other and share memories, but when they are not they can start doing stuff like hide memories from each other especially if an alter is scared of being destroyed. Hopefully Cerberus will see my clunky explanation and help put it better than I possibly could.
thejeff
There’s been speculation that their divide will go far enough that they won’t share memories, but there’s been no real evidence of it so far. A couple things like this that might be hints, but nothing close to definite.
Doki
Nah, not all systems work the same in regards to memory sharing, even those officially diagnosed with DID.
223 thoughts on “Amassment”
Ana Chronistic
“That’s different–that was a RANDO!”
Orion Fury
He was speaking in memes! Memes!
Mr. Random
I take exception to that.
Orion Fury
But you’re Random, not Rando. There’s a difference. You got ‘M’. Think of all those gadgets…
AnvilPro
I don’t think Batman tries to distance himself from his alter-ego as much as Amber does
Dean
Sure he does. Bruce Wayne is just the place where Batman goes to do the stuff that he absolutely can’t do as Batman.
Tnoy
Yeah, but Bruce can have a conversation with Alfred without saying “No, Batman said that.”
Orion Fury
I wouldn’t be surprised if there’s a one-off where he did, though.
timemonkey
That’s because Alfred is aware there’s only one real identity. Bruce is a mask, nothing more.
Killian
That’s because Batman doesn’t disassociative identity disorder. (At least, I’m not aware of any evidence that he does.)
SgtWadeyWilson
No, he says: “Bruce Wayne said that. I didn’t” and even Alfred says things like: “Bruce Wayne has a party to attend, maybe you could learn more about this Cobblepot fellow there.”
AGV
But do they really mean it?
To me they were just playing roles
Deanatay
When Batman refers to Bruce Wayne in the third person, it’s more of a tongue-in-cheek, throwaway line, meant more for the audience than for himself. When Amber refers to AG in the third person, she’s serious.
I know, that’s subjective, but it’s how it seems to me.
thejeff
Depends on who’s writing it, of course, but I’ve always seen that take as being Batman is the real person, Bruce Wayne is just the mask. He refers to Bruce Wayne in the third person because Bruce Wayne is a role he plays.
Distinct from most superheroes, where the secret id is the real person and the mask is the hero, but also distinct from Amber because “Bruce Wayne” has no mind of his own.
It’s worth noting that those close to him, Dick & Tim in particular, often try not to let him make this distinction – calling him Bruce in private.
StClair
Different writers, and fans, have lots of different takes on this. Personally, I’m fond of the interpretation that the “real” Bruce is who we see sitting the cave in his “working clothes” but with the cowl off/down, showing his face, and with his family present. No masks, no secrets.
StClair
* sitting in
Doctor_Who
“He thought Dreamwave handled the license better than IDW! This shall not stand!”
Orion Fury
“And you don’t even want to hear his thoughts on you Shockwave/Longarm slashfic!”
The Other Mike
“I mean, his favorite episode of the G1 cartoon was B.O.T., for crying out loud!”
Wheelpath
So many people dumb about toys, probably didn’t like new rewind cuz they don’t like MTMTE
MatthewTheLucky
Oh dear. It begins.
Orion Fury
It’ll be “Goodbye Florida” all over again.
Injuryman
Amazigirl is more about gleefully pursuing PEOPLE that make Amber angry.
Train Moblin
i never break up with anyone, it’s always my alter ego Sodomy-Sam the homosexual emo clown breaking up with them
Jess
Good grief, the last thing we need right now is more clowns.
Bluewind
My brain melted due to conjuring the image of an emo clown who could possibly be called Sodomy – Sam
Orion Fury
I just pictured a clown.
Bluewind
I pictured a clown with a sad and sinister face, monochromatic outfit and makeup, and black styled uneven hair with a giant strap on.
Orion Fury
Terrifying. Still stand by my statement though.
Train Moblin
he does that a lot
Lailah
Eh, that was easy. “emo clown” just means a Sad Clown in an Iron Lung. From there, you just have to question whether a particular trait needs further on-screen representation. Given that they’re in an iron lung, we can safely say sexuality doesn’t need representation at this time (If you’re in an Iron Lung, I suspect you have other things on your mind.)
Orion Fury
Named Mr. Frump?
Slartibeast Button, BIA
I just outsource the visualization to Randy Millholland.
Slartibeast Button, BIA
s/Millholland/Milholland/
Mr. Mendo
Can you imagine if this leads to stress eating?
“Amazi-Girl did not eat the donuts! That was Amber! Amber is weak!”
This image tickles me. ^_^
Orion Fury
And just more fuel for the fire for Amazi-Girl to hate Amber, really.
Bluewind
Agreed
SgtWadeyWilson
“Amber ate five donuts today… tonight, I train for an extra hour.”
I’m picturing a vicious cycle. (and not in the fun Ghost Rider way.)
Orion Fury
But what about the Nic Cage way? I bet bees would be involved.
SgtWadeyWilson
I said the fun Ghost Rider!
Wait… I also said not… so Nic Cage would be an alternative.
Orion Fury
Gotta say, always a bit weird when it comes to those reviled Marvel movies. I was a fan of both Nic Cage Ghost Riders films, and the Affleck Daredevil, though with that one the director’s cut. Fan4astic? Couldn’t even finish that one.
Fart Captor
I enjoyed both Ghost Rider movies for reasons clearly not intended by their creators.
I was super made about the second Fantastic Four though. I was expecting a GIANT PURPLE MAN IN A HELMET BEING TREATED LIKE A SERIOUS GRITTY VILLAIN, DAMNIT
SgtWadeyWilson
I did enjoy the Ghost Rider movie as one does any bad movie. That doesn’t make him the fun Ghost Rider.
My main beef with F4 movies is that they try to cram origin stories and character delelopment for the team and Doom into one movie. Obviously each of those stories need more time to be done right.
…and this would be the second time I started my “Doom needs a solo film” rant on the internet, so I’ll quit while I still can.
Deanatay
“Amazi-Girl does not EAT donuts.”
…
“However, she can be FED donuts.”
inqntrol
Looks like Shortpacked Ethan has returned.
Doctor_Who
He was always here, just waiting dormant in DoA!Ethan’s subconscious, ready to take control should anyone express a stupid opinion about Transformers.
Teddae
I wonder if he’s talking about Shortpacked Willis here.
Orion Fury
Headcannon till Willis bans my comments otherwise.
Lipke the Articulate
Interesting how exactly Amber’s phrasing this all.
Jason
Hmm, on the bright side, this frees up Danny to date Amber. Since they’re TOTALLY DIFFERENT PEOPLE and all.
Haven
By that logic, Danny is also free to date Ethan. After all, why would she be mad about some random guy from her comp-sci class dating her ex?
Orion Fury
Well, maybe Danny and Amber were friends, but AG doesn’t want them hanging out anymore, because she sees it as a betrayal of their, friendship?
Raen
“Yeah, who does he think he is, creator of the universe or something?”
Dean
Amber is carefully not mentioning that Amazi-Girl was the primary source of danger for Danny.
Doctor_Who
I dunno, the time he got kidnapped was because he knew Amber, not Amaz-Girl.
Orion Fury
Well that time. I think the next time was the future possibility, given his association with that vile heathen of a miscreant.
newllend(henryvolt)
Which is odd because Amazi-girl feels the same way about amber, is this still part of that self loathing issue she has.
Bluewind
The question is, is Amber lying to Ethan about how her and Danny broke up to cover up what really happened or does Amber actually believe that’s what happened?
Teddae
Coming from someone who’s familiar with dissociation, I don’t think she’s lying.
Bluewind
See that’s the part that scares me. It would be better if Amber was just covering for what Amazi-Girl did, but if she truly believes it then Amazi-Girl might be hiding memories from Amber or at least part of a memory. Heck, it might have been Amazi-Girl posing as Amber who told Ethan that he was not to talk to Danny anymore after they broke up since Amber doesn’t jump on Ethan here for going against her request not to speak to Danny anymore.
Teddae
(hmm, well I’m gonna have to look for the comic where she asks Ethan not to speak to Danny to see the tags, but from what I remember it said Amber so I dunno.)
I doubt Amazi-girl hid memories from Amber though. It’s very highly likely that Amber could access Amazi-girl’s memories(I know a few people who’re like that) since it seemed to be that way from the comic (I dunno, I could be reading it wrong).
But yeah, The both of them are kinda a mess right now in regard to that relationship… :\
Fart Captor
I think it came up when Danny talked to Ethan about the breakup.
http://www.dumbingofage.com/2016/comic/book-6/03-when-god-closes-the-door/personanongrata/
Ethan mentioned being told that Danny was now “persona non grata”, though I don’t think that means she told Ethan not to talk to him, only that she’s not talking to him.
BBCC
Or even that she doesn’t want to talk ABOUT him or for Ethan to talk to her about him, which normally would be a reasonable request for a painful breakup. Considering how much she’s isolating herself, this concerns me though.
Bluewind
I looked up the definition
In non-diplomatic usage, referring to someone as persona non grata is to say that he or she is ostracized. Such a person is for all intents and purposes culturally shunned, so as to be figuratively non-existent.
BBCC
Yes, it does, but she could also be being colloquial – as in, referring to not wanting to bring him up. It could also mean she doesn’t want Ethan talking to him though, and he definitely seems like that might be the case, which is soooooo not okay I can’t even begin to describe it.
The Chosen One
cf Taboo, Ixnay. She’s trying not to think about it, is all.
Fart Captor
”This boyfriend is no more! He has ceased to be! He’s passed on! Bereft if life, he rests in peace! He’s shuffled off ‘is mortal coil, run down the curtain and joined the bleedin’ choir invisibile!!
THIS IS AN EX-BOYFRIEND!!”
Roborat
This thread is the last place I would expect a Monty Python reference.
Slartibeast Button, BIA
No One expects the Monty Python Reference!
Bluewind
Here’s the comic
http://www.dumbingofage.com/2016/comic/book-6/03-when-god-closes-the-door/personanongrata/
Also, I’m honestly basing the memory hiding issue on what Cerberus has said on previous strips as she has personal experience with DID and all I have is a neighbor from many years ago who was not even close to integrated. From what I understand, when they are integrated they can talk to each other and share memories, but when they are not they can start doing stuff like hide memories from each other especially if an alter is scared of being destroyed. Hopefully Cerberus will see my clunky explanation and help put it better than I possibly could.
thejeff
There’s been speculation that their divide will go far enough that they won’t share memories, but there’s been no real evidence of it so far. A couple things like this that might be hints, but nothing close to definite.
Doki
Nah, not all systems work the same in regards to memory sharing, even those officially diagnosed with DID.