Question: Would this alternate universe mean that Joyce is Zuko, or would Becky be a better fit? And does that make Joe Jet?
Someone
I don’t know about the Dumbiverse, but I do feel that every member of Squad 128 has a team avatar counterpart
Walky=Aang, goofy acting hero who secretly hurts on the inside
Sal=Zuko, constantly walks the line between good and evil, before settling on good
Joyce=Katara, love interest of the hero, largest heart of the group
Jason=Sokka, has no powers but frequently fights (and wins) against those who do, acts as both the main strategist and leader of the team (before the hero matures enough to take the role as leader)
Mike=Toph, this one is kinda stretching it, but they both make fun of their teammates, although Mike would probably make Toph cry, she really has nothing on him
Commodore Jeep-Eep
Yeah… but those who make Toph cry… have unpleasant things with soil and rocks happen to them.
Given that i’ve been waiting to say this for a while, i’m just gonna leave it here now.
Kinda a double standard to get on Roz’s back for going off on joyce, when, the time they’d spoken before, joyce was openly slut shaming her. Not saying Roz was right to do it, but in her shoes, i’d have personally said a LOT worse.
they are both really self-righteous kind of passionate. except now Joyce’s worldview has been shattered and she doesn’t have a steady foundation on which to be self-righteous.
Honestly? Yeah. As well as what altalemur said. They both want to be their best self. They are both full of passion for what they believe and are not afraid to share their opinions. And both are full of empathy and care for others even if they are not aware at the time the full impact of their words.
And in some ways, Joyce is always going to bring out Roz’s worst. Not just because she slut-shamed her a lot and comes from a background that has fought tirelessly against a lot of issues she cares about. But because she’s rooming with Mary and is constantly being inundated with the worst of fundie culture and so often has reduced tolerance for Joyce’s fundier moments than most.
Well, she was also very disrespectful to Leslie, who is both her teacher and a member of the group she supposedly cares so much about defending. That might be factoring into it a tiny bit.
If I say that as a LGBT individual, I punched the air and screamed in triumph the moment Roz said ‘That was you’, does that make it okay then? I mean, Leslie, and Leslie’s desires, absolutely deserved respect. But let’s not pretend that she’s in charge of the Gay Hive Mind. That’s Neil Patrick Harris.
Rabid Rabbit
The “That was you” moment? Yeah, that was fine. Carrying on while the teacher shouts at you to be quiet? Going a little bit far. Then yelling at the teacher even after your target has run from the room, apparently in tears? You should probably start thinking about toning it down at that point.
Commodore Jeep-Eep
I can’t really fault her for any point. Because if you’re not in tears after that, you’ve not had your nose rubbed in it hard enough.
thejeff
Does that help though? Is rubbing someone’s nose in it productive?
Especially a kid who’s been immersed in it her whole childhood and who’s making those kinds of breakthroughs within weeks of being exposed to the world.
Is punishing her and making her feel even worse about it a good way to make allies? Is it something the class should encourage?
Commodore Jeep-Eep
It sorts out the twerps who turn back into reactionaries as soon as they’re vaguely challenged – the white moderates as described by King. Anyone who won’t learn would have turned out to be useless anyway.
thejeff
I’m not at all sure of that. Particularly not with someone like Joyce who really is coming face to face with reality outside of her bubble. It’s easy for open hostility to drive someone away, when they’re making those first tentative steps.
Welcome them in and challenge them more gradually and they’re more likely to stick to it.
LauraS
Sure, as long as I can also say that, as an LGBT individual, I punched the air and went “yes!!!” When Leslie shouted Roz down for talking over her in her own classroom. That is the last kind of behavior we want to encourage in allies and I don’t blame her one bit for not immediately being all buddy-buddy with Roz.
Spencer
Or in other words; it’s complicated!
At first I thought Roz was right, then I thought she was just being a self righteous jerk, then I realized it was both and the answer lied in the middle.
I think Roz is one of those who’s much more into being (self) right(eous) than actually helping anyone. The cause, and other people, only matter insofar as they allow her to claim moral superiority. In the end, it’s all about her (and her own family quarrels, and winning them).
Wanderso
Exactly what evidence do you have for that? I mean, Roz doesn’t get as much screen-time as Joyce, so she can’t have as many moments of ‘but she’s actually a good person, really!’ but there is right now, where she says outright that she’s going to try to keep things peaceful (a very low bar to clear given the circumstances, but I could see a completely amoral Roz saying ‘wish you’d said that to her after the Dean showed up’) and she gave Joyce a business card for a psychiatrist after she heard what happened (which Joyce proceeded to assume was a witch.)
Yeah, we’ve seen her out and about passing out her condoms and doing legitimate activism and we’ve seen her be supportive of Joyce trying to get her resources for the sexual assault and try and pass on support to Riley with regards to potential sexual orientations.
She cares.
She just has no tolerance for fundie culture because her roommate is Mary and as she notes here, she’s full of passion. Passion that can lead her to go overboard or put herself into unsustainable or inappropriate positions. See her rant at Joyce or her attempted political gotcha with her sister that was completely defused by the Dean.
And a large part of that isn’t that she’s a fake activist. It’s that she’s young and still learning the right balance between activism and passion and being respectful of everyone around you and their potential backgrounds. And with things like gender politics, she feels she knows everything because she’s educated herself a lot, but is having to learn humility and a realization that she’s still got a bit to go to fully grow into the person she wants to be.
Groundhoggy
When did Roz ever help Joyce with the sexual assault? I was under the impression she didn’t even know that Joyce had been assaulted at the party.
I just assumed that since Dorothy was part of the press sent to cover what happened, she intentionally left out Becky from the report so there wouldn’t be any more problems.
It isn’t clear at this point (I think) whether Becky’s housing situation has been resolved at all. It may be that her presence was downplayed by the group to prevent people from questioning what she was doing on campus in the first place.
Becky is acting almost completely unaffected by the whole thing while Joyce is visibly distressed about it. I agree that Becky deserves AT LEAST as much care attention as Joyce, but so far she hasn’t shown any indication that she WANTS that. Becky seems like she has things mostly sorted out at the moment (no idea whether she actually does, but that’s what it looks like). Joyce is acting completely different than her normal self and is obviously extremely unhappy. It makes sense that people are more worried about her right now, because she’s doing things that would worry anybody who knows her.
I think it’s mostly due to the fact that she did pretty much go through a primer when her dad took her out of school. Which Joyce helped her through. After that, she had already altered her perception of her dad, and had changed herself enough to feel comfortable.
When her dad came with the gun, it was painful to force her idea of her dad further down that slope, but easier after having been through her last week.
But Joyce didn’t really have that experience first hand.
She didn’t have the teachings she grew up with turn on her, almost violently.
The closest she got was where her parents came over, and that was her teachings turning on those that she had already been told to hate.
She didn’t have a primer for her old authority figures turning violent against her.
…
That being said, yeah, Becky should be getting some attention, but she seem to be receptive to help. She knows what happens was her dad going out of control, and that who and what she is, is natural and comfortable.
But Joyce… She’s confronting a whole new idea. That her religion can be twisted to violence.
Psychotic Mantis
‘That her religion can be twisted to violence.’
This is actually really important to consider in the long run. Yes, we know that Joyce is having a crisis of faith at the moment. As I’ve mentioned before, that’s perfectly justifiable given the rather extraneous circumstances. But think about it. If her crisis of faith doesn’t shake her off completely, it’s entirely possible that she’ll become another Ross. She may actually end up retreating FURTHER into her religion the worse her religion is revealed to be.
Think about it like this. A rat is trapped under a deck with a feral cat during a massive storm. The cat is sleeping, and the rat is terrified of the rain. The rat has three options. It could either venture out into the storm, face the threat of death, and be consumed entirely by the unknown. The rat could also just dig a small hole and sleep there in the HOPES that the feral cat doesn’t find it, and if it does, it isn’t hungry. The final option is to kill the cat using it’s (freakishly) sharp front teeth.
In that scenario, the ‘rat’ is Joyce. The ‘rain’ is the change brought about by her crisis of faith, and the ‘cat’ is her religion. Joyce will either venture out further into her fears and hope that she can overcome them, retreat further back into her religion and hope that it doesn’t turn around on her, or attempt to vanquish her religion, but in the process potentially becoming what she hated.
I look forward to seeing where this goes.
Needfuldoer
It’s far more likely that she’ll abandon the extremism than double down on it. Remember how horrified she was when she realized her mother was justifying Ross’s armed kidnapping using the same reasoning he was? Her outrage in gender studies class after learning religious organizations actively persecute LGBT people? The speech full of bible quotes she threw at her parents when they told her to stop associating with athiests, just because they found their lack of faith disturbing? She’s eyeballs-deep in a crisis of faith, but she’s still treading water. I’d be surprised if she went full Mary after all that.
Also, Joyce is a reflection of David Willis’s experiences growing up in a fundie household. We probably wouldn’t be here discussing it right now had he chosen to retreat into religion.
Void
I know your comment is insightfull and/or stuff but all I Can think about is the possibly unintentional paraphrasing of star wars.
Psychotic Mantis
You raise an excellent point on all counts. Well said.
Commodore Jeep-Eep
Not as an end point certainly; but as a temporary and alienating detour causing pain to all parties concerned? Possible.
Commodore Jeep-Eep
Doubling down I mean. Fuck threaded comment sections, they’re terrible
193 thoughts on “Behave”
Ana Chronistic
“I’m just gonna go over here and change my name to Ms. Glass, ’cause I’m so transparent”
inqntrol
“You seem transparent, but I can see you plotting something in the background.”
GoldStarz
But that would ruin a perfectly good pun.
tyersome
… this does make things panefully clear …
Nono
Hate to shatter your illusions but…
Rutee
That’s it. Glass the planet. Only way to be sure.
SgtWadeyWilson
No, not Glass! I thought Spinny blew him up! Wait… wrong comic.
Jay Eff
“While we’re at it, tell your sister to consider changing her name to Ms. Mirror. ‘Cause I wanna gaze into her all day long.
“Nope, that doesn’t sound like street harassment one bit..”
Jay Eff
The next morning, Leslie awoke to find her name had been legally changed to “Glass Joe.”
“No need to thank me,” the Legally-Renaming Fairy exclaimed as she fluttered toward the horizon.
Skai Cyan
I guess Leslie’s a French man now? I think she has a match later today.
Rowen Morland
Leslie Glass hmmm, needs a little more. Letsee Thru Glass.
blackouthart
goddammit i’m waiting for someone to make an ira glass joke since i can’t come up with a good enough one
Emperor Norton
“Hughnon reflected that ‘entirely transparent’ meant either that you could see right through them or that you couldn’t see them at all.”
Mr. Random
… She really should wear glasses. To make sure her eyes stay near her skull.
Mada
I hope this class goes well for everyone…
Oh who am I kidding.
Tacos
The day when the class goes well for everyone will end up being the day the Fire Nation attack or something >.>
Someone
Leslie: Well that was a fun class, where nothing went wrong!
Meanwhile, in an alternate universe: ALL THE AIRBENDERS ARE BURNING!
Rukduk
Question: Would this alternate universe mean that Joyce is Zuko, or would Becky be a better fit? And does that make Joe Jet?
Someone
I don’t know about the Dumbiverse, but I do feel that every member of Squad 128 has a team avatar counterpart
Walky=Aang, goofy acting hero who secretly hurts on the inside
Sal=Zuko, constantly walks the line between good and evil, before settling on good
Joyce=Katara, love interest of the hero, largest heart of the group
Jason=Sokka, has no powers but frequently fights (and wins) against those who do, acts as both the main strategist and leader of the team (before the hero matures enough to take the role as leader)
Mike=Toph, this one is kinda stretching it, but they both make fun of their teammates, although Mike would probably make Toph cry, she really has nothing on him
Commodore Jeep-Eep
Yeah… but those who make Toph cry… have unpleasant things with soil and rocks happen to them.
DarkoNeko
Well, she asked Roz to behave, not to apologize. I don’t think the current Joyce is gonna initiate any kind of conv, if she bother coming at all.
David Herbert
Damn politicians and their careers, why can’t they just show up immediately?
inqntrol
VIP-s always arrive late, don’t you know that?
gkheyf
gasp! does that mean that all electricians, movers, and plumbers are super important??
gc
Well YEAH.
inqntrol
Well, if they wear ties, I guess you can say they are important.
AeromechanicalAce
Given that i’ve been waiting to say this for a while, i’m just gonna leave it here now.
Kinda a double standard to get on Roz’s back for going off on joyce, when, the time they’d spoken before, joyce was openly slut shaming her. Not saying Roz was right to do it, but in her shoes, i’d have personally said a LOT worse.
Someone
aren’t they basically exact opposites and at the same time exactly the same.
Joyce: Conservative girl, who’s means well but sometimes has trouble understanding different viewpoints
Roz: Liberal girl, who means well but sometimes has trouble understand different viewpoints
Doctor_Who
Leslie: Sane person caught in the middle.
Watch when happens when they all move in together, Tuesdays on CBS.
tim gueguen
“Last week CBS’s new sitcom Bean There generated continued strong ratings, and expectations are that it will be given a full season order.”
altalemur
they are both really self-righteous kind of passionate. except now Joyce’s worldview has been shattered and she doesn’t have a steady foundation on which to be self-righteous.
Cerberus
Honestly? Yeah. As well as what altalemur said. They both want to be their best self. They are both full of passion for what they believe and are not afraid to share their opinions. And both are full of empathy and care for others even if they are not aware at the time the full impact of their words.
And in some ways, Joyce is always going to bring out Roz’s worst. Not just because she slut-shamed her a lot and comes from a background that has fought tirelessly against a lot of issues she cares about. But because she’s rooming with Mary and is constantly being inundated with the worst of fundie culture and so often has reduced tolerance for Joyce’s fundier moments than most.
LauraS
Well, she was also very disrespectful to Leslie, who is both her teacher and a member of the group she supposedly cares so much about defending. That might be factoring into it a tiny bit.
Wanderso
If I say that as a LGBT individual, I punched the air and screamed in triumph the moment Roz said ‘That was you’, does that make it okay then? I mean, Leslie, and Leslie’s desires, absolutely deserved respect. But let’s not pretend that she’s in charge of the Gay Hive Mind. That’s Neil Patrick Harris.
Rabid Rabbit
The “That was you” moment? Yeah, that was fine. Carrying on while the teacher shouts at you to be quiet? Going a little bit far. Then yelling at the teacher even after your target has run from the room, apparently in tears? You should probably start thinking about toning it down at that point.
Commodore Jeep-Eep
I can’t really fault her for any point. Because if you’re not in tears after that, you’ve not had your nose rubbed in it hard enough.
thejeff
Does that help though? Is rubbing someone’s nose in it productive?
Especially a kid who’s been immersed in it her whole childhood and who’s making those kinds of breakthroughs within weeks of being exposed to the world.
Is punishing her and making her feel even worse about it a good way to make allies? Is it something the class should encourage?
Commodore Jeep-Eep
It sorts out the twerps who turn back into reactionaries as soon as they’re vaguely challenged – the white moderates as described by King. Anyone who won’t learn would have turned out to be useless anyway.
thejeff
I’m not at all sure of that. Particularly not with someone like Joyce who really is coming face to face with reality outside of her bubble. It’s easy for open hostility to drive someone away, when they’re making those first tentative steps.
Welcome them in and challenge them more gradually and they’re more likely to stick to it.
LauraS
Sure, as long as I can also say that, as an LGBT individual, I punched the air and went “yes!!!” When Leslie shouted Roz down for talking over her in her own classroom. That is the last kind of behavior we want to encourage in allies and I don’t blame her one bit for not immediately being all buddy-buddy with Roz.
Spencer
Or in other words; it’s complicated!
At first I thought Roz was right, then I thought she was just being a self righteous jerk, then I realized it was both and the answer lied in the middle.
MrZombieScordo
Like the answers to almost every issue.
StClair
I think Roz is one of those who’s much more into being (self) right(eous) than actually helping anyone. The cause, and other people, only matter insofar as they allow her to claim moral superiority. In the end, it’s all about her (and her own family quarrels, and winning them).
Wanderso
Exactly what evidence do you have for that? I mean, Roz doesn’t get as much screen-time as Joyce, so she can’t have as many moments of ‘but she’s actually a good person, really!’ but there is right now, where she says outright that she’s going to try to keep things peaceful (a very low bar to clear given the circumstances, but I could see a completely amoral Roz saying ‘wish you’d said that to her after the Dean showed up’) and she gave Joyce a business card for a psychiatrist after she heard what happened (which Joyce proceeded to assume was a witch.)
Cerberus
Yeah, we’ve seen her out and about passing out her condoms and doing legitimate activism and we’ve seen her be supportive of Joyce trying to get her resources for the sexual assault and try and pass on support to Riley with regards to potential sexual orientations.
She cares.
She just has no tolerance for fundie culture because her roommate is Mary and as she notes here, she’s full of passion. Passion that can lead her to go overboard or put herself into unsustainable or inappropriate positions. See her rant at Joyce or her attempted political gotcha with her sister that was completely defused by the Dean.
And a large part of that isn’t that she’s a fake activist. It’s that she’s young and still learning the right balance between activism and passion and being respectful of everyone around you and their potential backgrounds. And with things like gender politics, she feels she knows everything because she’s educated herself a lot, but is having to learn humility and a realization that she’s still got a bit to go to fully grow into the person she wants to be.
Groundhoggy
When did Roz ever help Joyce with the sexual assault? I was under the impression she didn’t even know that Joyce had been assaulted at the party.
Lord Stoneheart
http://www.dumbingofage.com/2012/comic/book-2/03-the-first-step-towards-recovery/card-2/
Here.
Groundhoggy
Huh, guess I missed that.
invisiblemoose
You’re right, she didn’t, and she put her foot in her mouth unwittingly. But, well, there is what Stoneheart linked.
invisiblemoose
Oh, this nonsense again.
Wanderso
This. I absolutely refuse to come down harder on Roz rather than Joyce, just because Joyce’s beliefs are more prevalent.
Stephen R. Bierce
*plays Tears For Fears’ “Everybody Wants To Rule The World” on the hacked Muzak*
Doctor_Who
I can never hear that song without wanting popcorn.
JustCheetoDust
I envy you. That song leaves me with contempt for Dennis Miller.
Jay Eff
That song tends to make me think about Mojo Jojo these days.
Dana
Remind me never to find video of Dennis Miller Live in case it turns out I’m agree with you now.
StClair
“You think it’s getting too weird around here?”
“Absolutely.”
“I didn’t notice.”
“I like it.”
Captain Button
Your mother puts license plates on your underwear? How do you sit?
Just Me
Interesting. Everyone seems to know about Joyce and what happened.
Funny that it was Becky who abducted at gunpoint, not Joyce.
There is something slightly off kilter about this set up.
Tacos
I just assumed that since Dorothy was part of the press sent to cover what happened, she intentionally left out Becky from the report so there wouldn’t be any more problems.
Skizz
That doesn’t seem likely. Also unethical and unneeded.
Emma
I assumed Joyce was mentioned and Becky was left unnamed.
invisiblemoose
There’s also the fact that this is a campus, and gossip could easily spread like wildfire.
DinaWho
It isn’t clear at this point (I think) whether Becky’s housing situation has been resolved at all. It may be that her presence was downplayed by the group to prevent people from questioning what she was doing on campus in the first place.
Wublub
Becky is acting almost completely unaffected by the whole thing while Joyce is visibly distressed about it. I agree that Becky deserves AT LEAST as much care attention as Joyce, but so far she hasn’t shown any indication that she WANTS that. Becky seems like she has things mostly sorted out at the moment (no idea whether she actually does, but that’s what it looks like). Joyce is acting completely different than her normal self and is obviously extremely unhappy. It makes sense that people are more worried about her right now, because she’s doing things that would worry anybody who knows her.
Mr. Random
I think it’s mostly due to the fact that she did pretty much go through a primer when her dad took her out of school. Which Joyce helped her through. After that, she had already altered her perception of her dad, and had changed herself enough to feel comfortable.
When her dad came with the gun, it was painful to force her idea of her dad further down that slope, but easier after having been through her last week.
But Joyce didn’t really have that experience first hand.
She didn’t have the teachings she grew up with turn on her, almost violently.
The closest she got was where her parents came over, and that was her teachings turning on those that she had already been told to hate.
She didn’t have a primer for her old authority figures turning violent against her.
…
That being said, yeah, Becky should be getting some attention, but she seem to be receptive to help. She knows what happens was her dad going out of control, and that who and what she is, is natural and comfortable.
But Joyce… She’s confronting a whole new idea. That her religion can be twisted to violence.
Psychotic Mantis
‘That her religion can be twisted to violence.’
This is actually really important to consider in the long run. Yes, we know that Joyce is having a crisis of faith at the moment. As I’ve mentioned before, that’s perfectly justifiable given the rather extraneous circumstances. But think about it. If her crisis of faith doesn’t shake her off completely, it’s entirely possible that she’ll become another Ross. She may actually end up retreating FURTHER into her religion the worse her religion is revealed to be.
Think about it like this. A rat is trapped under a deck with a feral cat during a massive storm. The cat is sleeping, and the rat is terrified of the rain. The rat has three options. It could either venture out into the storm, face the threat of death, and be consumed entirely by the unknown. The rat could also just dig a small hole and sleep there in the HOPES that the feral cat doesn’t find it, and if it does, it isn’t hungry. The final option is to kill the cat using it’s (freakishly) sharp front teeth.
In that scenario, the ‘rat’ is Joyce. The ‘rain’ is the change brought about by her crisis of faith, and the ‘cat’ is her religion. Joyce will either venture out further into her fears and hope that she can overcome them, retreat further back into her religion and hope that it doesn’t turn around on her, or attempt to vanquish her religion, but in the process potentially becoming what she hated.
I look forward to seeing where this goes.
Needfuldoer
It’s far more likely that she’ll abandon the extremism than double down on it. Remember how horrified she was when she realized her mother was justifying Ross’s armed kidnapping using the same reasoning he was? Her outrage in gender studies class after learning religious organizations actively persecute LGBT people? The speech full of bible quotes she threw at her parents when they told her to stop associating with athiests, just because they found their lack of faith disturbing? She’s eyeballs-deep in a crisis of faith, but she’s still treading water. I’d be surprised if she went full Mary after all that.
Also, Joyce is a reflection of David Willis’s experiences growing up in a fundie household. We probably wouldn’t be here discussing it right now had he chosen to retreat into religion.
Void
I know your comment is insightfull and/or stuff but all I Can think about is the possibly unintentional paraphrasing of star wars.
Psychotic Mantis
You raise an excellent point on all counts. Well said.
Commodore Jeep-Eep
Not as an end point certainly; but as a temporary and alienating detour causing pain to all parties concerned? Possible.
Commodore Jeep-Eep
Doubling down I mean. Fuck threaded comment sections, they’re terrible