I can see that, I’m more curious as to when it happened.
Could really be anywhere between a day ago and immediately after the day they broke into Becky’s old home together
Thag Simmons
But it kind of sounds like Joss knows Dina? Did they have an offscreen adventure we didn’t get to see?
RassilonTDavros
I’m just gonna file that under “places Dina and Charlie went during their reality-bending escapades last storyline”.
Michael Steamweed
Headcanon accepted.
Charlie and Dina did their quantum-wave-collapse thing, ended up at Jocelyne’s home, and they all talked and hit it off nicely. Thankfully, Jocelyne’s mother wasn’t home.
not someone else
I think it was in fact during the home break-in but I don’t have links to it.
It’s not entirely clear. I’m guessing she didn’t know yet the last time she and Joss shared panel time, when the trio broke into Becky’s house, but I could see her finding out at basically any point after that.
Dina knows because she was secretly in the room the whole time and heard everything.
Joss did accept Becky as her ‘poopface new sister’ so it’s really sweet to see that Joss took that to heart and even came out to her already! Adorable.
I agree, and I think Becky took place in line before Joyce because Becky has had to come out too, and Joyce was still going through a lot of learning. Kinda like Joyce asked Ethan, sometimes having similar experiences is what people need to come out or begin talking about changes.
I now want a buddy cop movie with Becky and Dina. They would not be good at being cops and would likely somehow destroy the system, but I still want the movie.
Six if you count the TV show with Riggs, and then with Cole. They really should have kept that going with Seann William Scott and Maggie Lawson in the cast – it kept getting better.
I feel tremendous relief. I wasn’t expecting Becky to be shitty or anything, but I mean, glad she ISN’T.
I do hope that Joyce doesn’t take this as Joss saying she CAN’T keep a secret, I just imagine Joss knew it was going to be tougher for her to come out to Joyce, same as Ethan knowing first (of this group) isn’t an indictment of Joyce, either.
And Jocelyne gets to tell her little sister in front of Joe and Becky why taking photos like that and having them uploaded to the cloud automatically because everyone’s phones do by default these days is a bad idea, because you don’t know what the recipient’s default setting is…
thejeff
I’d say the recipient is still far more of a threat than them just being on the cloud. Photos are far more likely to be spread deliberately by the person you sent them to (maybe after a breakup) than hacked off the cloud.
Or in Joyce’s case, since she already sent them to the wrong person, that wrong person could have been far worse than Dorothy.
It’s likely to FEEL shitty to Joyce though. ‘Literally everyone knew already except me, and you’re only telling me because you thought Dad was about to, not because you actually wanted me to know. Thanks for the love and trust, favorite sib.’
And that’s the sort of thing that Becky is, historically, going to be shitty about. Because she likes making Joyce upset because she enjoys the facial expressions of traumatized/upset Joyce.
Mark
Or because it’s the surest, fastest way to get Joyce’s undivided attention.
It is interesting that Joyce seems to recognize that something’s going on with Dorothy and her stated desire to transfer to an Ivy League College, even though she’s been kept in the dark about the specifics.
Yeah, my entire comment was ‘oof, poor Joyce’. Pretty much everyone got to know but her, and apparently Jocelyne’s only telling her because she thinks their dad is about to.
I mean, of course Jocelyne gets to come out in her own way and time but still… it’s got to sting for Joyce to be the person least trusted/respected in her favorite sib’s sphere. And for Becky to be keeping yet more secrets.
To be fair, she’s grown a lot in a relatively short time. August/September Joyce absolutely would have gone running to Carol if she found out.
anonymsly
As Jocelyne was actually present to witness both Joyce’s willingness to oppose their parents AND Joyce’s full-throated and absolute support of Becky, claiming that Jocelyne could have reasonably thought that Joyce was still a total fundie robot even as late as early October feels very odd to me.
Nymph
Two actions versus the entirety of a lifetime of knowing someone, no matter how strong the actions were, doesn’t always help the deep anxiety of being disowned or harmed by coming out to the wrong people. Jocelyne could reasonably assume Joyce wasn’t safe even now, because plenty of people are unsafe. Even when they seem to be safe.
thejeff
But even her last line “Becky is trustworthy and can keep a secret”
Implying that Joyce is not trustworthy.
Needfuldoer
For Becky growing up, keeping a big secret was a matter of survival.
Joyce was an open book by comparison.
thejeff
Sure, it’s true.
But having your sister say you’re not trustworthy has got be at least a twinge.
LamnaDitropis
I agree that it might emotionally sting for Joyce that Jocelyne told others first, but it does make sense that Jocelyne would be nervous about telling Joyce. While Joyce has made progress, it can be hard for Jocelyne to assess how much, especially since tolerance of gay people (like Becky) does not necessarily mean tolerance of transgender people. Becky is LGBTQ+ herself (and went through difficult things as a result) and she is not Jocelyne’s little sister. Jocelyne probably felt more confident that Becky would accept her, and she may have been much more afraid of Joyce’s rejection than Becky’s rejection. Also as Joyce demonstrated in the previous strip, she can have a rigid view about how things should be (in the previous strip it was about the colour of picture bible Jesus’ sash) and perhaps Jocelyne was also concerned she might not handle a change well.
It’s honestly a weird mix of sarcasm and not sarcasm. Becky does act like a loose cannon, so it can be literal, and it can be figurative because the act is just that, and becky actually does strategically withhold information.
Clif
Becky can be a loose cannon and Dina is both perceptive and perspicuous.
Needfuldoer
Unfortunately for Becky, withholding information was a survival strategy for the longest time. Never forget, she’s the one who regularly broke out of her house overnight.
Ed Callahan
Well, she snuck out when her parents weren’t looking. But what I wonder about is what was she sneaking out to do, and with whom? It certainly wasn’t to get up to mischief with Joyce, or this would be a different strip.
Well, no, actually. Dina is blunt if asked for an opinion. She normally doesn’t engage with most people beyond what she sees as an appropriate level of surface politeness, since she finds them confusing. But if someone wants to know how she feels, there’s no truth shading involved.
178 thoughts on “Beholden”
Ana Chronistic
then it turns out that Joss’s apartment is one of the places where Dina and Charlie ended up, and it just went from there
NGPZ
Dina AND Jocelyne??!?!??! DINA AND JOCELYNE?!?!
STIMMING SO MUCH EEEEEEEEEK!!!!! ^^ <3
*plays “Welcome to Jurassic Park” on hacked muzak*
Needfuldoer
The world wasn’t ready for this.
DJTsurugi
oh shit this is not a drill, we’re getting Dina AND Jocelyne! ~<3
Yeet
wonder how mad joyce is gonna be about people knowing before she did
Nono
Well there’s still Ethan to go.
Random832
Ultimately she has all the information she needs to realize that Ethan knew.
Once she thinks to recontextualize that conversation.
Charles Phipps
But what happens when Joyce tries to introduce Jocelyn to her other sister, Carla?
Bryy
….. oh no.
ktbear
Oh yes!
Decidedly Orthogonal
Welcome to tomorrow. It’s not too bad.
Thag Simmons
Wait, since when has Becky known?
Sirksome
Before Joyce did apparently.
Thag Simmons
I can see that, I’m more curious as to when it happened.
Could really be anywhere between a day ago and immediately after the day they broke into Becky’s old home together
Thag Simmons
But it kind of sounds like Joss knows Dina? Did they have an offscreen adventure we didn’t get to see?
RassilonTDavros
I’m just gonna file that under “places Dina and Charlie went during their reality-bending escapades last storyline”.
Michael Steamweed
Headcanon accepted.
Charlie and Dina did their quantum-wave-collapse thing, ended up at Jocelyne’s home, and they all talked and hit it off nicely. Thankfully, Jocelyne’s mother wasn’t home.
not someone else
I think it was in fact during the home break-in but I don’t have links to it.
Ana Chronistic
Jocelyne and Becky have met for the diner/break-in
Dina wasn’t there
Yumi
Since that one Tuesday.
HueSatLight
Just guessing, but maybe shortly after https://www.dumbingofage.com/scanner/
Thag Simmons
That would make a lot of sense actually
ValdVin
Joyce will have to change that phone contact from Big Brother #2.
RassilonTDavros
It’s not entirely clear. I’m guessing she didn’t know yet the last time she and Joss shared panel time, when the trio broke into Becky’s house, but I could see her finding out at basically any point after that.
Dina knows because she was secretly in the room the whole time and heard everything.
Envy
I’m guessing Jocelyn came out to her off-screen to get advice about how Joyce would react.
thejeff
Could be as simple as Becky answered her phone when Jocelyne called, unlike Joyce. 🙂
Probably with Dina in the room.
Sirksome
This feels like how Joyce knew who Liz was for months before Sarah knew Joyce was aware she even had a sister.
Jonah (firelight_waltz)
Becky MacIntyre: Super Suave
Pergola
Finger guns.
Doopyboop
Joss did accept Becky as her ‘poopface new sister’ so it’s really sweet to see that Joss took that to heart and even came out to her already! Adorable.
pope suburban
I agree, and I think Becky took place in line before Joyce because Becky has had to come out too, and Joyce was still going through a lot of learning. Kinda like Joyce asked Ethan, sometimes having similar experiences is what people need to come out or begin talking about changes.
IntangibleMatter
I now want a buddy cop movie with Becky and Dina. They would not be good at being cops and would likely somehow destroy the system, but I still want the movie.
Darkseide
so a variant of Lethal Weapon
Ed Callahan
Which one? There’s four choices.
Shadowsnail
Six if you count the TV show with Riggs, and then with Cole. They really should have kept that going with Seann William Scott and Maggie Lawson in the cast – it kept getting better.
Michael Steamweed
The neuro-queer buddy cop movie we all need.
Opus the Poet
+1!
DailyBrad
I feel tremendous relief. I wasn’t expecting Becky to be shitty or anything, but I mean, glad she ISN’T.
I do hope that Joyce doesn’t take this as Joss saying she CAN’T keep a secret, I just imagine Joss knew it was going to be tougher for her to come out to Joyce, same as Ethan knowing first (of this group) isn’t an indictment of Joyce, either.
Clif
Don’t feel too much relief yet. Becky is now on hand for when Joyce receives the pix.
Miri
Pffft… Bwahahahahaahahaha!
And Jocelyne gets to tell her little sister in front of Joe and Becky why taking photos like that and having them uploaded to the cloud automatically because everyone’s phones do by default these days is a bad idea, because you don’t know what the recipient’s default setting is…
thejeff
I’d say the recipient is still far more of a threat than them just being on the cloud. Photos are far more likely to be spread deliberately by the person you sent them to (maybe after a breakup) than hacked off the cloud.
Or in Joyce’s case, since she already sent them to the wrong person, that wrong person could have been far worse than Dorothy.
anonymsly
It’s likely to FEEL shitty to Joyce though. ‘Literally everyone knew already except me, and you’re only telling me because you thought Dad was about to, not because you actually wanted me to know. Thanks for the love and trust, favorite sib.’
anonymsly
And that’s the sort of thing that Becky is, historically, going to be shitty about. Because she likes making Joyce upset because she enjoys the facial expressions of traumatized/upset Joyce.
Mark
Or because it’s the surest, fastest way to get Joyce’s undivided attention.
Kyrik Michalowski
Oh dear, Joyce is feeling the guilt of making characters based on your friends.
People change every day,, so trying to keep up in real time with someone can be difficult.
Also, I’m happy Jocelyne is naturally fitting in with this group, and that she can finally be the older sister she wants to be. Can you ask for more?
Wraithy2773
It is interesting that Joyce seems to recognize that something’s going on with Dorothy and her stated desire to transfer to an Ivy League College, even though she’s been kept in the dark about the specifics.
Kyrik Michalowski
Wasn’t Joyce there when raidah was being an asshole to Dorothy about being president?
Also, Dorothy has stopped talking about it, and it is possibly why Joyce is realizing something is wrong.
Jeremiah
No that was Walky.
Tan
Dorothy explicitly told Joyce already. https://www.dumbingofage.com/2024/comic/book-14/03-trystin-in-the-wind/miscreants/
Wraithy2773
derp, i are a dummy.
Then again, they were both like three sheets to the wind at that point, entirely possible they both forgot? >_>
Mr. Random
I mean… that’s gonna sting a… well, a lot.
anonymsly
Yeah, my entire comment was ‘oof, poor Joyce’. Pretty much everyone got to know but her, and apparently Jocelyne’s only telling her because she thinks their dad is about to.
I mean, of course Jocelyne gets to come out in her own way and time but still… it’s got to sting for Joyce to be the person least trusted/respected in her favorite sib’s sphere. And for Becky to be keeping yet more secrets.
Needfuldoer
To be fair, she’s grown a lot in a relatively short time. August/September Joyce absolutely would have gone running to Carol if she found out.
anonymsly
As Jocelyne was actually present to witness both Joyce’s willingness to oppose their parents AND Joyce’s full-throated and absolute support of Becky, claiming that Jocelyne could have reasonably thought that Joyce was still a total fundie robot even as late as early October feels very odd to me.
Nymph
Two actions versus the entirety of a lifetime of knowing someone, no matter how strong the actions were, doesn’t always help the deep anxiety of being disowned or harmed by coming out to the wrong people. Jocelyne could reasonably assume Joyce wasn’t safe even now, because plenty of people are unsafe. Even when they seem to be safe.
thejeff
But even her last line “Becky is trustworthy and can keep a secret”
Implying that Joyce is not trustworthy.
Needfuldoer
For Becky growing up, keeping a big secret was a matter of survival.
Joyce was an open book by comparison.
thejeff
Sure, it’s true.
But having your sister say you’re not trustworthy has got be at least a twinge.
LamnaDitropis
I agree that it might emotionally sting for Joyce that Jocelyne told others first, but it does make sense that Jocelyne would be nervous about telling Joyce. While Joyce has made progress, it can be hard for Jocelyne to assess how much, especially since tolerance of gay people (like Becky) does not necessarily mean tolerance of transgender people. Becky is LGBTQ+ herself (and went through difficult things as a result) and she is not Jocelyne’s little sister. Jocelyne probably felt more confident that Becky would accept her, and she may have been much more afraid of Joyce’s rejection than Becky’s rejection. Also as Joyce demonstrated in the previous strip, she can have a rigid view about how things should be (in the previous strip it was about the colour of picture bible Jesus’ sash) and perhaps Jocelyne was also concerned she might not handle a change well.
Frelance
dense comic! this is characterization for, like, half the cast!
Clif
And a situational set-up besides.
Opus the Poet
Dina is the soul of discression.
Opus the Poet
*discretion
StClair
I feel like she’s… let’s say, shading the truth, to support Becky, and I wonder if it caused her distress. Even though it was for love.
Davus
It’s honestly a weird mix of sarcasm and not sarcasm. Becky does act like a loose cannon, so it can be literal, and it can be figurative because the act is just that, and becky actually does strategically withhold information.
Clif
Becky can be a loose cannon and Dina is both perceptive and perspicuous.
Needfuldoer
Unfortunately for Becky, withholding information was a survival strategy for the longest time. Never forget, she’s the one who regularly broke out of her house overnight.
Ed Callahan
Well, she snuck out when her parents weren’t looking. But what I wonder about is what was she sneaking out to do, and with whom? It certainly wasn’t to get up to mischief with Joyce, or this would be a different strip.
Ed Callahan
Well, no, actually. Dina is blunt if asked for an opinion. She normally doesn’t engage with most people beyond what she sees as an appropriate level of surface politeness, since she finds them confusing. But if someone wants to know how she feels, there’s no truth shading involved.
Laura
Dina is the soul of digression.
…Especially about dinosaurs!
not someone else