Well I assume first you’d need to like gingerbread, which isn’t that hard last I checked. Then a bunch of random stimuli that lead to a craving. (Example stimuli: not having had it in awhile, smelling it, hearing it; its component words; or even just similar words, building a house, men in ovens, gumdrop buttons, being chased by a mob, being tricked by a fox.)
Heavensrun
(“…men in ovens…”) OдO
SgtWadeyWilson
I had begun to think nobody was reading that. Honestly, your avatar’s expression alone gets the sentiment across quite nicely.
She can sign the Miranda rights to hearing impaired criminals and perhaps “Yak Back” type of device for the criminals who can hear.
Butterscotch
There is a lot more to being a police officer and a lot of it involves being able to direct people around and use of a radio.
GenericScreenName101
Such as community policing, investigations, directing traffic, security posts. Yes there is a lot more to policing but being unable to speak is an easy accommodation to make for an aspiring law enforcement officer.
Butterscotch
The amount of liability the police force would have would far outweigh any ‘easy accommodation’. I feel bad for her, it’s like a blind guy who wants to be a pilot. It wouldn’t happen.
zoelogical
idk the police seem to be managing all the liabilities from these cops who kill black civilians, they should be able to manage Marcie’s handicap just fine
Yeah, for beat cops, but I can definitely see a mute police officer serving as a special interpreter for deaf or mute witnesses, suspects, or victims, doing crime scene investigation, working forensics, working in the lab, and so on.
Not all police officers are beat cops.
Butterscotch
They all start as beat cops though. You still need to be able to talk. She at best will be able to be some sort of professional within a precinct but she wouldn’t be a cop.
GenericScreenName101
Assuming DoA has comparable & contemporary technology as real life. There is other methods for Marcie to communicate without using her voice. Just as you can reply to my comment and I can reply to your comment without hearing each other’s voice.
Butterscotch
That is hardly a fair comparison.
GenericScreenName101
I Stephen Hawkings can make speaches at TED Talks, I don’t see how Marcie cannot have a text to speech software available to her when she would be on the beat.
Butterscotch
So she’s walking around with a computer, speakers, extra equipment to keep it running for the duration of a shift, along with her gear. This equipment is expensive (if it wasn’t, she’d have it) and likely not friendly to what a normal police officer has to go through.
It’s still not a fair comparison. Hawkings is in a very controlled environment when he uses his equipment. Marcie won’t be.
GenericScreenName101
The speaker from her radio could double as a speaker for the text to speech software. The computer could be a program on her smart phone. Where many people today type complete and concise messages every day. But good point on Marcie not owning a cell phone. I hadn’t noticed that before.
I have text-to-speech on my cheapy Android phone I got when I changed carriers. It’s not even that big an app compared to the voice command function.
ischemgeek
Cell phones exist.
AAC apps are cheap or free depending on the app.
It would literally cost no more than the cost of the app and maybe an external battery for Marcie to have access to AAC on-hand all the time.
Autistic people who are nonverbal and use AAC in their day-to-day lives exist. People with speech impediments who find AAC helpful in communication exist, as well. AAC users in general have found many ways to make the tech both easy to use and portable.
(Part-time AAC user here – use it when my stutter gets too hard to talk through, mainly)
FireSTK
No no no no Stephen Hawking’s TED talks speech required a lot of preparation on his part. He spends an incredibly long time writing his speeches and any kind of questions are prereviewed so he can answer in a quick way. The fact that he can speak in any form is amazing but the technology isn’t there yet.
ischemgeek
@FireSTK, Marcie has several advantages for speedy AAC use over Hawking – she’s ambulatory and can use her hands. In that respect she’s more like a me than a Hawking, and I often have times where I can speak much faster by typing than by vocalization.
It’s not quite as fast as speaking aloud when I’m relatively fluent, but at the same time, I on average type no more slowly than a Southern USian speaks.
Tomas
All this talk of technological fixes and no one mentions police whistles?
FireSTK
@ischemgeek, I understand that. I’m only talking about how Stephen Hawking talks. But now that we’re back to it, Marcie would be at a severe disadvantage not being able to effectively communicate if her hands are occupied.
@Tomas. Great point. Whistles are very effective for drawing attention, especially for hand signals, and possibly breaking up hostile situations. But the question is still effective communication past that point.
Did they ever say why Marcie can’t speak? The page bio just says that she lost the ability as a child. The closet possibilities I can find are aphasia or dysarthria but these are apparently treatable.
Not really. They don’t make Forensics Investigators walk the street as a beat cops. Nor their interpreters.
Dean
Forensics investigators mostly need college degrees, I think.
Butterscotch
Forensics either begin their careers as cops (and typical requirement for advancement within the agency is 5 years on the street. Varies from State to State), or never are cops in the first place but part of the department through an outside hire.
So, yes, a lot of them do work as regular police officers before they advance within the ranks. One of my friends is doing exactly that.
That being said, I doubt any of this applies to Marcie, who is working two jobs at the moment and hasn’t been shown in school. Nobody is become a forensic investigator off the street with no degree in the field.
Andy
They actually don’t. I’m a professional mapmaker, and when I was looking for a job, about half my job applications were to police departments. I’ve never been a cop or anything like.
Butterscotch
This doesn’t apply to Marcie.
WaytoomanyUIDs
@Butterscotch
Someone who is comfined to a wheelchair is a rather bad comparison to Marcie. As others have noted there is cheap & free cellphone software that will fulfill most or all of her needs.
Hawkings uses that rather complex setup because he likes it, even though the software is old & hardware is obsolete and hard to replace. Not because its the only option, there are several other more compact and less complex systems he could use. Allegedly, he likes sounding like a dalek.
WaytoomanyUIDs
Oops, Not only did I reply to wrong comment, but it wasn’t even you who brought up Hawkings.
Sorry
Fart Captor
The ability to communicate verbally isn’t the only issue there. I’m not aware of any device which would not require at least one hand free in order to input what she wants to say. This means if she ever had to draw her weapon, issuing orders to the person she was pointing it at would be difficult if possible at all. That makes the situation much more dangerous for both her and the suspect.
That may not exclude her from roles where she’d need to carry a gun, but it would take many options off the table
HMRC4EVR
She could go right into the forensic sciences. Even Barry Allen was a CSI guy before he became the Flash.
Hell for all we know Marcie could be the next Quincy!
Tomas
Or the next Dexter.
thejeff
All of which requires not just college, but graduate work. For whatever reason, that doesn’t seem to be in Marcie’s plans. At least in the short term.
well there is always paper work and training of other cops to do things. you don’t need to talk to be the one who sprays people with pepper spray so they know what it feels like before becoming cops
A buddy of mine tells me that some of his colleagues lost the paperwork stating that they’d done that.
We had a few laughs. Schadenfreud: the best freud.
miados
you forgot an e at the end of schadenfreude. I guess we should get all the paper work out and make sure there are no further errors before turning it into the boss. I’ll put on the coffee.
In this thread: A bunch of people talking about how a mute person shouldn’t/can’t be a police officer like that kind of discrimination is alright in this day and age.
There are plenty of things one can do for the police force that would not require a voice. And if you really don’t think allowances are made for those with different strengths and weaknesses you’re naive.
I can’t understand this line of thinking where it’s okay to talk about what a bad cop she’d be because she lacks a voice, but if it was some jerk here talking about how someone couldn’t do something because they were gay/fat/female/male/tall/short/black/physically disabled instead of ‘mute’ which is less often encountered, you’d be all over them.
If she wants to be a cop, then she could work her lil ass off and be a cop. Mute doesn’t mean inept.
There are certain implicit requirements to every job. Many people, on first thought, would think that the (very broad) job descriptor of ‘cop’ would pretty much require the ability to audibly speak to others. The technology to get around that is available, yes, but most people either don’t know that or think it’s not easily applied to the situations a cop might find themselves in.
Your comparison is flawed as well; in your list of generally irrelevant descriptors you include ‘fat’ and ‘physically disabled’. Both terms are sufficiently broad that, combined with the wide variety of things a cop could be doing, your argument technically holds. However, on the subject of beat cop (which is what most people I’ve seen are talking about, and likely the only thing that pops into most people’s mind by the word cop) either one would be sufficient to disqualify – a beat cop must be physically fit. End of story.
trlkly
And those people who think “beat cop” when they are thinking about the police are factually wrong, and thus it’s okay to bring it up. To think that shows ignorance of what the police are.
If you’re going to say something that could be discriminatory, it’s in your best interest to make sure it isn’t. It takes two seconds of thought to realize that there are other types of cops that Marcie could be.
If you don’t think about that, people may interpret what you say as bigoted, and it’s not easy to fix that. Better to not allow it in the first place by actually thinking about what you type before you type it.
(And, no, I don’t think anyone here knows so little about cops that they think that the only type of cop is the beat cop. They’ve at least seen TV shows with detectives.)
thejeff
But as far as I know, the usual route to detective starts with the Police Academy and goes through beat Cop. (Not that most actually walk beats these days, but that’s another rant.)
Same for most other jobs I’m aware of. Some technical ones may bypass it, but they require degrees.
Thank you for writing this. My thoughts exactly. G also think Sal’s tone with Marcie is incredibly hostile, even though I’m sure Sal is totes correct about Robin.
Jobs involving the safety of the public have a minimum standard you need to meet. This isn’t discrimination, it’s reality. You can attack my character all you want, but it doesn’t change the fact you need to be able to speak to be a police officer. I’d be very pleased to find out I’m wrong, trust me.
trlkly
No one attacked your character. And you just ignored everything the person said who you were responded to. Instead, you decided to make it all about you and repeat the stuff that had already been refuted.
Reality is that every possible accommodation has to be made for those with disabilities. Reality is that she can be a cop. She just can’t do the jobs that require the ability to talk to the general public at a moment’s notice.
Most police jobs do not actually involve that, so she can definitely be a police officer. And if you really would love to hear this, you’d listen to this instead of making it about how someone dared point out that something you said had bigoted implications.
The response to someone saying something you said is bigoted is to apologize. Not to double down. That’s when your character may be questioned.
Butterscotch
“She just can’t do the jobs that require the ability to talk to the general public at a moment’s notice.”
Which is almost all of them. You don’t apply to be a police officer and skip the academy/training/etc. I’m not apologizing for being ‘bigoted’ because I didn’t say anything to warrant the accusation. You’re using it as a buzzterm to diffuse the actual argument.
Sadly, I did look around to see if it is possible for a mute person to be a police officer and all I found was instances of them shooting deaf/mute people.
But, again, attack me, don’t attack the argument. Very mature.
thejeff
Yeah, I did the same search. Scary and depressing as hell.
373 thoughts on “Cadet”
miados
nice to have a job where people can talk with you.
TheAnonymousGuy
yea, now we just need decent conversation
miados
look over there a distraction
*runs from the conversation*
Oberon
It looks ot me as if someone doesn’t think that it’s all that nice at all.
Moblin Umbrella
Marcie looks kinda like she works at walmart in this
Doctor_Who
Maybe that’s why they hang out there.
inqntrol
And get booze.
AnvilPro
Let’s play “Where’s Leslie?”
Cheshrin
To the left of the pink shirt guy in the back of the first panel, blonde w/ blue shirt, hiding her face behind the sign.
So, what’s the prize, do I get a cookie? Because I’ve been craving gingerbread all freakin’ day and I could not tell you why.
SlipcasedAnt2
How. The. Fuck. Even.
SgtWadeyWilson
Well I assume first you’d need to like gingerbread, which isn’t that hard last I checked. Then a bunch of random stimuli that lead to a craving. (Example stimuli: not having had it in awhile, smelling it, hearing it; its component words; or even just similar words, building a house, men in ovens, gumdrop buttons, being chased by a mob, being tricked by a fox.)
Heavensrun
(“…men in ovens…”) OдO
SgtWadeyWilson
I had begun to think nobody was reading that. Honestly, your avatar’s expression alone gets the sentiment across quite nicely.
Disloyal Subject
Would you prefer children?
HMRC4EVR
The prize is an old Marvel ‘No Prize’. You don’t get a prize for finding it, other than the fame from getting your letter published for finding it.
Woobie
I bet an old No-Prize would be worth money on eBay now.
Needfuldoer
She needs more doppelgangers to make this a real challenge.
Carms
Oh also is that the student newspaper woman who hits on billy occasionally? Just behind and to right (ours) of the sign waving trio in blue?
Fart Captor
Yeah, that’s Daisy
Butterscotch
A cop who can’t talk? That doesn’t seem like it would work.
Undrave
She wouldn’t be able to yell ‘FREEZE!’ or read the perps their rights… Also how is she suppose to call for backup?!
Butterscotch
She wouldn’t be able to give instructions. Be it to criminals, civilians, her colleagues, and everything in between. That’s a lot of liability.
GenericScreenName101
She can sign the Miranda rights to hearing impaired criminals and perhaps “Yak Back” type of device for the criminals who can hear.
Butterscotch
There is a lot more to being a police officer and a lot of it involves being able to direct people around and use of a radio.
GenericScreenName101
Such as community policing, investigations, directing traffic, security posts. Yes there is a lot more to policing but being unable to speak is an easy accommodation to make for an aspiring law enforcement officer.
Butterscotch
The amount of liability the police force would have would far outweigh any ‘easy accommodation’. I feel bad for her, it’s like a blind guy who wants to be a pilot. It wouldn’t happen.
zoelogical
idk the police seem to be managing all the liabilities from these cops who kill black civilians, they should be able to manage Marcie’s handicap just fine
TheGrammarLegionary
*shots fired*
… I’m an asshole…
N0083rP00F
You got em in the end [that’s’ gotta hurt]
Woobie
Police are civilians, too.
And often black.
Cerberus
Yeah, for beat cops, but I can definitely see a mute police officer serving as a special interpreter for deaf or mute witnesses, suspects, or victims, doing crime scene investigation, working forensics, working in the lab, and so on.
Not all police officers are beat cops.
Butterscotch
They all start as beat cops though. You still need to be able to talk. She at best will be able to be some sort of professional within a precinct but she wouldn’t be a cop.
GenericScreenName101
Assuming DoA has comparable & contemporary technology as real life. There is other methods for Marcie to communicate without using her voice. Just as you can reply to my comment and I can reply to your comment without hearing each other’s voice.
Butterscotch
That is hardly a fair comparison.
GenericScreenName101
I Stephen Hawkings can make speaches at TED Talks, I don’t see how Marcie cannot have a text to speech software available to her when she would be on the beat.
Butterscotch
So she’s walking around with a computer, speakers, extra equipment to keep it running for the duration of a shift, along with her gear. This equipment is expensive (if it wasn’t, she’d have it) and likely not friendly to what a normal police officer has to go through.
It’s still not a fair comparison. Hawkings is in a very controlled environment when he uses his equipment. Marcie won’t be.
GenericScreenName101
The speaker from her radio could double as a speaker for the text to speech software. The computer could be a program on her smart phone. Where many people today type complete and concise messages every day. But good point on Marcie not owning a cell phone. I hadn’t noticed that before.
Opus the Poet
I have text-to-speech on my cheapy Android phone I got when I changed carriers. It’s not even that big an app compared to the voice command function.
ischemgeek
Cell phones exist.
AAC apps are cheap or free depending on the app.
It would literally cost no more than the cost of the app and maybe an external battery for Marcie to have access to AAC on-hand all the time.
Autistic people who are nonverbal and use AAC in their day-to-day lives exist. People with speech impediments who find AAC helpful in communication exist, as well. AAC users in general have found many ways to make the tech both easy to use and portable.
(Part-time AAC user here – use it when my stutter gets too hard to talk through, mainly)
FireSTK
No no no no Stephen Hawking’s TED talks speech required a lot of preparation on his part. He spends an incredibly long time writing his speeches and any kind of questions are prereviewed so he can answer in a quick way. The fact that he can speak in any form is amazing but the technology isn’t there yet.
ischemgeek
@FireSTK, Marcie has several advantages for speedy AAC use over Hawking – she’s ambulatory and can use her hands. In that respect she’s more like a me than a Hawking, and I often have times where I can speak much faster by typing than by vocalization.
It’s not quite as fast as speaking aloud when I’m relatively fluent, but at the same time, I on average type no more slowly than a Southern USian speaks.
Tomas
All this talk of technological fixes and no one mentions police whistles?
FireSTK
@ischemgeek, I understand that. I’m only talking about how Stephen Hawking talks. But now that we’re back to it, Marcie would be at a severe disadvantage not being able to effectively communicate if her hands are occupied.
@Tomas. Great point. Whistles are very effective for drawing attention, especially for hand signals, and possibly breaking up hostile situations. But the question is still effective communication past that point.
Did they ever say why Marcie can’t speak? The page bio just says that she lost the ability as a child. The closet possibilities I can find are aphasia or dysarthria but these are apparently treatable.
Cerberus
Not really. They don’t make Forensics Investigators walk the street as a beat cops. Nor their interpreters.
Dean
Forensics investigators mostly need college degrees, I think.
Butterscotch
Forensics either begin their careers as cops (and typical requirement for advancement within the agency is 5 years on the street. Varies from State to State), or never are cops in the first place but part of the department through an outside hire.
So, yes, a lot of them do work as regular police officers before they advance within the ranks. One of my friends is doing exactly that.
That being said, I doubt any of this applies to Marcie, who is working two jobs at the moment and hasn’t been shown in school. Nobody is become a forensic investigator off the street with no degree in the field.
Andy
They actually don’t. I’m a professional mapmaker, and when I was looking for a job, about half my job applications were to police departments. I’ve never been a cop or anything like.
Butterscotch
This doesn’t apply to Marcie.
WaytoomanyUIDs
@Butterscotch
Someone who is comfined to a wheelchair is a rather bad comparison to Marcie. As others have noted there is cheap & free cellphone software that will fulfill most or all of her needs.
Hawkings uses that rather complex setup because he likes it, even though the software is old & hardware is obsolete and hard to replace. Not because its the only option, there are several other more compact and less complex systems he could use. Allegedly, he likes sounding like a dalek.
WaytoomanyUIDs
Oops, Not only did I reply to wrong comment, but it wasn’t even you who brought up Hawkings.
Sorry
Fart Captor
The ability to communicate verbally isn’t the only issue there. I’m not aware of any device which would not require at least one hand free in order to input what she wants to say. This means if she ever had to draw her weapon, issuing orders to the person she was pointing it at would be difficult if possible at all. That makes the situation much more dangerous for both her and the suspect.
That may not exclude her from roles where she’d need to carry a gun, but it would take many options off the table
HMRC4EVR
She could go right into the forensic sciences. Even Barry Allen was a CSI guy before he became the Flash.
Hell for all we know Marcie could be the next Quincy!
Tomas
Or the next Dexter.
thejeff
All of which requires not just college, but graduate work. For whatever reason, that doesn’t seem to be in Marcie’s plans. At least in the short term.
miados
well there is always paper work and training of other cops to do things. you don’t need to talk to be the one who sprays people with pepper spray so they know what it feels like before becoming cops
Disloyal Subject
A buddy of mine tells me that some of his colleagues lost the paperwork stating that they’d done that.
We had a few laughs. Schadenfreud: the best freud.
miados
you forgot an e at the end of schadenfreude. I guess we should get all the paper work out and make sure there are no further errors before turning it into the boss. I’ll put on the coffee.
jeffepp
Not police, security. Completely different animal.
Butterscotch
It’s more a reply to Sal’s comment then the current situation.
Spencer
I have a completely baseless headcanon of Marcie as a writer/poet.
I think it’d be really neat!
steelplatedheart
she’s not a cop though she’s a security officer.
Believe me, there is NO training or requirements to becoming a security officer. Just stand there and look menacing.
Needfuldoer
She could wreck anyone who starts causing trouble.
Lailah
There is definitely some minimal standard of training. You do generally have to sit in a classroom.
Like it’s not high concept shit, but you do actually need a license.
YourPartnerInScience
In this thread: A bunch of people talking about how a mute person shouldn’t/can’t be a police officer like that kind of discrimination is alright in this day and age.
There are plenty of things one can do for the police force that would not require a voice. And if you really don’t think allowances are made for those with different strengths and weaknesses you’re naive.
I can’t understand this line of thinking where it’s okay to talk about what a bad cop she’d be because she lacks a voice, but if it was some jerk here talking about how someone couldn’t do something because they were gay/fat/female/male/tall/short/black/physically disabled instead of ‘mute’ which is less often encountered, you’d be all over them.
If she wants to be a cop, then she could work her lil ass off and be a cop. Mute doesn’t mean inept.
yomi
Exactly my thought, thank you very much for writing it first!
KSClaw
That’s what I was thinking too. Things change all the time, so there could probably be a way for her to become a cop.
Sarda
There are certain implicit requirements to every job. Many people, on first thought, would think that the (very broad) job descriptor of ‘cop’ would pretty much require the ability to audibly speak to others. The technology to get around that is available, yes, but most people either don’t know that or think it’s not easily applied to the situations a cop might find themselves in.
Your comparison is flawed as well; in your list of generally irrelevant descriptors you include ‘fat’ and ‘physically disabled’. Both terms are sufficiently broad that, combined with the wide variety of things a cop could be doing, your argument technically holds. However, on the subject of beat cop (which is what most people I’ve seen are talking about, and likely the only thing that pops into most people’s mind by the word cop) either one would be sufficient to disqualify – a beat cop must be physically fit. End of story.
trlkly
And those people who think “beat cop” when they are thinking about the police are factually wrong, and thus it’s okay to bring it up. To think that shows ignorance of what the police are.
If you’re going to say something that could be discriminatory, it’s in your best interest to make sure it isn’t. It takes two seconds of thought to realize that there are other types of cops that Marcie could be.
If you don’t think about that, people may interpret what you say as bigoted, and it’s not easy to fix that. Better to not allow it in the first place by actually thinking about what you type before you type it.
(And, no, I don’t think anyone here knows so little about cops that they think that the only type of cop is the beat cop. They’ve at least seen TV shows with detectives.)
thejeff
But as far as I know, the usual route to detective starts with the Police Academy and goes through beat Cop. (Not that most actually walk beats these days, but that’s another rant.)
Same for most other jobs I’m aware of. Some technical ones may bypass it, but they require degrees.
Oysteinthenoisy
Thank you for writing this. My thoughts exactly. G also think Sal’s tone with Marcie is incredibly hostile, even though I’m sure Sal is totes correct about Robin.
Butterscotch
Jobs involving the safety of the public have a minimum standard you need to meet. This isn’t discrimination, it’s reality. You can attack my character all you want, but it doesn’t change the fact you need to be able to speak to be a police officer. I’d be very pleased to find out I’m wrong, trust me.
trlkly
No one attacked your character. And you just ignored everything the person said who you were responded to. Instead, you decided to make it all about you and repeat the stuff that had already been refuted.
Reality is that every possible accommodation has to be made for those with disabilities. Reality is that she can be a cop. She just can’t do the jobs that require the ability to talk to the general public at a moment’s notice.
Most police jobs do not actually involve that, so she can definitely be a police officer. And if you really would love to hear this, you’d listen to this instead of making it about how someone dared point out that something you said had bigoted implications.
The response to someone saying something you said is bigoted is to apologize. Not to double down. That’s when your character may be questioned.
Butterscotch
“She just can’t do the jobs that require the ability to talk to the general public at a moment’s notice.”
Which is almost all of them. You don’t apply to be a police officer and skip the academy/training/etc. I’m not apologizing for being ‘bigoted’ because I didn’t say anything to warrant the accusation. You’re using it as a buzzterm to diffuse the actual argument.
Sadly, I did look around to see if it is possible for a mute person to be a police officer and all I found was instances of them shooting deaf/mute people.
But, again, attack me, don’t attack the argument. Very mature.
thejeff
Yeah, I did the same search. Scary and depressing as hell.