Um. Yeah. LARC for all — it’s all we’ve got right now.
SO glad Joyce is getting on birth control! *Whew!*
Reading all that **** in the news recently about child abuse in the Southern Baptist Convention, in the Catholic Church, in The Church of Latter Day Saints, in Amish communities, in the Church of Scientology, among Jehovah’s Witnesses, in the breakaway Presbyterian Church in America, at Contemporary Christian Music concerts… I’m really hoping that Joyce and Becky and their friends never had to deal with that particular kind of hell, anyway.
Body autonomy is hard enough to figure out even when you get to wait until adulthood before having to face the hard questions about sexuality and personal privacy.
? I’m sorry Willis. All I wanted to do was have a way for people to engage with the community without discussing issues that could potentially trigger them, but I’m really sorry if I caused you any trouble with this! ?
Thanks, Willis. I participated in the discussion the last couple days, but I really do tend to come to the comments section of a comic for discussion of the comic, so thanks.
I mean, it wasn’t drama, it just wasn’t about the comic. In my opinion, it didn’t help that the off-topic things would be among the first posts each day.
I do get not wanting to engage with the content of the comic each day, but then, it might be the best to be in a space literally for that.
Yumi
*it might be the best to NOT be in a space literally for that, lol
Kazuma Taichi
yea, I gotta agree on that
might be that I had a decent enough childhood and that I haven’t encountered the worst of it, but I hadn’t even found the last few strips that triggering. someone coming to terms with their own mental-scape? that’s character development to me. Dorothy and Billie being insensitive about things? I mean sure but I’ve seen far worse than them in my life on all kinds of issues. heck I wouldn’t be surprised if my younger self was worse than the two of them
your comic, your prerogative, so that’s cool. having said that: I was really enjoying the off-topic discussions and felt like they were fostering a lot of goodwill around here. should we all start a subreddit or uhhh a discord or whatever the hip kids do to connect these days??
I mean, if you gotta have them, don’t…. post them right away. If every day you get to the comic and the first thing you gotta do is scroll several pages past people not actually using this space for what it’s for, then I might as well shut the comments down. Like, wait until morning, maybe, to start your OT thread, just to give folks who are here for the comic some time and space to talk about the comic. If talking about the comic bums you out and you need a reprieve, then this is probably not a great place to be to begin with.
FaerwenOfValenwood
nah, makes total sense that this isn’t the best place for, like, random chitchat esp if you have to moderate the whole thing yourself and other folk can’t skip past it all. hence my wish for a discord chat or whatever
I’m just glad at all that I can interact with the here in this wonderful, diverse, accepting community, without having to talk about triggering issues.
I like all of you, you understand me better than any community I’ve ever been to, and I don’t want triggering things to render it inaccessible for me and lots of others here for indefinite numbers of days.
Hopefully fan games don’t count as off topic. When I publish them I mean.
Maybe don’t say THE doa discord. It’s an unaffiliated fan space and I hope you make that clear in the discord itself. Also I hope this doesn’t become another thing you spam.
I know you have good intentions, but just what do you intend to achieve by gate-keeping what counts as “spam”?
Nova
That isn’t what “gatekeeping” means.
You have been using the comments to advertise/ask for help with your DoA fan game every single day, often multiple times per day. That’s spam by my definition.
What I’m intending to achieve is a little self-awareness on your part. You’ve been responsible for a new rule AND the ability to flag/report comments – take a hint that you’re being disruptive.
I wasn’t talk about my game in regards to “spam”. I was talking about the discord link.
Is it really that “disruptive” to remind people that there’s a non-triggering way to engage with the community with but a single comment linking the discord that people don’t really need to respond to?
All I want to do is foster good will around here so things don’t get too fiery to the point to which this place becomes inaccessible to lots of people around here.
If people really think that anything I post here counts as spam, they could easily flag it themselves without anyone reminding them what counts as spam.
Nova
I do flag your comments now that the option has been made available. Unfortunately there is no option to block you, which I would prefer.
I will, however, refrain from interacting with you from this point on. Please do not reply/respond to any of my comments in future, and I’ll do the same to yours.
I can’t make you care about other people, but you personally made this comments section a stressful and less fun place for me to be. YOU are one of the people making it inaccessible to people. I’m sure you’ll ignore that and continue on the way you want to, but I hope I’m wrong.
(For the record, this server existed long before these off-topic shenanigans and is more affiliated to the DoA subreddit than anything else.)
Nova
I appreciate the clarification, thank you.
Wack'd
Hey uh
This server has seemed, every time I tiptoe into it, to be reserved exclusively for screaming about how bad the kidnapping plotline was and how awful Willis is
I would not recommend it as a sober and non-confrontational alternative to the comments
It’s changed quite some time since last time you’ve been there, it seems.
Wack'd
Yeah I poked my head in there again because I wasn’t expecting it to be the same server and the most recent conversations in both the room for the comic and the room about Willis??? That’s a normal thing to have were bellyaching about the same stuff they were bellyaching about the last time I went in there, so
Good god thank you. It’s been an increasing slog, and its not really heartening to scroll past like 300 posts of increasingly off topic discussion just to get to ‘so heres why X female character is A Monster’. I’d at least like to have enough energy to keep scrolling.
sometimes vs often I begin at the bottom of the comments, where heavy toned comments and shitpost has already happened and I feel it’s more level headed.
Doesn’t work everytime though, and probably not since I said it…
Really? It was pretty funny, my guess.
It’s a long running comic, it’s natural to people here know each other more.
But if the creator wishes ti end it, I’ll understood. It’s hard to moderate a lot of communities.
junesky
I should say I think it’s fine, nice even when off-topic conversations come up naturally, but an entire thread for the purpose of being off topic was a lot to scroll through (esp. on mobile).
To be fair this was/is an issue with a daily advice column where they wanted a community but also just clogged up discussion of the column to where they had to INVENT AN OFF-TOPIC FLAG which at least allowed people to hide posts flagged as such
This was great until they updated the site and this unfortunately broke that functionality ?
I sure hope that feature returns. Sounds like it would be a VERY good thing to have, to create a situation where everyone wins. ?
Kelibath
I frequent another comic where the off-topic replies are marked clearly with OT: (in the same vein as a CW content warning, pre-text).
Unfortunately they’re also nearly always the only content on the thread.
It does seem like creating an off-topic social space *within* the comment threads, especially if unmarked, but generally either way, shuts down commentary to some degree on the content. Even though this other community had their comment replies nested by default – which DoA does not!
It’s a shame, but one worthy of considering, sadly.
Kelibath
Just to say I absolutely second the creation of a fanmade or official forum or other content area to engender more community conversation. It’s a much more appropriate place than randomly on the comment threads (and while I understood the OT threads you began to be specifically meant as a distract from this current in-universe day/plot/ND focus, they were growing in scale and overload more than they were shutting it down, IMHO – sorry..). But that sort of a community needs good, even-handed, reliable regular moderation to avoid negativity spiralling long-term just as the comment section on a comic does, and I don’t know if Willis has the time for that or any plans to recruit others to work on the matter. Also, any mods/runners from the community would probably need to have avoided strong partisanship, which then rules out some more passionate members – it’s not the easiest thing in the world. But I’ve seen other comics succeed at running a forum (Gunnerkrigg for example), so maybe it’s possible…?
Like, sorry, are you talking about something a completely different website/content provider did? Or was this a thing Willis did with a previous website?
Thank you. I’m in the UK so by the time I was checking the comic each day, it was impossible for me to scroll through a wall of utterly unrelated musings to try and read the comic discussion, so I gave up.
Calling them breaks from heavy subjects was a mockery when you couldn’t actually FIND the heavy subjects.
Ditto, I appreciated the sentiment, but I wasn’t heading to the comments to /not/ see others’ takes on the material whether for discussion, elucidation, venting, checking before adding my own, etc. It’s a nice idea but it doesn’t work quite as intended when readers have to choose to access comments to begin with (as opposed to say, having to click through them before seeing the comic, like a FB headline-and-image with a thousand “top comments” flagged before first click).
This whole discussion feels incredibly disingenuous when half or more of the people complaining don’t post regularly and have apparently come out of the woodwork specifically about this; if scrolling down past threads you don’t want to read is so taxing, why am I so sure 90% of you are on twitter?
It’s Willis’ website and he can do as he pleases, but this whole discussion of the issue is just dishonest.
Uh, from my end I can actually see how many comments each person has made on this site, right next to their names, and the “the people complaining don’t post regularly” claim is not supported by these numbers in any way. And even if it was? The reading experience of lurkers matters, too.
And comparing it to scrolling through Twitter makes no sense??? Because Twitter isn’t a dedicated forum for discussion about one specific topic, and also you can choose???? who you read??? and if you don’t like their content you can just unfollow them??? so I don’t understand how it’s relevant?????????
Maybe some of the people saying they want the comments section to…be more focused on actually commenting on the comic…have been alienated or put off by the comments section being commandeered as a community building website that doesn’t have a lot to do with the actual comic?
I’m not on Twitter and I like this damn comic strip and I’d like to be able to talk about it without having to navigate every single day through hundreds of comments about toast, on a thread I can’t collapse, that is only there in the first place because someone wanted to talk about toast toppings more than they wanted to talk about the comic that this comments section is supposed to be here for.
Consider that some of the people posting read but don’t often add to the comments, and that others may have not commented recently, especially if the OT threads were putting them off…!
But honestly, I think the biggest issue for anything like this is that DoA’s site doesn’t auto-nest discussion threads. (Or bold new thread headlines, or do anything else in particular to make thread-starters stand out…) This makes a single off-topic thread of a few dozen chats and replies into a massive, sprawling mess that honestly I have to agree has been unreadable over the last week or so. To me, anyway.
I actually thought the OT-to-chill section was a sweet idea but it doesn’t seem like it’s been working as intended and I’ve seen similar efforts backfire (or at least solidly alter reader engagement, good or ill) even on comics that DO nest comments, so alternative chat host options are a good call at this point.
199 thoughts on “Dejennifered”
Ana Chronistic
also it’s legit unhelpful to be worried about something that hasn’t actually happened yet
like, sure, be prepared, but spending your time ACTIVELY worrying about a POSSIBILITY is unproductive at best
or so sayeth the serenity prayer
might not even be autistic = don’t worry about it rn
on the other hand, being of child-incubating age in the U.S. = absolutely worry rn, maybe with pitchforks
Laura
Um. Yeah. LARC for all — it’s all we’ve got right now.
SO glad Joyce is getting on birth control! *Whew!*
Reading all that **** in the news recently about child abuse in the Southern Baptist Convention, in the Catholic Church, in The Church of Latter Day Saints, in Amish communities, in the Church of Scientology, among Jehovah’s Witnesses, in the breakaway Presbyterian Church in America, at Contemporary Christian Music concerts… I’m really hoping that Joyce and Becky and their friends never had to deal with that particular kind of hell, anyway.
Body autonomy is hard enough to figure out even when you get to wait until adulthood before having to face the hard questions about sexuality and personal privacy.
The Wellerman
Seriously, if I hear any more of this injustice imma turn into fucking Ghost Rider ???
*plays “Exorcism” from Ghost Rider OST on hacked muzak*
Reaver
Yeah it’s unhelpful to be worried about stuff you dont know yet, but anxiety doesn’t work that way, and Joyce certainly doesn’t work that way lol
Kazuma Taichi
why settle on inefficient pitchforks when Joseph-Ignace Guillotin already came up with a much more efficient metal and wood device back in the 1700s?
Sirksome
Not even in the top 13 really. Early Joyce, was a lot to deal with.
David M Willis
okay no more six solid pages of off-topic discussion to scroll through anymore, don’t try to start offtopic stuff here on purpose
Schpoonman
But how will I know what people feel about 30XX if I don’t start hilariously off-topic discussions in this extremely charged comment section?
True Survivor
Oh no. This going to turn into six pages off-topic discussion about off-topic discussion isn’t it?
Slartibeast Button, BIA
argh! Flagged by accident.
Of course not, it will turn into six pages of off-topic discussion about off-topic discussion about off-topic discussion.
The Wellerman
? I’m sorry Willis. All I wanted to do was have a way for people to engage with the community without discussing issues that could potentially trigger them, but I’m really sorry if I caused you any trouble with this! ?
The Wellerman
(If only there were a way to collapse threads or something)
crow
Y’all should start a subreddit. Just people who like Dumbing of Age talking about anything they want.
alongcameaspider
Maybe a discord channel would work better
Of course nothing like this should be done without Willis’s permission
crow
I don’t see why we would need Willis’s permission to talk to each other.
Needfuldoer
To talk to each other? No.
To use his intellectual property (the comic and related characters and logos)? Yes.
Jamie
Make it clear he doesn’t endorse the channel and it should be fine.
Yumi
Thanks, Willis. I participated in the discussion the last couple days, but I really do tend to come to the comments section of a comic for discussion of the comic, so thanks.
BBCC
Dare I ask what the topic was?
Yumi
I mean, it wasn’t drama, it just wasn’t about the comic. In my opinion, it didn’t help that the off-topic things would be among the first posts each day.
I do get not wanting to engage with the content of the comic each day, but then, it might be the best to be in a space literally for that.
Yumi
*it might be the best to NOT be in a space literally for that, lol
Kazuma Taichi
yea, I gotta agree on that
might be that I had a decent enough childhood and that I haven’t encountered the worst of it, but I hadn’t even found the last few strips that triggering. someone coming to terms with their own mental-scape? that’s character development to me. Dorothy and Billie being insensitive about things? I mean sure but I’ve seen far worse than them in my life on all kinds of issues. heck I wouldn’t be surprised if my younger self was worse than the two of them
Axel
sandwiches largely
Thag Simmons
I feel like it’s usually been sandwiches
FaerwenOfValenwood
your comic, your prerogative, so that’s cool. having said that: I was really enjoying the off-topic discussions and felt like they were fostering a lot of goodwill around here. should we all start a subreddit or uhhh a discord or whatever the hip kids do to connect these days??
David M Willis
I mean, if you gotta have them, don’t…. post them right away. If every day you get to the comic and the first thing you gotta do is scroll several pages past people not actually using this space for what it’s for, then I might as well shut the comments down. Like, wait until morning, maybe, to start your OT thread, just to give folks who are here for the comic some time and space to talk about the comic. If talking about the comic bums you out and you need a reprieve, then this is probably not a great place to be to begin with.
FaerwenOfValenwood
nah, makes total sense that this isn’t the best place for, like, random chitchat esp if you have to moderate the whole thing yourself and other folk can’t skip past it all. hence my wish for a discord chat or whatever
The Wellerman
OK Willis, thank you for letting me know.
I’m just glad at all that I can interact with the here in this wonderful, diverse, accepting community, without having to talk about triggering issues.
I like all of you, you understand me better than any community I’ve ever been to, and I don’t want triggering things to render it inaccessible for me and lots of others here for indefinite numbers of days.
Hopefully fan games don’t count as off topic. When I publish them I mean.
The Wellerman
*interact with the people here
typos bruh…
ktbear
I’m pretty sure thats bro, bro.
The Wellerman
Nah, bruh’s a lot more gender neutral IMO, I’m gender fluid (she/they) ?
PASchaefer
Do you ever wish that people addressed you as DW, like you were Darkwing Duck?
DailyBrad
I’d imagine they wouldn’t want people calling them when something troubling them, though.
The Wellerman
Your wish has been granted!
Here’s the DOA Discord Server:
https://discord.gg/j2VZ6jbw
See you on the other side! ?
Nova
Maybe don’t say THE doa discord. It’s an unaffiliated fan space and I hope you make that clear in the discord itself. Also I hope this doesn’t become another thing you spam.
The Wellerman
I know you have good intentions, but just what do you intend to achieve by gate-keeping what counts as “spam”?
Nova
That isn’t what “gatekeeping” means.
You have been using the comments to advertise/ask for help with your DoA fan game every single day, often multiple times per day. That’s spam by my definition.
What I’m intending to achieve is a little self-awareness on your part. You’ve been responsible for a new rule AND the ability to flag/report comments – take a hint that you’re being disruptive.
The Wellerman
I wasn’t talk about my game in regards to “spam”. I was talking about the discord link.
Is it really that “disruptive” to remind people that there’s a non-triggering way to engage with the community with but a single comment linking the discord that people don’t really need to respond to?
All I want to do is foster good will around here so things don’t get too fiery to the point to which this place becomes inaccessible to lots of people around here.
If people really think that anything I post here counts as spam, they could easily flag it themselves without anyone reminding them what counts as spam.
Nova
I do flag your comments now that the option has been made available. Unfortunately there is no option to block you, which I would prefer.
I will, however, refrain from interacting with you from this point on. Please do not reply/respond to any of my comments in future, and I’ll do the same to yours.
I can’t make you care about other people, but you personally made this comments section a stressful and less fun place for me to be. YOU are one of the people making it inaccessible to people. I’m sure you’ll ignore that and continue on the way you want to, but I hope I’m wrong.
Either way, that’s all I’ll say.
Deadjolras
(For the record, this server existed long before these off-topic shenanigans and is more affiliated to the DoA subreddit than anything else.)
Nova
I appreciate the clarification, thank you.
Wack'd
Hey uh
This server has seemed, every time I tiptoe into it, to be reserved exclusively for screaming about how bad the kidnapping plotline was and how awful Willis is
I would not recommend it as a sober and non-confrontational alternative to the comments
The Wellerman
There’s also a thread about dogs and fanart too.
It’s changed quite some time since last time you’ve been there, it seems.
Wack'd
Yeah I poked my head in there again because I wasn’t expecting it to be the same server and the most recent conversations in both the room for the comic and the room about Willis??? That’s a normal thing to have were bellyaching about the same stuff they were bellyaching about the last time I went in there, so
EpochFlame
thank you willis
Friendly Frankenstein
Good god thank you. It’s been an increasing slog, and its not really heartening to scroll past like 300 posts of increasingly off topic discussion just to get to ‘so heres why X female character is A Monster’. I’d at least like to have enough energy to keep scrolling.
khn0
sometimes vs often I begin at the bottom of the comments, where heavy toned comments and shitpost has already happened and I feel it’s more level headed.
Doesn’t work everytime though, and probably not since I said it…
woobie
thank you
shrub
thank you
junesky
Thank you Willis that was getting irritating…
Amós Batista
Really? It was pretty funny, my guess.
It’s a long running comic, it’s natural to people here know each other more.
But if the creator wishes ti end it, I’ll understood. It’s hard to moderate a lot of communities.
junesky
I should say I think it’s fine, nice even when off-topic conversations come up naturally, but an entire thread for the purpose of being off topic was a lot to scroll through (esp. on mobile).
Cerusee
Appreciated. It was getting frustrating trying to find the on-topic comments, which are in fact what I’m looking for in a comments section.
Nova
THANK YOU. It was so annoying to have to scroll and scroll and scroll to find something about the comic rather than hotdogs or some nonsense.
Ana Chronistic
To be fair this was/is an issue with a daily advice column where they wanted a community but also just clogged up discussion of the column to where they had to INVENT AN OFF-TOPIC FLAG which at least allowed people to hide posts flagged as such
This was great until they updated the site and this unfortunately broke that functionality ?
The Wellerman
I sure hope that feature returns. Sounds like it would be a VERY good thing to have, to create a situation where everyone wins. ?
Kelibath
I frequent another comic where the off-topic replies are marked clearly with OT: (in the same vein as a CW content warning, pre-text).
Unfortunately they’re also nearly always the only content on the thread.
It does seem like creating an off-topic social space *within* the comment threads, especially if unmarked, but generally either way, shuts down commentary to some degree on the content. Even though this other community had their comment replies nested by default – which DoA does not!
It’s a shame, but one worthy of considering, sadly.
Kelibath
Just to say I absolutely second the creation of a fanmade or official forum or other content area to engender more community conversation. It’s a much more appropriate place than randomly on the comment threads (and while I understood the OT threads you began to be specifically meant as a distract from this current in-universe day/plot/ND focus, they were growing in scale and overload more than they were shutting it down, IMHO – sorry..). But that sort of a community needs good, even-handed, reliable regular moderation to avoid negativity spiralling long-term just as the comment section on a comic does, and I don’t know if Willis has the time for that or any plans to recruit others to work on the matter. Also, any mods/runners from the community would probably need to have avoided strong partisanship, which then rules out some more passionate members – it’s not the easiest thing in the world. But I’ve seen other comics succeed at running a forum (Gunnerkrigg for example), so maybe it’s possible…?
Cerusee
Like, sorry, are you talking about something a completely different website/content provider did? Or was this a thing Willis did with a previous website?
Buttery Commissar
Thank you. I’m in the UK so by the time I was checking the comic each day, it was impossible for me to scroll through a wall of utterly unrelated musings to try and read the comic discussion, so I gave up.
Calling them breaks from heavy subjects was a mockery when you couldn’t actually FIND the heavy subjects.
Kelibath
Ditto, I appreciated the sentiment, but I wasn’t heading to the comments to /not/ see others’ takes on the material whether for discussion, elucidation, venting, checking before adding my own, etc. It’s a nice idea but it doesn’t work quite as intended when readers have to choose to access comments to begin with (as opposed to say, having to click through them before seeing the comic, like a FB headline-and-image with a thousand “top comments” flagged before first click).
Deathjavu
This whole discussion feels incredibly disingenuous when half or more of the people complaining don’t post regularly and have apparently come out of the woodwork specifically about this; if scrolling down past threads you don’t want to read is so taxing, why am I so sure 90% of you are on twitter?
It’s Willis’ website and he can do as he pleases, but this whole discussion of the issue is just dishonest.
David M Willis
Uh, from my end I can actually see how many comments each person has made on this site, right next to their names, and the “the people complaining don’t post regularly” claim is not supported by these numbers in any way. And even if it was? The reading experience of lurkers matters, too.
And comparing it to scrolling through Twitter makes no sense??? Because Twitter isn’t a dedicated forum for discussion about one specific topic, and also you can choose???? who you read??? and if you don’t like their content you can just unfollow them??? so I don’t understand how it’s relevant?????????
Cerusee
Maybe some of the people saying they want the comments section to…be more focused on actually commenting on the comic…have been alienated or put off by the comments section being commandeered as a community building website that doesn’t have a lot to do with the actual comic?
I’m not on Twitter and I like this damn comic strip and I’d like to be able to talk about it without having to navigate every single day through hundreds of comments about toast, on a thread I can’t collapse, that is only there in the first place because someone wanted to talk about toast toppings more than they wanted to talk about the comic that this comments section is supposed to be here for.
Kelibath
Consider that some of the people posting read but don’t often add to the comments, and that others may have not commented recently, especially if the OT threads were putting them off…!
But honestly, I think the biggest issue for anything like this is that DoA’s site doesn’t auto-nest discussion threads. (Or bold new thread headlines, or do anything else in particular to make thread-starters stand out…) This makes a single off-topic thread of a few dozen chats and replies into a massive, sprawling mess that honestly I have to agree has been unreadable over the last week or so. To me, anyway.
I actually thought the OT-to-chill section was a sweet idea but it doesn’t seem like it’s been working as intended and I’ve seen similar efforts backfire (or at least solidly alter reader engagement, good or ill) even on comics that DO nest comments, so alternative chat host options are a good call at this point.
The Wellerman
Thanks for writing this, calling the OT-to-chill a “sweet idea”, even tho it didn’t quite turn out too well in the end. ?
Whatever happens from this point on, I just hope we can create a situation where everyone wins.
Kelibath
Sounds nice 😀
True Survivor
Wow, I guess Jennifer was pretty dusty. I guess that what happens when you leave them on the shelf too long.
Either that or her pockets were full of powdered doughnuts.
Needfuldoer
There might be
A little dust on the Jenny
But don’t let it fool ya, no matter what’s inside
Caro
you could take all the text out of this strip and have a pretty solid meme template i think
Kelibath
Hmm… I think you’re right!
Stephen Bierce
*sees an empty space in the wall housing where the hacked Muzak was*
I guess I’ll do something else for a while.
Plain Marie