Careless Whispers is playing in Becky’s head right now. I don’t care that she’s probably too young and too sheltered to know that song, that’s what those sort of fantasies sound like. It’s universal.
When we meet aliens from Rigel VI, communications will be facilitated when we discover that when they imagine any of their six preferred genders unfurling their fronds to reveal their pedipalps clad in tasteful lingerie, the sound they are imagining is indistinguishable from Careless Whispers.
Thus the song will act as our Rosetta Stone, until all the scientists get too turned on from listening to it on repeat and need to be alone for a bit.
However, Joyce is probably having “Careless Whispers” in her head; on account of how she feels guilty about her actions, and feels that she ruined the chance she was given.
Charlie Spencer
Her feet feel guilty too.
David T. Shaw
Thank you for drawing my attention to Rita Moreno’s version.
And I agree – that’s exactly what Becky seems to be going through.
I’m around Becky’s age, she’s absolutely not too young to know that song. If she had a normal upbringing, she’d at the very least know it from memes. She didn’t, however, so she’s absolutely too sheltered to know it
That’s what I thought her reason for being freaked out yesterday was. Once she starts with touching, she won’t stop until . . . what’s the lesbian version of “bo-o-o-o-oing”?
You know Joyce is all about that. “Well at least one of us is getting laid” life right now. That’s why she’s Becky’s bff! Great moment for Joyce here. Strong work.
I keep snapping from in-universe-perspective time to IRL time. I’m going back and forth from “about damn time, it’s only been an entire decade” to “Wow, Joyce, you’ve changed so fast in a few months.”
Yeah I’m in the “this is unrealistically fast change” due to in-universe time. The mitigating factor is that the whole disaster with Ross sped her worldview-shattering up a bit.
Touchfuzzy
Having been raised very Christian, I’ll just say that I’ve seen a lot of people who were very very “brainwashed Christian” that as soon as they hit 18 and moved out had a huge culture shock and changed very fast.
It really isn’t unrealistic. (Btw this isn’t against Christians in general, when I say brainwashed Christians i mean the specific type like how Joyce was raised).
ischemgeek
Yeah especially for someone like Joyce who is prone to all or nothing thinking.
To Joyce, if some of it is garbage, it all is.
Chris Phoenix
I was raised fundie. I believed gay people were literally going to Hell. Then my best friend came out to me. I knew immediately that my belief was wrong, and spent the next couple of hours deliberately re-thinking every belief I could find that derived from it.
On the other hand, it took me several more years to stop being Christian. And after I decided I was no longer Christian, it took me another six months to believe I was not going to Hell.
Having a belief system based on lies really messes with one’s head. The process of removing the lies is unpredictable. Joyce’s speed of change is completely realistic… and she may have lingering irrational/unfounded beliefs for many years.
Illithid
Agreed, and congratulations. It’s hard work reevaluating your beliefs. Takes guts.
BBCC
It’s not the same thing, but this is also my experience with cults. Nothing breaks you out until you’re ready to see the bullshit for what it is, but at that point, it could be something very small. And once that first bit of BS falls flat…well, it’s all connected, so it takes a bunch more out with it, like the world’s shittiest dominoes game.
Charles Phipps
As mentioned, I used to be a fundamentalist until I had a mystical experience where God told me not to be a asshole. It came at just the right time or I would have become a much worse person or lost an important part of my life.
Geneseepaws
Fastest way to reboot your reality; have a supreme being show up and offer you a cuppa, then yer braincells spontaneously regroup, and life is never the same old stupid it used to be.
fridge_logic
I also want to point out that Joyce probably gains a massive amount of objectivity by thinking about Becky’s situation instead of her own. Because she can see the goodness in Becky, she can see how that goodness would be unchanged by having sex with Dina. That makes it easy for her to see the wrongness in Becky not having sex.
HOWEVER, regarding her own goodness is a completely different story, or so I imagine for her. I imagine that while she can quickly dispense new doctrine to Becky, she cannot so quickly make the same allowances to herself, in part because she know’s she’s far more biased when deciding which rules to break personally.
To me this is the same as when Joyce basically instantly recognized that Becky being gay didn’t make her a bad person who was going to hell. She just knew that nothing had happened that was hell worthy and that her friend was still her friend and a good person.
God I’m so glad Joyce has Becky to help her make these sceptical breakthroughs. It might have taken her so much longer otherwise.
jmsr7
fridge_logic said: “To me this is the same as when Joyce basically instantly recognized that Becky being gay didn’t make her a bad person who was going to hell.”
I agree and think that was one of the things this scene conveyed. As many have pointed out, discovering that one aspect of your worldview is a flat out lie really can lead to it collapsing quickly.
While it is true that many people deconvert over the course of years as the “shelf of things that don’t make sense but i’d rather not think about for now” builds up and finally breaks; other people have no such shelf. The writer of the CES Letter (about mormonism) has publicly stated he had no such shelf, and thought everything about mormonism was true. Until he heard a church leader say that “there’s never since Kirkland has there been such a period of apostacy like now due to church history” which caused him to look into it. And given that mormonism is the second most easily disproven false religion (IMO), he was done pretty quickly too. He only wrote the letter as a courtesy to his grandfather. Publicizing it came much later.
tl,dr: quick deconversions are indeed a thing that happen
thejeff
But that doesn’t really match what she says here or her current bit of story arc. She doesn’t talk about Becky’s goodness or how God would be okay with it. It’s just “Everything else we were raised to believe is a lie”, so why not?
This comes from her recent doubts about God. The same place as her lie to Harrison.
Compare with the scene where she first accepts Becky – that’s affirming. This is dismissive.
Beckie: Don’t you ever take off that stupid hat?
Dina: I take my hat off for one thing, one thing only.
Beckie: Oh… Take your hat off… I mean, if you want to…
Dina: I want to.
I forgot that scene and just rewatched it and noticed something else, right before that conversation they do some expectation setting, though a bit implicit rather than explicit:
She asks him if they have anything in common. They quickly find that they do not; regardless she uses the metaphor of a desert island to suggest that they might as well get on if they don’t want to stay together because at the moment they’re stuck together.
The conversation is nuanced, but that’s often the way that people prefer to handle conversations about potentially having sex, rejections are easier to give and get if the proposition has plausible deniability. All and all it’s a good model for a random hookup.
Oh no Joyce is in the anger zone of post-apostasy angst. I was gonna call it the “anger-phase” but she’ll likely find herself in it pretty often over the next few years
My experience was that when I was out, I was out. After I left Catholicism at the age of fourteen, I never again gave religion the time of day. Although as a history buff I can say the history of religion is the most fascinating of all.
198 thoughts on “Drop”
Ana Chronistic
Rule #469 on the Internet:
If it exists,it’s somebody’s fetishMatthewTheLucky
I thought that was 34c?
Reltzik
It turns out there’s a fetish for redundant list entries.
Leorale
34C sounds like a bra size. So, that holds up.
(finger-guns)
Roborat
Hey, they already said to holster the finger guns in here.
Fiiiiilo
bruh
Ray
Ana’s rule number is definitely accurate…
Suet
HAAAAAAAAAATS
DarkoNeko
hats ! hats ! hats !
Jade
E’ERYBODY!
ASTAPHE
Is maith lei an cailin gan hata
BarerMender
Scots Gaelic: “She likes the girl without a hat.” So says Google translate.
Doctor_Who
Careless Whispers is playing in Becky’s head right now. I don’t care that she’s probably too young and too sheltered to know that song, that’s what those sort of fantasies sound like. It’s universal.
When we meet aliens from Rigel VI, communications will be facilitated when we discover that when they imagine any of their six preferred genders unfurling their fronds to reveal their pedipalps clad in tasteful lingerie, the sound they are imagining is indistinguishable from Careless Whispers.
Thus the song will act as our Rosetta Stone, until all the scientists get too turned on from listening to it on repeat and need to be alone for a bit.
Kravis
As soon as Dinah said “many places” three strips ago I commented
*The sax from Careless Whisper starts to play* three days ago.
I see I’m not the only one who noticed it started playing…
Emperor Norton II
Personally, I sort of feel that “Fever” is more likely to play in Becky’s head, in that last panel.
Probably the version with Rita Moreno in the Muppet Show.
Emperor Norton II
However, Joyce is probably having “Careless Whispers” in her head; on account of how she feels guilty about her actions, and feels that she ruined the chance she was given.
Charlie Spencer
Her feet feel guilty too.
David T. Shaw
Thank you for drawing my attention to Rita Moreno’s version.
And I agree – that’s exactly what Becky seems to be going through.
anonamousethatscurriesinthedarkness
Fever?
So more cow bell?
Zee
I’m around Becky’s age, she’s absolutely not too young to know that song. If she had a normal upbringing, she’d at the very least know it from memes. She didn’t, however, so she’s absolutely too sheltered to know it
laladoria
Took me a little bit to notice the drool. I don’t think Becky is going to last much longer on the Purity Train.
He Who Abides
That’s what I thought her reason for being freaked out yesterday was. Once she starts with touching, she won’t stop until . . . what’s the lesbian version of “bo-o-o-o-oing”?
Rei
Blip? Drip? P-psssshh!
(guess that last one?)
Stephen Bierce
*plays The Statler Brothers’ “Whatever” on the hacked Muzak*
0kami
*Follows up with the Tom Jones cover of “You can leave your hat on”*
Opus the Poet
The Doctor John version was far superior.
Kamino Neko
Becky: ‘NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!’
BBCC
This is gonna go for a while, and it might get more intense before it gets less.
Sunny
The Dastardly Dad-Duo will probably interfere just before things get saucy.
Androiddreams
Datum that’s a sexy hat
Opus the Poet
I know that’s a typo, but it’s a funny typo that reminds us of the singular of data.
Also, that is a sexy hat.
Roborat
I agree, and I am not even a Jaeger.
Sirksome
You know Joyce is all about that. “Well at least one of us is getting laid” life right now. That’s why she’s Becky’s bff! Great moment for Joyce here. Strong work.
Meagan
Ooh good angle.
Felian
Ha nice view.
Yeah she’s pretty much giving up, wow.
I like it, but i know it’s SO unsettling going through this.
Woomy
Sceptic Joyce is really catching me off guard.
It’s been years, but I feel like this is really sudden.
Madock345
I keep snapping from in-universe-perspective time to IRL time. I’m going back and forth from “about damn time, it’s only been an entire decade” to “Wow, Joyce, you’ve changed so fast in a few months.”
Meagan
Yeah I’m in the “this is unrealistically fast change” due to in-universe time. The mitigating factor is that the whole disaster with Ross sped her worldview-shattering up a bit.
Touchfuzzy
Having been raised very Christian, I’ll just say that I’ve seen a lot of people who were very very “brainwashed Christian” that as soon as they hit 18 and moved out had a huge culture shock and changed very fast.
It really isn’t unrealistic. (Btw this isn’t against Christians in general, when I say brainwashed Christians i mean the specific type like how Joyce was raised).
ischemgeek
Yeah especially for someone like Joyce who is prone to all or nothing thinking.
To Joyce, if some of it is garbage, it all is.
Chris Phoenix
I was raised fundie. I believed gay people were literally going to Hell. Then my best friend came out to me. I knew immediately that my belief was wrong, and spent the next couple of hours deliberately re-thinking every belief I could find that derived from it.
On the other hand, it took me several more years to stop being Christian. And after I decided I was no longer Christian, it took me another six months to believe I was not going to Hell.
Having a belief system based on lies really messes with one’s head. The process of removing the lies is unpredictable. Joyce’s speed of change is completely realistic… and she may have lingering irrational/unfounded beliefs for many years.
Illithid
Agreed, and congratulations. It’s hard work reevaluating your beliefs. Takes guts.
BBCC
It’s not the same thing, but this is also my experience with cults. Nothing breaks you out until you’re ready to see the bullshit for what it is, but at that point, it could be something very small. And once that first bit of BS falls flat…well, it’s all connected, so it takes a bunch more out with it, like the world’s shittiest dominoes game.
Charles Phipps
As mentioned, I used to be a fundamentalist until I had a mystical experience where God told me not to be a asshole. It came at just the right time or I would have become a much worse person or lost an important part of my life.
Geneseepaws
Fastest way to reboot your reality; have a supreme being show up and offer you a cuppa, then yer braincells spontaneously regroup, and life is never the same old stupid it used to be.
fridge_logic
I also want to point out that Joyce probably gains a massive amount of objectivity by thinking about Becky’s situation instead of her own. Because she can see the goodness in Becky, she can see how that goodness would be unchanged by having sex with Dina. That makes it easy for her to see the wrongness in Becky not having sex.
HOWEVER, regarding her own goodness is a completely different story, or so I imagine for her. I imagine that while she can quickly dispense new doctrine to Becky, she cannot so quickly make the same allowances to herself, in part because she know’s she’s far more biased when deciding which rules to break personally.
To me this is the same as when Joyce basically instantly recognized that Becky being gay didn’t make her a bad person who was going to hell. She just knew that nothing had happened that was hell worthy and that her friend was still her friend and a good person.
God I’m so glad Joyce has Becky to help her make these sceptical breakthroughs. It might have taken her so much longer otherwise.
jmsr7
fridge_logic said: “To me this is the same as when Joyce basically instantly recognized that Becky being gay didn’t make her a bad person who was going to hell.”
I agree and think that was one of the things this scene conveyed. As many have pointed out, discovering that one aspect of your worldview is a flat out lie really can lead to it collapsing quickly.
While it is true that many people deconvert over the course of years as the “shelf of things that don’t make sense but i’d rather not think about for now” builds up and finally breaks; other people have no such shelf. The writer of the CES Letter (about mormonism) has publicly stated he had no such shelf, and thought everything about mormonism was true. Until he heard a church leader say that “there’s never since Kirkland has there been such a period of apostacy like now due to church history” which caused him to look into it. And given that mormonism is the second most easily disproven false religion (IMO), he was done pretty quickly too. He only wrote the letter as a courtesy to his grandfather. Publicizing it came much later.
tl,dr: quick deconversions are indeed a thing that happen
thejeff
But that doesn’t really match what she says here or her current bit of story arc. She doesn’t talk about Becky’s goodness or how God would be okay with it. It’s just “Everything else we were raised to believe is a lie”, so why not?
This comes from her recent doubts about God. The same place as her lie to Harrison.
Compare with the scene where she first accepts Becky – that’s affirming. This is dismissive.
BarerMender
It can be sudden. Reality has a way of catching up to you. I thought about it for a month and decided in a week.
PBManning
I’m sad for Joyce that her oldest friend is completely oblivious to her crisis of faith, but also Becky’s face in that last panel is so good
oh no
You’ve put to words why Joyce’s delivery bothered me so much.
I hope Becky considers it regardless.
Deanatay
Becky is… a bit distracted, right now. She may notice later, and act appropriately then, but for now, she is… what’s the term? Oh, yes, a…
DOOOOOOFUS
fridge_logic
I’m so hoping the next few pages turn out to be Dorothy seeing the crisis and doing what she can to listen and help.
LeslieBean4shizzle
I’m amused that a very similar conversation to this strip happened in the comments yesterday.
Kravis
Ya know, Becky, those horns on Dinah’s hat aren’t there just for aesthetic purposes…
BarerMender
Oh, Lordy. What are you thinking?
Deanatay
I’ve already stated my belief that Dina is Loki.
Bicycle Bill
Beckie: Don’t you ever take off that stupid hat?
Dina: I take my hat off for one thing, one thing only.
Beckie: Oh… Take your hat off… I mean, if you want to…
Dina: I want to.
RacingTurtle
It will never stop fascinating me that one of the best examples of consent in all of American cinema is in Smokey and the freakin’ Bandit.
fridge_logic
I forgot that scene and just rewatched it and noticed something else, right before that conversation they do some expectation setting, though a bit implicit rather than explicit:
She asks him if they have anything in common. They quickly find that they do not; regardless she uses the metaphor of a desert island to suggest that they might as well get on if they don’t want to stay together because at the moment they’re stuck together.
The conversation is nuanced, but that’s often the way that people prefer to handle conversations about potentially having sex, rejections are easier to give and get if the proposition has plausible deniability. All and all it’s a good model for a random hookup.
Beef
Oh no Joyce is in the anger zone of post-apostasy angst. I was gonna call it the “anger-phase” but she’ll likely find herself in it pretty often over the next few years
Madock345
Based on my own experiences, now is around the time to discover Buddhism and Wicca and spend the next decade bouncing back and forth between them.
Meagan
Hello friend.
Prometheus
I feel that on a personal level. Though I only bounced for about two or three years.
drs
Or joining American Atheists and ranting about how religion is a tool for fleecing the sheeple.
BarerMender
American Atheists are more concerned that it’s a tool for controlling the people.
Opus the Poet
Why bounce, Wicca and Buddhism are not incompatible. I have been Wiccan/UU Pagan for 30 years now.
BarerMender
My experience was that when I was out, I was out. After I left Catholicism at the age of fourteen, I never again gave religion the time of day. Although as a history buff I can say the history of religion is the most fascinating of all.
avistel
OUT WITH THIS HUMMING HYMNAL BULLSHIT
TIME FOR SOME FUCKING BEHEMOTH
*cue wall-shattering Slavic cacophony*
abysswatcher1993
Is that some Nordic metal band I don’t know about?
Emperor Norton II
Polish.
But to be fair, I’d never heard of them either until just now, so I did assume Czech based on “Slavic cacophony.