DUH. In DnD, religions are full of people who can cast healing magic, but only a limited number of times per day, and usually in exchange for “donations” to their respective churches.
Meanwhile, alchemists, apothecaries, and physicians have no theoretical limits on how many people they can cure through non-magical means.
So the only conceptual leap to be made to “medicine is against religion” is imagining that religions might allow worldy competition to influence their spiritual dogma. It’s a stretch, I know, but the setting IS fantasy.
Except you’re not going deep enough. Dungeons and Dragons functions on the Discworld principle. the Gods and Goddesses are a known factor. They exist as a fact, and if they wish to, they could break any atheist’s windows.
it’s a poor business person who only destroys instead of ensnaring. Clerical casting limits are also known, as far as potency( Cure Minor, Light, Moderate, Serious Wounds) and times per day. A smart church will endorse alchemists, apothecaries, and TRAIN their clerics as physicians to conserve spellpower. Then they get the Resurrection and “FIX THIS NAO” business, and then charge a lesser fee for “well, I don’t need this fixed now, but it would be nice to get this splinted” business. as well as distributing palliatives and prophylactics to their holy soldiers on the Crusade against EVIL….
or trees. cuz Dungeons and Dragons can be that way.
While there is no theoretical limitations for physicians to provide curative means, i know that in german health care system, there actually are lawful limitations to e.g. physiotherapy prescriptions – not per person, but per all of them in a quarter of a year. if they’ve already prescribed all of them to other people, tough luck for you… no matter how bad your back pain is.
Ruth: Right, I’ll be GM’ing this game, everyone introduce your characters.
Becky: Wait, YOU’RE GM’ing? I thought you thought DnD was for nerds.
Ruth: I did, but then I heard Joyce thought it was ‘blasphemous’, and I thought, “I’m in!” So what are you playing?
Becky: My character’s a Human Ranger named Chris Sprat!
*Ruth raises an eyebrow* How… original. Dina?
Dina: I’m playing a Raptrosian Arcane Trickster named-
Becky: Blue! BlueBlueBlueBlueBLUE!
Dina: NO.
Becky: Awww…
Dina: Her name is unpronounceable by human tongues. However, you may CALL her ‘Blue’.
Becky: YAAAAASSSS!!
Ruth: *sigh*
That would be a serious reversal from the fund opposition to D&D when it was first released. They said it was Satan worship. I expect this is DYW’s inspiration.
thejeff
Not really, even then. They hated D&D, because occult, but generally didn’t know anything about roleplaying games beyond that. Hell, even today if you mention some non-D&D tabletop rpg to a non-gamer, you’ll probably have to describe it as “like D&D, but cyberpunk” or whatever.
For your average fundie, even back in the day if you just described roleplaying games generically, didn’t mention D&D and your particular game didn’t trigger the same “occult” flags, they’d never realize you were essentially doing the same thing.
Goshii
And i’ve always laughed at the “satan worship” when the game encouraged you to go out and slay demons and devils and rescue childrens and you know, be a pretty damn great person.
King Daniel
But the thing is, you’re not doing it in the name of Jesus, which makes it evil, see? /s
Yeah, there is a HUGE influence from medieval stories about saints and knights.
jy3
That’s something I never really got. One of TSR/WOTC’s big competitors is a studio that currently puts out one setting with heavy Gnostic influences and another with vague Taoist flavoring, and the one that’s all knights-and-priests is the one they go after?
Oh, I have stories because we did “fundie-approved” gaming when I was a kid cause all my friends were stuck in that culture.
So it was almost all home-brew systems surrounding systems of “psionics” where magic was one to one replaced with psionics” and there were consistent sci-fi elements.
No one was allowed to play D&D proper, so we snuck it to school to play there instead.
You don’t think Amber is a gamer? Or at the very least WAS one before everything happened with Not-Ryan.
Reltzik
Wrong type of gamer. She’s pretty talkative about her fandoms and hobbies (at times) and DnD has NEVER come up.
BBCC
She’s got a ridiculously high level paladin and talks about how she doesn’t like playing elves. Is that a WoW thing? Regardless, I can see her being into D&D.
N0083rp00F
That pretty much could be any “standard” fantasy RPG.
You would have to go off the beaten path to avoid things like elves or paladins – like Legend of the five rings – Legends of the Shinning Jewel – Fellowship of the White Star – oh, hey, that would be a hoot and a half with this group – 1880-1912 era – no elves or paladins though there are Knights. No armor or swords. Avoid playing with the dynamite or you WILL have a bad time.
thejeff
But it was in context of “raids” and “killing spiders” and always sitting at her computer – maybe not WoW specifically, but very definitely Computer MMO rpgs, not table top ones.
She could have played D&D, but I’d guess for most of her high school career she was too introverted for what is essentially a face to face social activity – even if it is traditionally one for social outcasts.
BBCC
You can play D&D online now. My group uses roll20. She could still do that.
thejeff
She could. But the only things that might hint at it, point more strongly to some WoW like MMO.
Rachel
I could totally see Amber being into WoW, or Guild Wars. If it were the early 2000’s, she so would have played Runescape. I think she loves the fantasy concepts and heroism stuff and can deal with multiplayer in an online setting but the idea of tabletop gaming probably stresses her out because social anxiety.
“Hey, moses, um, what does “Thou shalt spin fidgets everyday of your lives until the end of time” mean? I mean I get the commandments about adultery and stuff, but what does this one even mean?”
“… …. Yeah, no, I have no idea. He goes off on random stuff pretty often. Usually I just nod and smile a lot.”
Look, it was never EXPLICITLY in the Constitution, but neither were the words “Freedom from Religion” or “Democracy”. Like so much else, various PIECES of the Constitution come together to create a space for spinning.
Give her some time in the waiting room, and then check in. A little false idolatry starts looking a lot more appealing when you realize there’s a good chance they won’t get around to seeing you for another eight hours or so.
I am suddenly interested in any possible Joe and Carla interaction. After all they’re AU!father and daughter kind of? I hope they do have some sort of friendship/relationship in this verse too.
I want to see their interactions but I also want to know how/if Joe ranked her on his list since I feel like that’d sort of give an idea of how those interactions might go. Idk why it’s a big deal to me considering that Carla didn’t really linger on it.
The thought did cross my mind if Joe counted transwomen on his list. But yeah, given Joe and Carla’s alternate history it would be nice to see them talk about something.
Something I was pretty sad about from Shortpacked was that we never got to see how it ended up with Joe and Ultracar. Did we see them together at all after the portal thing?
302 thoughts on “Hobble”
Ana Chronistic
just build her a new toe, Carla
AnvilPro
Time for a Shower Shoes upgrade for the bug
Marsh Maryrose
“Freshman, do you even medicine?”
I’m guessing a re-engineered toe would require a plenitude of magic words.
HeatherJean
Ladies, we can rebuild it. We have the technology. We have the capability to make the world’s first bionic toe.
King Daniel
Medicine is against D&D religion?
Doctor_Who
If you worship Nerull, yeah probably.
Smiling Cat
It cuts in to the tithing to clerics if you can just fix yourself.
Foxhack
Considering the amount of anti-vaxxer religious crazies I’d say yes.
Dean
In D&D all injuries and diseases are curable by magic, so I guess?
FacelessDeviant
In D&D, religion is medicine. Clerics are the best at curing whatever ails people.
Reltzik
DUH. In DnD, religions are full of people who can cast healing magic, but only a limited number of times per day, and usually in exchange for “donations” to their respective churches.
Meanwhile, alchemists, apothecaries, and physicians have no theoretical limits on how many people they can cure through non-magical means.
So the only conceptual leap to be made to “medicine is against religion” is imagining that religions might allow worldy competition to influence their spiritual dogma. It’s a stretch, I know, but the setting IS fantasy.
Khyrin
Except you’re not going deep enough. Dungeons and Dragons functions on the Discworld principle. the Gods and Goddesses are a known factor. They exist as a fact, and if they wish to, they could break any atheist’s windows.
it’s a poor business person who only destroys instead of ensnaring. Clerical casting limits are also known, as far as potency( Cure Minor, Light, Moderate, Serious Wounds) and times per day. A smart church will endorse alchemists, apothecaries, and TRAIN their clerics as physicians to conserve spellpower. Then they get the Resurrection and “FIX THIS NAO” business, and then charge a lesser fee for “well, I don’t need this fixed now, but it would be nice to get this splinted” business. as well as distributing palliatives and prophylactics to their holy soldiers on the Crusade against EVIL….
or trees. cuz Dungeons and Dragons can be that way.
Felian
While there is no theoretical limitations for physicians to provide curative means, i know that in german health care system, there actually are lawful limitations to e.g. physiotherapy prescriptions – not per person, but per all of them in a quarter of a year. if they’ve already prescribed all of them to other people, tough luck for you… no matter how bad your back pain is.
Stu
…I’d legitimately love to see Joyce stumble across a D&D game.
Doctor_Who
“When do they don robes and sacrifice the goat? Those dice don’t even look like they are carved from the bones of children!”
Mr. Bulbmin
I wonder if Joyce ever had to watch/read Dark Dungeons.
Shade
We know she has Chick Tracts so she probably read it.
DailyBrad
D&D’s rather popular right now, so it’s certainly possible. It’d be weirder if people WEREN’T playing it on campus somewhere.
Tev
If Willis ever wanted another comic, he could do the cast playing D&D.
Schpoonman
Oh my god I would pay for that.
TachyonCode
I would be extremely willing to write the system.
Wright
Seconded.
Deanatay
Ruth: Right, I’ll be GM’ing this game, everyone introduce your characters.
Becky: Wait, YOU’RE GM’ing? I thought you thought DnD was for nerds.
Ruth: I did, but then I heard Joyce thought it was ‘blasphemous’, and I thought, “I’m in!” So what are you playing?
Becky: My character’s a Human Ranger named Chris Sprat!
*Ruth raises an eyebrow* How… original. Dina?
Dina: I’m playing a Raptrosian Arcane Trickster named-
Becky: Blue! BlueBlueBlueBlueBLUE!
Dina: NO.
Becky: Awww…
Dina: Her name is unpronounceable by human tongues. However, you may CALL her ‘Blue’.
Becky: YAAAAASSSS!!
Ruth: *sigh*
Bagge
Ruth: Roll D4 to see how many femurs you loose.
Rachel
“Her name is unpronounceable by human tongues. However, you may CALL her ‘Blue’.”
PERFECTION
Needfuldoer
I’m almost afraid to ask, but is there a fundie-approved tabletop RPG built off the D20 system?
ProfessorDetective
I don’t know of any PnP RPGs ENDORSED by any Christian groups. But I do know of a D20 campaign setting BASED on the Bible. Yes, this is real.
Erik
Honestly? That looks kind of cool. I think I’d enjoy playing a “Canaanite maker of idols”
Patrick McGraw
I seriously considered running a campaign using this book, set in Babylon just before the Persian conquest.
LaShawn
I actually have this! Haven’t planned a campaign yet, but it’s a pretty cool read.
Bagge
The Swedish church has published a roleplaying game called “the road” which is centered about moral choices. It’s pretty awesome.
https://svenskakyrkan.se/vasterasstift/app/WebShop/Item/Details/76
Ryan
That would be a serious reversal from the fund opposition to D&D when it was first released. They said it was Satan worship. I expect this is DYW’s inspiration.
thejeff
Not really, even then. They hated D&D, because occult, but generally didn’t know anything about roleplaying games beyond that. Hell, even today if you mention some non-D&D tabletop rpg to a non-gamer, you’ll probably have to describe it as “like D&D, but cyberpunk” or whatever.
For your average fundie, even back in the day if you just described roleplaying games generically, didn’t mention D&D and your particular game didn’t trigger the same “occult” flags, they’d never realize you were essentially doing the same thing.
Goshii
And i’ve always laughed at the “satan worship” when the game encouraged you to go out and slay demons and devils and rescue childrens and you know, be a pretty damn great person.
King Daniel
But the thing is, you’re not doing it in the name of Jesus, which makes it evil, see? /s
Bagge
Yeah, there is a HUGE influence from medieval stories about saints and knights.
jy3
That’s something I never really got. One of TSR/WOTC’s big competitors is a studio that currently puts out one setting with heavy Gnostic influences and another with vague Taoist flavoring, and the one that’s all knights-and-priests is the one they go after?
Cerberus
Oh, I have stories because we did “fundie-approved” gaming when I was a kid cause all my friends were stuck in that culture.
So it was almost all home-brew systems surrounding systems of “psionics” where magic was one to one replaced with psionics” and there were consistent sci-fi elements.
No one was allowed to play D&D proper, so we snuck it to school to play there instead.
Bagge
That sounds like a rather fun system.
Reltzik
I don’t think ANY of the cast are gamers, so probably won’t happen.
…… though it would be awesome if it did. Especially if Joyce didn’t find out the NAME of the game until a few hours in.
laladoria
You don’t think Amber is a gamer? Or at the very least WAS one before everything happened with Not-Ryan.
Reltzik
Wrong type of gamer. She’s pretty talkative about her fandoms and hobbies (at times) and DnD has NEVER come up.
BBCC
She’s got a ridiculously high level paladin and talks about how she doesn’t like playing elves. Is that a WoW thing? Regardless, I can see her being into D&D.
N0083rp00F
That pretty much could be any “standard” fantasy RPG.
You would have to go off the beaten path to avoid things like elves or paladins – like Legend of the five rings – Legends of the Shinning Jewel – Fellowship of the White Star – oh, hey, that would be a hoot and a half with this group – 1880-1912 era – no elves or paladins though there are Knights. No armor or swords. Avoid playing with the dynamite or you WILL have a bad time.
thejeff
But it was in context of “raids” and “killing spiders” and always sitting at her computer – maybe not WoW specifically, but very definitely Computer MMO rpgs, not table top ones.
She could have played D&D, but I’d guess for most of her high school career she was too introverted for what is essentially a face to face social activity – even if it is traditionally one for social outcasts.
BBCC
You can play D&D online now. My group uses roll20. She could still do that.
thejeff
She could. But the only things that might hint at it, point more strongly to some WoW like MMO.
Rachel
I could totally see Amber being into WoW, or Guild Wars. If it were the early 2000’s, she so would have played Runescape. I think she loves the fantasy concepts and heroism stuff and can deal with multiplayer in an online setting but the idea of tabletop gaming probably stresses her out because social anxiety.
shadowcell
IF JESUS WANTED US TO SPIN FIDGETS HE WOULD’VE PUT IT IN THE CONSTITUTION >:C >:C >:C
Ana Chronistic
IT WAS THE FIFTEENTH
AMENDMENTCOMMANDMENTProxiehunter
Oh, one of the five on the tablet Moses dropped. That explains everything.
adjudicus
“Hey, moses, um, what does “Thou shalt spin fidgets everyday of your lives until the end of time” mean? I mean I get the commandments about adultery and stuff, but what does this one even mean?”
“… …. Yeah, no, I have no idea. He goes off on random stuff pretty often. Usually I just nod and smile a lot.”
Reltzik
Look, it was never EXPLICITLY in the Constitution, but neither were the words “Freedom from Religion” or “Democracy”. Like so much else, various PIECES of the Constitution come together to create a space for spinning.
(Mostly Articles I and II.)
Dafydd
Mostly, though, we just fidget.
Opus the Poet
So I should just keep my level 26 ChG Warlock and his healing spells away from her?
MM
Give her some time in the waiting room, and then check in. A little false idolatry starts looking a lot more appealing when you realize there’s a good chance they won’t get around to seeing you for another eight hours or so.
Shaunock
Yes, because all the cool kids are playing 5th edition now.
Reltzik
And before that the cool kids were play 3.x.
…. let’s face it, the cool kids NEVER played 4th ed for more than a couple of sessions.
N0083rp00F
We played “PARANOIA” as well as “Lords of Creation” and sometimes “Slayers” because who doesn’t want to occasionally be a landscaper?
StClair
They were all playing WoD, mostly as an excuse to try to get in each other’s pants.
ValdVin
I love Joyce’s whiparound in panel 2. Really captures the surprise of Carla showing up.
Thor
That wasn’t actually a whiparound. That was almost the birth of Anti-Joyce, except that she managed to re-absorb her at the last second.
Fock
I am suddenly interested in any possible Joe and Carla interaction. After all they’re AU!father and daughter kind of? I hope they do have some sort of friendship/relationship in this verse too.
Beef
I want to see their interactions but I also want to know how/if Joe ranked her on his list since I feel like that’d sort of give an idea of how those interactions might go. Idk why it’s a big deal to me considering that Carla didn’t really linger on it.
JessWitt
The thought did cross my mind if Joe counted transwomen on his list. But yeah, given Joe and Carla’s alternate history it would be nice to see them talk about something.
Cattleprod
Carla’s father is secretly Joe’s biological father, since as we all know the character claiming to be Joe’s father is simply Joe from the future.
Rowen Morland
Something I was pretty sad about from Shortpacked was that we never got to see how it ended up with Joe and Ultracar. Did we see them together at all after the portal thing?
Needfuldoer
I like to think Carla and Rachel are collaborating on a self-driving car project, maybe based off a red Nissan Versa.
Reltzik
…. eh, Carla doesn’t strike me as the “collaborating” type.
MatthewTheLucky
@alt-text They’ll spin open a gateway to the netherrealm, just you wait and see.
N0083rp00F
I initially read that as “Nephalem” and thought – drop in on Tyrael preparing tea for some expected yet unknown guests – Them. [snerk]
Tacos