Man, I wrote this punchline months before Frozen was released, in which Disney finally acknowledged the possibility of having exes, somewhat blunting the potency of the punchline. DAMN YOU FROZEN!
Narnia would probably be approved since it’s Christian allegory.
…unless her parents don’t know it was written as Christian allegory and instead think it’s ripping off the Bible in a secular manner.
John
I did once have someone tell me that the Chronicles of Narnia were bad and wrong because Jesus wasn’t a lion.
Daibhid C
Also, C.S. Lewis was a Catholic, which according to some religious people is as bad as being an atheist, if not worse.
malisteen
C.S. Lewis was not a Catholic. he was Anglican, though he left the faith for many years, and only returned thanks in part to the influence of his friend JRR Tolkien, who was Catholic, and always hoped Lewis would eventually convert. Some of Lewis’s later allegorical writings lean more towards Catholic than Anglican doctrine.
I think he was atheist before Tolkien helped him convert.
hexalm
Meh, Anglicanism is just a divorced king’s Catholicism.
Catullus
It was at first, but under Elizabeth I it transitioned to be more Protestant in its doctrine.
Cybersnark
I’d be more inclined to say the bible is bad because Jesus wasn’t a lion.
brionl
Jesus’ brother from another planet is a Lion. Is that close enough? 😉
Arkadi
I haven’t read the Chronicles and so I probably shouldn’t speak, but I wonder what Lewis was thinking about when he made a lion a Christ-like figure. I mean, lions are such huge pimps and jerks; really, whoever called the lion “King of the Jungle” clearly didn’t have a high concept of monarchy.
Moreso since Lions don’t even LIVE in the jungle, they live in the savanna.
Kladeos
Everyone knows the English thought lions were noble and perfect!
felonius
The book of Revelation uses “Lion of Judah” as a reference to Jesus… It could be related to that.
Rex Hondo
It’s been a while since I’ve read it, but I’m pretty sure Aslan is literally Jesus, just in the form he wears in Narnia. So, basically, according to the Narnia books, Jesus is a multiversal singularity, like Unicron or Primus.
Cory
Actually it fits into Christian iconography due to Jesus being referred to as “the lion of of the tribe of Judah”.
I don’t see how too many people would miss the context of it if they’re even remotely familiar with the Christ narrative.
Far
There was a female editorial page columnist that said that if her parents had known that the Narnia Chronicles were Christian allegory, they would never have read them to her. This was published about the time the first big movie was made.
A god, yes. The Christian interpretation? That’s a shaky interpretation.
It also makes a religious leader the villain, so…
Dean
A Catholic religious leader, don’t forget.
David Willis
In Disney’s version, Frollo is no longer technically a religious leader but a judge. They created a new character to be the benevolent head of the church just so the Christians didn’t get mad.
SUGauthor
I’ve been meaning to ask this for a while, what is your current religious status? Whenever I meet someone in person who wasn’t allowed to watch disney movies as a kid because they showed happiness without God’s love, they tended to grow up to become strict atheists. Just curious.
Alex Stritar
That does make sense. I had a more lazi-fair religious upbringing and I still identify as Christian. Maybe what they say about the tight grip is true.
TPman
Wait, you mean there are actually a lot of people who’s parents wouldn’t let them watch FREACKING DISNEY MOVIES because they’re “sinful”? I got that Willis was from some crazy background, but like, you’re talking about that like it’s somewhat typical.
Please god tell me that I’m misinterpreting.
Happiness without god’s love is bad? WTF? It’s happiness! How can happiness be bad?
SUGauthor
Well my parents were a lot like Dorothy’s, so maybe I’m not the best person to ask about this, but I have met people in my life who were Atheists because of their over bearing religious parents, and while my mom isn’t exactly atheist, I’d definitely say part of of the reason she raised me so casually religion wise is because of my extremely religious grandparents. I don’t know if they weren’t allowed to watch Disney movies, but frankly I wouldn’t be surprised. I’m guessing the reason happiness would be considered bad to a religious extremest would be because if your happy without God, that means you don’t need God, and just like that, you’re a gay atheist sleeping with 4 people at once shouting HAIL SATAN when you climax.
The mis- part is what denotes hatred, the -andry part denotes dudes. Gaysandry would be … I dunno, something about being gay for dudes? Huh. I guess that kind of works?
Dammit, I’m tired, leave me alone. 😛
anonymous
Homophobia should be called… *googles Greek word for homosexual*
…mysarsenocoity? Except that apparently would mean hatred for those who PRACTICE on their desires…
Mysarsenagapy?
Or I guess we could take the discrimination based on inherent sexuality and call that “agapism.” And discrimination against certain practiced sexualities would be “coitism.” …I’m beginning to doubt these coined words would mean what I want them to, though.
I really liked Care Bears 2 because they were also so adorable as babies and also there was now a horse and cat and a dog care bear. That was very important when I was 9.
nothri
I hear what you are saying, but nothing beats Carebears 1. Creepy-face-in-a-book lady still scares the crap of me even now.
Jen Aside
Actually, that face in the book reminds me of Sour Grapes from Strawberry Shortcake–it’s like they used the same model sheet =o (and same animators!)
That’s possibly a good thing- some of those films are REALLY not examples to live your life by. My favourite ever Onion headline (from about 10 years ago) is “Man Arrested for Romantic Comedy Behavior.”
333 thoughts on “Hyperventilating”
Idon'tcarenomore
Ah Joyce..no Disney?
Ishai
Only the movies Jesus approves!
Tunaro
Like maybe…
http://www.shortpacked.com/2012/comic/book-14/01-deady-dearest/avengers/
Totz the Plaid
Narnia would probably be approved since it’s Christian allegory.
…unless her parents don’t know it was written as Christian allegory and instead think it’s ripping off the Bible in a secular manner.
John
I did once have someone tell me that the Chronicles of Narnia were bad and wrong because Jesus wasn’t a lion.
Daibhid C
Also, C.S. Lewis was a Catholic, which according to some religious people is as bad as being an atheist, if not worse.
malisteen
C.S. Lewis was not a Catholic. he was Anglican, though he left the faith for many years, and only returned thanks in part to the influence of his friend JRR Tolkien, who was Catholic, and always hoped Lewis would eventually convert. Some of Lewis’s later allegorical writings lean more towards Catholic than Anglican doctrine.
Jeffrywith1e
I think he was atheist before Tolkien helped him convert.
hexalm
Meh, Anglicanism is just a divorced king’s Catholicism.
Catullus
It was at first, but under Elizabeth I it transitioned to be more Protestant in its doctrine.
Cybersnark
I’d be more inclined to say the bible is bad because Jesus wasn’t a lion.
brionl
Jesus’ brother from another planet is a Lion. Is that close enough? 😉
Arkadi
I haven’t read the Chronicles and so I probably shouldn’t speak, but I wonder what Lewis was thinking about when he made a lion a Christ-like figure. I mean, lions are such huge pimps and jerks; really, whoever called the lion “King of the Jungle” clearly didn’t have a high concept of monarchy.
Plasma Mongoose
Moreso since Lions don’t even LIVE in the jungle, they live in the savanna.
Kladeos
Everyone knows the English thought lions were noble and perfect!
felonius
The book of Revelation uses “Lion of Judah” as a reference to Jesus… It could be related to that.
Rex Hondo
It’s been a while since I’ve read it, but I’m pretty sure Aslan is literally Jesus, just in the form he wears in Narnia. So, basically, according to the Narnia books, Jesus is a multiversal singularity, like Unicron or Primus.
Cory
Actually it fits into Christian iconography due to Jesus being referred to as “the lion of of the tribe of Judah”.
I don’t see how too many people would miss the context of it if they’re even remotely familiar with the Christ narrative.
Far
There was a female editorial page columnist that said that if her parents had known that the Narnia Chronicles were Christian allegory, they would never have read them to her. This was published about the time the first big movie was made.
Doctor_Who
…The Small One! That’s a Disney film that should be Fundie Approved®!
And I guess Hunchback has God take vengeance on the villain at the end.
Totz the Plaid
But “heathens” are made sympathetic…
Doctor_Who
Esmeralda sings a song to God though. I could see it getting by.
Totz the Plaid
A god, yes. The Christian interpretation? That’s a shaky interpretation.
It also makes a religious leader the villain, so…
Dean
A Catholic religious leader, don’t forget.
David Willis
In Disney’s version, Frollo is no longer technically a religious leader but a judge. They created a new character to be the benevolent head of the church just so the Christians didn’t get mad.
SUGauthor
I’ve been meaning to ask this for a while, what is your current religious status? Whenever I meet someone in person who wasn’t allowed to watch disney movies as a kid because they showed happiness without God’s love, they tended to grow up to become strict atheists. Just curious.
Alex Stritar
That does make sense. I had a more lazi-fair religious upbringing and I still identify as Christian. Maybe what they say about the tight grip is true.
TPman
Wait, you mean there are actually a lot of people who’s parents wouldn’t let them watch FREACKING DISNEY MOVIES because they’re “sinful”? I got that Willis was from some crazy background, but like, you’re talking about that like it’s somewhat typical.
Please god tell me that I’m misinterpreting.
Happiness without god’s love is bad? WTF? It’s happiness! How can happiness be bad?
SUGauthor
Well my parents were a lot like Dorothy’s, so maybe I’m not the best person to ask about this, but I have met people in my life who were Atheists because of their over bearing religious parents, and while my mom isn’t exactly atheist, I’d definitely say part of of the reason she raised me so casually religion wise is because of my extremely religious grandparents. I don’t know if they weren’t allowed to watch Disney movies, but frankly I wouldn’t be surprised. I’m guessing the reason happiness would be considered bad to a religious extremest would be because if your happy without God, that means you don’t need God, and just like that, you’re a gay atheist sleeping with 4 people at once shouting HAIL SATAN when you climax.
Jen Aside
WHAT YOU MEAN LOVE AT FIRST SIGHT AND HAPPILY EVER AFTER DOESN’T HAPPEN WITHOUT WORK
LIES
Van Dyne
I MEAN IT’S CRAZY
Kladeos
BLASPHEMY
Just a Web Comic Reader
MISANDRY
JUST BECAUSE ETHAN’S A GUY HE’S BEING BLAMED FOR SOMETHING
I CALL MISANDRY
Mr. Random
No, he’s being blamed because he isn’t meeting Joyce’s unrealistic expectations for a guy in a relationship.
Tunaro
Unrealistic in that people can fall in love within 5 seconds or that in she’s trying to do this with a self-confessed gay dude?
Sageress
Yes.
Arkantos
*Hits with Ki blast* WHAT DID I SAY?
Sageress
I didn’t think you’d remember aaaah
Totz the Plaid
I _THINK_ the “misandry” comment was a joke.
I mean an intentional joke. All comments claiming misandry and other MRA bullshit are jokes, but usually at the commenter’s expense.
Mr. Random
I realized about three seconds after i hit post comment.
Then again, someone was bound to do the same thing.
Jelli
He’s also being blamed for choosing to recloset himself and using Joyce as his beard.
KevinGriffin3CD
So really it’s gaysandry.
(I just wanted to make that a word…)
Narf
The mis- part is what denotes hatred, the -andry part denotes dudes. Gaysandry would be … I dunno, something about being gay for dudes? Huh. I guess that kind of works?
Dammit, I’m tired, leave me alone. 😛
anonymous
Homophobia should be called… *googles Greek word for homosexual*
…mysarsenocoity? Except that apparently would mean hatred for those who PRACTICE on their desires…
Mysarsenagapy?
Or I guess we could take the discrimination based on inherent sexuality and call that “agapism.” And discrimination against certain practiced sexualities would be “coitism.” …I’m beginning to doubt these coined words would mean what I want them to, though.
Jen Aside
Though, dear Alt Text, I should add that I really like Care Bears II BECAUSE it emphasizes friendship and forgiveness over vanquishing the enemy.
Despite the “clap your hands if you BELIEVE!” element.
Yotomoe
Clap your hands if you Believe in the lord and savior jesus christ
BlueRam
Clap your lesbians if your lesbian for Godoka
Rex Hondo
Just don’t make a big deal when Jesus doesn’t clap along. He’s self-conscious about how the holes in his hands make it sound wierd.
BlueRam
I find that sound quite holey.
Leorale
::swish-clap!:: ::swish-clap!:: ::swish-clap!::
Wut.
Anyone who can both whistle AND clap, using only their hands, simultaneously, could only be the second coming.
On the upside, you’d never get slapped by him, without prior notification.
Jelli
I really liked Care Bears 2 because they were also so adorable as babies and also there was now a horse and cat and a dog care bear. That was very important when I was 9.
nothri
I hear what you are saying, but nothing beats Carebears 1. Creepy-face-in-a-book lady still scares the crap of me even now.
Jen Aside
Actually, that face in the book reminds me of Sour Grapes from Strawberry Shortcake–it’s like they used the same model sheet =o (and same animators!)
gc
_”WHAT YOU MEAN LOVE AT FIRST SIGHT AND HAPPILY EVER AFTER DOESN’T HAPPEN WITHOUT WORK”_
Well, better a naïve view of love than one that makes it sound like a startup company (“doesn’t happen without work”).
Tunaro
So has Joyce like never seen any romantic comedy ever?
Azhrei Vep
Oh god, no. That would be WAY too raunchy for Joyce.
Mr. Random
Now what would she experience if she watched ‘bo strings attached’…
Ishai
She’d probably be screeching “Pre-Marital Hanky Panky” for a week.
Mr. Random
Bo strings attached. Mr. Burnham’s new puppet show.
Daddy
Why can I not find this on Google! It sounds hilarious!
Mr. Random
Now i wish it was real.
Wack'd
I’m imaging Joyce watching When Harry Met Sally now so thank you for that.
Yotomoe
I was thinking 40 year old Virgin. A movie Joyce would have liked up until the whole sex part.
Plasma Mongoose
I like to imagine that Joyce watched Romantic Comedies as a way of rebelling against her parents.
TPman
But that’s so evil! I dunno, I think Joyce rebelled by reading the bible after her curfew. Dun Dun Dun!
saltchocolate
Plasma! You’re Susan tonight! 😀
Plasma Mongoose
YES and it’s HAMMER TIME! ^_^
saltchocolate
Nobody wields a hammer like Susan! Make that two hammers!
Roborat
Bum-bum-bum-bum, you can’t touch this.
davidbreslin101
That’s possibly a good thing- some of those films are REALLY not examples to live your life by. My favourite ever Onion headline (from about 10 years ago) is “Man Arrested for Romantic Comedy Behavior.”
ankhtahr
I have most experience in this field from Disney movies.
Iit’s not really helping…
Mr. Random
Wait… Then where?
C.
Evangelical Christian movies/books/songs/etc.