I believe this is what Philip Sandifer termed a narrative collapse–when an in-universe threat is such that its success threatens to completely eliminate any potential for a story continue.
Since we know the comic lasts at least three more months, this will presumably be averted somehow.
For all we know, the comic ends tomorrow and the strips then and Sept 17 are just about butts disease! (it could happen! DW *is* an evil genius)
Lord Stoneheart
My first thought regarding that was “You mean there won’t be Dina in that triceratops costume?” This was eventually followed by “You mean there won’t be everyone else in the comic?”
Cholma
Not even Ruth could deprive Dina of her femurs. (the rest of the floor is not so lucky) Dina DOES “walk the dinosaur”, and also gets a bad (good?) case of Butts Disease. Decades later, she is still talked about in hushed tones by awed Freshmen.
She’s had 18 years of controls. She doesn’t need to test a different hypothesis until this one (‘do I enjoy kissing this girl who’s expressed interest in me?’) is determined to have failed.
Actually, that should be phrased as a statement. The hypothesis is ‘I enjoy kissing this girl’…’do I…’ is the question the hypothesis is answering if it’s correct.
Shade
Well, Dina is, if anything, a dedicated scientist. Or at the very least dedicated to the scientific method. She would be remiss if she didn’t explore this new development further.
David Alexander McDonald
From this point on, the comic is about Buttrocket.
…I could totally see Willis making fake images of future comics if he decided to end it. I don’t think he will since part of ending Shortpacked! was to focus on DoA, but still.
People don’t get expelled for one infraction. I got caught smoking pot and bringing hard liquor into my dorm 5 times and I never saw more than a letter of warning and a semester on probation.
Tacos
I’d assume it depends on the college on what it takes to expel someone.
Eva
Definitely depends on the school. Our RAs tell us to keep the door open when we drink and go 20 ft away from the building when we smoke weed. Other schools will expel you for being gay.
That would be such a twist if Dina’s into it, but Becky dumps her because she just can’t let go of her upbringing. You know, the non-anti-gay parts at least.
AgentKeen
She’s turned on by repeatedly testing hypotheses, so I think we’re ok.
‘Talky nerdy to me, baby…’
LeslieBean4Shizzle
Repeated kissing is an excellent method of performing science.
So THAT’S what you kids are calling it these days!
Rycan
What did you think we meant by ‘experimenting’?
overdosed
“sexual experimentaion is a process best repeated to support the hypothesis of possibly being lesbian when asked what sexuality i am”~ possible dina quote 2015 :3
Nobody
No need to be nervous. It’s just a simple test of stimulus and response.
Actually. . . that might save everyone involved here. Both Ruth and Joyce’s party will have equal dirt on the other, resulting in a no-expulsion truce of Mutually Assured Destruction.
LeslieBean4Shizzle
… except the one person you really don’t want to trust in a mutually assured destruction scenario IS Ruth.
Rowen Morland
Heck she’ll just go with her own assured destruction.
StClair
As a character in a… vaguely similar situation, else-fic, once said:
“You want to do this [terribly ill-advised and self-destructive thing]? Fine. Let’s all go together. I’ll drive.“
Billie has proof that Ruth’s been drinking though. Ruth trying to kick out Billie will result in Billie trying to kick out Ruth.
Mr. Morningstar
Would they really believe her though?
I mean, I would imagine trying to bring down the person who got you kicked out in the first place is a common thing.
Yet_One_More_Idiot
Ruthie’s gonna see Billie in the party and drag her outside to tell her off for getting the others drunk (because really, that is pretty obvious), and then their ensuing shouting match will lead to the two of them dragging each other off back to Ruthie’s room – or Billie’s – for lots of sexy goings-on. 😉 Meanwhile, everyone else just quickly and quietly packs up and goes back to their own rooms before Ruthie comes back again.
And Becky goes with Dina to continue testing her hypothesis. “Oh yeah, talk scientifically to me, baby!” :3
timemonkey
Billie’s room is right next door, so I doubt they’ll go there.
417 thoughts on “Hypotheses”
Jen Aside
then everyone was expelledCOMIC’S OVER
new comic: LAWsome SCHOOL
Justin
There are other characters to focus on! We’ve still got Joe, Mike, Roz, Mary…
Yeah OK they all kill each other in three days, comic over.
thecanvashat
So the comic still runs for five years.
JeremiahTheBulldog
At least through September 17th.
Garrett
We just have a Sal comic, with her crew and those other not in trouble characters you mentioned (plus Jacob)
a4lbi
Or it becomes the Carla and Sal show.
…
…
well maybe not but it’s really cool in my head.
Wack'd
I believe this is what Philip Sandifer termed a narrative collapse–when an in-universe threat is such that its success threatens to completely eliminate any potential for a story continue.
Since we know the comic lasts at least three more months, this will presumably be averted somehow.
Cholma
For all we know, the comic ends tomorrow and the strips then and Sept 17 are just about butts disease! (it could happen! DW *is* an evil genius)
Lord Stoneheart
My first thought regarding that was “You mean there won’t be Dina in that triceratops costume?” This was eventually followed by “You mean there won’t be everyone else in the comic?”
Cholma
Not even Ruth could deprive Dina of her femurs. (the rest of the floor is not so lucky) Dina DOES “walk the dinosaur”, and also gets a bad (good?) case of Butts Disease. Decades later, she is still talked about in hushed tones by awed Freshmen.
Plasma Mongoose
Now I kinda wanna see Dina use Ruth as a ‘control subject’. 😀
Kamino Neko
She’s had 18 years of controls. She doesn’t need to test a different hypothesis until this one (‘do I enjoy kissing this girl who’s expressed interest in me?’) is determined to have failed.
Kamino Neko
Actually, that should be phrased as a statement. The hypothesis is ‘I enjoy kissing this girl’…’do I…’ is the question the hypothesis is answering if it’s correct.
Shade
Well, Dina is, if anything, a dedicated scientist. Or at the very least dedicated to the scientific method. She would be remiss if she didn’t explore this new development further.
David Alexander McDonald
From this point on, the comic is about Buttrocket.
Ozzi
Ninja Butrocket, no latte is safe!
Osaru Sensei
Darth Willis, yeeeesss…
timemonkey
Considering the booze came from Billie reporting them would be like shooting herself in the leg.
Foxhack
I think it was that angry evil girl that reported them. The one that wasn’t invited. Whasshername.
Heatth
Mary?
Jacknoir
considering Ruth’s per-established self destructive streak that’s not exactly reassuring.
the bigger concern than the alcohol though is the fact that there is a homeless person squatting there illegally.
Kryss LaBryn
Prove it.
AgentKeen
…I could totally see Willis making fake images of future comics if he decided to end it. I don’t think he will since part of ending Shortpacked! was to focus on DoA, but still.
Kelly
I am reminded of Larry Niven’s “Down in Flames”, though he never went ahead with it.
Rowen Morland
🙁
Bibulb
Okay, giving you points for the reference there. I’ve been on a Known Space kick recently.
Kelly
Niven was pretty much my main intro to sci-fi as a kid!
Jonathan S
Frankly, given where the Ringworld stories went in the end, I think I’d rather have had “Down In Flames”.
That Damn Rat
Probably due to Ruth dragging Billie off for “Punishment”.
DarkoNeko
Kinky.
Kennerly
People don’t get expelled for one infraction. I got caught smoking pot and bringing hard liquor into my dorm 5 times and I never saw more than a letter of warning and a semester on probation.
Tacos
I’d assume it depends on the college on what it takes to expel someone.
Eva
Definitely depends on the school. Our RAs tell us to keep the door open when we drink and go 20 ft away from the building when we smoke weed. Other schools will expel you for being gay.
Nobody
Joyce might get expelled over letting Becky stay there, but how does Dina get expelled?
overdosed
oh no
Wire Segal
please let her like chicks
the ship must go on
Agemegos
Please let Becky like scientists!
JessWitt
She wants to make crazy science with Dina.
Mr. Morningstar
sexy science?
Doctor_Who
That would be such a twist if Dina’s into it, but Becky dumps her because she just can’t let go of her upbringing. You know, the non-anti-gay parts at least.
AgentKeen
She’s turned on by repeatedly testing hypotheses, so I think we’re ok.
‘Talky nerdy to me, baby…’
LeslieBean4Shizzle
Repeated kissing is an excellent method of performing science.
Packy
So THAT’S what you kids are calling it these days!
Rycan
What did you think we meant by ‘experimenting’?
overdosed
“sexual experimentaion is a process best repeated to support the hypothesis of possibly being lesbian when asked what sexuality i am”~ possible dina quote 2015 :3
Nobody
No need to be nervous. It’s just a simple test of stimulus and response.
Willoughby Chase
Becky is *blinded* by science – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-FIMvSp01C8
Scott John Harrison
I was afraid that no one else would mention this. (My fault for searching for “She Blinded”)
Taigan
I was literally going to sleep and thinking I wouldn’t wait up for the update, when I suddenly remembered what happened in the last strip.
DarkoNeko
You tell them, Dina !
DarkoNeko
Now if Billie suddenly kisses Ruth out of the blue, that would be both hilarous (for the moment) and horrifying (for their future).
Wire Segal
Billie’ll have enough self-control to avoid that kinda thing.
Right?
Right???
Oh no.
Cin
That’s wildly inappropriate unless you scream “FOR SCIENCE!” right before doing it.
Doctor_Who
I’m pretty sure you can excuse just about any behavior by saying “FOR SCIENCE!” before doing it.
It’s like the intellectual version of “Hey y’all, watch this!”
TJ in Pittsburgh
As an actual real-life scientist, I am going to test this hypothesis. Especially after a lot of alcohol consumption.
Tacos
FOR SCIENCE, of course.
overdosed
“thats real science”~ dr membrane from invader zim
this quote best fit this reply :3 you’re welcome
Andrew
Actually. . . that might save everyone involved here. Both Ruth and Joyce’s party will have equal dirt on the other, resulting in a no-expulsion truce of Mutually Assured Destruction.
LeslieBean4Shizzle
… except the one person you really don’t want to trust in a mutually assured destruction scenario IS Ruth.
Rowen Morland
Heck she’ll just go with her own assured destruction.
StClair
As a character in a… vaguely similar situation, else-fic, once said:
“You want to do this [terribly ill-advised and self-destructive thing]? Fine. Let’s all go together. I’ll drive.“
addude
Time to place bets on who will be kick out first.
JessWitt
Billie? Yeah, Billie.
Airyu
Billie has proof that Ruth’s been drinking though. Ruth trying to kick out Billie will result in Billie trying to kick out Ruth.
Mr. Morningstar
Would they really believe her though?
I mean, I would imagine trying to bring down the person who got you kicked out in the first place is a common thing.
Yet_One_More_Idiot
Ruthie’s gonna see Billie in the party and drag her outside to tell her off for getting the others drunk (because really, that is pretty obvious), and then their ensuing shouting match will lead to the two of them dragging each other off back to Ruthie’s room – or Billie’s – for lots of sexy goings-on. 😉 Meanwhile, everyone else just quickly and quietly packs up and goes back to their own rooms before Ruthie comes back again.
And Becky goes with Dina to continue testing her hypothesis. “Oh yeah, talk scientifically to me, baby!” :3
timemonkey
Billie’s room is right next door, so I doubt they’ll go there.
Qwil man
I completely forgot about the anime door
Chinoy Industries, Ltd.
(Rocks fall, everyone dies)
MatttheeTheLucky
i ended a performance project for school that way once.
Disloyal Subject
Where did the rocks come from?
StrawGirl
Several people called the third panel’s response yesterday. Props!
Leorale
YEAH DINA
Also, Ruth should’ve waited, they were gonna test their hypothesis repeatedly! Dangit Ruth!