The thing is, the sort of attitude shown in this strip isn’t helping the Lelands of the world, either. I’m not into punative measures of justice, but there are people who others bend over backwards to AVOID teaching them any sort of responsibility, and it doesn’t end well. See the ‘affluenza’ kid where the defense was basically he was so rich and his parents were so shitty at actually raising him he didn’t know not to drive drunk. Not only is that defense all sorts of bullshit, by the defense itself HIS PARENTS WERE NOT DOING THEIR JOB.
(((Mkvenner)))
Ooooooh we could send Leland to Ms. Susan’s class that would take care of both the little bastard and his parents in one go.
ioasuka
I admittedly just Googled “Walkyverse Ms. Susan” with no clear results, is she from a Willis comic? or someplace else?
Libsent
Miss Susan is from Terry Pratchett’s Discworld series.. She’s a primary teacher and nanny in the books as well as a duchess. Ands he’s also death’s granddaughter, which gives her certain gifts.
Jhon
Try “Susan Sto Helit”. What is wrong with you people?
Gordon
Not only did he not know to drive drunk. He didn’t know that shoplifting alcohol while underage and then driving drunk was bad and would have serious negative consequences and therefore he shouldn’t be liable for his actions.
There’s something horribly wrong with the world when articles from the Onion end up coming true.
David
Well, were you expecting “poetic justice” like in Shakespeare’s “Titus Andronicus” where two guys who raped a girl and cut off her hands and tongue so she won’t tell on them (spoiler: she still does) are punished by being served to their Gothic Queen mother (well, not exactly because she wasn’t doing her job) after turning them into pastry? Still, the victim in that play gets killed by her father since he does not care for a permanent reminder of “his” loss.
There is a lesson in that, and lots of pig blood flooding the stage.
SgtWadeyWilson
I believe the lesson is: “Maybe Shakespeare would’ve benefited from some therapy?”
Funny, when a kid beat me up at school, I got the opposite justification. “He has a troubled home and is going through a difficult time, so it’s really your fault that he broke your nose and gave you two black eyes after you splashed him.”
It’s not even a commentary on the current climate. He’s written ’em months in advance. It’s just the general failure to acknowledge that a white cis dude from a well-to-do family can be a shithead.
I think that Willis might be doing an homage to Dead Poet’s Society with this backstory. Asshole upper-crust private school administrators caring more about the reputation of their school among the rich “elite” than caring for the children in their charge, or teaching them any kind of responsibility, is an old trope. And it has been around for so long probably because it reflects the truth often enough.
Given the hints Willis has been dropping lately, I’d say Brock Turner is the main inspiration from this one, but there’s really no end to rich white guys getting slaps on the wrists for their crimes while the victims get victim blamed.
Kris
Exactly. I honestly think any outcome short of Marcie dying would have turned out like this. Very common.
Reltzik
Wow, really? I thought the parade of rich white guys getting slaps on the wrists ended when we reached the ones that don’t get slaps on the wrists.
…. yeah, I know, I could be giving a dose of sunshine, but it’s the midnight here. What do you expect?
Hiraku
What school ISN’T doing that
(((Mkvenner)))
It’s not really a trope.
JonRich
It’s absolutely a trope. Sometimes fiction reflects life, after all. I’m not sure if it’s on TV Tropes, but it’s definitely a trope. “Rich (or simply a “good”) boy gets away with bullying/(insert crime here) while the victim is punished” definitely happens quite a bit, both in fiction and, sadly, in life.
If by “years” y’all mean “decades” or maybe “centuries” y’all might be getting closer to the truth. It’s been around at least since the first king’s first bratty son got his whipping boy.
(((Mkvenner)))
The demographic that’s mainly responsible is dying out rapidly or that’s how long before Armageddon.
Bird
There is no “demographic that’s mainly responsible”. 20-year-olds are just as capable of perpetuating this nonsense as 50-year-olds, and frequently do (while patting ourselves on the back for being “the progressive generation”).
Oysteinthenoisy
This has gone on forever. I live in Columbus and am sorry that Turner didn’t get put away for at least twenty years. Other than his family and out of touch rich friends, nobody here is happy he’s back. We all think justice was mocked.
By forever, I meant that history is a tale of the richest, the strongest, and the most powerful taking whatever they want and receiving no negative consequences. What’s happening now is not a recent phenomenon.
It’s also important not to forget that one’s ethnicity, nationality, gender identity, sexuality, immigrant status, physical well-being and mental capacity — don’t exempt one from being a horrible person. Because, SPOILERS: Those are all PEOPLE and PEOPLE often suck. We pick favourites and divide each other into little groups because we are dumb and immature and have to see the world through our little lenses where the bad SORT gets punished and the good SORT are all brave, beautiful struggling souls. We want to improve the world by swapping the consensus on who the BAD SORT are and who the GOOD SORT ought to be, never realising that the act of doing that in the first place makes us no worse than the bigots we condemn. No wonder the furries and otherkin want to ditch this species so bad.
Solarn
Yes, why don’t you tell us more about how there are also bad minority folks, as if that somehow negated the fact that people in the majority get far more protection for their bad deeds.
Emma
Hoo boy, do I really wish these comments had a “like” option.
3-I
Seconded. Right on, Solarn.
Janine
By ‘minorities’ you mean black and hispanic people right? Because… that notion kind of falls apart once you look at literally any other minority in the states. They are definitely unjustly persecuted by the police and in poverty caused by white people, but their problems don’t stem from there being less of them but from toxic preconceptions. No one complains that asians earn far more money on average than white people.
Lailah
That’s because they don’t. The kids of well-off chinese and korean immigrants do, but asians as a whole still get screwed.
I wouldn’t even say white and cis have a play here. I’m sure they do at some level, but people like this tend not to be able to see beyond “well-to-do family” and some strange idea that they might ingratiate themselves to said family and either inherit the wealth or save themselves a 1980s college movie of trouble.
thejeff
Except that white is often a proxy for “well-to-do” – or more accurately the other way around – not-white implies poor.
Maybe Leland’s family is richer, but the Walkerton’s are pretty well off themselves, IIRC. And Billie’s family is even more so. We really know nothing about the relative wealth of Leland’s family.
Maybe it’s just a coincidence that the school’s catering to the only white kid involved in the incident, but I wouldn’t bet on it.
3-I
Being seen as “normal” and “default” as opposed to the other represented by angry biracial girl Sal and “possibly illegal” Marcie absolutely plays into this. Don’t discount race just because of class, when race is often a determining factor in class status.
Wait, I’m confused, I thought Adam Ruins Everything? *rimshot*
Pantheon the Mantheon
Hi, I’m Adam Conover and I’ve got a couple of things to share about the /real/ consequences of thinking shielding people from consequences will somehow make the world better in any way. This is, Adam Ruins Everything!
Athedia
See at least Adam admits to ruining everything. He is honest about it.
It’s the people who claim 4 ways to Sunday that they are helping that you have to watch out for.
Who is the victim here? Marcie clearly crossed a boundary here. He was merely defending his school premises against the incursion of illegals. Leland should build a fence around the school and let Marcie pay for it. Presidential material, that.
Reltzik
The school should pay for it, because they’re the ones who would end up owning the fence. Otherwise, sure. I love this plan. Give Leland about three hundred hours of community service building the fence.
(Yes I know you were being something adjacent to sarcasm and/or parody and I’m not missing the point, just playing with the idea some.)
thejeff
Well, though I’m all for letting Marcie in, a fence between the playground and the ditch filled with construction rubble wouldn’t be a bad thing.
And I approve of Leland building it – or at least doing some of the helping, elementary school kids doing construction work isn’t really a great plan.
It’s called dumbing of age. The adults (well, parental-generation adults – all of the characters are adults in the present day) have more age, therefore they do more dumbing.
No. I look and I read. I find it the easiest way to consume this particular medium.
miados
to be fair if the adult actually did what they should have or raised him better he might not be like that.
that being said he is like that so smack him upside the head and tell him to stop being a bongo
Reltzik
Because corporal punishment ALWAYS makes kids moral!
Seriously, isn’t there research being done on how to reform bullies? There’s got to be a solution more sophisticated than just targeting them with vitriol, right? I’m not saying they don’t deserve scorn and censure, but does that actually lead to them no longer being bullies?
TheAnonymousGuy
Corral punishment is actually legal in most states, they just don’t do it.
vlademir1
Legality doesn’t shield them from liability for injury, including psychological injury, nor the costs of mounting a legal defense. The fact that we socially don’t any longer consider it appropriate for anyone but a child’s parents to use corporal punishment on that child suggests it would be exceptionally difficult to get a jurry to not award for plaintiff. Hence, corporal punishment doesn’t get used because schools don’t want to face and/or couldn’t afford lawsuits.
Zach
YES. Operant conditioning is a powerful teacher, just like fear.
It would be NICE if he didn’t want to beat others with impunity, but it is NECESSARY that he stop.
Or maybe he’s really good at swimming… We might never know if we punish him now! I’m sure letting this behavior slide will have no negative consequences whatsoever.
Kris
I just think it’s money because the voice specifically said there’s so much “at risk”. Like what could that mean besides money?
Pantheon the Mantheon
I figured as much. Just thought I could also throw in some scalding social commentary of relevant recent events
556 thoughts on “Liability”
Ana Chronistic
fuckin boys always being so good and full of promise when they injure people and riot and shit
THIS IS TOTES NOT COMMENTARY ON THE CURRENT POLITICAL CLIMATE IS IT
Wheelpath
Everyone who’s ever had “he’s a good kid” or some variation of that as their defense deserves to be taught a damn thing or two
Petra
The thing is, the sort of attitude shown in this strip isn’t helping the Lelands of the world, either. I’m not into punative measures of justice, but there are people who others bend over backwards to AVOID teaching them any sort of responsibility, and it doesn’t end well. See the ‘affluenza’ kid where the defense was basically he was so rich and his parents were so shitty at actually raising him he didn’t know not to drive drunk. Not only is that defense all sorts of bullshit, by the defense itself HIS PARENTS WERE NOT DOING THEIR JOB.
(((Mkvenner)))
Ooooooh we could send Leland to Ms. Susan’s class that would take care of both the little bastard and his parents in one go.
ioasuka
I admittedly just Googled “Walkyverse Ms. Susan” with no clear results, is she from a Willis comic? or someplace else?
Libsent
Miss Susan is from Terry Pratchett’s Discworld series.. She’s a primary teacher and nanny in the books as well as a duchess. Ands he’s also death’s granddaughter, which gives her certain gifts.
Jhon
Try “Susan Sto Helit”. What is wrong with you people?
Gordon
Not only did he not know to drive drunk. He didn’t know that shoplifting alcohol while underage and then driving drunk was bad and would have serious negative consequences and therefore he shouldn’t be liable for his actions.
It didn’t work..completely.
Truk2
http://www.theonion.com/article/wealthy-teen-nearly-experiences-consequence-2551
Fart Captor
There’s something horribly wrong with the world when articles from the Onion end up coming true.
David
Well, were you expecting “poetic justice” like in Shakespeare’s “Titus Andronicus” where two guys who raped a girl and cut off her hands and tongue so she won’t tell on them (spoiler: she still does) are punished by being served to their Gothic Queen mother (well, not exactly because she wasn’t doing her job) after turning them into pastry? Still, the victim in that play gets killed by her father since he does not care for a permanent reminder of “his” loss.
There is a lesson in that, and lots of pig blood flooding the stage.
SgtWadeyWilson
I believe the lesson is: “Maybe Shakespeare would’ve benefited from some therapy?”
Howard Bannister
“…from Shakespeare’s brief Quentin Tarantino phase.”
Betrayer
Funny, when a kid beat me up at school, I got the opposite justification. “He has a troubled home and is going through a difficult time, so it’s really your fault that he broke your nose and gave you two black eyes after you splashed him.”
Mollyscribbles
It’s not even a commentary on the current climate. He’s written ’em months in advance. It’s just the general failure to acknowledge that a white cis dude from a well-to-do family can be a shithead.
TemporalShrew
I mean, the current climate has been like this for a good bit longer than a few months, in fairness.
Fred
At least a few decades … or longer … by my count.
(((Mkvenner)))
it’s been lurking in the shadows.
TeamAG
I think that Willis might be doing an homage to Dead Poet’s Society with this backstory. Asshole upper-crust private school administrators caring more about the reputation of their school among the rich “elite” than caring for the children in their charge, or teaching them any kind of responsibility, is an old trope. And it has been around for so long probably because it reflects the truth often enough.
Cerberus
Given the hints Willis has been dropping lately, I’d say Brock Turner is the main inspiration from this one, but there’s really no end to rich white guys getting slaps on the wrists for their crimes while the victims get victim blamed.
Kris
Exactly. I honestly think any outcome short of Marcie dying would have turned out like this. Very common.
Reltzik
Wow, really? I thought the parade of rich white guys getting slaps on the wrists ended when we reached the ones that don’t get slaps on the wrists.
…. yeah, I know, I could be giving a dose of sunshine, but it’s the midnight here. What do you expect?
Hiraku
What school ISN’T doing that
(((Mkvenner)))
It’s not really a trope.
JonRich
It’s absolutely a trope. Sometimes fiction reflects life, after all. I’m not sure if it’s on TV Tropes, but it’s definitely a trope. “Rich (or simply a “good”) boy gets away with bullying/(insert crime here) while the victim is punished” definitely happens quite a bit, both in fiction and, sadly, in life.
Ana Chronistic
yeah, “current climate” means like the last two or three years, possibly longer
(((Mkvenner)))
at this point it’s more like 10 years at the least.
DSL
If by “years” y’all mean “decades” or maybe “centuries” y’all might be getting closer to the truth. It’s been around at least since the first king’s first bratty son got his whipping boy.
(((Mkvenner)))
The demographic that’s mainly responsible is dying out rapidly or that’s how long before Armageddon.
Bird
There is no “demographic that’s mainly responsible”. 20-year-olds are just as capable of perpetuating this nonsense as 50-year-olds, and frequently do (while patting ourselves on the back for being “the progressive generation”).
Oysteinthenoisy
This has gone on forever. I live in Columbus and am sorry that Turner didn’t get put away for at least twenty years. Other than his family and out of touch rich friends, nobody here is happy he’s back. We all think justice was mocked.
By forever, I meant that history is a tale of the richest, the strongest, and the most powerful taking whatever they want and receiving no negative consequences. What’s happening now is not a recent phenomenon.
Janine
It’s also important not to forget that one’s ethnicity, nationality, gender identity, sexuality, immigrant status, physical well-being and mental capacity — don’t exempt one from being a horrible person. Because, SPOILERS: Those are all PEOPLE and PEOPLE often suck. We pick favourites and divide each other into little groups because we are dumb and immature and have to see the world through our little lenses where the bad SORT gets punished and the good SORT are all brave, beautiful struggling souls. We want to improve the world by swapping the consensus on who the BAD SORT are and who the GOOD SORT ought to be, never realising that the act of doing that in the first place makes us no worse than the bigots we condemn. No wonder the furries and otherkin want to ditch this species so bad.
Solarn
Yes, why don’t you tell us more about how there are also bad minority folks, as if that somehow negated the fact that people in the majority get far more protection for their bad deeds.
Emma
Hoo boy, do I really wish these comments had a “like” option.
3-I
Seconded. Right on, Solarn.
Janine
By ‘minorities’ you mean black and hispanic people right? Because… that notion kind of falls apart once you look at literally any other minority in the states. They are definitely unjustly persecuted by the police and in poverty caused by white people, but their problems don’t stem from there being less of them but from toxic preconceptions. No one complains that asians earn far more money on average than white people.
Lailah
That’s because they don’t. The kids of well-off chinese and korean immigrants do, but asians as a whole still get screwed.
Furie
I wouldn’t even say white and cis have a play here. I’m sure they do at some level, but people like this tend not to be able to see beyond “well-to-do family” and some strange idea that they might ingratiate themselves to said family and either inherit the wealth or save themselves a 1980s college movie of trouble.
thejeff
Except that white is often a proxy for “well-to-do” – or more accurately the other way around – not-white implies poor.
Maybe Leland’s family is richer, but the Walkerton’s are pretty well off themselves, IIRC. And Billie’s family is even more so. We really know nothing about the relative wealth of Leland’s family.
Maybe it’s just a coincidence that the school’s catering to the only white kid involved in the incident, but I wouldn’t bet on it.
3-I
Being seen as “normal” and “default” as opposed to the other represented by angry biracial girl Sal and “possibly illegal” Marcie absolutely plays into this. Don’t discount race just because of class, when race is often a determining factor in class status.
(((Mkvenner)))
You can’t swing a dead cat without it being a commentary on the current political climate. The dark horrible political climate.
dom
That kid is Brock Turner
Nono
Dumbing of Age: ADULTS RUIN EVERYTHING
DRA2840
Life: ADULTS RUIN EVERYTHING
Flipz
Wait, I’m confused, I thought Adam Ruins Everything? *rimshot*
Pantheon the Mantheon
Hi, I’m Adam Conover and I’ve got a couple of things to share about the /real/ consequences of thinking shielding people from consequences will somehow make the world better in any way. This is, Adam Ruins Everything!
Athedia
See at least Adam admits to ruining everything. He is honest about it.
It’s the people who claim 4 ways to Sunday that they are helping that you have to watch out for.
Pantheon the Mantheon
I identify with Adam on a spiritual level.
That Damn Rat
Adam is an adult is he not?
Chandra
But kids would run things right
(((Mkvenner)))
Humans ruin everything.
TheAnonymousGuy
Fuck this shit, don’t punish the bully, play it off on the victim
(((Mkvenner)))
And then people are surprised when the their senator makes comments using the phrase “legitimate rape”.
David
Who is the victim here? Marcie clearly crossed a boundary here. He was merely defending his school premises against the incursion of illegals. Leland should build a fence around the school and let Marcie pay for it. Presidential material, that.
Reltzik
The school should pay for it, because they’re the ones who would end up owning the fence. Otherwise, sure. I love this plan. Give Leland about three hundred hours of community service building the fence.
(Yes I know you were being something adjacent to sarcasm and/or parody and I’m not missing the point, just playing with the idea some.)
thejeff
Well, though I’m all for letting Marcie in, a fence between the playground and the ditch filled with construction rubble wouldn’t be a bad thing.
And I approve of Leland building it – or at least doing some of the helping, elementary school kids doing construction work isn’t really a great plan.
Random832
It’s called dumbing of age. The adults (well, parental-generation adults – all of the characters are adults in the present day) have more age, therefore they do more dumbing.
Blackbird
Fuckin’ Leland
Jackson
Fuckin. Leland.
Dana
No, fuckin’ Marcie. Don’t you listen?
Blackbird
No. I look and I read. I find it the easiest way to consume this particular medium.
miados
to be fair if the adult actually did what they should have or raised him better he might not be like that.
that being said he is like that so smack him upside the head and tell him to stop being a bongo
Reltzik
Because corporal punishment ALWAYS makes kids moral!
Seriously, isn’t there research being done on how to reform bullies? There’s got to be a solution more sophisticated than just targeting them with vitriol, right? I’m not saying they don’t deserve scorn and censure, but does that actually lead to them no longer being bullies?
TheAnonymousGuy
Corral punishment is actually legal in most states, they just don’t do it.
vlademir1
Legality doesn’t shield them from liability for injury, including psychological injury, nor the costs of mounting a legal defense. The fact that we socially don’t any longer consider it appropriate for anyone but a child’s parents to use corporal punishment on that child suggests it would be exceptionally difficult to get a jurry to not award for plaintiff. Hence, corporal punishment doesn’t get used because schools don’t want to face and/or couldn’t afford lawsuits.
Zach
YES. Operant conditioning is a powerful teacher, just like fear.
It would be NICE if he didn’t want to beat others with impunity, but it is NECESSARY that he stop.
Jackson
FUCKIN.
LELAND.
Kris
But…but Leland is so full of promise!…..Promise most likely meaning money his family donates to the school.
Pantheon the Mantheon
Or maybe he’s really good at swimming… We might never know if we punish him now! I’m sure letting this behavior slide will have no negative consequences whatsoever.
Kris
I just think it’s money because the voice specifically said there’s so much “at risk”. Like what could that mean besides money?
Pantheon the Mantheon
I figured as much. Just thought I could also throw in some scalding social commentary of relevant recent events
Reltzik
Nononono. “Promise” is indicative of future potential. It clearly indicates money that his family WILL donate to the school.
Nono
Also, what is Marcie’s ethnicity? It’s not explicitly established is it?
Jay Eff