Admittedly it would make for some interesting dynamics (such as Sarah being jealous, or walky trying to win Lucy back).
But would they have much to connect over? Lucy is into cartoons while Jacob is more of a sports guy. I think they are in different courses too. Plus, Jacob was impressed with Joyce’s actions… Not sure if Lucy has a strong enough character yet.
Jacob dated Raidah and they had nothing in common aside from performative box-checking. Lucy is a “nice girl” he can bring home to his family, and she might even belong to the same religion. They could both do worse. It would be funny if his family hates her though and is just as rude as Walky’s mom.
KM
Well Jacob’s Episcopal while Lucy seems to be some sort of vaguely defined nondenominational liberal Protestant, seeing as she attended the same services as Becky et. al. But I guess they can’t be too serious about it if Jacob was in a serious relationship with Raidah.
Mturtle7
Raidah was also a pre-law student, like Jacob; presumably that’s how they met, and one of the primary things they had to talk about together. I can’t actually remember what Lucy’s major is, but I don’t think it’s pre-law.
Also, remember that Lucy just broke up with Walky yesterday, SPECIFICALLY because she realized she had been idealizing romance way too much, and needed to take a break to think about what she actually wanted out of life. I don’t think she’s going to want to get together with yet another earnest, hot, and kind of oblivious dude after meeting him for the first time.
Personally, I’ve always found that a partner with wildly different interests just means more opportunities to learn about new things with someone whose company I enjoy.
Formerly Glenn
My wife and my interests have very little overlap, but we get along great and always support each other’s hobbies.
People don’t have to have the same interests as their SOs.
Shipped them a long time ago but it seemed too hijinx free to happen. Church going serious students who will spend time building a relationship. Maybe Lucy needed to go through a Walky phase first.
They’re also both on the periphery of the main cast. Hook them up and they’d likely lose most of their connection to others and we wouldn’t see much of them.
If Raidah sees him with Lucy, rest assured that she will retaliate, if she already did a cowardly act by annoying Dorothy, she will do it again.
thejeff
Though it would be amusing if Lucy went to another breakfast/lunch with Raidah and invited her new boyfriend along without mentioning names to either side.
Nymph
Not sure Lucy would get to go to another breakfast with Raidah without Walky. They were only invited because of Walky’s perceived “in” with the Dean. Lucy was collateral, not genuine interest.
thejeff
Probably true, though I still think Raidah’s plotting something against Joyce and Sarah, not just social climbing.
Bryy
Ridah’s entire plan hinges on the fact that people only like other people because they are popular. It’s incredibly hollow and flawed.
Bryy
Raidah is probably going to take Lucy dating Jacob as some sort of chess move by Joyce.
They are like if you took [earlier] Joyce, dialed her back to about half, and took [earlier] Dorothy, dialed her back to about half, and then unqueered the situation.
justin8448
This take is both hilarious and accurate.
Reltzik
…. I don’t disagree, but when you put it that way it sounds like “Triple Vanilla”.
anon
triple vanilla would be a great name for something lol
They are both Black and Christian, perhaps even the same denomination. They are both pretty serious people, good at school, without obvious crippling hangups (aside from the Christian brainwashing.) We don’t know if he is into anything other than working out and school, and checking performative boxes to please his family, but maybe that’s enough? Their families might get along. I betcha he could use some cartoon and movie watching to destress.
Sirksome
See, to me that’s all what is so unappealing about them. They’re so similar it would just be two people with similar personalities and interests getting along. It’s kind of boring to me. Sal and Danny are interesting because they’re so different. Danny being the opposite of what you’d expect a “cool” girl like Sal to want. Or supremely horny Becky dating a likely ace or demisexual. Joe and Joyce fit this dynamic too.
What are Jacob and Lucy? What do they have to play off each other with?
Jeremiah
It is a pretty simple “two cute people that would be nice if they were happy together” thing. That can not be your thing but it’s not more complicated than that.
Ed Callahan
In terms of the narrative, given how extreme most of the main characters are, some straight men would be beneficial.
Ntrovert
Absolutely. While I completely get that a good chunk of readership enjoy enjoys combining people with very different personalities (which is part of the college experience for many), some others aren’t looking for all drama all the time. I think that Jacob and Lucy probably fall into that category. They are both genuinely nice people who deserve some happiness, too.
KM
Jacob’s been pretty clearly confirmed Episcopal while Lucy seems to attend the same services as Becky so not likely to be the same denomination at least.
Schpoonman
The entire situation with Joyce showed that he didn’t actually like filling out checkboxes to please his family. He likes filling out checkboxes, but he still wants those to please himself.
100% because of that time Jacob realized he’d like someone who is like Joyce but isn’t Joyce. I have zero strong feelings about Jacob/Lucy—they hadn’t even met until just now!—but I’ve been curious about the possibility ever since.
thejeff
Except the similarities are superficial and the differences run deep.
Lucy hasn’t punched out a kidnapper, for example. And I can’t really see her doing it.
Shogeton
I think the things that Jacob is interested in aren’t the kidnapper punching, but some things they do have in common. Both of them are upbeat, earnest and extroverted.
thejeff
He commented specifically about how much that impressed him.
Username Taken
I’d guess that “punched a kidnapper” isn’t a minimum dating standard for Jacob even if it impressed him.
thejeff
No, but it suggests it isn’t just the superficial “upbeat, earnest and extroverted” part that worked on him.
There is an argument that Lucy could be what Jacob is looking for. But it’s a flawed argument. The chemistry is impossible to predict and so it is interesting.
The only issue with Jacob is having an unlikeable girlfriend, the only issue with Lucy is being terminally horny. Otherwise, they are both way to well adjusted to be main characters in this comic:)
Li
I do Not understand the “terminally horny” take on Lucy. It wouldn’t be much of a flaw even if it were one, but I think her excitement to have sex for the first time is at a pretty normal level for 18/19. Her flaw, such as it was, was more her idealized, unrealistic expectations for a first relationship. And now she’s Had her first relationship, so that part is at least somewhat mitigated.
Lee
I agree. I wouldn’t call her terminally horny, she just had the typical teen romance novel and movie idea of how a first boyfriend should go. X number of dates, say Y specially at point Z, sex is supposed to happen.
HueSatLight
He seems naive to me at times. His apparent patience with Sarah sometimes feels like he’s trying to teach her to be social by saying earnestly, “have you tried not being introverted?”
My guess would be that both Jacob and Lucy have been done dirty by main characters recently (Joyce’s manipulative behavior and Walky’s spinelessness, respectively). So you kind of want to just see two (mostly) well-adjusted people have a quiet, happy relationship now that they’ve paid their debts to the Relationship Drama Gods.
Needfuldoer
Take this reply in lieu of an upvote, because I agree with your take.
I figured it was either gonna be her or Jocelyne. The latter of which would have been funny in terms of “just how badly can the universe possibly fuck with Ethan,” but would have limited potential for development unless she was actually sticking around long-term, which was always a long shot.
195 thoughts on “Mundanely-occurring”
Ana Chronistic
“DON’T SPEAK FOR ME AS THOUGH YOU WERE MY FRIEND OR EVEN ACKNOWLEDGE MY EXISTENCE”
Doctor_Who
“Okay.”
“THAT’S ACKNOWLEDGEMENT!”
Animedingo
Heres a combo I hadnt considered…
Marvelman
I have!
Thag Simmons
Trying to remember if they ever interacted much in Shortpacked!, I can’t recall anything in specific.
Verdande
Actually I think Jacob had a bit of a thing for her in Shortpacked! Nothing ever came of it, tho (Lucy started dating Ken iirc)
Segnosaur
You mean a romantic combo?
Admittedly it would make for some interesting dynamics (such as Sarah being jealous, or walky trying to win Lucy back).
But would they have much to connect over? Lucy is into cartoons while Jacob is more of a sports guy. I think they are in different courses too. Plus, Jacob was impressed with Joyce’s actions… Not sure if Lucy has a strong enough character yet.
Vanessa
Jacob dated Raidah and they had nothing in common aside from performative box-checking. Lucy is a “nice girl” he can bring home to his family, and she might even belong to the same religion. They could both do worse. It would be funny if his family hates her though and is just as rude as Walky’s mom.
KM
Well Jacob’s Episcopal while Lucy seems to be some sort of vaguely defined nondenominational liberal Protestant, seeing as she attended the same services as Becky et. al. But I guess they can’t be too serious about it if Jacob was in a serious relationship with Raidah.
Mturtle7
Raidah was also a pre-law student, like Jacob; presumably that’s how they met, and one of the primary things they had to talk about together. I can’t actually remember what Lucy’s major is, but I don’t think it’s pre-law.
Also, remember that Lucy just broke up with Walky yesterday, SPECIFICALLY because she realized she had been idealizing romance way too much, and needed to take a break to think about what she actually wanted out of life. I don’t think she’s going to want to get together with yet another earnest, hot, and kind of oblivious dude after meeting him for the first time.
BBCC
She’s in telecommunications, like Walky is.
Xujhan
Personally, I’ve always found that a partner with wildly different interests just means more opportunities to learn about new things with someone whose company I enjoy.
Formerly Glenn
My wife and my interests have very little overlap, but we get along great and always support each other’s hobbies.
People don’t have to have the same interests as their SOs.
NGPZ
It would be an effective way to kill two birds with one stone, namely Walky x Lucy and Sarah x Jacob.
TheLurkerAbove
Ooo, that’d be an interesting couple, I’d say!
ValdVin
I have, especially since Lucy is like a normal, presentable version of Joyce.
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2019/comic/book-9-comic/02-but-the-sun-still-shines/guys-2/
Roe
i screamed!!! thank you
Colineo
Slipshine material
Hof1991
Shipped them a long time ago but it seemed too hijinx free to happen. Church going serious students who will spend time building a relationship. Maybe Lucy needed to go through a Walky phase first.
thejeff
They’re also both on the periphery of the main cast. Hook them up and they’d likely lose most of their connection to others and we wouldn’t see much of them.
davidbreslin101
Glad I’m not the only one who suddenly built a ship out of 3 panels….
Marvelman
I’ve been waiting for this moment for… forever!
Clif
Same.
NGPZ
Lucy, that’s not anti-social, that’s asocial.
They’re not the same, don’t conflate them.
brute
thank you
Regret
I agree that the distinction is important, but I’m pretty sure Sarah is both.
Hambone Jones
What part of Sarah’s misanthropy isn’t antisocial? At times, she’s like a less funny Mike.
HueSatLight
none of it is anti-social. It’s asocial.
Schpoonman
I’ve been waiting for this ever since Jacob said he was updating what he was looking for in a relationship.
Bryy
They are going to bang so goddamn hard.
Amós Batista
…in Christ.
Marvelman
Right! Lucy & Joyce do have similar personalities.
Schpoonman
This is going to end with Lucy and Jacob attending another breakfast/lunch with Raidah and her posse and Jacob defending her better, isn’t it?
UrsulaDavina
I’m pretty sure that won’t happen Raidah and Jacob broke up and Raidah did not take it well.
Coatl
If Raidah sees him with Lucy, rest assured that she will retaliate, if she already did a cowardly act by annoying Dorothy, she will do it again.
thejeff
Though it would be amusing if Lucy went to another breakfast/lunch with Raidah and invited her new boyfriend along without mentioning names to either side.
Nymph
Not sure Lucy would get to go to another breakfast with Raidah without Walky. They were only invited because of Walky’s perceived “in” with the Dean. Lucy was collateral, not genuine interest.
thejeff
Probably true, though I still think Raidah’s plotting something against Joyce and Sarah, not just social climbing.
Bryy
Ridah’s entire plan hinges on the fact that people only like other people because they are popular. It’s incredibly hollow and flawed.
Bryy
Raidah is probably going to take Lucy dating Jacob as some sort of chess move by Joyce.
Hoboturtle
Ranking characters base on how Joyce-like they are:
1. Joyce
2. Liz
3. Lucy
Marvelman
How is Liz Joyce-like?
Sirksome
I’m actually really interested in what people see in this couple so I’m sincerely asking why people want it? Just cause they seem compatible on paper?
Schpoonman
They seem like they’ll be nice together.
HueSatLight
They are like if you took [earlier] Joyce, dialed her back to about half, and took [earlier] Dorothy, dialed her back to about half, and then unqueered the situation.
justin8448
This take is both hilarious and accurate.
Reltzik
…. I don’t disagree, but when you put it that way it sounds like “Triple Vanilla”.
anon
triple vanilla would be a great name for something lol
Vanessa
They are both Black and Christian, perhaps even the same denomination. They are both pretty serious people, good at school, without obvious crippling hangups (aside from the Christian brainwashing.) We don’t know if he is into anything other than working out and school, and checking performative boxes to please his family, but maybe that’s enough? Their families might get along. I betcha he could use some cartoon and movie watching to destress.
Sirksome
See, to me that’s all what is so unappealing about them. They’re so similar it would just be two people with similar personalities and interests getting along. It’s kind of boring to me. Sal and Danny are interesting because they’re so different. Danny being the opposite of what you’d expect a “cool” girl like Sal to want. Or supremely horny Becky dating a likely ace or demisexual. Joe and Joyce fit this dynamic too.
What are Jacob and Lucy? What do they have to play off each other with?
Jeremiah
It is a pretty simple “two cute people that would be nice if they were happy together” thing. That can not be your thing but it’s not more complicated than that.
Ed Callahan
In terms of the narrative, given how extreme most of the main characters are, some straight men would be beneficial.
Ntrovert
Absolutely. While I completely get that a good chunk of readership enjoy enjoys combining people with very different personalities (which is part of the college experience for many), some others aren’t looking for all drama all the time. I think that Jacob and Lucy probably fall into that category. They are both genuinely nice people who deserve some happiness, too.
KM
Jacob’s been pretty clearly confirmed Episcopal while Lucy seems to attend the same services as Becky so not likely to be the same denomination at least.
Schpoonman
The entire situation with Joyce showed that he didn’t actually like filling out checkboxes to please his family. He likes filling out checkboxes, but he still wants those to please himself.
RacingTurtle
100% because of that time Jacob realized he’d like someone who is like Joyce but isn’t Joyce. I have zero strong feelings about Jacob/Lucy—they hadn’t even met until just now!—but I’ve been curious about the possibility ever since.
thejeff
Except the similarities are superficial and the differences run deep.
Lucy hasn’t punched out a kidnapper, for example. And I can’t really see her doing it.
Shogeton
I think the things that Jacob is interested in aren’t the kidnapper punching, but some things they do have in common. Both of them are upbeat, earnest and extroverted.
thejeff
He commented specifically about how much that impressed him.
Username Taken
I’d guess that “punched a kidnapper” isn’t a minimum dating standard for Jacob even if it impressed him.
thejeff
No, but it suggests it isn’t just the superficial “upbeat, earnest and extroverted” part that worked on him.
Clif
There is an argument that Lucy could be what Jacob is looking for. But it’s a flawed argument. The chemistry is impossible to predict and so it is interesting.
Emil
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PairTheSpares
The only issue with Jacob is having an unlikeable girlfriend, the only issue with Lucy is being terminally horny. Otherwise, they are both way to well adjusted to be main characters in this comic:)
Li
I do Not understand the “terminally horny” take on Lucy. It wouldn’t be much of a flaw even if it were one, but I think her excitement to have sex for the first time is at a pretty normal level for 18/19. Her flaw, such as it was, was more her idealized, unrealistic expectations for a first relationship. And now she’s Had her first relationship, so that part is at least somewhat mitigated.
Lee
I agree. I wouldn’t call her terminally horny, she just had the typical teen romance novel and movie idea of how a first boyfriend should go. X number of dates, say Y specially at point Z, sex is supposed to happen.
HueSatLight
He seems naive to me at times. His apparent patience with Sarah sometimes feels like he’s trying to teach her to be social by saying earnestly, “have you tried not being introverted?”
His interpretation of Joyce and Ethan dating was naive too.
Sirksome
I’m actually really interested in what people see in this couple so I’m sincerely asking why people want it? Just cause they seem compatible on paper?
Vanessa
She doesn’t seem cowed by his hotness, that’s a good start.
Jon
My guess would be that both Jacob and Lucy have been done dirty by main characters recently (Joyce’s manipulative behavior and Walky’s spinelessness, respectively). So you kind of want to just see two (mostly) well-adjusted people have a quiet, happy relationship now that they’ve paid their debts to the Relationship Drama Gods.
Needfuldoer
Take this reply in lieu of an upvote, because I agree with your take.
RassilonTDavros
I figured it was either gonna be her or Jocelyne. The latter of which would have been funny in terms of “just how badly can the universe possibly fuck with Ethan,” but would have limited potential for development unless she was actually sticking around long-term, which was always a long shot.
RassilonTDavros
(not that i wouldn’t love it if jocelyne stuck around full time)
(just sayin)