I mean, it’s bordering dangerously on full-blown emotional manipulation, actually. But he’s a clever boy for recognizing it was going to be effective! Boybossing above and beyond the sun.
>there is actually no classic i feel guilty about never reading because i strongly believe buckaroos should not feel guilt over this kind of thing. there are LOTS of classics i have never read because while i consume a LOT of art there are lots of BOOKS i have never read, it is not really my main medium when compared to music or film, which is something that i think many would feel shame about and tuck away to never admit.
Ethan needs this. Hell, Asher needs this. Might be good for both of them. Might not be. Who knows, but it will be fun, and they both need that distract them for awhile.
I mean…this is about one step removed from “if you ever stop fucking me/seeing me, I will kill myself,” so I think that long-term, it’s an ill omen. Just because bad things are happening to these two and they deserve some happiness, doesn’t mean that happiness should resemble Billie and Ruth’s relationship arc, lmao.
Because Ethan is doing it for purely selfish reasons. Asher told him he had a girlfriend, and while Asher may no longer have one, Ethan doesn’t know that (unless he’s been stalking Asher). Also Amber told him who Asher was and that it’d be a terrible idea for them to hook up, and that actually convinced Ethan to hook up with him.
He’s basically using Asher for sex and also to make himself feel worse with no consideration for Asher’s feelings. Will they both come out better? Maybe, it’s a comic, but Ethan’s intentions aren’t to come out better.
Thag Simmons
I love that despite Asher being an accessory to murder and heir to a crime empire, he’s the more level headed of the two
bemisawa
…And that this STILL somehow feels healthier for Asher than Jennifer’s BS?
Throwatron
To be fair to Asher, now there’s *two* people in his love life, who are about to be disappointed that he isn’t as dangerous to them, as they think he is, and want him to be. He seems to literally be trying to be a normal guy with a normal life, doing normal college stuff, and his current girlfriend now resents him for [checks notes] resembling her childhood friend by being too much of a normal guy who isn’t cool enough for her, while his potential rebound is only dating him because he thinks he can use the relationship as an opportunity for self-harm.
What Asher is getting from Jennifer currently, is some serious bullshit. But given the evil grin on Ethan in the last panel, I’m willing to bet that Ethan will do exponentially more psychological harm to Asher than Jennifer is exposing him to, right now. That sort of one-sided and selfish relationship, where someone is using you as an emotional battery and an emotional sponge, can completely ruin your ability to have normal relationships with other people, for literally forever.
spriteless aunty
Got to be level headed, to get away with it.
Needfuldoer
Ethan can have a little self-destruction, as a treat?
while Asher may no longer have one, Ethan doesn’t know that (unless he’s been stalking Asher)
Honestly even if he has been. I don’t think Asher knows if he still has a girlfriend or not. I’d be genuinely surprised if Jennifer really knows.
Throwatron
Jennifer will reserve the right to hold Asher fully accountable for everything he does wrong in their relationship, ever since he had the unmitigated gall to [checks notes] slightly resemble a guy who Jennifer is currently bitter at, and have normal human emotions.
However, once Asher responds to Jennifer’s deliberate, punitive, and stinging neglect in any way that could possibly make him look bad, she WILL retroactively blame him for all the ways she is mistreating him, and claim that HER behavior is a result of HIS, and not the other way around, and she will expose him to their entire new friend group, and get him kicked out of his support network as a result. Jennifer will see nothing wrong with this, and Asher will have to double down into Ethan…which is terrible for Asher, and exactly what Ethan has now decided he wants.
Ethan openly is self-sabotaging and Asher has already stated he’s compelled by fatalistic short-sightedness and is trying to be a better person. It is practically textbook “I can make him worse.”
Dante
Meanwhile Asher is like “I can make him right” (poor dude, if only he knew…)
imagine the bombshell that’d be dropped if it was revealed that asher was part of amber’s dad’s death, tho would ethan blame him for that or be glad for that too since it’s notl ike it’s asher’s fault indirectly that mike died too
it is if the investigation/cover-up uncovered someone who heard this, and a cop gave him an air embolism or something.
Needfuldoer
That’s apparently Eric in the window, and he hasn’t been seen since, so you might be on to something…
thejeff
It’s theoretically possible, but there’s little reason to believe it. Everything makes sense without it. The pieces tie together. Motivations are clear. Mike’s death works better thematically as a redemptive sacrifice.
Asher also becomes completely unredeemable if he’s responsible for that, which really doesn’t seem to be where Willis is taking the character.
I’d say it’s less likely than Mike being alive in witness protection and that’s a damn slim chance.
HueSatLight
I’m not saying it’s likely, but it is a non-zero chance.
The idea of redemptive sacrifice should be subverted, Mike’s death means Mike can’t become the better person he seems like he wanted to try becoming. His journey ended with a grand gesture showing he had the potential, it didn’t realize a life better lived.
Because it’s plausible, it doesn’t effect Asher’s guilt much. Whether or not cops killed Mike, he risked Mike’s life, and risked cops potentially going after who they think Amazigirl is (Amber or Sal). It’s not Asher putting a hit on Mike or Amber or Sal, it’s him risking their lives. It’s redeemable, but not by looking hot or by being otherwise very courteous or by being a goofball.
thejeff
I’m not fond of redemptive sacrifice, but I’d rather it be subverted by the character actually having to live and grow and deal with the ramifications of his actions, rather than by surviving his sacrifice and then getting murdered off screen.
It only affects Asher’s guilt if Asher was actually involved. If they somehow already knew about Mike, then they would have already known about Blaine and wouldn’t have needed Asher to set up any of it. I don’t see how Asher brings any more risk to Mike or Amazi-Girl – unless he somehow points the baddies at them. Which he shouldn’t have known enough to do.
Ethan is literally doing all of this to punish Amber for not being there for him. Since Amber has currently wronged him, he will be ECSTATIC that Asher is the one who ruined Amber’s life.
You know what I think about? Kit Fisto. We know Jennifer eagerly told Malaya and co about him, which means at some point during the New Jennifer arc, she was more comfortable with her nerdy interests than she’s ever been before. This isn’t just about Jennifer getting insecure about dating a dorky nerd. Something fell apart.
Billie Jennifer finding Walky hot for a second, recoiling in disgust, and then finding out Asher coincidentally brocloning it up with Walky (And not despising him at all) happened.
Yeah, people forget, she is not actually mad at Asher. She’s mad at Walky, and she’s so unfathomably, inimitably petty and borderline, that she has temporarily lost all respect for Asher’s humanity, because enough of her anger at Walky gets triggered by her constantly remembering the moment where she realized he was Like Walky, that she has thus decided that Asher has personally done her wrong, and must be punished with distance.
This is probably pretty similar to how her parents treat her, I bet. If the way she currently is, happens to make them feel like the way she currently appears and acts reflects positively on them, then she gets some amount of love and attention as a reward. If she ever does anything to embarrass them, though…well, she’s better get to re-perfecting herself, so that she’s not a bad reflection of the people who see her as an extension of themselves, who owes them for the great privilege of existing within or near their bubble.
Malaya griping about being told about Kit Fisto stuff. I forget the comic in question.
Mr D phone posting
And Raidah complaining about pretending to know or care about who Kit Fisto is
Imogen
Oh, yeah, sorry, not Malaya, Raidah. Big fan of Malaya. Malaya would never. (they would (but they didn’t))
Needfuldoer
Malaya would call Jennifer fakey for not being honest about her nerdy interests.
Li
I actually think Raidah isn’t the first person to complain about Kit Fisto, just the first person to do it behind Jennifer’s back while pretending to like her. (I think Ruth and maybe Walky have also teased Jennifer for being a Star Wars nerd.)
thejeff
It’s a subtle distinction and one Jennifer might not recognize, but I think Ruth and Walky tease her for being a closet Kit Fisto nerd. For hiding it, not for being one.
And Lucy of course, whose reaction was basically “One of us!” Which hurt Jennifer worse than anything.
Li
I mean, Raidah isn’t teasing her at all; Raidah is pretending to like her and not mind hearing about Kit Fisto while secretly not liking her at all and hating hearing about Kit Fisto.
Walky and Ruth’s teasing was always definitely friendly, and yeah, Lucy was just delighted.
This is why my thesis of Billie’s arc is that after her and Ruth split, she’s running away from herself. Walky and Asher getting along and brocloning means Asher now reminds her of the part of herself she hates, so she’s pushing him away in hopes he’ll either become controlling and violent or leave her. Either one’s good at this point.
is it actually cheating when Billie made it abundantly clear he’s not actually her boyfriend ten minutes ago?
Zero
No, but it is awful quick.
DashWallkick
I don’t disagree.
Dante
I wonder if it’s the first time Jennifer has withheld affection and respect from Asher. I wonder if it’s the time she’s pushed him away somehow.
We’ve seen them be lovey-dovey before this last conflict but that ensures nothing. We don’t know how they got together, nor how long they’ve been together, and there’s a three-month (or more?) gap between Halloween and now.
thejeff
Kind of. Since that was more Jennifer rejecting the term than breaking up with him. It’s a thing they’re going to have to deal with and Asher’d be well within his rights to break up with her over it, but that was clearly not her intent.
273 thoughts on “Persisting”
Ana Chronistic
now THAT is an invitation
Clif
Now that is some 3D chess level level flirting. No wonder Ethan is pleased with himself.
Throwatron
I mean, it’s bordering dangerously on full-blown emotional manipulation, actually. But he’s a clever boy for recognizing it was going to be effective! Boybossing above and beyond the sun.
Needfuldoer
No strings attached, emotionally.
Dante
DUDE DUDE DUDE. I just realized!! This is the kind of line MIKE used on Ethan!! Back when they first kissed. Omg. No wonder it’s so smooth???
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2018/comic/book-8/04-of-mike-and-men/reward/
BOOSTER SHOT
damn
Animedingo
Hot
Rose by Any Other Name
Your Lucy grav makes that comment so much funnier. ^^
shadowcell
Ethan Persists Long Enough for Asher to Take What He Wants From Him: A Dumbing of Age Pornographique
Casi
Hmmm this feels like a Tingler. You know, I’ve never seen David M Willis and Chuck Tingle in the same room together….
Opus the Poet
I’ve never seen Chuck Tingle. I have seen Mr. Willis.
Decidedly Orthogonal
To make Chuck tingle, you just have to make the right offer. See: Ethan, panel 3.
Casi
<a href="https://lithub.com/chuck-tingle-on-how-writing-is-like-driving-being-an-autistic-artist-and-more/" Chuck Tingle wears a mask so they could still very well be the same person.
Casi
darn html fail
ShellShockBP
>there is actually no classic i feel guilty about never reading because i strongly believe buckaroos should not feel guilt over this kind of thing. there are LOTS of classics i have never read because while i consume a LOT of art there are lots of BOOKS i have never read, it is not really my main medium when compared to music or film, which is something that i think many would feel shame about and tuck away to never admit.
Absolute king
Jon S.
<Pounded In the Butt By My Sense of Ennui and Self-Loathing, and Also Asher, perhaps?
Samniel
Ethan, no
Katosen27
Ethan needs this. Hell, Asher needs this. Might be good for both of them. Might not be. Who knows, but it will be fun, and they both need that distract them for awhile.
Daibhid C
(Gestures vaguely at literally every time someone’s used that reasoning in the comic previously.)
Throwatron
I mean…this is about one step removed from “if you ever stop fucking me/seeing me, I will kill myself,” so I think that long-term, it’s an ill omen. Just because bad things are happening to these two and they deserve some happiness, doesn’t mean that happiness should resemble Billie and Ruth’s relationship arc, lmao.
Mr D
Ethan, yes
PedanticJerkass
Ethan, *indifferent shrug*
Reltzik
Why no?
Samniel
Because Ethan is doing it for purely selfish reasons. Asher told him he had a girlfriend, and while Asher may no longer have one, Ethan doesn’t know that (unless he’s been stalking Asher). Also Amber told him who Asher was and that it’d be a terrible idea for them to hook up, and that actually convinced Ethan to hook up with him.
He’s basically using Asher for sex and also to make himself feel worse with no consideration for Asher’s feelings. Will they both come out better? Maybe, it’s a comic, but Ethan’s intentions aren’t to come out better.
Thag Simmons
I love that despite Asher being an accessory to murder and heir to a crime empire, he’s the more level headed of the two
bemisawa
…And that this STILL somehow feels healthier for Asher than Jennifer’s BS?
Throwatron
To be fair to Asher, now there’s *two* people in his love life, who are about to be disappointed that he isn’t as dangerous to them, as they think he is, and want him to be. He seems to literally be trying to be a normal guy with a normal life, doing normal college stuff, and his current girlfriend now resents him for [checks notes] resembling her childhood friend by being too much of a normal guy who isn’t cool enough for her, while his potential rebound is only dating him because he thinks he can use the relationship as an opportunity for self-harm.
What Asher is getting from Jennifer currently, is some serious bullshit. But given the evil grin on Ethan in the last panel, I’m willing to bet that Ethan will do exponentially more psychological harm to Asher than Jennifer is exposing him to, right now. That sort of one-sided and selfish relationship, where someone is using you as an emotional battery and an emotional sponge, can completely ruin your ability to have normal relationships with other people, for literally forever.
spriteless aunty
Got to be level headed, to get away with it.
Needfuldoer
Ethan can have a little self-destruction, as a treat?
Ana Chronistic
c’mon, it’s Cheat Day!
Needfuldoer
Every day is a The Cheat day.
Daibhid C
while Asher may no longer have one, Ethan doesn’t know that (unless he’s been stalking Asher)
Honestly even if he has been. I don’t think Asher knows if he still has a girlfriend or not. I’d be genuinely surprised if Jennifer really knows.
Throwatron
Jennifer will reserve the right to hold Asher fully accountable for everything he does wrong in their relationship, ever since he had the unmitigated gall to [checks notes] slightly resemble a guy who Jennifer is currently bitter at, and have normal human emotions.
However, once Asher responds to Jennifer’s deliberate, punitive, and stinging neglect in any way that could possibly make him look bad, she WILL retroactively blame him for all the ways she is mistreating him, and claim that HER behavior is a result of HIS, and not the other way around, and she will expose him to their entire new friend group, and get him kicked out of his support network as a result. Jennifer will see nothing wrong with this, and Asher will have to double down into Ethan…which is terrible for Asher, and exactly what Ethan has now decided he wants.
DashWallkick
Ethan openly is self-sabotaging and Asher has already stated he’s compelled by fatalistic short-sightedness and is trying to be a better person. It is practically textbook “I can make him worse.”
Dante
Meanwhile Asher is like “I can make him right” (poor dude, if only he knew…)
anon
imagine the bombshell that’d be dropped if it was revealed that asher was part of amber’s dad’s death, tho would ethan blame him for that or be glad for that too since it’s notl ike it’s asher’s fault indirectly that mike died too
HueSatLight
it is if the investigation/cover-up uncovered someone who heard this, and a cop gave him an air embolism or something.
Needfuldoer
That’s apparently Eric in the window, and he hasn’t been seen since, so you might be on to something…
thejeff
It’s theoretically possible, but there’s little reason to believe it. Everything makes sense without it. The pieces tie together. Motivations are clear. Mike’s death works better thematically as a redemptive sacrifice.
Asher also becomes completely unredeemable if he’s responsible for that, which really doesn’t seem to be where Willis is taking the character.
I’d say it’s less likely than Mike being alive in witness protection and that’s a damn slim chance.
HueSatLight
I’m not saying it’s likely, but it is a non-zero chance.
The idea of redemptive sacrifice should be subverted, Mike’s death means Mike can’t become the better person he seems like he wanted to try becoming. His journey ended with a grand gesture showing he had the potential, it didn’t realize a life better lived.
Because it’s plausible, it doesn’t effect Asher’s guilt much. Whether or not cops killed Mike, he risked Mike’s life, and risked cops potentially going after who they think Amazigirl is (Amber or Sal). It’s not Asher putting a hit on Mike or Amber or Sal, it’s him risking their lives. It’s redeemable, but not by looking hot or by being otherwise very courteous or by being a goofball.
thejeff
I’m not fond of redemptive sacrifice, but I’d rather it be subverted by the character actually having to live and grow and deal with the ramifications of his actions, rather than by surviving his sacrifice and then getting murdered off screen.
It only affects Asher’s guilt if Asher was actually involved. If they somehow already knew about Mike, then they would have already known about Blaine and wouldn’t have needed Asher to set up any of it. I don’t see how Asher brings any more risk to Mike or Amazi-Girl – unless he somehow points the baddies at them. Which he shouldn’t have known enough to do.
Throwatron
Ethan is literally doing all of this to punish Amber for not being there for him. Since Amber has currently wronged him, he will be ECSTATIC that Asher is the one who ruined Amber’s life.
DarkoNeko
Ethan YES
Imogen
You know what I think about? Kit Fisto. We know Jennifer eagerly told Malaya and co about him, which means at some point during the New Jennifer arc, she was more comfortable with her nerdy interests than she’s ever been before. This isn’t just about Jennifer getting insecure about dating a dorky nerd. Something fell apart.
DailyBrad
Yeah, there’s a lot more to this than “Jennifer decided he’s not that cool”. Like, quite a lot more.
Mr D
BillieJennifer finding Walky hot for a second, recoiling in disgust, and then finding out Asher coincidentally brocloning it up with Walky (And not despising him at all) happened.Throwatron
Yeah, people forget, she is not actually mad at Asher. She’s mad at Walky, and she’s so unfathomably, inimitably petty and borderline, that she has temporarily lost all respect for Asher’s humanity, because enough of her anger at Walky gets triggered by her constantly remembering the moment where she realized he was Like Walky, that she has thus decided that Asher has personally done her wrong, and must be punished with distance.
This is probably pretty similar to how her parents treat her, I bet. If the way she currently is, happens to make them feel like the way she currently appears and acts reflects positively on them, then she gets some amount of love and attention as a reward. If she ever does anything to embarrass them, though…well, she’s better get to re-perfecting herself, so that she’s not a bad reflection of the people who see her as an extension of themselves, who owes them for the great privilege of existing within or near their bubble.
Jamie
When did we find out about this? My memory fails me.
Imogen
Malaya griping about being told about Kit Fisto stuff. I forget the comic in question.
Mr D phone posting
And Raidah complaining about pretending to know or care about who Kit Fisto is
Imogen
Oh, yeah, sorry, not Malaya, Raidah. Big fan of Malaya. Malaya would never. (they would (but they didn’t))
Needfuldoer
Malaya would call Jennifer fakey for not being honest about her nerdy interests.
Li
I actually think Raidah isn’t the first person to complain about Kit Fisto, just the first person to do it behind Jennifer’s back while pretending to like her. (I think Ruth and maybe Walky have also teased Jennifer for being a Star Wars nerd.)
thejeff
It’s a subtle distinction and one Jennifer might not recognize, but I think Ruth and Walky tease her for being a closet Kit Fisto nerd. For hiding it, not for being one.
And Lucy of course, whose reaction was basically “One of us!” Which hurt Jennifer worse than anything.
Li
I mean, Raidah isn’t teasing her at all; Raidah is pretending to like her and not mind hearing about Kit Fisto while secretly not liking her at all and hating hearing about Kit Fisto.
Walky and Ruth’s teasing was always definitely friendly, and yeah, Lucy was just delighted.
DashWallkick
This is why my thesis of Billie’s arc is that after her and Ruth split, she’s running away from herself. Walky and Asher getting along and brocloning means Asher now reminds her of the part of herself she hates, so she’s pushing him away in hopes he’ll either become controlling and violent or leave her. Either one’s good at this point.
Yumi
I just really want them to have sex and (probably after) form an emotionally healthy bond and have sex again.
Reltzik
I think these two would have an emotionally healthy bond in the same way that Ruth and Billie had an emotionally healthy bond.
Yumi
Yeah, but 2 out of 3 ain’t bad.
Reltzik
Well, as scores go, it means they scored twice.
anon
Asher: I can fix him
Ethan: I can make him worse
Thag Simmons
Ethan of course, tragically unaware of what “worse Asher” looks like
rachel
lmao bless you
The Jighole Man
Forget billie, they’ll make their own relationship; with love, and happiness…and blackjack.
shrub
Well Billie would deserve it
Warcodered
I mean she deserves to get broken up with, he shouldn’t just be shitty himself in response.
shrub
Well you withhold affection and respect from someone and its likely they’ll look for it elsewhere
DashWallkick
is it actually cheating when Billie made it abundantly clear he’s not actually her boyfriend ten minutes ago?
Zero
No, but it is awful quick.
DashWallkick
I don’t disagree.
Dante
I wonder if it’s the first time Jennifer has withheld affection and respect from Asher. I wonder if it’s the time she’s pushed him away somehow.
We’ve seen them be lovey-dovey before this last conflict but that ensures nothing. We don’t know how they got together, nor how long they’ve been together, and there’s a three-month (or more?) gap between Halloween and now.
thejeff
Kind of. Since that was more Jennifer rejecting the term than breaking up with him. It’s a thing they’re going to have to deal with and Asher’d be well within his rights to break up with her over it, but that was clearly not her intent.