I’m gonna be really picky here, they’re not going to rob Becky’s house, because:
Becky is one of the residents of said house, so she can’t actually steal her own stuff because she has a right to be in the house and invite the others in
Also robbery is theft from a victim by intimidation. Gaining access to a property as part of stealing from said property is burglary.
The family that has burgers together, burgles together. ;D
Just Saying
You. I like you.
Yet_One_More_Idiot
Heh, thanks. xD I once got curious as to what exactly the difference between robbery and burglary were, so I looked it up. Along with the reason why the verb form of burglary is “Burglarize” in America, but “Burgle” here in the UK. I get curious a lot, I look up a lot of random s***t. 😛
Nicknack Paddywack
You are me at 2AM falling deeper and deeper into the Wikipedia rabbit hole when I have an 8AM exam the next day.
White Rice
Burglary is a funny one (at least in the “exact letter of the law” sense of it) in that technically if you go somewhere with the intent to rob the place and/or steal something all stealthy like then you’ve committed burglary. The key is the intent, regardless of any actions taken once you’ve arrived.
It’s easy enough to prove in court if the person is found with “burglary tools” and/or has a written plan (who really does that anymore) after the act’s been committed, but burglary without actual theft isn’t commonly charged (usually it becomes something like conspiracy to commit some other crime)
Thorbjorn
Well as she is an adult an her father have thrown her out I am kinda sure she is not a resident anymore. Meaning that she do not have the rights to enter nor invite anyone else.
On the other hand she deffinetly can’t steal her own Personal infromation papers as I am quite sure that you actually can’t own other peoples personal information paper, which is funny because the deffinition of burglary is intering a hosue with the intention to commit a crime, but these people are only entering the house with intention to collect Becky’s private property. (I have no reason what the punishment for that is)
Krisalys
Actually, he didn’t throw her out; he was actually planning to take her back home. It’s her house too.
Her father never threw her out of her house. He pulled her out of school and then expended a lot of effort trying to get her back *into* the house.
Oruncrest
I think he did throw her out. You don’t deny someone a key to keep them from leaving your home, only to keep them from coming in. I think Toedad kicked her out expecting her to come crawling back all repentant for being a lesbian and Becky went, ‘Screw that! Maybe Joyce can help me out.’
Pat
An abusive parent denies the kids a key to deny them the freedom to come and go.
Also, she wasn’t living at home at the moment and also fled without much preparation, so maybe she owns one but doesn’t have it any more.
Random832
Legally he may not actually have the right to “kick her out” without going through a formal eviction process. Different states have different laws about this, and I wasn’t able to find much information specific to Indiana.
Thorbjorn
True.
I don’t really know Indiana’s law (or US law for that matter) well enough to know the specefics but at least in some western countries, as long as she does not live at home anymore (Her home adress is at another place) that would be enough to technically require permission from a person living in the house to enter.
Pat
That’s breaking and entering, then, no other crime.
But then, he stole her property. Like, all of it.
In addition to his other many, many crimes.
Thorbjorn
Question is how much of that she actually legally own though. Not saying he isn’t an ass, but she should be very carefull on what she takes from that home, because as soon she takes something she thinks is legally hers but is not we move directly from breaking and entering (Which is debateable even if I am to believe other people who I assume know more about us law to robbery)
patricklukcy13
but they did not have burgers…….
AngryBamboo
the family that crimes together, is sublime together.
lejwocky
the family that transitions directly from the solid to gas phase sublimates together
Actually it is, strictly speaking. If Joyce’s parents called the police about the car being missing, that’s what she’d be charged with. Same for breaking and entering.
it also takes at least two weeks, which is like THREE YEARS
Birdra
You need a birther certificate to get a SSN, which I assume is also in her house.
Freemage
I assume a birther certificate is what conservative Christians use, in order to establish that Jesus confirms they were born as Americans, unlike that Seekrit Mooslim, Obama?
Viktoria
Nope, some fundies tend to not have birth certificates, because that’s how the gubmint tracks you. It’s fine though, they’re american*, why would anyone ask them to prove it.
*white
-Sentinel-
How is that even legal?
Conuly
It’s not. Welcome to the world of sovereign citizens.
They think that since your birth certificate writes your name in ALL CAPS, that’s a secret move by the government to set up a fake persona to steal all your money. You can stymie the government by not playing their game and never writing your name in ALL CAPS, and by not getting your kids BCs or SSNs.
(I can only conclude that they believe the government is run by magical faeries, btw.)
zoomer296
Did you know that if you spill salt or sugar in front of a government official, they have to stop and count every grain?
Zoomer — no, they require you count every grain, account for any salt or sand you have left, and determine how much you then have to give them. And if you get it wrong, you have to give them more salt or sand.
This, also, reiterating the multiple weeks thing. Not a big problem if you’re not desperately searching for work now so you can stop feeling like a lump sponging off your friends (and for any stray Becky haters who want to say this is exactly what she is, I offer all three of Ultra Car’s middle fingers). But Becky is very anxious to start earning money and start getting her life in order, especially by now, I imagine the deadline for Winter/Spring Enrollment is coming up and I guarantee that Indiana University is going to need not only her SS card, but probably also her certificate of home schooling (assuming Indiana requires those like California does) and GED (if she got one).
Plus, rule of drama would argue that she’d either have to add the extra couple of weeks to get her address changed first or risk having her new SS card and birth certificate sent to her “home” address either at Anderson or the locked up house she can’t easily access after this weekend.
Doing it the proper way will take a lot longer and cost some initial scratch, though not as much as I was initially fearing, thanks, commenter who looked that up. It will also involve risking far less jail time and harassment by cops…
The pragmatist in me is worried for them. The fan in me is excited to see this go epically wrong, because I’m an awful human being.
Dana
Given your comments here, you are anything but an awful human being.
Clearly you don’t know about the woodshed full of bodies… okay, fine, they’re less bodies and more azaleas… I’m terrible at being awful, okay?!?
Shiro
Oh jeez, you just made me think…what if she has no certificate of homeschooling, like, Ross never bothered to take care of the paperwork? Given fundies, we can’t take anything for granted.
That’s very possible. As is her not having a GED. If so, she’s going to have to complete one of those before she can even think about being transferred into Indiana U and she might need to get some community college classes under her belt to prove to the school that she can do well at the college level.
Toedad may have reeeeeeally fucked her over in more ways than just the obvious.
Drath
Is there any way in the USA to get all those papers in case your parents decided that having you off the grid was a great idea ?
If Toedad did this, combined with the mysterious circumstances of his wife’s death, he might have different reasons altogether to keep Becky away from legal overseeing. A terrifying thought.
AeromechanicalAce
I dunno, would she have been able to enroll at Anderson without that information?
Slartibeast Button, BIA
Which now reminds me that she should swing by a post office and fill out change of address cards to get her mail forwarded. As I recall, no documentation is needed for that, at least.
DinaJoyce
Regarding homeschool-related paperwork, it looks like Indiana doesn’t have much in the way of requirements for homeschooling and therefore Becky wouldn’t have any documentation of completion anyway (http://www.hslda.org/laws/analysis/indiana.pdf) This is pretty normal across the U.S. NY (where I was homeschooled) is one of the most stringent states and doesn’t give any certificate of completion or anything. I made my transcript on MS word and my diploma (which I never bothered to print and have never been asked for) on MS publisher. GEDs are also unusual for homeschoolers and are often considered an insult (I’m not a high school dropout). Most colleges just accept SAT or ACT scores like they would for anybody else.
Galdan
But Joyce and her siblings study in a real college, so they must have their papers in order ot prove that they are legal US residents.
Even that Christian wannabe college Becky went to had to keep their papers in order (even if the government didn’t acknowledge their degrees, they would still have to justify how they earn their money to operate). So Becky most likely has a birth certificate.
thejeff
Anderson is actually a real college with a pretty decent reputation, as religious colleges go anyway. It probably has lower standards than IU, but there’s no reason to think she wouldn’t have needed most of the usual documentation to go there.
There’s also no real reason to think even Toedad was that particular flavor of crazy. The Browns aren’t. There’s no indication it was common in their church. Home-schooling bigoted fundies are a lot more common than the sovereign citizen wackos.
Yep. And I don’t know about other states, but here getting a copy of your birth certificate is about $30 and takes several weeks to get in itself. Add that to several weeks to get her social security card and that’s about 1-2 months she’d have to delay filling out applications.
I remember when I was consistently broke. I made a hair more than minimum wage and worked at least 40 hours a week. Even then when I needed my birth certificate to apply for a better job, that $30 might as well have been a million. It was a completely unattainable sum for me. At least not without saving every dime I could manage for at least 6 months. And that was with a job. If I hadn’t had a job that money would have been down-right impossible to get.
Breaking in to her house seems like the most reasonable option to me. Especially if Becky has no proof of address that she lives there in order to get a cop or even a locksmith to help.
Raza
I’m in WA. Here anyone can order anyone’s BC if they know name, DOB, and city/state. It’s 20 bucks and ready the next, or sometimes the same day. Got bc for my unofficial foster kid without identifying myself in anyway. And no way they thought I was a bio parent. I’m black, and in my 20’s, kid was suuuper white and 17 so…. It’s considered public record here. SS card is more effort though, and takes longer. But I never needed to show it for college. I just needed the number. They didn’t even check if my GED was real as far as I know. I had a different name then so I do t know how they would have found it.
My money is on Becky not having a ssn. Which is legal in the US actually, but you can’t access any rights or benefits given to citizens until you prove you were born here. Lots of fundies don’t register their children’s births.
Slartibeast Button, BIA
At the risk of contradicting myself below, about 10 years ago I was able to order a birth certificate for an elderly friend of my mother online with nothing except her information, current address, and my credit card. They mailed it to her in a week for $25 + $50 speedup fee to a private company.
zoomer296
It gets worse, you have a limit of three cards per year, and ten cards per lifetime. My mom tried to reach the limit and withhold the cards from me, but got nine instead of ten. So now I have one card that I REALLY have to protect. It’d be nice if the limit reset when you turn eighteen or twenty-five, kids aren’t responsible for what their parents do.
Shiro
Holy shit, I’m sorry, that is the suckiest way to find out very useful information.
Woah, crap! I didn’t know that!
And I’m reeeeally glad that apparently my mother didn’t know that when I was a teen. Yikes.
I’m sorry she did that too you.
I agree that it should reset. Not all parents are benevolent and have your best interests at heart.
Also, sometimes shit just happens. When I was little my (now ex) step-mom used my SSN to get credit cards and things like that. It got all sorted out before I ever knew it happened, and dad divorced her as soon as he could, but what if he hadn’t? Or what if he didn’t find out for years? She could have gotten copies of my card without me ever knowing.
Wow, that’s a ridiculous rule.
Ana Chronistic
what the actual fuck =(
I feel like by that point, if you didn’t have the one, you’d have to move to another country… what a shit law
SSG
The SSA website says that they may wave the limit if you can prove that not having the card would cause “significant hardship.” I’m guessing that an abusive parent trying to control you by preventing you from legal access to your own documents would probably qualify.
678 thoughts on “Personal”
Ana Chronistic
the family that robs together, sobs together
wait no
the family that thieves together leaves together
no wait
the family that breaks and enters together… makes a renter together?
Ana Chronistic
DOSE BECKY EYES
KingSpenser
A family who steals together, heals together.
Freemage
Brilliant!
Yet_One_More_Idiot
I’m gonna be really picky here, they’re not going to rob Becky’s house, because:
Becky is one of the residents of said house, so she can’t actually steal her own stuff because she has a right to be in the house and invite the others in
Also robbery is theft from a victim by intimidation. Gaining access to a property as part of stealing from said property is burglary.
The family that has burgers together, burgles together. ;D
Just Saying
You. I like you.
Yet_One_More_Idiot
Heh, thanks. xD I once got curious as to what exactly the difference between robbery and burglary were, so I looked it up. Along with the reason why the verb form of burglary is “Burglarize” in America, but “Burgle” here in the UK. I get curious a lot, I look up a lot of random s***t. 😛
Nicknack Paddywack
You are me at 2AM falling deeper and deeper into the Wikipedia rabbit hole when I have an 8AM exam the next day.
White Rice
Burglary is a funny one (at least in the “exact letter of the law” sense of it) in that technically if you go somewhere with the intent to rob the place and/or steal something all stealthy like then you’ve committed burglary. The key is the intent, regardless of any actions taken once you’ve arrived.
It’s easy enough to prove in court if the person is found with “burglary tools” and/or has a written plan (who really does that anymore) after the act’s been committed, but burglary without actual theft isn’t commonly charged (usually it becomes something like conspiracy to commit some other crime)
Thorbjorn
Well as she is an adult an her father have thrown her out I am kinda sure she is not a resident anymore. Meaning that she do not have the rights to enter nor invite anyone else.
On the other hand she deffinetly can’t steal her own Personal infromation papers as I am quite sure that you actually can’t own other peoples personal information paper, which is funny because the deffinition of burglary is intering a hosue with the intention to commit a crime, but these people are only entering the house with intention to collect Becky’s private property. (I have no reason what the punishment for that is)
Krisalys
Actually, he didn’t throw her out; he was actually planning to take her back home. It’s her house too.
Jams
Her father never threw her out of her house. He pulled her out of school and then expended a lot of effort trying to get her back *into* the house.
Oruncrest
I think he did throw her out. You don’t deny someone a key to keep them from leaving your home, only to keep them from coming in. I think Toedad kicked her out expecting her to come crawling back all repentant for being a lesbian and Becky went, ‘Screw that! Maybe Joyce can help me out.’
Pat
An abusive parent denies the kids a key to deny them the freedom to come and go.
Also, she wasn’t living at home at the moment and also fled without much preparation, so maybe she owns one but doesn’t have it any more.
Random832
Legally he may not actually have the right to “kick her out” without going through a formal eviction process. Different states have different laws about this, and I wasn’t able to find much information specific to Indiana.
Thorbjorn
True.
I don’t really know Indiana’s law (or US law for that matter) well enough to know the specefics but at least in some western countries, as long as she does not live at home anymore (Her home adress is at another place) that would be enough to technically require permission from a person living in the house to enter.
Pat
That’s breaking and entering, then, no other crime.
But then, he stole her property. Like, all of it.
In addition to his other many, many crimes.
Thorbjorn
Question is how much of that she actually legally own though. Not saying he isn’t an ass, but she should be very carefull on what she takes from that home, because as soon she takes something she thinks is legally hers but is not we move directly from breaking and entering (Which is debateable even if I am to believe other people who I assume know more about us law to robbery)
patricklukcy13
but they did not have burgers…….
AngryBamboo
the family that crimes together, is sublime together.
lejwocky
the family that transitions directly from the solid to gas phase sublimates together
Bicycle Bill
DOSE JOYCE EYES!!
butts
THIS IS MOST EXCELLENT
Viktoria
The family that steals together heals together.
…
Now I’m disappointed that Leverage never had that as a tagline.
Ana Chronistic
I was about to come back and say “feels together”
Mollyscribbles
that’s the best description of Leverage ever.
David
Leverage FTW!
JULES GOLDSTEIN
The family with meals together, steals together.
Go Chicken Fingers!
pdp15
The family the burgles together, gurgles together.
The family that heists together, gets iced together …
SmilingNid
Second grand theft in less than a week Joyce is well on her way to becoming a master criminal.
thejeff
I’m pretty sure taking the family car to drive around town and meet the rest of the family for lunch isn’t exactly “Grand Theft Auto”.
Nor, for that matter, is collecting your personal effects from your residence, even if you don’t happen to have a key.
qman
Actually it is, strictly speaking. If Joyce’s parents called the police about the car being missing, that’s what she’d be charged with. Same for breaking and entering.
Reltzik
The family that liberates together libates together?
Reltzik
… also, saying it in-universe would be an excuse to see the last two panels again.
Baf
The family that burgles together gurgles together
Baf
Wait, no, that’s already been done.
The family that filches together… zilches together?
The family that pilfers together… um…
Catty
A family that nicks together sticks together.
Just Saying
^ Best one.
Sambo
Agreed
Max
Yaaas
Heavensrun
Finds their center together.
Pat
I mean, leaving together after thieving is probably the best way to do it.
sarahlost36
a family that does crime together, does time forever?
Ana Chronistic
the family that takes the shit together, gets away with it together
Ranial
This is exactly where I dreamed this was going, I’m so pleased.
Durandal_1707
But of course they can’t just go to the Social Security office and apply for a new card, because that would be crazy!
Dave
Real life makes dull fiction. ;3
Ana Chronistic
it also takes at least two weeks, which is like THREE YEARS
Birdra
You need a birther certificate to get a SSN, which I assume is also in her house.
Freemage
I assume a birther certificate is what conservative Christians use, in order to establish that Jesus confirms they were born as Americans, unlike that Seekrit Mooslim, Obama?
Viktoria
Nope, some fundies tend to not have birth certificates, because that’s how the gubmint tracks you. It’s fine though, they’re american*, why would anyone ask them to prove it.
*white
-Sentinel-
How is that even legal?
Conuly
It’s not. Welcome to the world of sovereign citizens.
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/a-look-at-the-sovereign-citizen-movement/
They think that since your birth certificate writes your name in ALL CAPS, that’s a secret move by the government to set up a fake persona to steal all your money. You can stymie the government by not playing their game and never writing your name in ALL CAPS, and by not getting your kids BCs or SSNs.
(I can only conclude that they believe the government is run by magical faeries, btw.)
zoomer296
Did you know that if you spill salt or sugar in front of a government official, they have to stop and count every grain?
DSL
Zoomer — no, they require you count every grain, account for any salt or sand you have left, and determine how much you then have to give them. And if you get it wrong, you have to give them more salt or sand.
Saucy Jack
And then they fine you for littering.
Dean
You should receive the receipt for your salt or sand by mail within 4-6 weeks.
Cerberus
This, also, reiterating the multiple weeks thing. Not a big problem if you’re not desperately searching for work now so you can stop feeling like a lump sponging off your friends (and for any stray Becky haters who want to say this is exactly what she is, I offer all three of Ultra Car’s middle fingers). But Becky is very anxious to start earning money and start getting her life in order, especially by now, I imagine the deadline for Winter/Spring Enrollment is coming up and I guarantee that Indiana University is going to need not only her SS card, but probably also her certificate of home schooling (assuming Indiana requires those like California does) and GED (if she got one).
Plus, rule of drama would argue that she’d either have to add the extra couple of weeks to get her address changed first or risk having her new SS card and birth certificate sent to her “home” address either at Anderson or the locked up house she can’t easily access after this weekend.
Doing it the proper way will take a lot longer and cost some initial scratch, though not as much as I was initially fearing, thanks, commenter who looked that up. It will also involve risking far less jail time and harassment by cops…
The pragmatist in me is worried for them. The fan in me is excited to see this go epically wrong, because I’m an awful human being.
Dana
Given your comments here, you are anything but an awful human being.
Cerberus
Clearly you don’t know about the woodshed full of bodies… okay, fine, they’re less bodies and more azaleas… I’m terrible at being awful, okay?!?
Shiro
Oh jeez, you just made me think…what if she has no certificate of homeschooling, like, Ross never bothered to take care of the paperwork? Given fundies, we can’t take anything for granted.
Cerberus
Shiro-
That’s very possible. As is her not having a GED. If so, she’s going to have to complete one of those before she can even think about being transferred into Indiana U and she might need to get some community college classes under her belt to prove to the school that she can do well at the college level.
Toedad may have reeeeeeally fucked her over in more ways than just the obvious.
Drath
Is there any way in the USA to get all those papers in case your parents decided that having you off the grid was a great idea ?
If Toedad did this, combined with the mysterious circumstances of his wife’s death, he might have different reasons altogether to keep Becky away from legal overseeing. A terrifying thought.
AeromechanicalAce
I dunno, would she have been able to enroll at Anderson without that information?
Slartibeast Button, BIA
Which now reminds me that she should swing by a post office and fill out change of address cards to get her mail forwarded. As I recall, no documentation is needed for that, at least.
DinaJoyce
Regarding homeschool-related paperwork, it looks like Indiana doesn’t have much in the way of requirements for homeschooling and therefore Becky wouldn’t have any documentation of completion anyway (http://www.hslda.org/laws/analysis/indiana.pdf) This is pretty normal across the U.S. NY (where I was homeschooled) is one of the most stringent states and doesn’t give any certificate of completion or anything. I made my transcript on MS word and my diploma (which I never bothered to print and have never been asked for) on MS publisher. GEDs are also unusual for homeschoolers and are often considered an insult (I’m not a high school dropout). Most colleges just accept SAT or ACT scores like they would for anybody else.
Galdan
But Joyce and her siblings study in a real college, so they must have their papers in order ot prove that they are legal US residents.
Even that Christian wannabe college Becky went to had to keep their papers in order (even if the government didn’t acknowledge their degrees, they would still have to justify how they earn their money to operate). So Becky most likely has a birth certificate.
thejeff
Anderson is actually a real college with a pretty decent reputation, as religious colleges go anyway. It probably has lower standards than IU, but there’s no reason to think she wouldn’t have needed most of the usual documentation to go there.
There’s also no real reason to think even Toedad was that particular flavor of crazy. The Browns aren’t. There’s no indication it was common in their church. Home-schooling bigoted fundies are a lot more common than the sovereign citizen wackos.
Annie
Yep. And I don’t know about other states, but here getting a copy of your birth certificate is about $30 and takes several weeks to get in itself. Add that to several weeks to get her social security card and that’s about 1-2 months she’d have to delay filling out applications.
I remember when I was consistently broke. I made a hair more than minimum wage and worked at least 40 hours a week. Even then when I needed my birth certificate to apply for a better job, that $30 might as well have been a million. It was a completely unattainable sum for me. At least not without saving every dime I could manage for at least 6 months. And that was with a job. If I hadn’t had a job that money would have been down-right impossible to get.
Breaking in to her house seems like the most reasonable option to me. Especially if Becky has no proof of address that she lives there in order to get a cop or even a locksmith to help.
Raza
I’m in WA. Here anyone can order anyone’s BC if they know name, DOB, and city/state. It’s 20 bucks and ready the next, or sometimes the same day. Got bc for my unofficial foster kid without identifying myself in anyway. And no way they thought I was a bio parent. I’m black, and in my 20’s, kid was suuuper white and 17 so…. It’s considered public record here. SS card is more effort though, and takes longer. But I never needed to show it for college. I just needed the number. They didn’t even check if my GED was real as far as I know. I had a different name then so I do t know how they would have found it.
My money is on Becky not having a ssn. Which is legal in the US actually, but you can’t access any rights or benefits given to citizens until you prove you were born here. Lots of fundies don’t register their children’s births.
Slartibeast Button, BIA
At the risk of contradicting myself below, about 10 years ago I was able to order a birth certificate for an elderly friend of my mother online with nothing except her information, current address, and my credit card. They mailed it to her in a week for $25 + $50 speedup fee to a private company.
zoomer296
It gets worse, you have a limit of three cards per year, and ten cards per lifetime. My mom tried to reach the limit and withhold the cards from me, but got nine instead of ten. So now I have one card that I REALLY have to protect. It’d be nice if the limit reset when you turn eighteen or twenty-five, kids aren’t responsible for what their parents do.
Shiro
Holy shit, I’m sorry, that is the suckiest way to find out very useful information.
Annie
Woah, crap! I didn’t know that!
And I’m reeeeally glad that apparently my mother didn’t know that when I was a teen. Yikes.
I’m sorry she did that too you.
I agree that it should reset. Not all parents are benevolent and have your best interests at heart.
Also, sometimes shit just happens. When I was little my (now ex) step-mom used my SSN to get credit cards and things like that. It got all sorted out before I ever knew it happened, and dad divorced her as soon as he could, but what if he hadn’t? Or what if he didn’t find out for years? She could have gotten copies of my card without me ever knowing.
Wow, that’s a ridiculous rule.
Ana Chronistic
what the actual fuck =(
I feel like by that point, if you didn’t have the one, you’d have to move to another country… what a shit law
SSG
The SSA website says that they may wave the limit if you can prove that not having the card would cause “significant hardship.” I’m guessing that an abusive parent trying to control you by preventing you from legal access to your own documents would probably qualify.