What would be the male equivalent of this, I wonder? My buddy is depressed his coming out to his family went badly, so I –his straight friend– console him by rubbing his face in my junk?
Girls are lucky; they get WAY more plausible deniability!
I’m hoping she does actually. I hope this makes her realize she doing basically the same thing Becky’s dad was doing in trying to “Fix” him.
Evan Dark
The difference is, Ethan wants to be “fixed” (at least in DoA), while Becky isn’t. There was no harm in Joyce trying to fix Ethan. That said, since it isn’t something you can fix, she is trying in vain.
I usually ship Joyce+Dorothy, but I’ll accept to sail on bor of the Joyce+Becky too.
djaevlenselv
Even if Ethan wants to, I’m not sure there’s really “no harm” in trying to “fix” him.
Evan Dark
Well, as long as he can say “No thanks, that’s enough” to Joyce, they can try all the fixing they want, and it’s all good. (presumably the “fixing” would involve premarital hanky-panky, in the name of the greater good)
The problem thing with “fixing” gay people is 1. When you are forcing someone, 2. It doesn’t actually work.
JWLM
If Joyce doesn’t figure out how cruel “fixing” Ether would be all by herself, then I think the Becky will be extremely happy to fix her on that score. I’m pretty sure that Becky would take the chance to make clear to Ethan’s parents what can happen to parents who continue to insist on “fixing” their gay children. I also think that Becky, being Becky, will (a) recognize Ethan as gay, and (b) have some words with him about coming out and staying out.
Jay
I wouldn’t say there’s NO harm, but Ethan’s active participation makes it a very different situation. That and, she’s his peer with no abilities to discipline him or leave him homeless if he doesn’t want to be ‘fixed’ or fails at it.
Kitty
I think Joyce also sticks with Ethan because he’s safe. She’s always been taught sex is evil and, with what happened at the party and with Joe, that idea has only been reinforced (and probably mixed with a hefty dose of fear). So while she probably still has an idea of “fixing” him, I think she’s more with him because she feels he’s someone she can be with without fear.
She looks scared, and she SHOULD: this is pretty huge. For someone of Joyce’s basic integrity, there is NO going back from this. She tries to find a safe neutral ground first. Then hesitates. Stammers.
And then rejects one of the most important tenets she grew up with, the one so-called Christians most often use to deny others the love and charity that should be the heart of their religion, and is the heart of Joyce.
Sorry Becky couldn’t help you stay true to your pre-college self, Joyce. But trust me: one day you’ll see that she gave you something much better.
I’m really scared what she means by Becky’s mistakes. Please Willis don’t do this again. All of these relationships are going reasonably well, and I just know you will destroy them when the time comes. I will already be crying when Shortpacked! ends. Give us some time her please!
Disloyal Subject
Not locking the door was probably a mistake.
But it looms like it may be turning out for the best.
I’d say that this loving and generous version of Christianity has always been part of Joyce’s beliefs. In fact, in the showdown over her friendship with Dorothy, Joyce reminded her parents that *they* were the ones who instilled that belief in her. So Becky is actually helping Joyce see what it truly means to stand up for what she believes . . . even though it forces her to break with some of the lesser dogma, so to speak. : ) Joyce is following the Golden Rule, which is supposed to trump all the others, right?
Oh geez, that’s where this is going isn’t it XD It would be kind of perfect. Like in Twelfth Night when Olivia fell for Viola dressed as a guy, only to find she had a brother who looked just like her.
663 thoughts on “Pit”
Jen Aside
*motorboat noises*
sorry
(not sorry)
Cheryl
This guy^
AlexanderHammil
…Sex Criminals reference?
liahansen
You can tell she’s thinkin about it
That Damn Rat
You can see the hint of a smile there on Becky’s face.
l33tmaster
we were all thinking about it
TrueVCU
You deserved first comment more than anyone else here
Orangey
this was only first comment there could have been, anything else wouldn’t have been good enough
A5PECT
I’ll just leave this here.
http://www.dumbingofage.com/2013/comic/book-3/03-answers-in-hennessy/belong-here/
Hinoron
What would be the male equivalent of this, I wonder? My buddy is depressed his coming out to his family went badly, so I –his straight friend– console him by rubbing his face in my junk?
Girls are lucky; they get WAY more plausible deniability!
Gordon
I think you’re not realizing the amount of body contact a good hug provides.
Cheryl
aaaawwww
Cheryl
jocey i just want to strangle her sometimes but then I want to squeeze her so tight with hugs…..ugh….that thin line….
Doctor_Who
Coming from Cheryl, that line is even thinner.
Cheryl
IKR?!…….Sploosh
Hugo_ebeds
Phrasing. Boom.
Cheryl
Also holy crap second comment?!
Camachri
Joyce’s eyes are the eyes of someone who’s realising a lot of things. Not all of them good…
Mr k
“Hey, you can stop looking at my chest now, Becky”
Lume
“Hell no I’m staying here forever.”
Deanatay
“I could just crawl into them and be safe forever.”
Fixed it for ya.
Cheryl
Gonna through one of these in there. talk about iorny
http://www.dumbingofage.com/2010/comic/book-1/01-move-in-day/forget/
SUGauthor
You want to talk about Irony?
http://www.dumbingofage.com/2014/comic/book-5/01-when-somebody-loved-me/get-ready/
Joe Kushner
It’s amazing how much his style has changed since then.
SUGauthor
I fully expect Joyce to break up with Ethan the next time she sees him, it won’t be pretty.
SonicBlueRanger
I’m hoping she does actually. I hope this makes her realize she doing basically the same thing Becky’s dad was doing in trying to “Fix” him.
Evan Dark
The difference is, Ethan wants to be “fixed” (at least in DoA), while Becky isn’t. There was no harm in Joyce trying to fix Ethan. That said, since it isn’t something you can fix, she is trying in vain.
I usually ship Joyce+Dorothy, but I’ll accept to sail on bor of the Joyce+Becky too.
djaevlenselv
Even if Ethan wants to, I’m not sure there’s really “no harm” in trying to “fix” him.
Evan Dark
Well, as long as he can say “No thanks, that’s enough” to Joyce, they can try all the fixing they want, and it’s all good. (presumably the “fixing” would involve premarital hanky-panky, in the name of the greater good)
The problem thing with “fixing” gay people is 1. When you are forcing someone, 2. It doesn’t actually work.
JWLM
If Joyce doesn’t figure out how cruel “fixing” Ether would be all by herself, then I think the Becky will be extremely happy to fix her on that score. I’m pretty sure that Becky would take the chance to make clear to Ethan’s parents what can happen to parents who continue to insist on “fixing” their gay children. I also think that Becky, being Becky, will (a) recognize Ethan as gay, and (b) have some words with him about coming out and staying out.
Jay
I wouldn’t say there’s NO harm, but Ethan’s active participation makes it a very different situation. That and, she’s his peer with no abilities to discipline him or leave him homeless if he doesn’t want to be ‘fixed’ or fails at it.
Kitty
I think Joyce also sticks with Ethan because he’s safe. She’s always been taught sex is evil and, with what happened at the party and with Joe, that idea has only been reinforced (and probably mixed with a hefty dose of fear). So while she probably still has an idea of “fixing” him, I think she’s more with him because she feels he’s someone she can be with without fear.
fogel
Maybe she won’t just “break up” with him — if she accepts him instead of trying to use him, maybe that could help Ethan to accept himself.
Unkind Fish
No, those are the eyes of some one who is about to shut down or
explode.
Yotsuyasan
Good girl, Joyce!
T Campbell
She looks scared, and she SHOULD: this is pretty huge. For someone of Joyce’s basic integrity, there is NO going back from this. She tries to find a safe neutral ground first. Then hesitates. Stammers.
And then rejects one of the most important tenets she grew up with, the one so-called Christians most often use to deny others the love and charity that should be the heart of their religion, and is the heart of Joyce.
Sorry Becky couldn’t help you stay true to your pre-college self, Joyce. But trust me: one day you’ll see that she gave you something much better.
Carriethedragon
This post is so beautiful.
Yotsuyasan
Indeed!
Joe
That’s beautiful. You should be a writer or something.
…wait…
Jen Aside
I see what you did there
shammers
yeah.. THE D(ildo)
PbjZ
Not what she used to be, but I guess not to the point of “broken” as Sarah is expecting. But getting there.
geno
I’m really scared what she means by Becky’s mistakes. Please Willis don’t do this again. All of these relationships are going reasonably well, and I just know you will destroy them when the time comes. I will already be crying when Shortpacked! ends. Give us some time her please!
Disloyal Subject
Not locking the door was probably a mistake.
But it looms like it may be turning out for the best.
saltchocolate
I’d say that this loving and generous version of Christianity has always been part of Joyce’s beliefs. In fact, in the showdown over her friendship with Dorothy, Joyce reminded her parents that *they* were the ones who instilled that belief in her. So Becky is actually helping Joyce see what it truly means to stand up for what she believes . . . even though it forces her to break with some of the lesser dogma, so to speak. : ) Joyce is following the Golden Rule, which is supposed to trump all the others, right?
GrumpyPanda
“A new command I give you: Love one another. As I have loved you, so you must love one another.
JWLM
Also Deut. 6:4-9, Matthew 22:34-40 and Mark 12:28-34.
If Joyce has decided that this is not a mistake on Becky’s part, then she hasn’t got any way to avoid her change of heart.
AgentKeen
🙁
LiaHansen
No, no! It’s 🙂 !!! For once in your life, it’s 🙂 !!!!
AgentKeen
Not yet.
Khrene
Dammit, you made me re-realize that the Willis Pain Train has no breaks…
After every pleasant peak comes emotional troughs teeming with torrents of trauma.
Tualha
Cardinal rule of fiction. If your characters aren’t put through hell, it’s not good writing.
timemonkey
YES! No going back now Joyce, you’ve had the revelation!
l33tmaster
with the reboot picture it just makes it even more perfect.
Yotomoe
Ethan did too at one time, timemonkey.
timemonkey
Ethan did what too?
Yotomoe
Had a revelation!
timemonkey
That he likes dudes?
Yotomoe
Mhm. And that it’s fine to like dudes.
timemonkey
It’s quite enjoyable actually.
Yotomoe
Mhm. My point is he backtracked at some point and that’s what I’m worried about.
timemonkey
He didn’t actually. He’s pretending otherwise to regain control of his life but his thing with Joyce is nothing more than a lie to the general public.
Mr k
“Don’t worry, I’ll find a good boy to make things better for you, Becky”
Doctor_Who
“I think my brother Joshua is single. That’d be sorta like dating me, right?”
Ashley
Closer than you think!
astraea
Oh geez, that’s where this is going isn’t it XD It would be kind of perfect. Like in Twelfth Night when Olivia fell for Viola dressed as a guy, only to find she had a brother who looked just like her.
Pope William T Wodium
SPOILERS
Kryss LaBryn
FROM FOUR HUNDRED YEARS AGO.
Kelly
Spoiler: Odysseus gets home and kills Penelope’s suitors
John
Eh, that’s how all Shakespeare’s comedies turn out.
(Spoiler for the tragedies: SPOILER)
Disloyal Subject
Phone can’t read mousover text, so let me guess: everybody dies at the end?
Not entirely accurate, but enough to be amusing…