Dorothy *does* have charisma, she just isn’t a narcisistic selfish twat. So it manifests less like “everyone look at Bart, he’s doing something,” and more like “hey follow me, we’re going to go do this good thing,” and it *works*.
Charisma is partly superficial charm, but it’s also the ability to _exert_ that charm. That last part is where Ms. Billingsworth is somewhat lacking. She’s much more of a do it herself type, when she does anything at all.
No she doesn’t, nor do I have any idea how you could come to that conclusion. Her absolutely failed run for RA against Roz is evidence of that, as is the fact that Dorothy has literally one friend and that’s the girl who’ll be friends with anyone.
BBCC
Dorothy does have charisma issues but I don’t think it’s true she only has one friend. Sarah likes her, and so does Becky. She gets along alright with Amber. If we’re counting exes, then she still has Walky. Joe likes her too, even if they rarely hang out anymore.
JBento
We’re counting ACTUAL friends, not merely people she has ocasional positive interactions with. Sarah top relationship status is “tolerance” and Becky spent the near entirety of their interactions deliberately antagonising Dorothy.
Discounting Joyce, Dorothy doesn’t have friends, she has coworkers with whom she’s mutually polite (and Becky doesn’t even qualify for that).
BBCC
Sarah has said in no uncertain terms that she likes Dorothy. Dorothy’s also made it pretty clear she knows Becky’s antagonism is a bit and that they are friends, even if Becky won’t admit it. She and Amber got along pretty well, even if it’s been a while since we’ve seen them one on one. Joe’s been her friend since middle school. I don’t recall if she and Walky have explicitly said they’re still friends but they still like and spend time with each other.
It’s fine if that doesn’t pass your metric for friendship but it does mine and, I suspect, Dorothy’s too.
Decidedly Orthogonal
Exactly how that conclusion was reached was spelled out explicitly. Charisma isn’t a boolean variable, nor are all types of charisma applicable in all situations. A bunch of kids being swayed by a party animal is hardly an indictment.
JBento
I await your list of people who followed Dorothy anywhere, considering that her only friend had to be DRAGGED into doing something for her own good.
Decidedly Orthogonal
Dorothy kidnapped Joyce?! I could’ve sworn she did it with nothing more than her personality and words. If only there were a word to describe such a phenomenon.
Insanenoodlyguy
A bunch of kids being swayed by a party animal IS how charisma works.
She has a small, loyal friend group but in terms of charisma she doesn’t have much for winning over the average person on the street. As pointed out to her the other people in her dorm like her well enough but perceive her as the mom friend who tries too hard and less like the type of person they would want as a leader. Not saying she wouldn’t make a good leader but the average person in comic doesn’t respond well to Dorothy’s analytical method of pleasing people.
Don’t worry, it’s not a JOB job exactly, more like the guy’s commissioning me to do specific things every week for a hobby project he REALLY wants to take to the next level. Really nice guy too. ?
It’s more real-time strategy, taking after titles like Mobile Legends and Pikmin, with ant colonies. ?
JBento
Finally a SimAnt remake?
Marianne
My one piece of advice is to MAKE SURE that when an ant explodes, ant limbs fly off comedically in six directions. I think we can all agree that without the comedic insect gore, it would be a waste of “exploding ants” as a video game premise ?
I mean, this is Jennifer “Alpha bongo” Billingsworth we’re talking about here. I’m not sure her ego could handle recognizing someone as both interesting and decent.
The fact that Dorothy being angry for the first time in Jenifer’s memory is a turn on to Jenifer underlines how little Jenifer’s opinion matters on this issue.
lol i don’t think i’ve ever heard anyone call themselves ‘charismatic’, even the more confident ppl but i don’t go outta m yway to hang out with ‘arrogant’ ppl. that said maybe yale won’t work out after all lol
I could see someone saying they’ve got charisma in a group of 8+ people where someone is looking for a spokesperson. Since beyond 6 people it starts to get unreasonable that everyone knows everyone’s skills and talents.
And Jenifer is rare enough in Dorothy’s circles to get close to the 7 person limit on knowing everyone while also Jenifer can have a fairly solid read on Dorothy.
She only said that because Jennifer brought it up first, though. It’s not like she said “I’m charismatic!” unprompted. I don’t see how responding to a critical statement is arrogant
I wonder if Dorothy will actually make it as a politician. I don’t know if it is caused by stress or lack of sleep or other issues Dorothy is dealing. Probably all 3 if I had to take a guess. Anyone got a different take on this?
well by the time she’s the age to be a senator? congresswoman? hopefully she’d be used to dealing iwth the political bs assuming she doesn’t spend a few years interning for indiana’s governor or whatever (not sure if that’s a requirement but i imagine she’d want to intern unelss she wants to graduate yale and immediately announce her plans in a more ‘official’ announcement rather htan telling her peers
Dorothy’s got a decent head for a lot of actual management shit but politicking doesn’t come naturally to her in the way it does for say, Becky and Roz.
@thag: so she’s best suited to be ‘behind the scenes/closed doors’ as a more presidential advisor than a public face (which for some ppl might be ideal tbh, get some stuff accomplished with none of the backlash for the most partl ol)
thejeff
To some extent. Plenty of people without huge natural charisma or natural politicking talent still do well in politics though.
She’s just Hilary instead of Bill.
Honestly, I don’t consider Roz that charismatic, either. Mostly, her charisma comes across as an informed ability, because she makes a big stink and somehow it works out for her because that’s how Willis wants the plot to go.
Becky, OTOH, actually comes across as genuinely likeable and memorable. I buy her time as Robin’s campaign manager way more than I do Roz’ dog-and-pony shows.
It’s not a term I ever hear in the UK, but does policy wonk fit at all? She’s good at theoretical solutions, but they’d need to be run past a few real world ™ experts before you’d ever want to use them politically.
Maybe? Yes, I’d agree that she may need help voicing her opinions and solutions. However, she needs to learn to do so without emotions, or at the very least low level emotions.
@Pirate: flash forward ten years, she’s somehow /becky’/s campaign manager
Needfuldoer
At the inauguration:
[Chief Justice]: “… solemnly swear to preserve, protect, and defend the COnstitution of the United States of America?”
[Becky]: “You betcha!”
[Dorothy, internally]: ♫ How could this happen to me? ♫
I suspect Dorothy will become increasingly disillusioned (if Roz hasn’t already initiated the process) when she realizes how inevitably compromised (not in the good way) one becomes as a politician; I.e. constant fundraising, prioritizing constituencies over personal convictions, becoming more of the things you professed to hate. Of course Dorothy also seems very capable of self deception and denial.
I mean I kinda get what Dorothy is saying. I don’t think we’d have this outburst if Billie had followed through on helping Joyce all the way through getting the medication.
well, she did stay with the whole doctor visit, and attempting visiting her room later, i feel like after that interaction , she would’ve wanted joyce to text her asking for help rather than accompanying her and also getting past sarah again lol
256 thoughts on “Seething”
Ana Chronistic
which points did you dump into charisma tho, the + ones or the – ones
Morhek
Dorothy chooses bard and THEN rolls stats for it and puts the low charisma in where the dice gods intended it to be.
Doctor_Who
Dorothy: “I rolled 3d6, 6 times, IN ORDER! Any other method is houseruling!”
John Campbell
My first AD&D character, rolled that way, was a fighter with an 18/00 Strength.
Minkey93
I mean to be fair I roll stats after I choose a class. But I don’t make them put them in the order rolled. They can put them where-ever
Decidedly Orthogonal
Dorothy *does* have charisma, she just isn’t a narcisistic selfish twat. So it manifests less like “everyone look at Bart, he’s doing something,” and more like “hey follow me, we’re going to go do this good thing,” and it *works*.
Charisma is partly superficial charm, but it’s also the ability to _exert_ that charm. That last part is where Ms. Billingsworth is somewhat lacking. She’s much more of a do it herself type, when she does anything at all.
JBento
No she doesn’t, nor do I have any idea how you could come to that conclusion. Her absolutely failed run for RA against Roz is evidence of that, as is the fact that Dorothy has literally one friend and that’s the girl who’ll be friends with anyone.
BBCC
Dorothy does have charisma issues but I don’t think it’s true she only has one friend. Sarah likes her, and so does Becky. She gets along alright with Amber. If we’re counting exes, then she still has Walky. Joe likes her too, even if they rarely hang out anymore.
JBento
We’re counting ACTUAL friends, not merely people she has ocasional positive interactions with. Sarah top relationship status is “tolerance” and Becky spent the near entirety of their interactions deliberately antagonising Dorothy.
Discounting Joyce, Dorothy doesn’t have friends, she has coworkers with whom she’s mutually polite (and Becky doesn’t even qualify for that).
BBCC
Sarah has said in no uncertain terms that she likes Dorothy. Dorothy’s also made it pretty clear she knows Becky’s antagonism is a bit and that they are friends, even if Becky won’t admit it. She and Amber got along pretty well, even if it’s been a while since we’ve seen them one on one. Joe’s been her friend since middle school. I don’t recall if she and Walky have explicitly said they’re still friends but they still like and spend time with each other.
It’s fine if that doesn’t pass your metric for friendship but it does mine and, I suspect, Dorothy’s too.
Decidedly Orthogonal
Exactly how that conclusion was reached was spelled out explicitly. Charisma isn’t a boolean variable, nor are all types of charisma applicable in all situations. A bunch of kids being swayed by a party animal is hardly an indictment.
JBento
I await your list of people who followed Dorothy anywhere, considering that her only friend had to be DRAGGED into doing something for her own good.
Decidedly Orthogonal
Dorothy kidnapped Joyce?! I could’ve sworn she did it with nothing more than her personality and words. If only there were a word to describe such a phenomenon.
Insanenoodlyguy
A bunch of kids being swayed by a party animal IS how charisma works.
Archieve
She has a small, loyal friend group but in terms of charisma she doesn’t have much for winning over the average person on the street. As pointed out to her the other people in her dorm like her well enough but perceive her as the mom friend who tries too hard and less like the type of person they would want as a leader. Not saying she wouldn’t make a good leader but the average person in comic doesn’t respond well to Dorothy’s analytical method of pleasing people.
The Wellerman
Stay presidential, Dorothy ?
Also, I finally got a paid coding gig! Yay!!! ?
I’m helping make a 3D strategy game for mobile! Wish me luck!
RassilonTDavros
Congrats and good luck!
anon
congrats! get that bread as the kids say
Kyrik Michalowski
Congratulations, it seems like finding coding work is difficuot lately. Good luck and may the winds be ever in your favor.
Laura
Prosperity and success to you!
Decidedly Orthogonal
Dude thats awesome! Congrats!
cbwroses
Good luck!
Clif
Yay!!!
fridge_logic
Having seen the gaming industry treat coders like shit, I wish you well and hope you have found a good roost to nest in.
fridge_logic
Also if they start abusing you look for better work. it’s out there and will be easier to find with some experience to your name.
The Wellerman
Don’t worry, it’s not a JOB job exactly, more like the guy’s commissioning me to do specific things every week for a hobby project he REALLY wants to take to the next level. Really nice guy too. ?
The Wellerman
*plays “Livin’ in the Sunlight, Lovin’ in the Moonlight” by Tiny Tim on the hacked muzak*
JBento
Congratulations!
Also, as a fan of strategy games (Friends and Dragons is my mobile past time of choice these days), I’d like to know more about this.
The Wellerman
It’s more real-time strategy, taking after titles like Mobile Legends and Pikmin, with ant colonies. ?
JBento
Finally a SimAnt remake?
Marianne
My one piece of advice is to MAKE SURE that when an ant explodes, ant limbs fly off comedically in six directions. I think we can all agree that without the comedic insect gore, it would be a waste of “exploding ants” as a video game premise ?
jpnr
Congratulations!
go code the shit out of some 3d
True Survivor
Congratulations!
BBCC
Awesome! Good luck with the new job and congrats <3
Joy
luck to you!
Amós Batista
Congratz! Dorothy for president.
Thag Simmons
Dorothy has solid dork charisma, which admittedly is probably not a form of charisma that Jennifer recognizes.
C.T. Phipps
Dorothy has charisma that makes only a select number of people like her and unable to persuade anyone of anything.
Sirksome
I kinda don’t like peeps implying Dorothy is bland because she’s a decent person most of the time.
anon
given Robin as a politician, I’d gladly welcome a “bland” future president
Wizard
Most of our better Presidents have arguably been a bit bland, but it’s entirely possible to be bland and terrible at the same time.
thakoru
I mean, this is Jennifer “Alpha bongo” Billingsworth we’re talking about here. I’m not sure her ego could handle recognizing someone as both interesting and decent.
fridge_logic
The fact that Dorothy being angry for the first time in Jenifer’s memory is a turn on to Jenifer underlines how little Jenifer’s opinion matters on this issue.
Sirksome
Jennifer’s not the only one to say this. Becky said it too in a somewhat more insulting manner.
Yotomoe
I don’t think she’s bland BECAUSE she’s a decent person. I just think she’s bland AND a decent person.
BarerMender
Well said.
Kyrik Michalowski
Can’t disagree there. Then again I don’t think about Dorothy much which might be more damning.
Reaver
Yeah poor Dorothy can’t win, lol either she’s bland and too perfect, or literally the worst thing ever because she’s overbearing.
anon
lol i don’t think i’ve ever heard anyone call themselves ‘charismatic’, even the more confident ppl but i don’t go outta m yway to hang out with ‘arrogant’ ppl. that said maybe yale won’t work out after all lol
StClair
“Hey! Nobody calls Soundwave uncrazimatic!”
fridge_logic
I could see someone saying they’ve got charisma in a group of 8+ people where someone is looking for a spokesperson. Since beyond 6 people it starts to get unreasonable that everyone knows everyone’s skills and talents.
And Jenifer is rare enough in Dorothy’s circles to get close to the 7 person limit on knowing everyone while also Jenifer can have a fairly solid read on Dorothy.
Needfuldoer
MBA-types do.
tunasammich
She only said that because Jennifer brought it up first, though. It’s not like she said “I’m charismatic!” unprompted. I don’t see how responding to a critical statement is arrogant
Kyrik Michalowski
I wonder if Dorothy will actually make it as a politician. I don’t know if it is caused by stress or lack of sleep or other issues Dorothy is dealing. Probably all 3 if I had to take a guess. Anyone got a different take on this?
anon
well by the time she’s the age to be a senator? congresswoman? hopefully she’d be used to dealing iwth the political bs assuming she doesn’t spend a few years interning for indiana’s governor or whatever (not sure if that’s a requirement but i imagine she’d want to intern unelss she wants to graduate yale and immediately announce her plans in a more ‘official’ announcement rather htan telling her peers
Needfuldoer
25 for the House, 30 for the Senate, and 35 for the presidency.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_candidacy_laws_in_the_United_States#Federal_government
Thag Simmons
Dorothy’s got a decent head for a lot of actual management shit but politicking doesn’t come naturally to her in the way it does for say, Becky and Roz.
anon
@thag: so she’s best suited to be ‘behind the scenes/closed doors’ as a more presidential advisor than a public face (which for some ppl might be ideal tbh, get some stuff accomplished with none of the backlash for the most partl ol)
thejeff
To some extent. Plenty of people without huge natural charisma or natural politicking talent still do well in politics though.
She’s just Hilary instead of Bill.
Freemage
Honestly, I don’t consider Roz that charismatic, either. Mostly, her charisma comes across as an informed ability, because she makes a big stink and somehow it works out for her because that’s how Willis wants the plot to go.
Becky, OTOH, actually comes across as genuinely likeable and memorable. I buy her time as Robin’s campaign manager way more than I do Roz’ dog-and-pony shows.
Needfuldoer
Dorothy would probably be an effective legislator, but not a good candidate.
PirateTawnee
It’s not a term I ever hear in the UK, but does policy wonk fit at all? She’s good at theoretical solutions, but they’d need to be run past a few real world ™ experts before you’d ever want to use them politically.
Kyrik Michalowski
Maybe? Yes, I’d agree that she may need help voicing her opinions and solutions. However, she needs to learn to do so without emotions, or at the very least low level emotions.
anon
@Pirate: flash forward ten years, she’s somehow /becky’/s campaign manager
Needfuldoer
At the inauguration:
[Chief Justice]: “… solemnly swear to preserve, protect, and defend the COnstitution of the United States of America?”
[Becky]: “You betcha!”
[Dorothy, internally]: ♫ How could this happen to me? ♫
Dr. Gonzo
I suspect Dorothy will become increasingly disillusioned (if Roz hasn’t already initiated the process) when she realizes how inevitably compromised (not in the good way) one becomes as a politician; I.e. constant fundraising, prioritizing constituencies over personal convictions, becoming more of the things you professed to hate. Of course Dorothy also seems very capable of self deception and denial.
Dr. Gonzo
* I meant to say Robin not Roz
bubba0077
She’s more of a Chief of Staff than a politician.
Cmasta1992
Dorothy is has poor SpD base stats, a negative SpD nature but still insists on putting max EVs into it and is surprised at the results
thakoru
Jennifer, that’s not quite what that idiom means – Dorothy basically perpetually has a fire lit under her ass.
fireprincesslily
I mean I kinda get what Dorothy is saying. I don’t think we’d have this outburst if Billie had followed through on helping Joyce all the way through getting the medication.
anon
well, she did stay with the whole doctor visit, and attempting visiting her room later, i feel like after that interaction , she would’ve wanted joyce to text her asking for help rather than accompanying her and also getting past sarah again lol