My grandmother, who was a huge football fan, actually DID have this – a separate room with equal access to the kitchen where people who didn’t want to watch the game could hide and watch something else.
In my experience, at Superbowl parties, the men tend to hang out in the living room to watch the game as the women hang out in the kitchen to talk. Just what I’ve noticed. Afterwards folks migrate outside to play darts. My favorite part!
Bittersweet
In Texas, weirdly, I’ve never seen a gender divide in Super Bowl parties. Mom makes all the cold food, Dad makes all the hot food, party guests bring all the extra stuff and then everybody watches the game together while the husbands/boyfriends cower from their wives/girlfriends because we’re 9000x louder about our support of a team than they are. Usually I can’t even talk by the end of the night, it’s so much fun (provided the teams are evenly matched but not too good.)
Among peers rather than families the division of labor might be different, but I don’t think I’ve ever met someone at a Super Bowl party that wasn’t there to watch the Super Bowl (other than my husband who does not know football and alternates between asking questions and devouring stuffed jalapeños.)
Yeah, I’m definitely rooting for him to be good, but it feels significant that both of the people we know he’s considered friends have been characterized as complete douchebags.
At least he’s made it clear that Paul isn’t a friend of his anymore, and who knows maybe Beef’s cleaned up his act since move-in day.
Dante
It’s important to consider what we’ve seen of Tony from the start (“freshman I won’t buy you beer” to Jennifer, telling Danny he wouldn’t bully him for being queer), apart from the rescue and all.
He’s been adamant on the No Nonsense thing. Some assholes are a part of the football team, so yeah, Tony knows them… And he’s probs been dropping them like yesterday’s garbage every time he spots Bullshit Behavior.
When you mention Paul, I think there may be a Message here. That Tony, favored son of the dean, star of the football team, extraordinarily level headed, firmly anti-bullying and all that, is not immune to having a close friend turn dangerously radical in very little time.
And also while we’re getting far too deep into these one note side characters, I theorize Beef has been dragged along with a bad crowd without much say in the matter. (Literally, cause he’s nonverbal.) Being with Tony would certainly help him stay out of trouble.
The Queer Agenda [frog memes]
I don’t assume too much about character by association at that age. Many people are only starting to sort themselves by ideological compatibility, thus social circles tend to be highly combustible.
My late teens friend groups were a mix of what turned out to be absolutely horrible and absolutely wonderful people. It took some fairly ugly dramafests to learn who the shitheads were, and that any further contact was a lost cause.
Needfuldoer
Yeah, I only got into social media many years after high school. “I wonder what so-and-so has been up to, I should look them up…” is a dangerous game.
well i don’t expect tony to have any hangups i wouldn’t mind depth but a lot of it is sarah’s issues with connecting with ppl , doesn’t mean tehy can’t have fun versus ending up being married in the long run lol
Didn’t Tony’s dad sleep with Sal and Walky’s shitty racist mom, though?
Thomas
You’re allowed to be mistaken about the people you sleep with. Hopefully not in a big way, though. Linda’s racism is quite subtle & may not have been apparent when they dated.
The Queer Agenda [frog memes]
And quit decades ago. For all we know, he might have dumped her for being cringe.
When I was younger and more social, I would go to a party, sit on the couch with a book or a crossword puzzle, and happily spend the whole evening “alone”, ensconced in my reading or puzzling, letting folks chatter around me. It was comforting social background noise, and nobody bothered me. In part because when I talked I usually said the wrong thing and made people uncomfortable! Then I would usually fall asleep on the couch and walk home the next morning. Social solitude. I was so lucky to find folks who let me do that. For a while.
I’m trying to think of who in the comic are boyfriends that are even in the same league as Tony right now. Joe? Pretty solid, but still finding his legs. Jacob? Loses too many points for kissing Joyce prior to breaking up with Raidah in previous boyfriending role. Walky? Too held back from emotional vulnerability. Jason, nah. Asher, nah.
Danny. Okay. Danny and Tony are the league, but I’m pretty sure Tony is currently winning.
Eh, Danny is a five. He’s perfectly fine, works hard, is available. I think his commitment to the ukulele bit smells like pure desperation to give himself something of a personality.
But Tony is a grade eleven boyfriend on a scale from one to ten. I’m a lesbian and I want to date him. Just look at this fine ass display – how he’s quietly accommodating Sarah’s lack of social interest, navigating her meeting with the nonverbal Beef, plainly stating the rules and expectations for their hang-out, AND digging up thirty pillows from somewhere. All this just for a casual daytime dorm room date. Completely off the charts.
Yumi
Danny may be mid in some ways, but he has been a pretty good boyfriend to Sal.
Dante
I’d say on Danny’s favor he’s younger so it’s perfectly normal he’s still finding his legs. But he learned a lot as Amber/AG’s boyfriend, and they broke up, and he kept learning and growing up. He wooed Sal through a series of sweet, thoughtful displays that demonstrated he understood her, and hasn’t given signs of stopping :33 I like him!
… That said: Super agreeing on Tony being off the charts. Saying he’s got game is doing him a disservice, dude’s on entirely another dimension.
Steamweed
If Tony’s not the team captain, I expect he’s one of the lieutenants.
Thanks for noticing! I thought I was pretty funny.
The Lurker
Did’nt XKCD have a rule for that?
Nadamás
I find his commitment to the ukelele bit to be very endearing in how genuine he is about it.
Sirksome
I won’t tolerate any Danny boyfriend slander. He is a top tier man. A catch if you will. He’s the kinda boyfriend that was doing Amber’s laundry unprompted just because she might have been having a tough day.
We never saw what he was really like dating Dorothy because she broke up with him at the very start of the comic but I assume he was excellent. Dorothy just didn’t like him anymore if she ever did.
And we’ve seen how he treats Sal a girl with plenty of walls she puts up. Patient, respectful, and thoughtful. Danny is great boyfriend material. Feel free to continue mocking him for what a huge dweeb he is though. That’s fair game.
Nadamás
And he makes sandwiches! Never forget about the sandwiches that is very important.
thejeff
There are hints about Danny when he was with Dorothy and I think he’s grown since then.
Li
+500
Yes, sometimes two people break up in a fully no-fault situation, because they’ve just grown apart, but this attitude about Dorothy/Danny is as frustrating as people who wanna act like Joe hasn’t changed.
Y’all are robbing these boys of hard-earned character arcs, darn it.
Sirksome
I’ll die on the Danny is not a bad boyfriend hill. He’s pure wife material. His faults in that break up weren’t about him being a bad partner. Arguably the exact opposite. He was too attached to what was likely never really a romantic relationship to begin with. Didn’t have his own identity. But I don’t think he was actually a bad guy to be around. Hell she was still asking him for favors post breakup and realized herself that was a lot to expect from her ex.
Danny has developed a lot as his own person. Not trying to undercut that. Just not sure what we’re judging his boyfriend level on. His compatibility with his partners or the actual actions he does as a partner like Tony here properly setting a place for his antisocial queen?
Danny is at the top of the boyfriend stack, and it’s not even close.
Li
I agree that he’s a good boyfriend now and that he handled Amber about as well as anyone could have at the time. I don’t agree that he and Dorothy broke up “because she just didn’t like him anymore, if she ever did”.
Li
Like, Dorothy told Walky that she’s had bad experiences with the moms of partners who have gotten too attached to her too fast, and she described getting a picture frame with a Bible verse engraved that talked about marital commitments. She was sixteen. She said this mom called her “a treasure”; Danny’s mom then called her a treasure later…
Li
Which, to be clear, isn’t Danny’s fault? Danny’s parents are definitely worse for him to deal with than they were for Dorothy.
I don’t actually think Danny’s clinginess was his main offense with Dorothy. As I’ve expressed elsewhere (but I say that to avoid feeling like a broken record, not because I expect anyone else to read all my comments lol), I think the conversation that led to their breakup prominently featured Danny not listening to Dorothy even a little bit. (He was misreading her tone and body language so badly, too badly for him to have been listening to her.) And then he was dismissive of her lifelong dream.
She would’ve broken up with him anyway, because by that point she didn’t want to be dating him anymore, but he was not being a stellar boyfriend in what little we saw of their interactions, and I doubt Willis showed us what they did by accident.
Sirksome
@Li- I mean I would like to talk about that at some point but maybe this isn’t the strip for it. Something more Dorothy or Danny focused. I just have a theory that I don’t think Dorothy was ever in love with Danny. She’s never shown that emotional of a connection with him like she has with Walky or Joyce even. But I’ll save it for later. This strips comments are already pretty intense which I did not see coming.
Li
I think that’s an interesting theory even though I don’t agree (I think we just saw the tail-end of a three-year relationship). But sure, we can talk about it some other time.
deliverything
It’s probably a good thing that, when I was still figuring out I’m aroace, I never ended up dating someone like Tony. Would’ve been so tempting to pretend to be romantically or sexually interested just to remain with someone so considerate…
Agree. Danny’s definitely in the running, and Joe is playing dark horse for the title, but Tony’s in the lead so far.
A fun metric might be “mistakes made, divided by number of strips they appear in”.
thejeff
Part of the trouble is how few strips Tony has appeared in. We’ve got a good feel for the flaws of the other contenders, but we don’t know anything of Tony’s yet.
If he’s to be an interesting character, they’ll show up eventually and we’ll be better able to judge then.
Okay, so with the time of year and being Indiana, I assume “the game” is basketball, but… let’s make some other suggestions for what it could be. I’d like it to be water polo or high-stakes Go Fish.
Granted I’m Australian so might just be cultural, but how is that the funniest?
CrimsonStorm
Just relatively obscure, given how self-obsessed America tends to be about its sports (and how cricket is mostly not a thing here).
Doctor_Who
Well, for one old school Cricket players dressed like this absolute dork.
Shade
Sadly they don’t dress like that anymore. They pretty much look the same as any other sports uniforms these days.
Aura
I wouldn’t necessarily say like any other sports uniforms. For ODIs sure, but in test cricket you have the ‘whites’ (everyone on both teams dressed all in white, with the exception of their hats/helmets), and I think local cricket also is often in whites not uniforms? But idk, I never really got into cricket, most of what I know is by osmosis from family members.
382 thoughts on “Steven”
NGPZ
YEEEEES let the romance commence! ^^
*plays “Masquerade” by Mystery Kindaichi Band on hacked muzak*
Anon
sarah being cat coded :3
Doctor_Who
In honor of this moment, something is getting renamed “Other Tony” tonight.
Or perhaps “Inferior Tony”.
Risky
Don’t do Tony’s little friend Tiny Tony dirty like that, that’s her chosen calling.
Arianod
Our Tony is clearly the superior one.
Charles Phipps
I wish my dad had allowed this during football games.
Rose by Any other Name
My grandmother, who was a huge football fan, actually DID have this – a separate room with equal access to the kitchen where people who didn’t want to watch the game could hide and watch something else.
Laura
In my experience, at Superbowl parties, the men tend to hang out in the living room to watch the game as the women hang out in the kitchen to talk. Just what I’ve noticed. Afterwards folks migrate outside to play darts. My favorite part!
Bittersweet
In Texas, weirdly, I’ve never seen a gender divide in Super Bowl parties. Mom makes all the cold food, Dad makes all the hot food, party guests bring all the extra stuff and then everybody watches the game together while the husbands/boyfriends cower from their wives/girlfriends because we’re 9000x louder about our support of a team than they are. Usually I can’t even talk by the end of the night, it’s so much fun (provided the teams are evenly matched but not too good.)
Among peers rather than families the division of labor might be different, but I don’t think I’ve ever met someone at a Super Bowl party that wasn’t there to watch the Super Bowl (other than my husband who does not know football and alternates between asking questions and devouring stuffed jalapeños.)
AeromechanicalAce
Damn. Sarah, don’t let this one go, he’s a Keeper.
Thag Simmons
Very strong opening plays at least, but honestly when a dude comes out this perfect in a story I’m always waiting for a shoe to drop.
clif
Considerate at any rate.
Thag Simmons
Yeah, I’m definitely rooting for him to be good, but it feels significant that both of the people we know he’s considered friends have been characterized as complete douchebags.
At least he’s made it clear that Paul isn’t a friend of his anymore, and who knows maybe Beef’s cleaned up his act since move-in day.
Dante
It’s important to consider what we’ve seen of Tony from the start (“freshman I won’t buy you beer” to Jennifer, telling Danny he wouldn’t bully him for being queer), apart from the rescue and all.
He’s been adamant on the No Nonsense thing. Some assholes are a part of the football team, so yeah, Tony knows them… And he’s probs been dropping them like yesterday’s garbage every time he spots Bullshit Behavior.
Thag Simmons
I certainly hope so.
Amelie Wikström
When you mention Paul, I think there may be a Message here. That Tony, favored son of the dean, star of the football team, extraordinarily level headed, firmly anti-bullying and all that, is not immune to having a close friend turn dangerously radical in very little time.
And also while we’re getting far too deep into these one note side characters, I theorize Beef has been dragged along with a bad crowd without much say in the matter. (Literally, cause he’s nonverbal.) Being with Tony would certainly help him stay out of trouble.
The Queer Agenda [frog memes]
I don’t assume too much about character by association at that age. Many people are only starting to sort themselves by ideological compatibility, thus social circles tend to be highly combustible.
My late teens friend groups were a mix of what turned out to be absolutely horrible and absolutely wonderful people. It took some fairly ugly dramafests to learn who the shitheads were, and that any further contact was a lost cause.
Needfuldoer
Yeah, I only got into social media many years after high school. “I wonder what so-and-so has been up to, I should look them up…” is a dangerous game.
Anon
well i don’t expect tony to have any hangups i wouldn’t mind depth but a lot of it is sarah’s issues with connecting with ppl , doesn’t mean tehy can’t have fun versus ending up being married in the long run lol
Steamweed
He has good administration and management traits in common with his father. Both of them seem to be good and thoughtful leaders of people.
Julie
Didn’t Tony’s dad sleep with Sal and Walky’s shitty racist mom, though?
Thomas
You’re allowed to be mistaken about the people you sleep with. Hopefully not in a big way, though. Linda’s racism is quite subtle & may not have been apparent when they dated.
The Queer Agenda [frog memes]
And quit decades ago. For all we know, he might have dumped her for being cringe.
Taffy
Dean McHenry, all those years ago: “Bro, you have posted cringe. You are going to lose husband.”
thejeff
Not just slept with, but married. And is still friendly with.
Steamweed
Oh, he did, but, y’know that’s sex. Definitely I’ve sexed some people I think I should not have nowadays.
Thag Simmons
He did marry her
Opus the Poet
He seems thoughtful that Sarah might not want to watch the game, but still might want to have snacks.
lightsabermario
Wrong football, I think he’s the quarterback.
Needfuldoer
Would it be worse if he was the Nickelback?
Elf grrl
PUT A RING ON IT, SARAH!!!!
Mr D
I Hope you mean his finger :V
morleuca
As long as it’s easily removable, it should be fine
HeatherJean
Depends on what you mean by “easily removable,” I suppose.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=do9xPQHI9G0&pp=ygUfbG9yZCBvZiB0aGUgY29ja3JpbmcgamFjayBibGFjaw%3D%3D
Steamweed
Always ask for consent before you do the prince albert thing with your boyfriend.
JD
finally someone treats her like the queen she is thank you tony i love you tony
Laura
I love it too.
When I was younger and more social, I would go to a party, sit on the couch with a book or a crossword puzzle, and happily spend the whole evening “alone”, ensconced in my reading or puzzling, letting folks chatter around me. It was comforting social background noise, and nobody bothered me. In part because when I talked I usually said the wrong thing and made people uncomfortable! Then I would usually fall asleep on the couch and walk home the next morning. Social solitude. I was so lucky to find folks who let me do that. For a while.
NGPZ
yep, that right there is my autistic experience with parties growing up in a nutshell, well put XD
Doopyboop
Tony is the perfect boyfriend for an introvert.
AK
Yeah the explicit parallel play option is so awesome.
Shade
Damn, Tony is gunning for title of best boyfriend and he might have already taken the lead.
Tan
I’m trying to think of who in the comic are boyfriends that are even in the same league as Tony right now. Joe? Pretty solid, but still finding his legs. Jacob? Loses too many points for kissing Joyce prior to breaking up with Raidah in previous boyfriending role. Walky? Too held back from emotional vulnerability. Jason, nah. Asher, nah.
Danny. Okay. Danny and Tony are the league, but I’m pretty sure Tony is currently winning.
Amelie Wikström
Eh, Danny is a five. He’s perfectly fine, works hard, is available. I think his commitment to the ukulele bit smells like pure desperation to give himself something of a personality.
But Tony is a grade eleven boyfriend on a scale from one to ten. I’m a lesbian and I want to date him. Just look at this fine ass display – how he’s quietly accommodating Sarah’s lack of social interest, navigating her meeting with the nonverbal Beef, plainly stating the rules and expectations for their hang-out, AND digging up thirty pillows from somewhere. All this just for a casual daytime dorm room date. Completely off the charts.
Yumi
Danny may be mid in some ways, but he has been a pretty good boyfriend to Sal.
Dante
I’d say on Danny’s favor he’s younger so it’s perfectly normal he’s still finding his legs. But he learned a lot as Amber/AG’s boyfriend, and they broke up, and he kept learning and growing up. He wooed Sal through a series of sweet, thoughtful displays that demonstrated he understood her, and hasn’t given signs of stopping :33 I like him!
… That said: Super agreeing on Tony being off the charts. Saying he’s got game is doing him a disservice, dude’s on entirely another dimension.
Steamweed
If Tony’s not the team captain, I expect he’s one of the lieutenants.
Freezer
Football teams tend to have multiple captains, with one considered “first among equals.” That one is usually, but not always, the quarterback.
Steamweed
Totally expect the Hoosier fb team to go that way.
eh, whatever
…Sometimes, hyphens are really, really important.
Amelie Wikström
Thanks for noticing! I thought I was pretty funny.
The Lurker
Did’nt XKCD have a rule for that?
Nadamás
I find his commitment to the ukelele bit to be very endearing in how genuine he is about it.
Sirksome
I won’t tolerate any Danny boyfriend slander. He is a top tier man. A catch if you will. He’s the kinda boyfriend that was doing Amber’s laundry unprompted just because she might have been having a tough day.
We never saw what he was really like dating Dorothy because she broke up with him at the very start of the comic but I assume he was excellent. Dorothy just didn’t like him anymore if she ever did.
And we’ve seen how he treats Sal a girl with plenty of walls she puts up. Patient, respectful, and thoughtful. Danny is great boyfriend material. Feel free to continue mocking him for what a huge dweeb he is though. That’s fair game.
Nadamás
And he makes sandwiches! Never forget about the sandwiches that is very important.
thejeff
There are hints about Danny when he was with Dorothy and I think he’s grown since then.
Li
+500
Yes, sometimes two people break up in a fully no-fault situation, because they’ve just grown apart, but this attitude about Dorothy/Danny is as frustrating as people who wanna act like Joe hasn’t changed.
Y’all are robbing these boys of hard-earned character arcs, darn it.
Sirksome
I’ll die on the Danny is not a bad boyfriend hill. He’s pure wife material. His faults in that break up weren’t about him being a bad partner. Arguably the exact opposite. He was too attached to what was likely never really a romantic relationship to begin with. Didn’t have his own identity. But I don’t think he was actually a bad guy to be around. Hell she was still asking him for favors post breakup and realized herself that was a lot to expect from her ex.
Danny has developed a lot as his own person. Not trying to undercut that. Just not sure what we’re judging his boyfriend level on. His compatibility with his partners or the actual actions he does as a partner like Tony here properly setting a place for his antisocial queen?
Taffy
Danny is at the top of the boyfriend stack, and it’s not even close.
Li
I agree that he’s a good boyfriend now and that he handled Amber about as well as anyone could have at the time. I don’t agree that he and Dorothy broke up “because she just didn’t like him anymore, if she ever did”.
Li
Like, Dorothy told Walky that she’s had bad experiences with the moms of partners who have gotten too attached to her too fast, and she described getting a picture frame with a Bible verse engraved that talked about marital commitments. She was sixteen. She said this mom called her “a treasure”; Danny’s mom then called her a treasure later…
Li
Which, to be clear, isn’t Danny’s fault? Danny’s parents are definitely worse for him to deal with than they were for Dorothy.
I don’t actually think Danny’s clinginess was his main offense with Dorothy. As I’ve expressed elsewhere (but I say that to avoid feeling like a broken record, not because I expect anyone else to read all my comments lol), I think the conversation that led to their breakup prominently featured Danny not listening to Dorothy even a little bit. (He was misreading her tone and body language so badly, too badly for him to have been listening to her.) And then he was dismissive of her lifelong dream.
She would’ve broken up with him anyway, because by that point she didn’t want to be dating him anymore, but he was not being a stellar boyfriend in what little we saw of their interactions, and I doubt Willis showed us what they did by accident.
Sirksome
@Li- I mean I would like to talk about that at some point but maybe this isn’t the strip for it. Something more Dorothy or Danny focused. I just have a theory that I don’t think Dorothy was ever in love with Danny. She’s never shown that emotional of a connection with him like she has with Walky or Joyce even. But I’ll save it for later. This strips comments are already pretty intense which I did not see coming.
Li
I think that’s an interesting theory even though I don’t agree (I think we just saw the tail-end of a three-year relationship). But sure, we can talk about it some other time.
deliverything
It’s probably a good thing that, when I was still figuring out I’m aroace, I never ended up dating someone like Tony. Would’ve been so tempting to pretend to be romantically or sexually interested just to remain with someone so considerate…
Jamie
Agree. Danny’s definitely in the running, and Joe is playing dark horse for the title, but Tony’s in the lead so far.
A fun metric might be “mistakes made, divided by number of strips they appear in”.
thejeff
Part of the trouble is how few strips Tony has appeared in. We’ve got a good feel for the flaws of the other contenders, but we don’t know anything of Tony’s yet.
If he’s to be an interesting character, they’ll show up eventually and we’ll be better able to judge then.
Yumi
Okay, so with the time of year and being Indiana, I assume “the game” is basketball, but… let’s make some other suggestions for what it could be. I’d like it to be water polo or high-stakes Go Fish.
Doctor_Who
I looked up what professional sports leagues play in January to find the funniest answer.
Tony and Beef are both huge fans of Australian Cricket until proven otherwise.
Shade
Granted I’m Australian so might just be cultural, but how is that the funniest?
CrimsonStorm
Just relatively obscure, given how self-obsessed America tends to be about its sports (and how cricket is mostly not a thing here).
Doctor_Who
Well, for one old school Cricket players dressed like this absolute dork.
Shade
Sadly they don’t dress like that anymore. They pretty much look the same as any other sports uniforms these days.
Aura
I wouldn’t necessarily say like any other sports uniforms. For ODIs sure, but in test cricket you have the ‘whites’ (everyone on both teams dressed all in white, with the exception of their hats/helmets), and I think local cricket also is often in whites not uniforms? But idk, I never really got into cricket, most of what I know is by osmosis from family members.