Huh, there are no male redheads in the cast, are there? And at least four girls (Carla, Ruth, Becky, Rose).
Taffy
There’s Joyce’s dad, he’s a redhead.
Nono
Is this a terminology thing? Last I checked Hank was blonde.
Taffy
I don’t know what people call it where you live, but in my area we call that hair color “red”.
Kamino Neko
By the patches of non-grey we see, he seems to have had the same colour hair as Joyce, back before he went grey. Which very much is not red. Dirty blond is what I’d call it.
Those overalls remind me of the outfits the Autobots wore in Only Human, which is perfectly suited to a character who started off as a car’s humansona.
In the Walkyverse, Carla began life as “Ultra Car”, a car that was granted sentience and various other abilities by Joe. He eventually installed her mind in a human looking body.
Since the sci-fi stuff doesn’t exist in this universe, Ultra Car is a television show that Carla merely loved growing up.
i don’t think i’ve worn overalls since first grade but be nice to find some ‘adult’ ones, other than like a jumpsuit, romper, some ‘overall dresses’ look nice, i know some were’ trendy’ again, maybe it’d be a good compromise versus finding jeans that might be too tight the next week (and i guess as long as they don’t look too “Farmer”-y, maybe some would be ok to wear as a work outfit? though i would hope any future min wage place wouldn’t care/allows anything other than being shirtless)
The problem with that is you’ll inevitably have to tell a story with her, which needs conflict, drama, stakes. You see all the crap main characters like Joyce, Becky, Amber, Sal, Ethan, Walky, etc went through in the first six months? Do you really want that for Carla? You really want to see Carla have to survive a car crash, or break her arm in a conflict when her parent’s business rival kidnaps her best friend? You wanna see her make a best friend only for that friendship to end over a difference in opinion on which episode of Ultra car was the best? Be careful what you wish for, cause more screen time is a double edged sword!
Wack'd
I mean. Yes? Trauma’s kind of the engine on which this comic runs. If it means more facetime, then she can have little a trauma, as a treat.
thejeff
No, this works.
I now want a Jason/Carla rivalry leading to a clash between Ruttech and Dargon Chesterfield.
not someone else
I’m pretty sure there’s enough pure backstory trauma mixed into “hey, I’ve been out since that cover of Newsweek”, regardless of how blithely she put it, that we can keep going on that for a few storylines.
I mean, in all seriousness- being openly trans can be hell. Being openly trans and a celebrity whose life is picked through like a dog through trash is worse. And imagine how that could have happened- did the magazine out her forcibly, did she get a choice? She’s barely an adult now, how young was she when she had to deal with this? We know her parents are supportive, but it’s not like she was a child actress, she was the daughter of some rich people, it’s about 50/50 that they thought she’d be a Jazz Jennings story of hope for other kids vs. ruh ruh look at these liberal rich people experimenting on their children.
Carla is relatively well-adjusted because she has to be to function at all, it doesn’t mean she hasn’t gone through mountains of shit to find and defend the self-confidence she has.
thejeff
It also doesn’t mean that self-confidence isn’t a fragile shell of armor wrapped around fear of rejection.
And she was not just outed on Newsweek, but the center of a court case that won some level of trans rights in Indiana. That Jacob’s brother was involved with.
Ruth and Carla are friends, and would probably have a really funny dynamic, but I dunno if they would see each other that way. I know Carla seemed to really not be into Ruth and Billie’s “shoves equals loves” dynamic.
Yeah, but the whole “shove = love” thing is very clearly something Ruth needs to move away from. Carla could channel that aversion-to-sincerity cute-destroy-response in a more healthy direction.
I don’t think Carla’s into dating anyway. She reads more like the type that’s into admiring cute girls but likes to act too cool to be in a relationship. She’s had crushes but they never seem romantic in nature.
Imogen
I don’t think I agree with that at all. She had a huge crush on Malaya and was visibly disappointed when Malaya went with Joe, and she’s been desperately hanging on Sal’s arm for, like, ever. Ultra-Car was also very much not aromantic, and we have no reason to think that’s changed.
Also, I think a big part of why Carla comes off as so exaggeratedly narcissistic is that her role lately has been to appear in one-off jokes and gags. She hasn’t been allowed to appear in a serious scene in a while. When she has, we saw a lot more nuance to her. She’s not actually narcissistic, she’s guarded and falls back a lot on comedy and brashness to protect herself and maintain her own identity in spite of others’ bad treatment of her.
Sirksome
See I think there’s a difference between having an attraction and actually wanting to be in a romantic relationship. I don’t know where Carla falls in the human’s ever changing scale of attraction, but to me she doesn’t seem like someone who is seeking or needing a romantic partner which is different from wanting to be friends with hot girls you know. Yeah she was crushing on Malaya and Sal and is seemingly turned on by dominant women, but I don’t think she wants to date them.
That’s just my take though. This stuff can be ambiguous since Carla as you’ve noted doesn’t have a lot of material to work with. Any interpretation could be valid. You’re right that she’s probably not as narcissistic as she fronts to be.
Daibhid C
Yeah, I think some of it’s real, but a lot of it is (sorry, I’m bringing out my Word of the Day Decade again) performative.
One of the fun things about this is that, to an extent, she actually is what Malaya would call “fakey”, and Malaya is far to concerned with proving this about Sal to notice or care.
Needfuldoer
She and Becky are more alike than they realize.
thejeff
Which reminds me, given her sometimes crushing on Sal, have we seen her reaction to Sal and Danny yet?
150 thoughts on “Style”
Ana Chronistic
to be fair, Bugs Bunny also acted just too good for the room
and was super genderfluid
StClair
All true. Tricksters be like that.
(Including Carla, definitely.)
Doctor_Who
Let this meeting of the Cool Awesome Redhead LGBT Alliance begin.
Yes, Carla came up with the name, can’t imagine how she picked it.
Laura
Which redhead is the G?
Taffy
The G stands for Girl now.
Nono
Huh, there are no male redheads in the cast, are there? And at least four girls (Carla, Ruth, Becky, Rose).
Taffy
There’s Joyce’s dad, he’s a redhead.
Nono
Is this a terminology thing? Last I checked Hank was blonde.
Taffy
I don’t know what people call it where you live, but in my area we call that hair color “red”.
Kamino Neko
By the patches of non-grey we see, he seems to have had the same colour hair as Joyce, back before he went grey. Which very much is not red. Dirty blond is what I’d call it.
Nathan
Do we see him with red hair in a flashback? I only recall him ever having white hair.
Thag Simmons
Ron is the only named male redhead in the comic I can think of and he appears in like two comics, total
King Daniel
There’s also Ruth’s brother Howard.
Thag Simmons
Oh right, I forgot about him. Been a while since he showed up
Sirksome
I hope he’s doing well. Game of Thrones is over but House of the Dragon is out now. He still has to live with Clint though, which probably sucks.
Thag Simmons
I wonder how Howard feels about the later seasons. Honestly could go either way with him.
Kamino Neko
I am amused that you forgot Howard but were able to bring Ron to mind…
Thag Simmons
I have been cursed to get disproportionately interested in minor characters who don’t matter.
the illerman
There’s also acompletely harmless stranger.
flake
Galasso might? and he is gender confused on a technicality
Lars
Howard is red head male. It’s been a semester since we’ve seen him.
Imogen
Carla is the Cool Awesome Redhead Lesbian Asexual.
Wack'd
Yeah, if we have to do the initialism and not just say “queer”, Who missed a spot.
a/snow/mous/e
thinking wack’d meant to reply to Laura’s reply? dope backronym though
Carla's #2 Fan
I think I’d fit right in with that alliance!
UrsulaDavina
Pretty sure Carla would call Carla is a cool and awesome redhead LBT club featuring some other rando redheads
Taffy
[Homer Simpson voice] Mmmm, LBT club… [drooling sound]
Wack'd
Well, Carla’s not bi. Maybe the Carla is a Cool and Awesome Redhead LTA Club Featuring Some Other Randos.
Meagan
Wow, I didn’t even notice that. Great observation.
Decidedly Orthogonal
Ginger nordic descendant canuck, reporting in.
Taffy
Hell yeah, the two hottest redheads are back on-panel.
Becky is also present.
Nova
Yes.
butts
Dumbing of Age: All Redheads
Bryy
Dumbing of Age: Oh No! All Redheads!
Opus the Poet
?I understood that reference dot gif
Needfuldoer
No “Oops!” about it.
alongcameaspider
Carla is perfect, no notes 10/10
chuckroast
Nice Mario outfit, idiot.
Sirksome
Mario or Mickey Mouse tho? I want to know what the consensus is.
anon
given that ruth has green overalls (https://dumbingofage.tumblr.com/post/153972250682/ruth), maybe mario/luigi would be fitting haha
Marianne
Honestly she’s kinda giving me Dr. Robotnik vibes if anything
darkgloomie
Mickey doesn’t wear overrals, as established by Sal his look is “just pants abs gloves”
Cattleprod
Those overalls remind me of the outfits the Autobots wore in Only Human, which is perfectly suited to a character who started off as a car’s humansona.
Laura
Huh? I never read the other Dumbiverse strips. She was a car?
StClair
Yup. Check out the left side of her character banner.
Taffy
Yes, of the Ultra variety.
Doctor_Who
In the Walkyverse, Carla began life as “Ultra Car”, a car that was granted sentience and various other abilities by Joe. He eventually installed her mind in a human looking body.
Since the sci-fi stuff doesn’t exist in this universe, Ultra Car is a television show that Carla merely loved growing up.
Laura
Wow!
Doctor_Who
Considering Carla’s creator (both in-universe and out), I’d bet that’s a deliberate reference.
anon
i don’t think i’ve worn overalls since first grade but be nice to find some ‘adult’ ones, other than like a jumpsuit, romper, some ‘overall dresses’ look nice, i know some were’ trendy’ again, maybe it’d be a good compromise versus finding jeans that might be too tight the next week (and i guess as long as they don’t look too “Farmer”-y, maybe some would be ok to wear as a work outfit? though i would hope any future min wage place wouldn’t care/allows anything other than being shirtless)
Stephen Bierce
Hasenpfeffer!
ValdVin
In the immoral words of Yosemite Sam, “Shaddup and start simmerin”!”
Imogen
hmmm who should ruth date, the funny ace transbian prankster roboticist nerd with a killer fashion sense and unapologetic “fuck you” energy
or the
the guy
jason
he’s british I guess?
Imogen
Carla is critically neglected and underspotlit in the Willisverse PLEASE let us have this
Sirksome
The problem with that is you’ll inevitably have to tell a story with her, which needs conflict, drama, stakes. You see all the crap main characters like Joyce, Becky, Amber, Sal, Ethan, Walky, etc went through in the first six months? Do you really want that for Carla? You really want to see Carla have to survive a car crash, or break her arm in a conflict when her parent’s business rival kidnaps her best friend? You wanna see her make a best friend only for that friendship to end over a difference in opinion on which episode of Ultra car was the best? Be careful what you wish for, cause more screen time is a double edged sword!
Wack'd
I mean. Yes? Trauma’s kind of the engine on which this comic runs. If it means more facetime, then she can have little a trauma, as a treat.
thejeff
No, this works.
I now want a Jason/Carla rivalry leading to a clash between Ruttech and Dargon Chesterfield.
not someone else
I’m pretty sure there’s enough pure backstory trauma mixed into “hey, I’ve been out since that cover of Newsweek”, regardless of how blithely she put it, that we can keep going on that for a few storylines.
I mean, in all seriousness- being openly trans can be hell. Being openly trans and a celebrity whose life is picked through like a dog through trash is worse. And imagine how that could have happened- did the magazine out her forcibly, did she get a choice? She’s barely an adult now, how young was she when she had to deal with this? We know her parents are supportive, but it’s not like she was a child actress, she was the daughter of some rich people, it’s about 50/50 that they thought she’d be a Jazz Jennings story of hope for other kids vs. ruh ruh look at these liberal rich people experimenting on their children.
Carla is relatively well-adjusted because she has to be to function at all, it doesn’t mean she hasn’t gone through mountains of shit to find and defend the self-confidence she has.
thejeff
It also doesn’t mean that self-confidence isn’t a fragile shell of armor wrapped around fear of rejection.
And she was not just outed on Newsweek, but the center of a court case that won some level of trans rights in Indiana. That Jacob’s brother was involved with.
Jamie
He has a bowtie.
Imogen
jason and danny would hit it off
v.gay.person
but consider: Carla in a bowtie Cate Blanchette style
like, idk if she’d vibe with a suit, but if she did she would kill it
Wack'd
Consider: Carla cosplaying as Marlene Dietrich
v.gay.person
I like the cut of your jib!
DailyBrad
Ruth and Carla are friends, and would probably have a really funny dynamic, but I dunno if they would see each other that way. I know Carla seemed to really not be into Ruth and Billie’s “shoves equals loves” dynamic.
Imogen
Yeah, but the whole “shove = love” thing is very clearly something Ruth needs to move away from. Carla could channel that aversion-to-sincerity cute-destroy-response in a more healthy direction.
Nono
I think Ruth can date whoever she wants.
(Also, I like Carla but right now she’s probably too narcisstic to focus properly on being in a healthy relationship dynamic.)
Sirksome
I don’t think Carla’s into dating anyway. She reads more like the type that’s into admiring cute girls but likes to act too cool to be in a relationship. She’s had crushes but they never seem romantic in nature.
Imogen
I don’t think I agree with that at all. She had a huge crush on Malaya and was visibly disappointed when Malaya went with Joe, and she’s been desperately hanging on Sal’s arm for, like, ever. Ultra-Car was also very much not aromantic, and we have no reason to think that’s changed.
Also, I think a big part of why Carla comes off as so exaggeratedly narcissistic is that her role lately has been to appear in one-off jokes and gags. She hasn’t been allowed to appear in a serious scene in a while. When she has, we saw a lot more nuance to her. She’s not actually narcissistic, she’s guarded and falls back a lot on comedy and brashness to protect herself and maintain her own identity in spite of others’ bad treatment of her.
Sirksome
See I think there’s a difference between having an attraction and actually wanting to be in a romantic relationship. I don’t know where Carla falls in the human’s ever changing scale of attraction, but to me she doesn’t seem like someone who is seeking or needing a romantic partner which is different from wanting to be friends with hot girls you know. Yeah she was crushing on Malaya and Sal and is seemingly turned on by dominant women, but I don’t think she wants to date them.
That’s just my take though. This stuff can be ambiguous since Carla as you’ve noted doesn’t have a lot of material to work with. Any interpretation could be valid. You’re right that she’s probably not as narcissistic as she fronts to be.
Daibhid C
Yeah, I think some of it’s real, but a lot of it is (sorry, I’m bringing out my Word of the
DayDecade again) performative.One of the fun things about this is that, to an extent, she actually is what Malaya would call “fakey”, and Malaya is far to concerned with proving this about Sal to notice or care.
Needfuldoer
She and Becky are more alike than they realize.
thejeff
Which reminds me, given her sometimes crushing on Sal, have we seen her reaction to Sal and Danny yet?