Poor Joyce. For her entire life she had her autonomy denied by fundies and their prejudices towards women. She worked so hard to free herself, only to discover something else people can use to deny her autonomy. ???
I think Joyce more than anything needs a place where she is not unfairly punished for her neurodivergence, her atheism nor her gender.
She should play games. Or join a Discord server where she can befriend other cartoonists.
Ha ha, it’s not all bad, you just gotta be in the right places ?
Librain
I assume in honour of the Roman goddess Discordia? Known as Eris to the Greeks before them? As the goddess of strife, if seems fitting that a platform that was (from memory) primarily set up for gamers to communicate with each other during games should be named after a goddess who’s primary role was making people miserable.
Probably not, considering the problems of having people who hate each other. If they were stuck in the discord with each other, it would eventually lead to some kind of altercation and then it is out for the world to see.
Kyrik Michalowski
Oh, I thought you meant a discord between the characters.
Yumi
Hm. I want that.
june gloom
No, no, we have a few interpersonal conflicts here too. Willis is just good at smacking it down before it gets too bad.
yeah me neither. the real question she should be asking is, why does it matter to her so much whether or not Joyce’s lettuce hang-up is an autism thing or a her thing?
I’d guess she assumes it’s helpful to consider putting it in that box, because she’d find it helpful to be able to put something distressing her into a category.
I’m sure there’s at least one member of the main cast who is neurotypical. I mean, not Walky, or Dorothy, or Sal, or Carla, or Ruth, or Danny… maybe Joe??
monkyvirus
This interesting, I just assumed Dorothy was curious. Like her brain went “huh I wonder if this preference is related to autism” and just asked. On reflection your explanation seems more in character (though irl people do just say random stuff with no motive).
Also I now wonder if she is curious because people have suggested she has autism. So she might be thinking “well I can’t be autistic I don’t have issues with food texture” and she wants Joyce to re-affirm that but saying her preference is due to autism.
Either way dorothy should chill out about this. But my initial reading was that it was just a random thought that popped out.
What Yeet said. Dorothy is using the approach that (she thinks) works for her and misapplying it to Joyce. And honestly, it may actually work for Joyce, too, since Joyce definitely *likes* having easy boxes to put things into.
The problem right now is mostly that Joyce doesn’t see them as easy boxes. Which is good for an accurate understanding, but bad for feelings of safety and confidence. If you can’t comfortably separate the peas from the carrots if you’re not sure what peas and carrots are anymore.
It’s a thing that people do, though, when trying to understand this thing that they don’t know much about and can’t envision. Dorothy’s questioning may not be pleasant, but it is realistic. I don’t think this will go on very long.
And I think it’s coming from a good place: Dorothy has new information that might help her be a good friend, and she’s trying to figure out how to use that. I’ve been there and it’s really difficult.
Needfuldoer
I’ve been on Joyce’s side of this. Someone turning every little thing into some kind of teachable moment when all you want is to do something else is exhausting.
thejeff
Joyce’s side of this at the moment seems to be “Yeah? No? Sometimes? I don’t know?!”
So I don’t think they’re really on opposing sides here at least.
I think Dorothy’s handling it pretty well, especially asking if Joyce wants her to keep asking about it.
Needfuldoer
She shouldn’t have asked at all, especially after Joyce bristled at this approach ‘yesterday’ and the day before. If I were in Joyce’s position I’d be walking on eggshells, just waiting for the next offhanded comment to turn into another condescending teachable moment.
BowlerHatGuy
Joyce and Dorothy are BFFs. And bffs have weird and deel conversations, from vibrators to existential crisis, boyfriends and crushes to surviving a kidnapping and winessing a murder.
They are fine.
If joyce wants it to stop, she can say so. You might want your bff to stop, and reading this might make you feel like joyce is internally screaming, but i read it and see two friends getting to know each other.
Few days ago, when joe asked “are we just friends?”, and Joyce didnt answer, some people projected their own experiences into tbe conversation and said joyce was cruel for stringing him along and should give him a straight answer.
But i saw that interaction as fine. Two kids maybe leading up to a first date. Theyre good.
What i wanna know is what happened to the cold rage dorothy fiest showed Joe a few minutes ago.
Martin B
I don’t think anyone is saying the Dorothy is making the right choice in linking everything to Joyce’s newly-diagnosed autism. I don’t think it is the right thing to do, as someone who has been on both sides of this kind of thing. But it is a realistically well-meaning wrong choice, and I think that is good enough in a story.
Absolutely, Wellerman. The best thing one can do for any neurodivergent person is remember that the most important word there is ‘person’. Even if it IS an ‘autism-thing’, that doesn’t mean it isn’t also a ‘Joyce-thing’. Everyone has foibles; autism may make them a little more extreme but they are still a fundamental part of the person. I learned a long time ago that if I can’t cope with a neurodivergent person’s quirks, that’s because I’M being the @$$hat, not them.
Agreed. In my experience, autism is helpful context for many of my hangups, but that doesn’t make them any less mine. And regardless of whether they’re “from” my neurodivergence or not, I still need respect and a way to navigate the situation.
I honestly get the feeling autism is something Dorothy simply doesn’t know much about. Like, she’s obviously an intelligent and progressive person, but as someone who is autistic, her reaction here isn’t a unique one in my experience.
Like Joyce said, though, it’s been like two days. I’m willing to cut her a bit of slack, but I am glad Joyce is saying something about it.
It’s not Joyce’s responsibility to teach her, especially when she’s still trying to figure it out herself.
BowlerHatGuy
“not Joyce’s responsibility to teach her”
This seems like a perfectly normal conversation between bff’s where conversations get to go to weirdly deep topics, and folks tend to be a bit more open and honest. Didnt these two have a frank conversation about maaturbation/vibrators at one point? And dorothy waa blunt with joyce when she was hiding behind her new found atheism to be cruel to becky. Joyce basucally called dorothy a “hussy” by proxy through her comic strip, and dorothy informed her shes only had sex with three people. This is how friends talk.
Needfuldoer
They were having a normal conversation, then Dorothy slammed the brakes on it by going “I’ve learned a new Joyce Fact! Do you think that behavior is just you, or could it be an Autism thing?”
Other people turning ordinary conversations around into surprise Autism discussion is just… rrgh. Do not do that. It’s forcing someone else to be introspective, because suddenly they’re under a microscope to satisfy your curiosity.
Believe me, I’ve been in that position before. Suddenly you’re not part of a conversation anymore, you’re their test subject.
thejeff
This seems to be a you thing, not a Joyce and Dorothy thing. Joyce doesn’t seem to be taking it the way you are.
I get that it’s useful advice in general. Many people probably feel like you do about it. That doesn’t mean that Dorothy specifically is doing what you’re talking about or that Joyce is bothered by it the way you would be.
I concur, Needful. Joyce may not be the best at reading social cues, but Dorothy herself is missing one that’s says what’s she’s doing is really unwelcome. ?
BowlerHatGuy
“Dorothy slammed the brakes on it by going “I’ve learned a new Joyce Fact! ”
That wasnt slamming of the brakes. Anymore than Joyce implying Dorothy is a hussy and Dorothy saying “ive had sex with three people”. No brakes being slammed.
When joe said “i am capable of being friends” and Dorothy spoke in a black text bubble “can you?”, now THAT was slamming some brakes.
Eyebrow
It sure was. Where did Dorothy get the Joe-hate from?
BowlerHatGuy
The source of dorothy’s seething silent rage at joe is TBD
It popped up out of the blue couple days ago
Then cut to a commercial break.
thejeff
Most likely going through high school with him and dating his best friend for a couple years and now seeing him apparently putting the moves on Joyce.
Oh shit, I’ve seen those at my local convenience store, but figured they were one of those things meant for kids, the kind of snack that tastes like spherical semi-plastic watery chicken broth and costs like $7.43 for a handful.
Needfuldoer
If you want cheap candy, there’s nothing quite like the blatantly artificial flavor of bank teller lollipops. (You know, the kind that never have a brand name, come in square cellophane, look like a Do Not Enter sign, and have a disintegrating stick they’re never lined up with.)
They’re tongue-laceratingly good!
Tasting your own blood builds character.
Laura
I loved those!
Yumi
This is tangential, but let me tell you about a Reddit comment that lives rent-free in my head (which I currently CAN’T FIND, ugh):
The poster used to work as a bank teller. Around the holidays, they would give out mini candy canes to customers. Person comes in and withdraws $100; the bank teller gave them a $100 bill and mini candy cane. The customer then asked, “Can I get that broken up?” The poster said sure, and then took a stapler or something and used it to smash the candy cane. Customer says, “Thanks” and leaves. Then the poster’s coworker turned to them and said, “I think he meant to break up the $100…”
I am like that with Joyce. I was also raised in a cult like environment, had an angry atheist phase and am autistic sooooo.
(On that note I kinda wanna see Willis explore the fallout of growing up thinking the world is going to collapse into mayhem any 5 minutes from now and you’re personally destined to be a Warrior for the Cause. Because uh yeah. Lotta fundie cults have that and my upbringing’s brand of far right doomsday prepper cult also did and hoo boy it does a number.
However, I wonder, are there important nuanced differences between a Doomsday Cult and a Death Cult?
David M Willis
Death cult- your group ends up dead at the end
Doomsday cult – everyone else ends up dead at the end
Clif
That does seem like an important nuance.
ischemgeek
This sums it up in a much more pithy way than I could.
Most Xtian cults are doomsday cult’s – and sometimes you can have cults that blur the lines between the two. I would argue the branch of evangelicals that spawned the left behind series splits the difference. The one I was raised in was actually a secular doomsday cult. Not all cults are religious.
ischemgeek
Willis summed it up best, but in terms of extreme case examples:
Death cult – People’s Temple
Doomsday cult – Branch Davidians
334 thoughts on “Unseparated”
darkoneko
Dotty’s back to smiling. Sorta
The Wellerman
Poor Joyce. For her entire life she had her autonomy denied by fundies and their prejudices towards women. She worked so hard to free herself, only to discover something else people can use to deny her autonomy. ???
I think Joyce more than anything needs a place where she is not unfairly punished for her neurodivergence, her atheism nor her gender.
She should play games. Or join a Discord server where she can befriend other cartoonists.
DarkoNeko
….thinking about that, does DoA have a Discord ?
Yumi
Not, like, an official one, and I’ve definitely gotten the vibe that the people on the one I know of aren’t thrilled about having it posted here.
The Wellerman
It does, but it’s full of REALLY toxic “fans” who do literally nothing but nit pick every single thing about Willis’s works 🙁
Mark
Gee, I wonder why they call it “Discord”.
The Wellerman
Ha ha, it’s not all bad, you just gotta be in the right places ?
Librain
I assume in honour of the Roman goddess Discordia? Known as Eris to the Greeks before them? As the goddess of strife, if seems fitting that a platform that was (from memory) primarily set up for gamers to communicate with each other during games should be named after a goddess who’s primary role was making people miserable.
True Survivor
I don’t know but this comment board is definitely pandemonium sometimes.
Needfuldoer
Only sometimes?
Kyrik Michalowski
Probably not, considering the problems of having people who hate each other. If they were stuck in the discord with each other, it would eventually lead to some kind of altercation and then it is out for the world to see.
Kyrik Michalowski
Oh, I thought you meant a discord between the characters.
Yumi
Hm. I want that.
june gloom
No, no, we have a few interpersonal conflicts here too. Willis is just good at smacking it down before it gets too bad.
Blume
I’d like to talk more with everyone tbh!
The Wellerman
me too. do you have a discord handle? 🙂
Blume
Oh! I hope this reply gets to you, I especially would like us to converse! lasagna#2516
Dave Van Domelen
The Taco Bell dragon’s eye….
True Survivor
What is that? It sounds cool.
woobie
Is it like an enchirito?
ValdVin
Its on the secret menu. It starts with a duck egg….
ValdVin
…and I’ve already said too much. You never read this.
Decidedly Orthogonal
It’s been rumored to be a Dragon’s Eye. (n.b. the arrow is pointing at the pupil, not a taco)
alongcameaspider
I still don’t like Dorothy being quick to ascribe every little Joyce thing to autism but it’s more reasonable here then it was before
The Wellerman
yeah me neither. the real question she should be asking is, why does it matter to her so much whether or not Joyce’s lettuce hang-up is an autism thing or a her thing?
And I think Jennifer already more or less found the answer:
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2022/comic/book-13/01-bring-me-to-life-drawing/sporadically/
Yeet
I’d guess she assumes it’s helpful to consider putting it in that box, because she’d find it helpful to be able to put something distressing her into a category.
The Wellerman
Booster is gonna sus Dorothy out as ND when? ?
BowlerHatGuy
Fish in a barrel.
Librain
I’m sure there’s at least one member of the main cast who is neurotypical. I mean, not Walky, or Dorothy, or Sal, or Carla, or Ruth, or Danny… maybe Joe??
monkyvirus
This interesting, I just assumed Dorothy was curious. Like her brain went “huh I wonder if this preference is related to autism” and just asked. On reflection your explanation seems more in character (though irl people do just say random stuff with no motive).
Also I now wonder if she is curious because people have suggested she has autism. So she might be thinking “well I can’t be autistic I don’t have issues with food texture” and she wants Joyce to re-affirm that but saying her preference is due to autism.
Either way dorothy should chill out about this. But my initial reading was that it was just a random thought that popped out.
Jamie
What Yeet said. Dorothy is using the approach that (she thinks) works for her and misapplying it to Joyce. And honestly, it may actually work for Joyce, too, since Joyce definitely *likes* having easy boxes to put things into.
The problem right now is mostly that Joyce doesn’t see them as easy boxes. Which is good for an accurate understanding, but bad for feelings of safety and confidence. If you can’t comfortably separate the peas from the carrots if you’re not sure what peas and carrots are anymore.
Needfuldoer
I think she’s trying to help Joyce figure herself out, but this isn’t the place or time for that.
Mark
It’s a thing that people do, though, when trying to understand this thing that they don’t know much about and can’t envision. Dorothy’s questioning may not be pleasant, but it is realistic. I don’t think this will go on very long.
And I think it’s coming from a good place: Dorothy has new information that might help her be a good friend, and she’s trying to figure out how to use that. I’ve been there and it’s really difficult.
Needfuldoer
I’ve been on Joyce’s side of this. Someone turning every little thing into some kind of teachable moment when all you want is to do something else is exhausting.
thejeff
Joyce’s side of this at the moment seems to be “Yeah? No? Sometimes? I don’t know?!”
So I don’t think they’re really on opposing sides here at least.
I think Dorothy’s handling it pretty well, especially asking if Joyce wants her to keep asking about it.
Needfuldoer
She shouldn’t have asked at all, especially after Joyce bristled at this approach ‘yesterday’ and the day before. If I were in Joyce’s position I’d be walking on eggshells, just waiting for the next offhanded comment to turn into another condescending teachable moment.
BowlerHatGuy
Joyce and Dorothy are BFFs. And bffs have weird and deel conversations, from vibrators to existential crisis, boyfriends and crushes to surviving a kidnapping and winessing a murder.
They are fine.
If joyce wants it to stop, she can say so. You might want your bff to stop, and reading this might make you feel like joyce is internally screaming, but i read it and see two friends getting to know each other.
Few days ago, when joe asked “are we just friends?”, and Joyce didnt answer, some people projected their own experiences into tbe conversation and said joyce was cruel for stringing him along and should give him a straight answer.
But i saw that interaction as fine. Two kids maybe leading up to a first date. Theyre good.
What i wanna know is what happened to the cold rage dorothy fiest showed Joe a few minutes ago.
Martin B
I don’t think anyone is saying the Dorothy is making the right choice in linking everything to Joyce’s newly-diagnosed autism. I don’t think it is the right thing to do, as someone who has been on both sides of this kind of thing. But it is a realistically well-meaning wrong choice, and I think that is good enough in a story.
Stifyn Baker
Absolutely, Wellerman. The best thing one can do for any neurodivergent person is remember that the most important word there is ‘person’. Even if it IS an ‘autism-thing’, that doesn’t mean it isn’t also a ‘Joyce-thing’. Everyone has foibles; autism may make them a little more extreme but they are still a fundamental part of the person. I learned a long time ago that if I can’t cope with a neurodivergent person’s quirks, that’s because I’M being the @$$hat, not them.
cain
Agreed. In my experience, autism is helpful context for many of my hangups, but that doesn’t make them any less mine. And regardless of whether they’re “from” my neurodivergence or not, I still need respect and a way to navigate the situation.
DailyBrad
I honestly get the feeling autism is something Dorothy simply doesn’t know much about. Like, she’s obviously an intelligent and progressive person, but as someone who is autistic, her reaction here isn’t a unique one in my experience.
Like Joyce said, though, it’s been like two days. I’m willing to cut her a bit of slack, but I am glad Joyce is saying something about it.
Needfuldoer
It’s not Joyce’s responsibility to teach her, especially when she’s still trying to figure it out herself.
BowlerHatGuy
“not Joyce’s responsibility to teach her”
This seems like a perfectly normal conversation between bff’s where conversations get to go to weirdly deep topics, and folks tend to be a bit more open and honest. Didnt these two have a frank conversation about maaturbation/vibrators at one point? And dorothy waa blunt with joyce when she was hiding behind her new found atheism to be cruel to becky. Joyce basucally called dorothy a “hussy” by proxy through her comic strip, and dorothy informed her shes only had sex with three people. This is how friends talk.
Needfuldoer
They were having a normal conversation, then Dorothy slammed the brakes on it by going “I’ve learned a new Joyce Fact! Do you think that behavior is just you, or could it be an Autism thing?”
Other people turning ordinary conversations around into surprise Autism discussion is just… rrgh. Do not do that. It’s forcing someone else to be introspective, because suddenly they’re under a microscope to satisfy your curiosity.
Believe me, I’ve been in that position before. Suddenly you’re not part of a conversation anymore, you’re their test subject.
thejeff
This seems to be a you thing, not a Joyce and Dorothy thing. Joyce doesn’t seem to be taking it the way you are.
I get that it’s useful advice in general. Many people probably feel like you do about it. That doesn’t mean that Dorothy specifically is doing what you’re talking about or that Joyce is bothered by it the way you would be.
Needfuldoer
Yeah, you’re probably right.
I just hope this doesn’t become a pattern.
The Wellerman
I concur, Needful. Joyce may not be the best at reading social cues, but Dorothy herself is missing one that’s says what’s she’s doing is really unwelcome. ?
BowlerHatGuy
“Dorothy slammed the brakes on it by going “I’ve learned a new Joyce Fact! ”
That wasnt slamming of the brakes. Anymore than Joyce implying Dorothy is a hussy and Dorothy saying “ive had sex with three people”. No brakes being slammed.
When joe said “i am capable of being friends” and Dorothy spoke in a black text bubble “can you?”, now THAT was slamming some brakes.
Eyebrow
It sure was. Where did Dorothy get the Joe-hate from?
BowlerHatGuy
The source of dorothy’s seething silent rage at joe is TBD
It popped up out of the blue couple days ago
Then cut to a commercial break.
thejeff
Most likely going through high school with him and dating his best friend for a couple years and now seeing him apparently putting the moves on Joyce.
Laura
Somehow, this playlist seems apropos:
“when you feel like quitting but you know you must carry on and push through(Moody Playlist)”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vtFA9rLIuTs
Laura
Today was a stressful day. I’m “chain-smoking” probiotic lollipops. Helps me calm down.
The Wellerman
I didn’t know those were a thing :0
Laura
Dr. John’s.
Taffy
Oh shit, I’ve seen those at my local convenience store, but figured they were one of those things meant for kids, the kind of snack that tastes like spherical semi-plastic watery chicken broth and costs like $7.43 for a handful.
Needfuldoer
If you want cheap candy, there’s nothing quite like the blatantly artificial flavor of bank teller lollipops. (You know, the kind that never have a brand name, come in square cellophane, look like a Do Not Enter sign, and have a disintegrating stick they’re never lined up with.)
They’re tongue-laceratingly good!
Tasting your own blood builds character.
Laura
I loved those!
Yumi
This is tangential, but let me tell you about a Reddit comment that lives rent-free in my head (which I currently CAN’T FIND, ugh):
The poster used to work as a bank teller. Around the holidays, they would give out mini candy canes to customers. Person comes in and withdraws $100; the bank teller gave them a $100 bill and mini candy cane. The customer then asked, “Can I get that broken up?” The poster said sure, and then took a stapler or something and used it to smash the candy cane. Customer says, “Thanks” and leaves. Then the poster’s coworker turned to them and said, “I think he meant to break up the $100…”
Laura
Made me laugh!!!
Cmasta1992
Dorothy is trying
But also please Dorothy stop trying
Chaucer59
Yes, Dorothy is SOOOOOO trying.
The Wellerman
yup. Jennifer sussed her out pretty well here
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2022/comic/book-13/01-bring-me-to-life-drawing/sporadically/
Nerrin
Dorothy is very trying.
I relate to her more than anyone else in the cast but occasionally in a “look back at myself and wince” kind of way.
ischemgeek
I am like that with Joyce. I was also raised in a cult like environment, had an angry atheist phase and am autistic sooooo.
(On that note I kinda wanna see Willis explore the fallout of growing up thinking the world is going to collapse into mayhem any 5 minutes from now and you’re personally destined to be a Warrior for the Cause. Because uh yeah. Lotta fundie cults have that and my upbringing’s brand of far right doomsday prepper cult also did and hoo boy it does a number.
The Wellerman
Yes, that would be very much welcome to explore.
However, I wonder, are there important nuanced differences between a Doomsday Cult and a Death Cult?
David M Willis
Death cult- your group ends up dead at the end
Doomsday cult – everyone else ends up dead at the end
Clif
That does seem like an important nuance.
ischemgeek
This sums it up in a much more pithy way than I could.
Most Xtian cults are doomsday cult’s – and sometimes you can have cults that blur the lines between the two. I would argue the branch of evangelicals that spawned the left behind series splits the difference. The one I was raised in was actually a secular doomsday cult. Not all cults are religious.
ischemgeek
Willis summed it up best, but in terms of extreme case examples:
Death cult – People’s Temple
Doomsday cult – Branch Davidians
Uly
Dorothy is trying my patience.
Clif
And yet Joyce seems okay.
Bathymetheus