Just chiming in here for anyone whose next stop is the Patreon page to guess what happens from the blurry previews:
The freebie Patreon previews are blurred A LOT less than they used to be, for some reason. You can just about read the dialogue. It’s less of a guessing game and more of an outright spoiler now.
I wrote a joke about huges, but then I decided it wasn’t funny, so instead you all get the meta commentary.
Rowen Morland
Well now I’m just curious. Then again sometimes you safely extract the funny from the rock of inspiration without mean or awkward by products as pollution.
Lysbeth
Some do want to get rid of their huge and get a regular instead, and it’s okay
Casi
I for one am happy with my huge, but i wouldn’t mind a regular as well but sadly medical technology is not quite there yet
Jay
I know a few people with both, but the medical technology isn’t *here* yet, geographically speaking
Lysbeth
Huge-preserving regularoplasty isn’t common, sadly. I considered it on a purely intellectual, “what-if” basis myself but it’s not worth the trouble of going all the way there when a regular does the trick I think.
Or one for her own daughter. Or a lunch invitation. Or even acknowledgement except when ‘misunderstood and directly addressed.
People rightly shit on Asher, but this body-temperature biological incubator has less parental love in her than Blaine. At least he felt something. She had more to do with Sal’s stick-up than Asher.
Honestly, I love this (what Willis is doing here). Linda is being reasonably polite here. Even to Lucy, an outsider, it could seem like she was more enthusiastic about teasing Walky (about Joyce), than necessarily that she was more enthusiastic about Joyce as a white girl. But WE know how enthusiastic Linda can be. She was such with Dorothy and we could read it for what it was with Joyce because we know Linda.
As someone who was victim to the “well you very clearly adore and make a strong effort with your nephew’s partners but you physically box your son’s partner out of conversations” MIL, it’s so cathartic to see this whole comment section see Linda’s behavior for what it is. Of course everyone would because, well, it’s Linda, but as a victim to this kind of behavior, it’s incredibly difficult IRL to articulate the problems with it without sounding whiny, entitled, etc.
As a side-note, f*ck Walky for subjecting Lucy to this. His past comments indicate he KNOWS his mother won’t be happy about her, and his parents allegedly gave him the heads-up they were coming (I believe them on this because that is in-character for everyone). At the very least, Lucy needed more of a warning than “oh, mom and dad are here right now—run!”
Vegetalss4
I imagine Walky might have imagined they’d come tomorrow.
After all they mentioned they’d come “this weekend”, and given the cast have class this morning I’m assuming it’s still Friday.
Walky’s still at fault for not warning people before the last moment through
Yeet
yeah if someone told me they were coming the weekend and showed up the friday morning when they know I have class/work/whatever I’d lose my fucking mind
Archieve
Aside from Lucy they are acting weirdly egar and affectionate(for them). Sal noted in an early comic that they were never a hugging family so Linda hugging walky unpromoted followed by the first white girl she sees with a smile is highly abnormal. Showing up first thing in the morning could be another symptom of whatever Linda’s up to.
Seregiel
There was also the whole kidnapping, rescue, and Mike dying so that might have converted their energy to a more affectionate outlet.
Liliet
I get the impression Walky had completely blanked out on them coming himself. ADHD brain goes brrrr.
zee
I refuse to believe walky had it in his head that they were coming. We know how much anxiety he has built up around Linda, he’d’ve been freaking out at least a little. He either didn’t see whatever messages she sent or adhd brain deleted the information
Taffy
Wh- “Subjecting Lucy to this”? C’mon, now.
Leorale
Oh, it’s only going to ramp up.
If my lowkey-racist parents were about to meet my lovely people-pleasing Black girlfriend, I’d sure want to give her a head’s up! Like “Sorry, my mom is a low-key racist Karen, and my dad puts up with it. I don’t know if Mom will act fine today, or subtly racist, or really put her foot in it. But you should know that you’re great, and anything they do will not be your fault.” Also some “I wish they weren’t even here to act weird at you. But do you want to meet them today? If you want to, how can I support you?”
Because, if I was about to meet somebody who was typically prejudiced against any of my own groups (such as antisemitic, anti-enby, etc), I’d want to mentally rehearse some of my conversational shutdowns and deflections (my Jew-jitsu?), and have a way out of there with minimal fuss, knowing that my partner would support me.
Leorale
But yeah, clearly Walky didn’t know they were coming. He didn’t check those emails, he’s kinda on his back foot here.
(And even if he’d warned her, Lucy would probably just be very excited about Meeting The Parents. Like, look at her, honored to meet Mrs. Walkerton.)
Guess they’ve got the space of their class together to try and minimize the fallout onto Lucy.
Second that. What is her problem? Happy with the thought of her son with a white girl… but not Lucy? She herself is in an interracial relationship… so I don’t *think* it would be that.
But is there maybe some internalized racism going on here? Or some other hang-up? Maybe she doesn’t like people with glasses?
Unfortunately, being in an interracial relationship doesn’t mean you can’t have a bad case of the racisms.
My headcanon is that Linda (and possibly also Charles) thinks that Charles is “One of the Good Ones”(tm). That backhanded compliment pits all Black people against each other for Linda’s approval, and lets Linda and Charles get married, without examining who are the Bad Ones, who got to make those tests throughout history, and why Linda gets to be the judge.
Once Carla realizes Joyce draws a comic with characters based on her friends and acquaintances but there’s no Carla parallel, the badgering will be relentless until the situation is remedied.
There’s something really bleak about Sal having the same body language as Linda. Like no matter how much you want to escape and be nothing like your parents, their blueprints are still on you.
Both have a lot of conviction and strong opinions about people, along with something of a self-righteous side at times. One’s just, y’know, not a classist bigot, so it’s a lot better served with Sal.
I don’t like Linda but her similarities to Sal make me think there’s probably more to her. Not likely enough to justify her awfulness so far, but she doesn’t seem so black and white evil as other parents in this comic.
DailyBrad
Oh yeah, I doubt Linda is an irredeemable person, and likely has all matter of rationalizations for what she does. Like, she isn’t a Blaine or Ryan, she doesn’t revel in being a piece of shit for piece of shit’s sake. I’m sure we may find out more of her motivations over time.
Mr D
I don’t think anyone is an irredeemable person. Everyone can atone for their mistakes and improve as a person. It just takes self reflection.
Even Toedad the Zealot gave up his life to try to fix something when he realized what Blaine’s plan was.
Mr D
…I may be misremembering.
I’m not actually sure.
Vegetalss4
I think you are, as I remember it Toedad released Amber because he believed her claim to be Amazigirl and the plan was to blackmail Amazigirl to make her bring them Becky. He didn’t release any of the others (they where still needed to blackmail her).
Then Blaine hit him in the head with a hammer because of that, which at first only stunned him and knocked him down, after which he got up and fought Blaine till he died.
At no point did he actually walk away from the plan or try to fix anything (other than the snag of holding hostage the person they wanted to blackmail with the hostages)
Miri
I think he expressed remorse for the believed need to kidnap the group of kids and thought at first he had the situation all under control and nobody would get hurt (coz obviously they’d all been thrown *carefully* into the cellar)… I think there was a point when he and Blaine were wrestling on the stairs over the hammer that he knew he’d been complicit in tying up a group of kids and putting them into the hands of a dangerous madman and he wanted to protect them…
He was wrong, stupid, bigoted, a terrible father, abusive… He was also manipulated and trying to protect his daughter from something he thought was worse.
Taffy
Nah, there’s definitely irredeemable people. They’re burning the country down right this very moment and they won’t stop, won’t self-reflect, won’t even momentarily inconvenience themselves the teeniest tiniest bit, until everyone and everything that doesn’t fit into their narrow, undefined worldview has been silenced and killed and erased. Maybe it’s vindictive, but I don’t think they should actually be allowed to “redeem” themselves, because that puts expectations on everyone else to accept them after everything they’ve done.
Shade of Blue
Agreed. Actually one of the themes of DoA is redemption and how it is ultimately an illusion, which is clutch imo.
There’s an overwhelming trend in (American) media today to redeem or empathize with the worst people. It’s really frustrating and makes me feel so depressed about art.
thejeff
I don’t think that’s actually one of the themes of DoA or a lot of our protagonists are in trouble.
I agree with you about the trend in media, but I see that as because they’re focused on getting us to empathize with those worst people while they’re still the worst people. They need to stop being bad first.
Schpoonman
Tall Rachel is an asshole and a coward. Redemption is not a story or illusion. People can improve themselves.
HueSatLight
You might be reading the wrong comic, if “people can change for the better” makes you depressed.
Rachel’s pessimism is possibly rooted in her own regrets that she doesn’t think she can be better than.
thejeff
I don’t think anyone is irredeemable. That doesn’t mean everyone gets redeemed. Even the worst people in the world can change and grow and become better. But they’ve got to actually do it.
Caveat: I don’t like the term “redemption”. It’s got way too many religious/Christian overtones for me.
UrsulaDavina
Can’t say if everyone but my sisters act exactly like my mother who acts like my grandmother( although they don’t insult people behind their backs in German that was my Oma’s own exclusive thing) and then they wonder why they get into fights with eachother.
Comic.phile
Ha! That was my Oma’s thing too, to until a stranger she was commenting rudely on actually spoke German back to her and called her out on it.
UrsulaDavina
We kept telling her not to do it but she was never called on it.
UrsulaDavina
I forgot to say it was funny coincidence
Sombrero
If there’s more to her, I’m not sure I want to know, but I’m sure Willis will tell us.
Rogue 7
Linda hurts for me because I see a lot of my mother in her. My mom can be controlling at times, and she’s a white woman who grew up in the 70s- she has her biases and stereotypes, but she’s still at least moderately left.
If Linda’s a 10, she’s about a 2. I love her, respect her, and think that ultimately she’s one of the smartest people I know. But she’s not flawless.
I think also Linda has trapped herself in a feedback loop with both kids. She came down hard on Sal, Sal rebelled, and so she came down harder, and so Sal rebelled more, and so on and so forth. She coddled Walky, he did what she wanted, she coddled him more, and so on and so forth. In neither case was her initial behavior as extreme as it escalated to.
Fortunately Walky seems to be well on his way to short-circuting his feedback loop and standing up for himself. Way easier than what Sal has to deal with.
Archieve
The thing to remember about Linda and Sals relationship is that Sal did attempt to be who she thought her mother wanted her to be ( ex parents day church school outfit and friendly greeting) and Linda did not treat her anybetter for the effort put in. Sals at the point where she’s stopped trying altogether because Linda’s only going to give her emotional scrapes regardless of whether she tries hard on not.
She started out with obsession with Danny being like half her character but in the Dumbingverse he’s just hat guy to her. Joyce seems to have a natural aversion to cross-universal romance.
As is typical of a wizened desert creature you speak enigmatically o Armored One, but i know what you mean. The “old verses” do now feel quaint and tentative, if charming, what with their featherless dromeiosaurs and such. Indeed indeed. Well spoken.
265 thoughts on “Whispering”
Ana Chronistic
I admit I was gonna laugh if Linda had instead gone,
(to Sarah): You?
Sarah: No…
(to Sal): Not YOU
Sal: WTF
(looks around)
Lucy: …
nobodybasically
Cue Mae Whitman. “…her?”
Needfuldoer
Just chiming in here for anyone whose next stop is the Patreon page to guess what happens from the blurry previews:
The freebie Patreon previews are blurred A LOT less than they used to be, for some reason. You can just about read the dialogue. It’s less of a guessing game and more of an outright spoiler now.
Leorale
Huh, yeah, that’s really true, isn’t it. You can read the dialogue and everything.
This one was exactly what we all would’ve predicted, but still, that’s an interesting development for more cliffhanger-y strips.
thejeff
Weird because that’s not true for me. Still as blurry as ever. Or at least blurry enough not to make much out. Certainly no text.
Angel
well sarah’s not tagged so i assume she took this moment to go to class lol
Ana Chronistic
made good on her escape
Yeet
wow, linda’s enthusiasm seems to have vanished, weird
Archieve
Not even a pretend huge for Lucy.
BarerMender
Linda’s a girl. She doesn’t have a huge.
Archieve
Edit’ hug’
Taffy
It’s 2023, girls have huges now.
Rose by Any Other Name
I wrote a joke about huges, but then I decided it wasn’t funny, so instead you all get the meta commentary.
Rowen Morland
Well now I’m just curious. Then again sometimes you safely extract the funny from the rock of inspiration without mean or awkward by products as pollution.
Lysbeth
Some do want to get rid of their huge and get a regular instead, and it’s okay
Casi
I for one am happy with my huge, but i wouldn’t mind a regular as well but sadly medical technology is not quite there yet
Jay
I know a few people with both, but the medical technology isn’t *here* yet, geographically speaking
Lysbeth
Huge-preserving regularoplasty isn’t common, sadly. I considered it on a purely intellectual, “what-if” basis myself but it’s not worth the trouble of going all the way there when a regular does the trick I think.
Decidedly Orthogonal
Or one for her own daughter. Or a lunch invitation. Or even acknowledgement except when ‘misunderstood and directly addressed.
People rightly shit on Asher, but this body-temperature biological incubator has less parental love in her than Blaine. At least he felt something. She had more to do with Sal’s stick-up than Asher.
What a despicable piece of work.
Regina phalange
Honestly, I love this (what Willis is doing here). Linda is being reasonably polite here. Even to Lucy, an outsider, it could seem like she was more enthusiastic about teasing Walky (about Joyce), than necessarily that she was more enthusiastic about Joyce as a white girl. But WE know how enthusiastic Linda can be. She was such with Dorothy and we could read it for what it was with Joyce because we know Linda.
As someone who was victim to the “well you very clearly adore and make a strong effort with your nephew’s partners but you physically box your son’s partner out of conversations” MIL, it’s so cathartic to see this whole comment section see Linda’s behavior for what it is. Of course everyone would because, well, it’s Linda, but as a victim to this kind of behavior, it’s incredibly difficult IRL to articulate the problems with it without sounding whiny, entitled, etc.
Regina phalange
As a side-note, f*ck Walky for subjecting Lucy to this. His past comments indicate he KNOWS his mother won’t be happy about her, and his parents allegedly gave him the heads-up they were coming (I believe them on this because that is in-character for everyone). At the very least, Lucy needed more of a warning than “oh, mom and dad are here right now—run!”
Vegetalss4
I imagine Walky might have imagined they’d come tomorrow.
After all they mentioned they’d come “this weekend”, and given the cast have class this morning I’m assuming it’s still Friday.
Walky’s still at fault for not warning people before the last moment through
Yeet
yeah if someone told me they were coming the weekend and showed up the friday morning when they know I have class/work/whatever I’d lose my fucking mind
Archieve
Aside from Lucy they are acting weirdly egar and affectionate(for them). Sal noted in an early comic that they were never a hugging family so Linda hugging walky unpromoted followed by the first white girl she sees with a smile is highly abnormal. Showing up first thing in the morning could be another symptom of whatever Linda’s up to.
Seregiel
There was also the whole kidnapping, rescue, and Mike dying so that might have converted their energy to a more affectionate outlet.
Liliet
I get the impression Walky had completely blanked out on them coming himself. ADHD brain goes brrrr.
zee
I refuse to believe walky had it in his head that they were coming. We know how much anxiety he has built up around Linda, he’d’ve been freaking out at least a little. He either didn’t see whatever messages she sent or adhd brain deleted the information
Taffy
Wh- “Subjecting Lucy to this”? C’mon, now.
Leorale
Oh, it’s only going to ramp up.
If my lowkey-racist parents were about to meet my lovely people-pleasing Black girlfriend, I’d sure want to give her a head’s up! Like “Sorry, my mom is a low-key racist Karen, and my dad puts up with it. I don’t know if Mom will act fine today, or subtly racist, or really put her foot in it. But you should know that you’re great, and anything they do will not be your fault.” Also some “I wish they weren’t even here to act weird at you. But do you want to meet them today? If you want to, how can I support you?”
Because, if I was about to meet somebody who was typically prejudiced against any of my own groups (such as antisemitic, anti-enby, etc), I’d want to mentally rehearse some of my conversational shutdowns and deflections (my Jew-jitsu?), and have a way out of there with minimal fuss, knowing that my partner would support me.
Leorale
But yeah, clearly Walky didn’t know they were coming. He didn’t check those emails, he’s kinda on his back foot here.
(And even if he’d warned her, Lucy would probably just be very excited about Meeting The Parents. Like, look at her, honored to meet Mrs. Walkerton.)
Guess they’ve got the space of their class together to try and minimize the fallout onto Lucy.
Bryy
I’m honestly surprised she said “and Lucy”.
Ana Chronistic
It doesn’t even work, when neither of the “both” she claims to have been talking about is participating in the conversation
DudeMyDadOwnsADealership
And there, in the last panel, goes her husband, covering for her true drab colors…
Sirksome
That mother/daughter relationship is colder than the weather.
butts
man. fuck you, Linda
Victor Riley
Second that. What is her problem? Happy with the thought of her son with a white girl… but not Lucy? She herself is in an interracial relationship… so I don’t *think* it would be that.
But is there maybe some internalized racism going on here? Or some other hang-up? Maybe she doesn’t like people with glasses?
Leorale
Unfortunately, being in an interracial relationship doesn’t mean you can’t have a bad case of the racisms.
My headcanon is that Linda (and possibly also Charles) thinks that Charles is “One of the Good Ones”(tm). That backhanded compliment pits all Black people against each other for Linda’s approval, and lets Linda and Charles get married, without examining who are the Bad Ones, who got to make those tests throughout history, and why Linda gets to be the judge.
Here’s an article about how Charles’s world might feel:
https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jun/06/growing-up-black-in-america-racism-education
Victor Riley
That would make sense… of sorts. Linda is just awful, and I wonder if Charles sees it?
Thanks for the article!
Stephen Bierce
Unrelated question: do you think the Rutten expy in Joyce’s comic is named Vanja, Suvla or Motoko?
Thag Simmons
I don’t know if Joyce interacts enough with Carla to give her a role in the comic.
Needfuldoer
Once Carla realizes Joyce draws a comic with characters based on her friends and acquaintances but there’s no Carla parallel, the badgering will be relentless until the situation is remedied.
HueSatLight
Jugs
Grimey
There’s something really bleak about Sal having the same body language as Linda. Like no matter how much you want to escape and be nothing like your parents, their blueprints are still on you.
DailyBrad
Both have a lot of conviction and strong opinions about people, along with something of a self-righteous side at times. One’s just, y’know, not a classist bigot, so it’s a lot better served with Sal.
Sirksome
I don’t like Linda but her similarities to Sal make me think there’s probably more to her. Not likely enough to justify her awfulness so far, but she doesn’t seem so black and white evil as other parents in this comic.
DailyBrad
Oh yeah, I doubt Linda is an irredeemable person, and likely has all matter of rationalizations for what she does. Like, she isn’t a Blaine or Ryan, she doesn’t revel in being a piece of shit for piece of shit’s sake. I’m sure we may find out more of her motivations over time.
Mr D
I don’t think anyone is an irredeemable person. Everyone can atone for their mistakes and improve as a person. It just takes self reflection.
Even Toedad the Zealot gave up his life to try to fix something when he realized what Blaine’s plan was.
Mr D
…I may be misremembering.
I’m not actually sure.
Vegetalss4
I think you are, as I remember it Toedad released Amber because he believed her claim to be Amazigirl and the plan was to blackmail Amazigirl to make her bring them Becky. He didn’t release any of the others (they where still needed to blackmail her).
Then Blaine hit him in the head with a hammer because of that, which at first only stunned him and knocked him down, after which he got up and fought Blaine till he died.
At no point did he actually walk away from the plan or try to fix anything (other than the snag of holding hostage the person they wanted to blackmail with the hostages)
Miri
I think he expressed remorse for the believed need to kidnap the group of kids and thought at first he had the situation all under control and nobody would get hurt (coz obviously they’d all been thrown *carefully* into the cellar)… I think there was a point when he and Blaine were wrestling on the stairs over the hammer that he knew he’d been complicit in tying up a group of kids and putting them into the hands of a dangerous madman and he wanted to protect them…
He was wrong, stupid, bigoted, a terrible father, abusive… He was also manipulated and trying to protect his daughter from something he thought was worse.
Taffy
Nah, there’s definitely irredeemable people. They’re burning the country down right this very moment and they won’t stop, won’t self-reflect, won’t even momentarily inconvenience themselves the teeniest tiniest bit, until everyone and everything that doesn’t fit into their narrow, undefined worldview has been silenced and killed and erased. Maybe it’s vindictive, but I don’t think they should actually be allowed to “redeem” themselves, because that puts expectations on everyone else to accept them after everything they’ve done.
Shade of Blue
Agreed. Actually one of the themes of DoA is redemption and how it is ultimately an illusion, which is clutch imo.
There’s an overwhelming trend in (American) media today to redeem or empathize with the worst people. It’s really frustrating and makes me feel so depressed about art.
thejeff
I don’t think that’s actually one of the themes of DoA or a lot of our protagonists are in trouble.
I agree with you about the trend in media, but I see that as because they’re focused on getting us to empathize with those worst people while they’re still the worst people. They need to stop being bad first.
Schpoonman
Tall Rachel is an asshole and a coward. Redemption is not a story or illusion. People can improve themselves.
HueSatLight
You might be reading the wrong comic, if “people can change for the better” makes you depressed.
Rachel’s pessimism is possibly rooted in her own regrets that she doesn’t think she can be better than.
thejeff
I don’t think anyone is irredeemable. That doesn’t mean everyone gets redeemed. Even the worst people in the world can change and grow and become better. But they’ve got to actually do it.
Caveat: I don’t like the term “redemption”. It’s got way too many religious/Christian overtones for me.
UrsulaDavina
Can’t say if everyone but my sisters act exactly like my mother who acts like my grandmother( although they don’t insult people behind their backs in German that was my Oma’s own exclusive thing) and then they wonder why they get into fights with eachother.
Comic.phile
Ha! That was my Oma’s thing too, to until a stranger she was commenting rudely on actually spoke German back to her and called her out on it.
UrsulaDavina
We kept telling her not to do it but she was never called on it.
UrsulaDavina
I forgot to say it was funny coincidence
Sombrero
If there’s more to her, I’m not sure I want to know, but I’m sure Willis will tell us.
Rogue 7
Linda hurts for me because I see a lot of my mother in her. My mom can be controlling at times, and she’s a white woman who grew up in the 70s- she has her biases and stereotypes, but she’s still at least moderately left.
If Linda’s a 10, she’s about a 2. I love her, respect her, and think that ultimately she’s one of the smartest people I know. But she’s not flawless.
I think also Linda has trapped herself in a feedback loop with both kids. She came down hard on Sal, Sal rebelled, and so she came down harder, and so Sal rebelled more, and so on and so forth. She coddled Walky, he did what she wanted, she coddled him more, and so on and so forth. In neither case was her initial behavior as extreme as it escalated to.
Fortunately Walky seems to be well on his way to short-circuting his feedback loop and standing up for himself. Way easier than what Sal has to deal with.
Archieve
The thing to remember about Linda and Sals relationship is that Sal did attempt to be who she thought her mother wanted her to be ( ex parents day church school outfit and friendly greeting) and Linda did not treat her anybetter for the effort put in. Sals at the point where she’s stopped trying altogether because Linda’s only going to give her emotional scrapes regardless of whether she tries hard on not.
John Campbell
BarerMender
Phillip Larkin. I follwed his advice.
BarerMender
I would never have noticed that.
Schpoonman
My dad’s not an ounce of the monster Linda is, but I’m most similar to him out of all my siblings and it irks me terribly.
Sirksome
I’ve never read the extended Walkyverse so Joyce and Walky ever being a couple doesn’t even seem real.
Dana
She started out with obsession with Danny being like half her character but in the Dumbingverse he’s just hat guy to her. Joyce seems to have a natural aversion to cross-universal romance.
Thag Simmons
I think basically all of the characters from the old ‘verse feel like awkward prototypes now after over a decade of Dumbing of Age.
The Shortpacked! main cast being the exceptions, at least for me. Those still feel like the true iterations of those characters to me
Zach
They were their own fully realized characters, and a decade older than these dumb kids. many of them were also veterans.
milu
As is typical of a wizened desert creature you speak enigmatically o Armored One, but i know what you mean. The “old verses” do now feel quaint and tentative, if charming, what with their featherless dromeiosaurs and such. Indeed indeed. Well spoken.
thejeff
I still really miss Head Alien as a villain though.