Yeah… no. Don’t sell your traumas, kids. It just gets exploitative after a while. And you can never live up to others’ expectations for “how brave you must be.”
Laura
Nobody wins the competitive trauma race.
Laura
Interesting article on the pitfalls of “selling” one’s trauma for college and scholarship applications, etc.
…And I am quite guilty of this practice, myself, until I realized how very hollow it was, and how much better I felt when I decided to keep certain life events private.
Laura
…If anything, all the applicant is doing is alerting the prospective employer or grantor or educational institution to the potential need to accommodate PTSD.
Which is fine, and sometimes what one wants to give a heads-up on, to be sure that accommodations will be in place.
But to see experience of trauma as a “selling point” only sells one’s other personal strengths short. …And there will ALWAYS be someone who comes along who’s more traumatized or whose trauma is more “authentic”. 😉
…OK, sorry, sorry, I’ll get off my hobby-horse now. I just saw a little too much of my younger self in Dorothy and wanted to reach back and give some advice from age.
YES to all of this Laura, thank you for sharing! ?
Yeah, the selling point practice, it can get REALLY toxic.
I sure hope we can move towards a society that removes the incentive to quite literally capitalize trauma like this, it just brings out the worse in everyone involved. At least in my experience.
Laura
I apologize, too, for the thread-jack. I keep trying to keep talk on topic and yet so many tendrils keep sneaking in from the sides. Did not mean to intervene where intervention is unnecessary.
NG, thanks for expressing appreciation. BTW, I don’t use pronouns. All good, just thought youse folks should know.
Laura
D’oh! Replied to the wrong comment. Sleepy. G’night, all!
I’ve had PTSD/depression for so long they’re more like personality traits you wish you could get rid of than mental illnesses. I mean I got the PTSD during Nixon’s first term, which led to the depression during Watergate through the Ford administration, when it set in permanently. That’s why getting killed by the pickup truck didn’t have any additional effect, I was already as damaged as I could get without dying (again).
Laura
I hear that, Opus! I hear you.
As Dina would say, *expresses concern by light physical contact on an in-bathing-suit area.*
Yumi
@Laura: OH no… I have to assume you meant “non-bathing-suit area” or something to that effect, but the typo did make me laugh.
T_T I relate a lot to this student’s story. I’m probably not going to finish reading the article.
AlexaSpuds
you’re absolutely correct, but also hey I at least can get something nice out of the horrible experiences I suffered, it’s ?SOMETHING?
Laura
Well, yeah. And I’m a firm believer in using every advantage, every possible piece of leverage available. Turning every setback into an opportunity, as Dorothy might say.
And there’s absolutely no reason why people shouldn’t get good things by highlighting what strengths set them apart from others, and what challenges have taught them those strengths.
It’s just when one starts to objectify oneself as nothing more than “the sum of one’s trials,” that one can start to lose sight of one’s own innate strengths that exist wholly outside of one’s trauma.
Oh, yeah, it was awful! Talk about putting trauma on display!
8-|
But yeah, MASSIVE trigger warning, there.
Just a warning to Dorothy, that the Ivies are not actually known for being accommodating to survivors of trauma. I know a few Ivy Leaguers who got badly burned at their universities after asking for mental health accommodations.
Laura
I do apologize for and empathize with how reading an article like that can kind of knock a person flat, for a while. I am sorry for bringing distress. (Almost didn’t post it for that reason, and perhaps should have listened to that warning voice better and not posted it.) I hope you’re doing OK.
Take good care of yourself, maybe drink some tea? It’s important to watch out for vicarious trauma after reading ugly stuff.
So far, Dorothy has watched Amber stab a dude hard enough to require long-term hospitalization, gotten kidnapped and tossed into a basement, used emotional manipulation a little too far and successfully distracted a guy into murdering his partner, and then watched her best friend get kidnapped again, by said murderer.
Bryy
Honestly, I have no idea how they all are doing this well.
Laura
It’s because they are fictional characters.
Laura
It would be pretty interesting to see the survivors in group therapy.
Might help them.
These 2 guys and their Batman figurines remind me a lot of Amber and Amazi-Girl (which autocorrect keeps changing to “Amazon Girl” — fitting, in more ways than one!).
If nothing else, Dorothy is confident that she will be the president one day and self-belief is good for you. Just don’t base your life on assuming you will be president one day.
Honestly, I wish we could do a Dumbing of Age bonus strip where Dorothy witnesses the much better candidate lose to the much-much worse one. It would be an interesting reality check.
But I imagine Dorothy doesn’t believe that could ever happen to her.
She should. She essentially lost that campaign for RA that she and Roz imagined up when Ruth went on that near comatose depression incident. If I’m remembering that right. She also realized Becky got an unfair inside track to a fledgling political career by hijacking a local congresswoman’s twitter account. She knows the game is rigged she just hasn’t figured out how to rig it in her favor.
justin8448
Thanks for reminding us of all that out Sirksome.
I’m not sure Dorothy has decided to try to rig the game in her favor though. That just doesn’t seem to me like her personality. I think rather that she’s in the grip of sunk-cost fallacy.
She’s made wanting to be president so central to everything she does in life and she refuses to give up on that dream. Evidence that the political game is not fair and that she may not actually be very good at it definitely disturbs her, but not enough yet to seriously re-evaluate her goals.
Though I could be wrong about that. Or maybe we’re both right. We’ll see!
I think Dorothy just doesn’t have it, her instincts are badly suited for politics and she doesn’t take to it naturally in the way Becky and Roz do.
To my mind that’s a compliment, but if you want to be president someday, that might be a hard thing to swallow
C.T. Phipps
There’s a good argument Dorothy’s biggest problem is that she’s probably not going to find President what she actually wants. A President is primarily a leader of a party platform and needs to be elected based on their communal desires as well as deal making (then sold to the American people). They’re not actually a person who gets to set their own agenda as a rule.
The key issue with Dorothy is that she is earnest, straight-forward, competent and well-meaning. Politicians are by definition underhanded manipulators who will throw any kind of dirt on the opposition to win. Dotty has no life in politics, she is too good a person.
This comment wasn’t mean was it? I was rereading it and I think it may have come off as derogatory rather than just an attempt show that someone has seen your fun comment. Sorry.
Straight as an arrow with a pronounced curve to it. Joyce is very easy to read as an incredibly repressed bisexual who rationalizes that the way she feels around certain girls is perfectly ordinary platonic friendship while deep in the throws of saphic romance.
King Daniel
I’ve floated/seen others float the headcanon of Joyce as possibly-biromantic heterosexual for a while now, myself. It helps to remember that there’s a romantic-orientation axis too (and that it can diverge from the sexual-orientation one—see people on the ace spectrum who still experience romantic attraction for example), not just a sexual-orientation one!
Laura
She was pretty enchanted with “Billie”‘s chest, though!
Maybe an “above the waist” lesbian as Jamie puts it.
I can imagine her ending up with Joe in teh endgame/long run but I can also see a version of Joyce where she’s enjoying holding hands with a girl and hugging w/o it being too physical or a ‘bambi’ lesbian or so if that terms still around
GeekyWarrior
As Joyce herself puts it, “Dealing with any parts below the neck”
260 thoughts on “Personal growth”
Ana Chronistic
costumes you have to explain are kinda crap tho, regardless of the fine quality of pantsuit
that, or everyone just assumes “Hillary”
bc, pantsuit
Ana Chronistic
First Lady Hot Dog Water
RassilonTDavros
…every time I think I can’t ship Joyce and Dorothy any more than I already do, something happens to prove me wrong.
Yet_One_More_Idiot
Joyothy supporters, UNITE! <3
ThunderNight
Hillary Dinkley
Doctor_Who
Vellary Clinkley.
Jess
has a certain ring to it.
Rahul
picks up the rice in a church where a wedding has been
Proxiehunter
She wore the orange Velma sweater over the pants suit to make it obvious.
Needfuldoer
Wouldn’t be the first time somebody’s drawn that parallel.
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2016/comic/book-6/04-it-all-returns/miss/
Clif
Costumes that you have to explain are fine, as long it’s an excuse to deliver a really awesome pun.
Twitcher
Joyce is Disney’s Rapunzel, yes? When would she have had the time to see it?
Ana Chronistic
The movie’s only like 2 hours long?
Ana Chronistic
like Edgar Allen Poe Dameron?
Doctor_Who
“I didn’t experience horrible trauma! I participated in the acquisition of material for future emotional breakthroughs in therapy!”
shrub
Yeah I find that second panel to be quite disturbing
LuminousLead
Same. “I wasn’t assaulted, I was taught a lesson!”
Inahc
yeah. I need to have a word with dorothy’s therapist about toxic positivity.
True Survivor
Don’t forget witnessed a murder. If a hostage situation is good on a resume just imagine how impressed potential employers will be with that!
Laura
Yeah… no. Don’t sell your traumas, kids. It just gets exploitative after a while. And you can never live up to others’ expectations for “how brave you must be.”
Laura
Nobody wins the competitive trauma race.
Laura
Interesting article on the pitfalls of “selling” one’s trauma for college and scholarship applications, etc.
(MASSIVE trigger warning…)
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/04/04/mackenzie-fierceton-rhodes-scholarship-university-of-pennsylvania
…And I am quite guilty of this practice, myself, until I realized how very hollow it was, and how much better I felt when I decided to keep certain life events private.
Laura
…If anything, all the applicant is doing is alerting the prospective employer or grantor or educational institution to the potential need to accommodate PTSD.
Which is fine, and sometimes what one wants to give a heads-up on, to be sure that accommodations will be in place.
But to see experience of trauma as a “selling point” only sells one’s other personal strengths short. …And there will ALWAYS be someone who comes along who’s more traumatized or whose trauma is more “authentic”. 😉
There’s a Doonesbury comic strip about the trauma Olympics:
https://www.gocomics.com/doonesbury/2006/12/14
…OK, sorry, sorry, I’ll get off my hobby-horse now. I just saw a little too much of my younger self in Dorothy and wanted to reach back and give some advice from age.
The Wellerman
YES to all of this Laura, thank you for sharing! ?
Yeah, the selling point practice, it can get REALLY toxic.
I sure hope we can move towards a society that removes the incentive to quite literally capitalize trauma like this, it just brings out the worse in everyone involved. At least in my experience.
Laura
I apologize, too, for the thread-jack. I keep trying to keep talk on topic and yet so many tendrils keep sneaking in from the sides. Did not mean to intervene where intervention is unnecessary.
NG, thanks for expressing appreciation. BTW, I don’t use pronouns. All good, just thought youse folks should know.
Laura
D’oh! Replied to the wrong comment. Sleepy. G’night, all!
The Wellerman
Oops. Sorry about the pronouns. ? if it makes you feel any better, i feel like a clumsy mess right now. Also, thank you.
I feel tired too. Going to sleep….
Laura
No worries at all, NG. Sleep well, rest well, and take good care of yourself.
Opus the Poet
I’ve had PTSD/depression for so long they’re more like personality traits you wish you could get rid of than mental illnesses. I mean I got the PTSD during Nixon’s first term, which led to the depression during Watergate through the Ford administration, when it set in permanently. That’s why getting killed by the pickup truck didn’t have any additional effect, I was already as damaged as I could get without dying (again).
Laura
I hear that, Opus! I hear you.
As Dina would say, *expresses concern by light physical contact on an in-bathing-suit area.*
Yumi
@Laura: OH no… I have to assume you meant “non-bathing-suit area” or something to that effect, but the typo did make me laugh.
Laura
D’oh! *Facepalm.* *blushes* SMDH. Oh NO! I am SOOO sorry, Opus! Gaaah… autocorrect and clumsy thumbs on a tiny cell phone are conspiring for my doom. Yes, I meant it ONLY as Dina did:
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2016/comic/book-6/03-when-god-closes-the-door/comfort/
…On a NON-bathing suit area! Eep! Please, flag my typos into oblivion!!! 8-|
Laura
Oh, hej, here’s the DOA equivalent on trauma-topping:
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2020/comic/book-10/03-when-it-crumbles/unaccounted/
Laura
Huh. Reply wound up in the wrong place. Sorry!
Joy
T_T I relate a lot to this student’s story. I’m probably not going to finish reading the article.
AlexaSpuds
you’re absolutely correct, but also hey I at least can get something nice out of the horrible experiences I suffered, it’s ?SOMETHING?
Laura
Well, yeah. And I’m a firm believer in using every advantage, every possible piece of leverage available. Turning every setback into an opportunity, as Dorothy might say.
And there’s absolutely no reason why people shouldn’t get good things by highlighting what strengths set them apart from others, and what challenges have taught them those strengths.
It’s just when one starts to objectify oneself as nothing more than “the sum of one’s trials,” that one can start to lose sight of one’s own innate strengths that exist wholly outside of one’s trauma.
Like in this comic:
https://asofterworld.com/index.php?id=911
“The terrible things that happened to you
Didn’t make you you.
You always were.”
🙂 <3
shellshockbp
Fucking hell, that article was brutal.
Laura
Oh, yeah, it was awful! Talk about putting trauma on display!
8-|
But yeah, MASSIVE trigger warning, there.
Just a warning to Dorothy, that the Ivies are not actually known for being accommodating to survivors of trauma. I know a few Ivy Leaguers who got badly burned at their universities after asking for mental health accommodations.
Laura
I do apologize for and empathize with how reading an article like that can kind of knock a person flat, for a while. I am sorry for bringing distress. (Almost didn’t post it for that reason, and perhaps should have listened to that warning voice better and not posted it.) I hope you’re doing OK.
Take good care of yourself, maybe drink some tea? It’s important to watch out for vicarious trauma after reading ugly stuff.
Jamie
So far, Dorothy has watched Amber stab a dude hard enough to require long-term hospitalization, gotten kidnapped and tossed into a basement, used emotional manipulation a little too far and successfully distracted a guy into murdering his partner, and then watched her best friend get kidnapped again, by said murderer.
Bryy
Honestly, I have no idea how they all are doing this well.
Laura
It’s because they are fictional characters.
Laura
It would be pretty interesting to see the survivors in group therapy.
Might help them.
These 2 guys and their Batman figurines remind me a lot of Amber and Amazi-Girl (which autocorrect keeps changing to “Amazon Girl” — fitting, in more ways than one!).
https://www.gocomics.com/doonesbury/2006/12/15
Laura
Oh, sorry! Spoiler for military trauma in the link.
Mr D
To quote Finn:
“That’s going in the vault- Annnd it’s gone”
Needfuldoer
Don’t forget she also had a front row seat for that time Amber julienned Druggo McScarface.
Kitschensyngk
“Where do you see yourself in five years?”
“Tied up in a basement watching someone getting his brains bashed in with a hammer.”
Kyrik Michalowski
If nothing else, Dorothy is confident that she will be the president one day and self-belief is good for you. Just don’t base your life on assuming you will be president one day.
C.T. Phipps
Honestly, I wish we could do a Dumbing of Age bonus strip where Dorothy witnesses the much better candidate lose to the much-much worse one. It would be an interesting reality check.
But I imagine Dorothy doesn’t believe that could ever happen to her.
Sirksome
She should. She essentially lost that campaign for RA that she and Roz imagined up when Ruth went on that near comatose depression incident. If I’m remembering that right. She also realized Becky got an unfair inside track to a fledgling political career by hijacking a local congresswoman’s twitter account. She knows the game is rigged she just hasn’t figured out how to rig it in her favor.
justin8448
Thanks for reminding us of all that out Sirksome.
I’m not sure Dorothy has decided to try to rig the game in her favor though. That just doesn’t seem to me like her personality. I think rather that she’s in the grip of sunk-cost fallacy.
She’s made wanting to be president so central to everything she does in life and she refuses to give up on that dream. Evidence that the political game is not fair and that she may not actually be very good at it definitely disturbs her, but not enough yet to seriously re-evaluate her goals.
Though I could be wrong about that. Or maybe we’re both right. We’ll see!
Laura
There’s a new novel out on that theme: “Tracy Flick Can’t Win”
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/58977852-tracy-flick-can-t-win
It’s a sequel to the Reese Witherspoon movie, “Election”. About how youngsters’ political ambitions can get thwarted with time.
Bryy
That would be a super interesting arc.
Thag Simmons
I think Dorothy just doesn’t have it, her instincts are badly suited for politics and she doesn’t take to it naturally in the way Becky and Roz do.
To my mind that’s a compliment, but if you want to be president someday, that might be a hard thing to swallow
C.T. Phipps
There’s a good argument Dorothy’s biggest problem is that she’s probably not going to find President what she actually wants. A President is primarily a leader of a party platform and needs to be elected based on their communal desires as well as deal making (then sold to the American people). They’re not actually a person who gets to set their own agenda as a rule.
Eldritchy
The key issue with Dorothy is that she is earnest, straight-forward, competent and well-meaning. Politicians are by definition underhanded manipulators who will throw any kind of dirt on the opposition to win. Dotty has no life in politics, she is too good a person.
anon
i don’t keep up with foreign politics but i wouldn’t be surprised if another country had a female president before the US does
C.T. Phipps
They have.
BBCC
We don’t need one. She was alive for 2016.
crow
Also, pick a better life goal than being part of the corrupt ruling class
RassilonTDavros
…I think my shipping goggles are permanently attached to my head at this point WRT these two.
True Survivor
Ehhh… I’m pretty sure Joyce is straight and as much as I like Dorothy I think her current life trajectory ends with her dying alone.
True Survivor
This comment wasn’t mean was it? I was rereading it and I think it may have come off as derogatory rather than just an attempt show that someone has seen your fun comment. Sorry.
RassilonTDavros
Nah, it’s all cool! I’ve done the same thing.
Proxiehunter
Straight as an arrow with a pronounced curve to it. Joyce is very easy to read as an incredibly repressed bisexual who rationalizes that the way she feels around certain girls is perfectly ordinary platonic friendship while deep in the throws of saphic romance.
King Daniel
I’ve floated/seen others float the headcanon of Joyce as possibly-biromantic heterosexual for a while now, myself. It helps to remember that there’s a romantic-orientation axis too (and that it can diverge from the sexual-orientation one—see people on the ace spectrum who still experience romantic attraction for example), not just a sexual-orientation one!
Laura
She was pretty enchanted with “Billie”‘s chest, though!
Laura
Hmmm… gets lost in moderation limbo.
Here’s the reference link:
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2013/comic/book-3/03-answers-in-hennessy/curiosity/
BarerMender
Joyce’s cherishing of “breathing the same air” as Dorothy says she’s straight-up bi, in my book.
eh, whatever
Biromantic – it doesn’t say anything about sexuality.
anon
https://www.girlswithslingshots.com/comic/gws-chaser-537
Maybe an “above the waist” lesbian as Jamie puts it.
I can imagine her ending up with Joe in teh endgame/long run but I can also see a version of Joyce where she’s enjoying holding hands with a girl and hugging w/o it being too physical or a ‘bambi’ lesbian or so if that terms still around
GeekyWarrior
As Joyce herself puts it, “Dealing with any parts below the neck”
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2015/comic/book-5/02-threes-a-crowd/foranybody/
Opus the Poet
I call those people “Boobiesexual”.