This month, Dumbing of Age Patreon folks voted for Howard to be featured in a bonus strip. Why would they do that? They just know I'm going to serve up something soulwrenching. You brought this all on yourselves!
Reminder: Folks who pledge $5/month or more to Patreon get to see tomorrow's strip a day early! Preface
This month, Dumbing of Age Patreon folks voted for Howard to be featured in a bonus strip. Why would they do that? They just know I'm going to serve up something soulwrenching. You brought this all on yourselves!
Reminder: Folks who pledge $5/month or more to Patreon get to see tomorrow's strip a day early!
261 thoughts on “Preface”
Ana Chronistic
breakups all around =(
BBCC
*appropriate gesture of support*
Delicious Taffy
…But I will go, fearless and free
AnvilPro
Everyone dumps Amber.
newllend(henryvolt)
She was too good for all of them.
Mr D
You know what? No. Have you seen all the horrible shit she’s done? She has pushed away almost everyone who cares for her. Having mental issues and past trauma doesn’t give you a free pass to treat people like garbage.
I’ve had to deal with that shit. My Li’l brother’s father, a man I lived with for 10 horrible years, was a man who pushed away and abused everyone near him because he had bad experiences growing up. He is an old, bitter and hateful man who made my family’s life horrible shit for 10 years, and even after my mum broke up with him he still manages to ruin our life by trying to brainwash my baby brother.
So yeah, having issues mental issues doesn’t give you an excuse to treat people like shit just because you don’t want to go to therapy.
Fart Captor
While it’s understandable that you feel that way, there’s absolutely no need for you to get hostile towards people who identify with her as someone struggling with a difficult and untreated mental illness, a history of abuse, and having trouble finding a way to handle those things in a healthy manner, all while – as you noted – pushing away those who would try to support her.
Especially considering it isn’t that Amber doesn’t want to go to therapy. It’s that her abusive piece of shit dad wouldn’t allow it.
So while yeah, she’s not great at handling her anger and she’s snapped at people, there’s a lot more to her character than those low moments.
I’m sorry for what you and your brother have been through, but people who are saying that they like or empathize with Amber aren’t expressing support for your brother’s dad, or even that Amber’s own bad behavior is okay. Amber isn’t him.
steelplatedheart
She didn’t snap at people, she assaulted people. She’s assaulted multiple people.
Dude above you was out of line, it was just a joke, yeah, but the response to that isn’t “she’s more than just her low moments” because that’s what they always say. That’s what my girlfriend said when she assaulted me, and it’s what she said the day after she tried to kill herself.
Amber is a dime-a-dozen narcissistic abuser. She doesn’t get a pass just because she has a character; she stabbed an unarmed person who was being detained by the cops and went on to become a vigilante so she could have a free pass to beat the shit out of people.
Spencer
So Amber’s never allowed to have a low moment? If she does, does that make her broken?
thejeff
Rachel was right!
gc
I’m enjoying that Willis has written Rachel as a parody of half the people in these comment sections
Fart Captor
I’m not actually bothered by your opinion so much as I am by how you felt the need to respond to me indicating that I sympathize with Amber by basically saying that she’s a violent, abusive monster and always will be.
I understand that people like who you’re describing exist, and will often claim to have hidden depths and genuine remorse just to trick people into staying. That isn’t Amber. For one, she isn’t the one arguing that, I am. We’ve literally seen her do good, and be genuinely kind and caring.
And I’ve never said she should be a pass on anything. Does saving Becky or trying to Ryan cancel out stalking and trying to assault Sal and her friends? Maybe not, but it sure as hell makes a difference.
Though it’s worth noting that most of the times when Amazi-Girl stops a crime, we don’t actually see violence unless someone is in danger. The rest of the time it’s heavily implied that she simply chases them off, or they attack her for interfering.
The only times she’s attacked someone who wasn’t an immediate threat were while stalking Sal (which I admit was bad enough even without the actual violence), and stabbing her after the robbery. You know, as a child, in the midst of a panic attack, while being egged on by her shitheel father.
I think she’s a good kid with some serious problems, who has made mistakes and is trying to do better. I don’t care if you disagree, or if you aren’t as willing to forgive those mistakes.
Spencer
Also when she went after Sal and co. (under the belief that she was going to be exposed and her life was over), she still, like, waited for them to throw the first strike. The only person who got hurt was Malaya and that’s because she actually tried to fight Amber, and then kneed her in the gut when she was taken down.
Not saying it’s okay, but it’s different than her violently charging at Sal with her fists swinging.
BBCC
I’d hesitate to give Amber credit for that, considering she made it very clear she intended to fight them regardless (‘I’ve found you underaged drinking. Breaking the law. That makes this so much easier’ is hard to construe as nonthreatening when it comes from a costumed AG and ‘It’ll have to be tonight’ from before she went out). And besides, if Malaya and the rest have to retreat before they can take a swing at her even though she came up to them threatening them, Amber had to retreat from Malaya before she was allowed to strike her (and considering Malaya had to skate up to her first, she can hardly argue she didn’t have time to leave), especially since she was restrained immediately almost after hitting Malaya, preventing her from hitting anyone else even if she wanted to.
Spencer
The whole point of Amber trying to fight Sal then was “to do it right.” Proving to herself that she’s stronger than Sal and that Sal was just a dirty criminal she didn’t have to be scared of. In fact Willis showed some proto-sketches of the scene where they do just restrain her and leave, and Amber doesn’t fight back.
BBCC
That doesn’t really change that she’s the one coming up to people, threatening them and picking fights and then claiming the moral high ground.
shammers
what’s your interpretation of hostile? because to me, that person is just venting. as many seem to do with characters they dislike that aren’t absolute asshats like grampa asshat.
Li
Hostile is when you vent AT another reader, telling them they’re wrong to identify with Amber.
If these people were making new comments instead of making their angry rants in RESPONSE to other readers, it would be different.
Fart Captor
Exactly.
Leorale
I’m sorry you had to put up with that hateful person, your experience is legit (and must’ve been super sucky).
Amber is different than that dude though. He’s an adult, who hopefully has been away from his bad upbringing for more than a few weeks. Amber is a teenager who hasn’t learned adult skills yet, and she hasn’t been offered psychological help to refuse or accept it yet. There’s still lots of hope that she will not go in the direction of the ierk who mistreated/mistreats your family.
newllend(henryvolt)
Wow, If I had a nickel for every time somebody here blew up at me for what I hope is and pretty sure is a none offensive joke, But I have already learned by that on the internet almost a lot of things you say will inevitably piss someone off.
Though one thing I think anyone should never get used to is being told who we should or shouldn’t be allowed to sympathize with. Sure maybe we’ll all guilty of doing exactly that at one point and yeah there are people who are who shouldn’t always get a free past just because they claim not be in the right state of mind, but that shouldn’t stop every single person for feeling basic compassion for others suffering through stuff like this.
Mr D I’m sorry about what your step father did to your family, and the right is yours to choose not to forgive him or not. But even though we’re talking about a fictional character right now there are plenty of real people out there like Amber who are desperately trying not to become what your step father is and I don’t think it’s healthy to take your anger out on them for mistakes some other selfish self destructive man did.
Or at least that’s just how I see it, no need to take me seriously.
AnvilPro
I can see where you’re coming from and I partially agree. I feel bad for her but think she may have went too far in trying to push Danny away, especially doing it after a moment where Danny was just trying to comfort her after one of the darkest days in this comic.
Flakky
Yet here we are with you ranting at some hapless person who was just joking around.
Delicious Taffy
This is darkly amusing, in the most repulsive way.
Lokitsu
I understand the reasons for your anger, but Amber has much more than “mental issues”. I have issues (severe depression and possibly bi-polar); Amber believes that she’s two different people. I don’t know what the diagnosis would be-maybe diasociative disorder, maybe schizophrenia? Either way, she probably needs medication, definitely needs counseling and possibly needs to be hospitalized. Right now she can tell right from wrong (which is why it’s reasonable to be angry at some of the things she’s done) but that’s not necessarily a given as her problems progress.
thejeff
Though there has been nothing official – since in-world Amber hasn’t seen a therapist and been diagnosed with anything – several commenters with Disassociative Identity Disorder have identified with Amber and said she matches their symptoms fairly well. She has other issues as well – the Amber persona had serious panic attacks at contact with Sal, for example.
I’m not sure about medication, but counseling and therapy are definitely in order.
“tell right from wrong” is more of a legal standard than a medical or moral one and I’m not sure it’s really useful to apply here. (Or frankly anywhere, but that’s a different rant.)
BBCC
Yeah, the general idea in the comments seems to be she probably has a dissociative disorder, either DID or DDNOS Type 1. Some others have suggested it may be BPD. It is almost certainly not schizophrenia – it doesn’t work that way.
Lokitsu
The only reason I mentioned right from wrong was because I’m worried that her lawyer will have to argue that in front of a jury someday.
Viri
So feeling like you have two different “mindsets” or personas (for lack of a better term, no memory issues, but two different “personalities” or ways of thinking and you identify with both/know that both are the “real” you) that kind of flow back and forth is an identity disorder?
That’s what I see in myself after my trauma and I can also sort of see it in Amber as well. Just transitioning between the mindset that can’t handle a situation to one that can. The self that cares and tries to see the best in people and wouldn’t hurt anything intentionally (except for maybe mosquitoes) and the self that sees no issue with doing whatever it takes to survive including discarding morals, seeing other people as either obstacles, things to be used, or just sort of there. I refer to whichever mindset isn’t dominant or present at the moment as “she” as well because it is a little too detached or different from the current me to refer to it as “I” or “me” even though I know quite well that it is.
I can see the struggle in Amber to re-consolidate the two selves into a whole again as I see it in myself. And I know firsthand that until self-worth and self-respect returns, the mere presence of the “bad” self is enough to incite feelings of shame and worthlessness. It’s an awful spiral and I feel like Amber is trying to gain some self-respect and redemption through channeling that “bad” self to do things that have a good outcome even if the method is more chaotic than most, though it backfires if she’s completely blinded by her trauma at the time.
Halpful
If you read the comments on previous amber strips, there’s some really great discussion of DID (especially Cerberus’ comments). Although as one commenter pointed out, it unintentionally ignores OSDD and related stuff.
Gem fusion makes a great metaphor for some of the concepts involved. 🙂
StClair
Here, let’s swap gravatars. This one definitely suits you better.
Kris
Especially Amber.
Kris
Relax. She’s your reporter not your wife.
MatthewTheLucky
There’s no relationship more sacred than a superhero and their Lois.
Kris
They’re dorm neighbors. They can see each other everyday.
MatthewTheLucky
That just makes this harder. Dorothy’s going to see her everyday and know that some other girl is being told exploits of daring-do.
Pablo360
Derring-do is heroism. Daring-Do is a pony.
OnyxIdol
I have been thinking about this, and I realized, Spiderman/Peter Parker is his own Lois.
MatthewTheLucky
As a teenager, he did a lot of self-journalism.
Emperor Daniel
“Journalism.”
Delicious Taffy
What else do you call photographing yourself and selling the pictures for cash?
NelC
Photographing yourself shooting web.
I’m just going to leave that there.
Delicious Taffy
Hey, it almost pays one of the smaller bills.
Deanatay
So, he’s a camwhore?
Yep, seems about right.
Delicious Taffy
Nah, he’d have to spend three hours standing in front of a webcam in his underwear, with music playing just loud enough to be audible but not loud enough to be recognised. muttering and typing something every few minutes. Also, demanding ridiculously high tips for the most mundane of things, then complaining when nobody’s tipped enough to clear his $50 “Spin in a Circle 5 Times” tier.
desolation0
And the relationship between Spiderman and his Lois is just as screwed up as the rest most of the time.
achallenger
thisis week is like emotional bumpercars!
Doctor_Who
Drama Dodge’ems
Delicious Taffy
Dragon’s Dodge-ma: Drama Arisen
Hellespont
I think we should see other people. In different states. Of different countries. But we can still stay in touch. By smoke signal. You like starting fires, don’t you? That will be fun.
Or is that just my exes?
BBCC
What, that’s not a normal post breakup situation for everyone?
Huh. Excuse me, I need to reconsider a few things.
missilentmurmur
I tend to become friends with them ~2 years after the break up
Delicious Taffy
I tried that with a guy, once. It didn’t turn out well, since he was the only one who thought we were dating. Also, the initial breakup happened shortly after I got a girlfriend, which made him jealous since now he couldn’t control my time. It took just about two years to even contact the guy again, and he spent basically the rest of the friendship after that holding petty grudges. I ended that last November, to the detriment of nearly my entire social life. To paraphrase Ruth, I acted with integrity and have no regrets.
With that preamble out of the way, how does that tend to go for you? I imagine it’s at least a bit awkward, at first?
missilentmurmur
I only have two exes altogether, so it’s not at all significant statistically, but in both cases the relation can be described as cordial. Yes, there is a lot of awkwardness in the beginning, especially in the case of the latter, because he spent half a year as a psychiatric inpatient and I was tiptoeing around. They are both very rational and self-aware, so they decided that they value my company over holding grudges. Actually, the final test of it was a few weeks ago at the wedding of a common friend, we first met in person since the break up. It turned out that we both benefit from that we care about each other.
Showler
Amber’s hair seems to be consuming her face.
Fart Captor
I like it. It both looks cute and fits her personality.
Needfuldoer
It’s something to hide behind that she can take everywhere! Like a portable lobby chair fort!
Emperor Daniel
Is this the mythical covfefe?
Delicious Taffy
That’s a made-up word, and you’re ruining the concept of written language.
begbert2
Actually Trump ruined it then, since that was a trumpism. Specifically, he used that in a word in a tweet and the Merriam-Webster dictionary tweeted resigned defeat at the idea of explaining its definition and announced it was going back to bed.
So yep, written language is ruined. Via the most predictable route imaginable.
Delicious Taffy
I was being facetious. Trump is just copying Sarah Palin for attention.
butts
“what’s her name”
“…Schtickshift.”
MatthewTheLucky
Yes.
UltraKyrie
Give us Schtickshift Willis, the people demand it
Delicious Taffy
How many people are really demanding a superhero named Schlickshift, though?
zoelogical
me
and not Schlickshift, Schtickshift. there’s a difference. imagine: a superhero who can completely change their form in order to borrow other people’s shticks. like taskmaster from marvel but better
Delicious Taffy
Taskmaster is a punk.
zoelogical
one time he got beat up by deadpool
zoelogical
u know what i changed my mind, this is rogue’s alternate alternate identity
Stephen Bierce
*looks in the pile of breakup songs*
*plays Chicago’s “Call On Me” on the hacked P.A. speakers*
m-m
Can’t wait for the “come back to me” hacked boom box
Needfuldoer
*Replaces “call on me” with “covfefe” in the karaoke lyrics*
Delicious Taffy
Not my “Call On Me” of choice, but it’s decent enough.
Adam