The neurodivergent closest to me (besides me) is a real life Joyce who refused to ever experience self doubt (and consequently growth) and is suddenly being crushed by realizations about the consequences of her actions.
Uh, are we even reading the same comic? I’m referring to the way she’s doubting her ability to understand things or feel real feelings on account of her being “autistic”.
Zach
I don’t know. I think, for us, self doubt (of our understanding of certain things) might be super important.
Hilen
To be fair you can feel the same way (_doubting her ability to understand things or feel real feelings on account of her being “autistic”_) if you have certain personality dissorders. As a person diagnosed with the later and feeling just the same as you descrive, I would like to ask if the difference resides on the origin of these feeligs? I mean, my crippling self-doubt and dificulties with socializing and “understanding” many social behaviors comes from a “voice” in the back of my mind constantly questioning every decision I make, every scenario “I think I understand”, the intentions of every person I meet, etc. It is the narrative of this voice which often changes what I initially perceive more “correctly” that then loops and distorts everything. Is this how it works for you? Or did I misunderstand and what you meant was that this self-doubt is only result of the diagnosis and posterior “judgment” people go through after being “tagged” with autism?
You also get the joy of wondering if it is you not understanding social situations correctly that makes people treat you the way that they do, or if it’s them being jerks like you originally thought. You wonder if you were being rude or difficult to deal with without realizing that you were acting that way.
oh is this abt the autism thing? I thought it was the feect of medication. I had a crisis of identity when I took birth control because messing up your hormones can change how you feel abt everything and my brain was super duper confused and I started thinking like a completely different person. I tried a few different brand and each time it was like WHO AM I WHO IS THIS STRANGER THAT I WAS UNTIL YESTERDAY anyway I dropped the pills after a year of weird tests
Even if she’s started taking birth control, it’s been at most a few hours since she took the first pill. Not likely any noticeable hormonal effects yet.
Yeah, but it’s a new kind of insufferable so it hits fresh for people. I for one embrace Jennifer’s new sense of control and confidence even if it’s bordering on arrogance now. Pre-time skip she was really down on herself except for very brief moments.
IDK, at some point you’re basically stepping over people’s agency and telling them what to do because you quote unquote know better and get shit done. Jennifer seems to be toeing that line a lot.
Bryy
Jennifer is more than over the line. It’s also no coincidence that she’s doing this right after her talk with Walky.
EDIT: I realize I flagged your post. I did not mean to. I apologize.
Needfuldoer
Now she’s extra-determined to talk to Joyce, to prove to herself that she was right and she helped someone in a crisis situation and that they didn’t take one step forward and two steps back due to her guidance.
Zach
But this time, it was glaringly obvious that someone had to step up and give Joyce ‘the talk’. She is in a foul mood after running into Ruth, but as long as she respects Joyce’s boundaries, about something we all have reason to believe she knows nothing (and many lies) about, I’d say she’s being responsible. It’s up to Joyce to express those boundaries.
Unless ‘over the line’ meant disregarding Sarah’s judgment of who can and can’t talk to Joyce. Because that’s not Sarah’s call to make.
Jennifer is trying to bull her way into Sarah’s room against her wishes and said if she doesn’t like it she can leave. Her own room. And she doesn’t give a shit about Joyce. She just wants to be the “problem solver head cheerleader” again for herself and Joyce had a problem. That’s all. Sarah is in the right and Jennifer needs to fuck off and respect Sarah’s space and Joyce’s privacy. No one asked for her help with medication.
Zach
It’s Joyce’s room, too. Joyce and Jen seamed to connect during the visit. If Sarah doesn’t want one of Joyce’s friends there, she may leave.
Now if the Joyce turns her down, that’s different.
And the ‘waiting for Joyce after the appointment’ exchange with Walky suggests this is more than that.
If Sarah didn’t constantly throw unprovoked insults at Jennifer, I’d be more sympathetic.
Rainhat
Seriously- nobody is responsible for maintaining that self image
And yet, Dan, when all her friends were putting Joyce in the too hard basket Jennifer was the one who got her help. Sarah even went so far as to drag her around campus, thank god it wasn’t something potentially fatal. If I had to choose, it wouldn’t be Sarah.
1.) I don’t know that I buy the stopped clock defense here.
2.) Maybe the feminine name and trans flag avatar do not make it clear but I do not appreciate being called “Dan”.
She never Sked Joyce if she wanted help. She just told her what to do and dragged her off. Joyce needed help, but Jennifer just wanted to control, much like now.
Yumi
That’s not what happened, though?
Joyfulldreams
She…literally did ask, though. And Joyce said sure? Like. C’mon.
JBento
Are you somehow confusing Jennifer with Dorothy in the “Joyce needs glasses arc”?
Every time I think about Twin Peaks, I still get a little mad at myself for believing it would get better for so long ;-; (according to my tastes, anyway; I know there’s a lot of people who enjoyed it).
The main problem with twin peaks isn’t hermetic symbolism or whatever we’ve shown as advancing sort of the plot. It’s the basic refusal of Lynch to care about any POC character to the point his depiction of an all-white community with token POCs (native and asian) as doomful and anxiety-inducing falls flat.
I’m gonna say it’s the autism thing. Considering the emotionless stereotype, I imagine there’s a lot of ugliness she’s learned running through Joyce’s head right now.
She was probably brought up with the “no soul” thing, hence why she said it to Dina.
Laura
“No soul”? What? WHAT? WHAT!?
…What is this?
Laura
Sorry, sorry. Sorry for the all caps. Feel free to flag. Just caught me off-guard there.
Bryy
Oh, never knew about that one, I see.
Bridgebrain
Fun fact: The concept of “Changelings” being fae children that were swapped in for regular children, usually in the first two years or so, who grew up strange and vaguely foreign, with strange mannerisms, weird emotional systems, strangely intelligent, and lacking in human social graces, tracks heavily with autism, in which symptoms begin to present at 12-18 months. Sometimes “changeling” children were left in the woods for the fae to take back.
As to “no soul”, flat affect was the cause for that rumor.
I dunno, being a soulless marxist alien parasite…. that sounds like a conservative bigot’s worse nightmare! ?
But in all seriousness, does anyone here know of any non-Western concepts of “autism”?
Many ancient cultures and aboriginal tribes around the world have concepts for non-binary people like me and accepting them as equals. Surely there are cultures out there with good words and comfortable places for neurodivergents too? ?
If so, I REALLY want to know. ?
Laura
Do you think the mentats, in “Dune,” were supposed to be based on folks with autism or savant syndrome or another neurodivergence? Or possibly just highly trained concentrators?
Laura
I thought that the “fair folk” were communities with high prevalence of Williams Syndrome? Maybe both.
Jamie
I don’t really feel comfortable making sweeping diagnoses of entire communities like that.
Laura
You’re right, of course, Jamie. Sorry, sorry, sorry. Yes, of course. How awful of me. I was just repeating what I had read a few different places, hypothesizing that Williams Syndrome was one of the factors that could have given rise to the legends of elves and faeries. I apologize for stereotyping. I should have been more nuanced.
Becci
I hadn’t heard that before but it makes sense, I have heard it referred to as “elfin faces syndrome” before.
Personally as an autistic fairy I love learning about mythologised history of neuro divergence, would greatly enjoy any relevant reading material. I know it’s not everyone’s thing though, I have an autistic friend for whom the idea of not being properly human is triggering for “doesn’t really deserve human rights” fears
Miri
I only learnt that a month or two ago! One of those things where I knew the folk stories but hadn’t made the connection – but it does make a lot of sense.
Taffy
Pff. The only ones with no souls are the empty freaks who go around accusing making life harder for others because they’ve only read one book and have terrible reading comprehension skills. Y”know that whole “Without God, people would have no morals” thing, the one that tells you that there’s nothing going on behind some people’s eyes, the moment they say it. They’re really good at pointing fingers though.
Taffy
Huh. Thought for sure I’d deleted that extra “accusing” there. Was gonna be a whole other sentence but I missed a spot.
Yeah it doesn’t help the case that figures like Mother Teresa viewed people as “empty spaces waiting to be filled by God”, mirrored rather eerily in the way Franciscan Priests treated native tribes in Mexico.
But yeah “soul” is really just a metaphor that humans use to “explain” the phenomena of consciousness, and I could go on for hours about the ways non-Christian cultures throughout time were a lot more nuanced and generous with the concept, but alas, why tempt myself? Neuro-fluid!!!!
BTW how are you Taffy?
Taffy
Stoned off my ass, mostly. Watched through Steven Universe Future and the only take-away is that Lapis Lazuli is hot and also that they sure wasted a lot of story opportunities in favor of relentless emotional constipation from the male lead.
LOL ? Funny you mention that, I just baked up a batch of pot brownies myself! Glad to know you’re enjoying yourself.
If you’re into high-octane story progression and cosmic mythic battles, might I recommend Maya and the Three? I just finished it, it’s THE BOMB!!! ?
Taffy
Any excuse to eat brownies is A+. Even people who can’t eat the usual ingredients find ways to make some kind of brownies. That’s how sloppy joes were invented, even.
It’s not even necessarily the Bad Evil Stereotypes about neurodivergence here. Like, I went through a similar process early in my ADHD diagnosis. In my case it was less a matter of negative stereotypes, and more a matter of “wait, THAT’S a symptom? And THAT’S a symptom? HOW MUCH OF MY PERSONALITY IS SYMPTOMS?” It wasn’t so much horror at the idea of being ADHD, it was reevaluating what I knew of myself in the light of new information and being overwhelmed. Like, this thing I thought was something EVERYBODY did, nope, ADHD symptom. This other thing I assumed was just a personal quirk that ONLY I did, nope, ADHD symptom. IS IT JUST SYMPTOMS ALL THE WAY DOWN? There was a bit of an existential crisis where I briefly felt like just a pile of symptoms in a trenchcoat.
That spiral where you paint over more and more of your uniqueness with a single brushstroke, more and more of your personality is attributed to a “disorder” that needs to be “corrected”, just DREADFUL. ??
313 thoughts on “Speak with”
Ana Chronistic
“ok you know what, this actually is above my paygrade”
Reltzik
Actually, Jennifer’s also become regrettably amazingly adept at never understanding anything.
Gigafreak
If nothing else, she still understands that Sal is Amazi-Girl!
Oh wait
bcb
Become? She’s always been amazing at it!
The Wellerman
All this insidious bigotry that’s EVERYWHERE, all this stuff people believe about us neurodivergents that just isn’t true. ???
Joyce…. oh Joyce…. that insidious self-doubt, that AWFUL spiral of emotions, I know EXACTLY what she’s going through, and it’s horrible ???
HANG IN THERE FAM FAM!!!! ???
*plays “The Innocent Abandoned” by Overdawn on hacked muzak*
Zach
The neurodivergent closest to me (besides me) is a real life Joyce who refused to ever experience self doubt (and consequently growth) and is suddenly being crushed by realizations about the consequences of her actions.
Is this a common thing?
Taffy
Yes.
The Wellerman
Uh, are we even reading the same comic? I’m referring to the way she’s doubting her ability to understand things or feel real feelings on account of her being “autistic”.
Zach
I don’t know. I think, for us, self doubt (of our understanding of certain things) might be super important.
Hilen
To be fair you can feel the same way (_doubting her ability to understand things or feel real feelings on account of her being “autistic”_) if you have certain personality dissorders. As a person diagnosed with the later and feeling just the same as you descrive, I would like to ask if the difference resides on the origin of these feeligs? I mean, my crippling self-doubt and dificulties with socializing and “understanding” many social behaviors comes from a “voice” in the back of my mind constantly questioning every decision I make, every scenario “I think I understand”, the intentions of every person I meet, etc. It is the narrative of this voice which often changes what I initially perceive more “correctly” that then loops and distorts everything. Is this how it works for you? Or did I misunderstand and what you meant was that this self-doubt is only result of the diagnosis and posterior “judgment” people go through after being “tagged” with autism?
Decidedly Orthogonal
“who refused to ever experience self doubt (and consequently growth) ”
…
This is a thing? People can refuse to feel doubt? about themselves???!!?
Reltzik
*eyes the NIFB*
Yes. Yes, they can.
Laura
NIFB?
Kimi
You also get the joy of wondering if it is you not understanding social situations correctly that makes people treat you the way that they do, or if it’s them being jerks like you originally thought. You wonder if you were being rude or difficult to deal with without realizing that you were acting that way.
The Wellerman
If you’re also a victim of abuse like Joyce, it all comes together to have a REALLY heavy effect on a person that cannot be overstated.
As good as my trust is in Willis’s skills as a writer, I sure hope this fact is reflected accurately in the way Joyce deals with this moving forward.
Oz
oh is this abt the autism thing? I thought it was the feect of medication. I had a crisis of identity when I took birth control because messing up your hormones can change how you feel abt everything and my brain was super duper confused and I started thinking like a completely different person. I tried a few different brand and each time it was like WHO AM I WHO IS THIS STRANGER THAT I WAS UNTIL YESTERDAY anyway I dropped the pills after a year of weird tests
thejeff
Even if she’s started taking birth control, it’s been at most a few hours since she took the first pill. Not likely any noticeable hormonal effects yet.
Joy
Wellerman, I just want to say that I appreciate you a lot and you’re my favorite part of reading the comments section.
Kaiyalai
Seconded,
You’re a good, Wellerman.
BBCC
Not the crisis you were expecting, maybe, Jennifer, but the one she’s having, nonetheless!
JBento
You deal with the crisis you got, not the crisis you wanted.
Danae Jay, Local Gay
Jenny’s kind of insufferable lately.
Thag Simmons
She has been consistently kind of insufferable for large chunks of this comic’s run, I’d say it’s a core part of her characterr
Sirksome
Yeah, but it’s a new kind of insufferable so it hits fresh for people. I for one embrace Jennifer’s new sense of control and confidence even if it’s bordering on arrogance now. Pre-time skip she was really down on herself except for very brief moments.
Zach
Sarah has always treaded her like shit. Jen should ask her why she didn’t bring Joyce to the doctor and also to go fuck herself.
No gratitude for helping her ‘little sister’, and constant, unprovoked disrespect.
Danae Jay, Local Gay
IDK, at some point you’re basically stepping over people’s agency and telling them what to do because you quote unquote know better and get shit done. Jennifer seems to be toeing that line a lot.
Bryy
Jennifer is more than over the line. It’s also no coincidence that she’s doing this right after her talk with Walky.
EDIT: I realize I flagged your post. I did not mean to. I apologize.
Needfuldoer
Now she’s extra-determined to talk to Joyce, to prove to herself that she was right and she helped someone in a crisis situation and that they didn’t take one step forward and two steps back due to her guidance.
Zach
But this time, it was glaringly obvious that someone had to step up and give Joyce ‘the talk’. She is in a foul mood after running into Ruth, but as long as she respects Joyce’s boundaries, about something we all have reason to believe she knows nothing (and many lies) about, I’d say she’s being responsible. It’s up to Joyce to express those boundaries.
Unless ‘over the line’ meant disregarding Sarah’s judgment of who can and can’t talk to Joyce. Because that’s not Sarah’s call to make.
MisterJinKC
Jennifer is trying to bull her way into Sarah’s room against her wishes and said if she doesn’t like it she can leave. Her own room. And she doesn’t give a shit about Joyce. She just wants to be the “problem solver head cheerleader” again for herself and Joyce had a problem. That’s all. Sarah is in the right and Jennifer needs to fuck off and respect Sarah’s space and Joyce’s privacy. No one asked for her help with medication.
Zach
It’s Joyce’s room, too. Joyce and Jen seamed to connect during the visit. If Sarah doesn’t want one of Joyce’s friends there, she may leave.
Now if the Joyce turns her down, that’s different.
And the ‘waiting for Joyce after the appointment’ exchange with Walky suggests this is more than that.
If Sarah didn’t constantly throw unprovoked insults at Jennifer, I’d be more sympathetic.
Rainhat
Seriously- nobody is responsible for maintaining that self image
ktbear
And yet, Dan, when all her friends were putting Joyce in the too hard basket Jennifer was the one who got her help. Sarah even went so far as to drag her around campus, thank god it wasn’t something potentially fatal. If I had to choose, it wouldn’t be Sarah.
Danae Jay, Local Gay
1.) I don’t know that I buy the stopped clock defense here.
2.) Maybe the feminine name and trans flag avatar do not make it clear but I do not appreciate being called “Dan”.
ESM
In her defense, Jennifer is the only one in this arc who has done anything at all that actually helped Joyce.
MisterJinKC
She never Sked Joyce if she wanted help. She just told her what to do and dragged her off. Joyce needed help, but Jennifer just wanted to control, much like now.
Yumi
That’s not what happened, though?
Joyfulldreams
She…literally did ask, though. And Joyce said sure? Like. C’mon.
JBento
Are you somehow confusing Jennifer with Dorothy in the “Joyce needs glasses arc”?
Needfuldoer
[citation needed]
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2022/comic/book-12/04-dont-stop-billie-ving/crampy/
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2022/comic/book-12/04-dont-stop-billie-ving/appointment-2/
Sombrero
Meet Insufferable Jennifer. It’s like Insufferable Billie, only more insufferable!!
poyo
lately ? lmao no i get what you mean. it’s worse than the first semester
Sirksome
This is probably a possible looming autism diagnosis thing, but I want to believe she heard about Becky and Dina smashing.
Dana
Yeah, that was my first impulse.
Doctor_Who
Plot twist: this has nothing to do with Joyce’s possible autism. She just watched Twin Peaks, and this is the natural reaction.
the illerman
Every time I think about Twin Peaks, I still get a little mad at myself for believing it would get better for so long ;-; (according to my tastes, anyway; I know there’s a lot of people who enjoyed it).
khn0
The main problem with twin peaks isn’t hermetic symbolism or whatever we’ve shown as advancing sort of the plot. It’s the basic refusal of Lynch to care about any POC character to the point his depiction of an all-white community with token POCs (native and asian) as doomful and anxiety-inducing falls flat.
Needfuldoer
The “Dual Spires” parody episode of Psych was a lot more fun.
Nono
Uhhhh.
Is this emotional trauma over the cult thing, or she heard Carla yelling about the pre-marital hanky panky, or the autism thing, or
RassilonTDavros
I’m gonna say it’s the autism thing. Considering the emotionless stereotype, I imagine there’s a lot of ugliness she’s learned running through Joyce’s head right now.
jeffepp
She was probably brought up with the “no soul” thing, hence why she said it to Dina.
Laura
“No soul”? What? WHAT? WHAT!?
…What is this?
Laura
Sorry, sorry. Sorry for the all caps. Feel free to flag. Just caught me off-guard there.
Bryy
Oh, never knew about that one, I see.
Bridgebrain
Fun fact: The concept of “Changelings” being fae children that were swapped in for regular children, usually in the first two years or so, who grew up strange and vaguely foreign, with strange mannerisms, weird emotional systems, strangely intelligent, and lacking in human social graces, tracks heavily with autism, in which symptoms begin to present at 12-18 months. Sometimes “changeling” children were left in the woods for the fae to take back.
As to “no soul”, flat affect was the cause for that rumor.
The Wellerman
I dunno, being a soulless marxist alien parasite…. that sounds like a conservative bigot’s worse nightmare! ?
But in all seriousness, does anyone here know of any non-Western concepts of “autism”?
Many ancient cultures and aboriginal tribes around the world have concepts for non-binary people like me and accepting them as equals. Surely there are cultures out there with good words and comfortable places for neurodivergents too? ?
If so, I REALLY want to know. ?
Laura
Do you think the mentats, in “Dune,” were supposed to be based on folks with autism or savant syndrome or another neurodivergence? Or possibly just highly trained concentrators?
Laura
I thought that the “fair folk” were communities with high prevalence of Williams Syndrome? Maybe both.
Jamie
I don’t really feel comfortable making sweeping diagnoses of entire communities like that.
Laura
You’re right, of course, Jamie. Sorry, sorry, sorry. Yes, of course. How awful of me. I was just repeating what I had read a few different places, hypothesizing that Williams Syndrome was one of the factors that could have given rise to the legends of elves and faeries. I apologize for stereotyping. I should have been more nuanced.
Becci
I hadn’t heard that before but it makes sense, I have heard it referred to as “elfin faces syndrome” before.
Personally as an autistic fairy I love learning about mythologised history of neuro divergence, would greatly enjoy any relevant reading material. I know it’s not everyone’s thing though, I have an autistic friend for whom the idea of not being properly human is triggering for “doesn’t really deserve human rights” fears
Miri
I only learnt that a month or two ago! One of those things where I knew the folk stories but hadn’t made the connection – but it does make a lot of sense.
Taffy
Pff. The only ones with no souls are the empty freaks who go around accusing making life harder for others because they’ve only read one book and have terrible reading comprehension skills. Y”know that whole “Without God, people would have no morals” thing, the one that tells you that there’s nothing going on behind some people’s eyes, the moment they say it. They’re really good at pointing fingers though.
Taffy
Huh. Thought for sure I’d deleted that extra “accusing” there. Was gonna be a whole other sentence but I missed a spot.
The Wellerman
Yeah it doesn’t help the case that figures like Mother Teresa viewed people as “empty spaces waiting to be filled by God”, mirrored rather eerily in the way Franciscan Priests treated native tribes in Mexico.
But yeah “soul” is really just a metaphor that humans use to “explain” the phenomena of consciousness, and I could go on for hours about the ways non-Christian cultures throughout time were a lot more nuanced and generous with the concept, but alas, why tempt myself? Neuro-fluid!!!!
BTW how are you Taffy?
Taffy
Stoned off my ass, mostly. Watched through Steven Universe Future and the only take-away is that Lapis Lazuli is hot and also that they sure wasted a lot of story opportunities in favor of relentless emotional constipation from the male lead.
The Wellerman
LOL ? Funny you mention that, I just baked up a batch of pot brownies myself! Glad to know you’re enjoying yourself.
If you’re into high-octane story progression and cosmic mythic battles, might I recommend Maya and the Three? I just finished it, it’s THE BOMB!!! ?
Taffy
Any excuse to eat brownies is A+. Even people who can’t eat the usual ingredients find ways to make some kind of brownies. That’s how sloppy joes were invented, even.
The Wellerman
Dark Magician, eh? ?
I draw… Pot of Greed! ?
Nelly Dreadful
It’s not even necessarily the Bad Evil Stereotypes about neurodivergence here. Like, I went through a similar process early in my ADHD diagnosis. In my case it was less a matter of negative stereotypes, and more a matter of “wait, THAT’S a symptom? And THAT’S a symptom? HOW MUCH OF MY PERSONALITY IS SYMPTOMS?” It wasn’t so much horror at the idea of being ADHD, it was reevaluating what I knew of myself in the light of new information and being overwhelmed. Like, this thing I thought was something EVERYBODY did, nope, ADHD symptom. This other thing I assumed was just a personal quirk that ONLY I did, nope, ADHD symptom. IS IT JUST SYMPTOMS ALL THE WAY DOWN? There was a bit of an existential crisis where I briefly felt like just a pile of symptoms in a trenchcoat.
The Wellerman
Oh my god…. I know how you feel. ???
That spiral where you paint over more and more of your uniqueness with a single brushstroke, more and more of your personality is attributed to a “disorder” that needs to be “corrected”, just DREADFUL. ??
*offers internet hug*
I don’t want to think that way ever again.
Sirksome