Today in the Dumbing of Age Book 13 Kickstarter, a SURPRISE SAL MAGNET was unlocked! Our sixth magnet, it's just regular ol' kick-ass SAL! She's gonna be about 2"x4" and you can have her tucked inside your book (along with your free Lucy magnet) if you pledge for the SAL MAGNET tier!
You can also decide to choose her amongst your curated selection of magnets if you go in for either the PICK THREE or PICK FIVE MAGNETs tiers, and of course she's included if you go all-in for COMPLETE MAGNET POWER!
Next up at $40K, we unlock LAUNDRY DOROTHY and LAUNDRY JOYCE! And there's probably.... four other magnets past them, at some point. WE'LL SEE. Burny
Today in the Dumbing of Age Book 13 Kickstarter, a SURPRISE SAL MAGNET was unlocked! Our sixth magnet, it's just regular ol' kick-ass SAL! She's gonna be about 2"x4" and you can have her tucked inside your book (along with your free Lucy magnet) if you pledge for the SAL MAGNET tier!
You can also decide to choose her amongst your curated selection of magnets if you go in for either the PICK THREE or PICK FIVE MAGNETs tiers, and of course she's included if you go all-in for COMPLETE MAGNET POWER!
Next up at $40K, we unlock LAUNDRY DOROTHY and LAUNDRY JOYCE! And there's probably.... four other magnets past them, at some point. WE'LL SEE.
239 thoughts on “Burny”
Ana Chronistic
not sure I’m comfortable with “assload” and “come out the other side” in the same discussion
Hagaren (FMA) touched on this pretty well, though, with, “Stand up and walk. Keep going forward. At least you have strong legs to take you there.”
Ana Chronistic
may as well also mention, I just read this book about college admissions, and in sum, they aren’t looking for the kids following the HYPS checklist like Dotty was doing so much as the kids actually experiencing life and even making mistakes (I guess, like in 21, the book/movie about the MIT card counters)
benito
It’s a bit late for a comment reply, but I went to grad school with Irena. Great lady. Great book!
Reltzik
Huh. From the context of the assload being of people who NEVER passed out the other side, I think that makes it a metaphor about anal retentiveness.
Miri
That can kill you, you know… It all gets compacted and blocked up and solid and just builds and builds and it sounds BAD.
clif
Still not as bad as being wrong about Star Wars.
Dante
Glorious reference, fam /o/ I should rewatch it (2003 is my fave though dhdnsh) Thanks for the reminder
Nathan
“Dhdnsh”?
Bash
Keyboard mash?
Cute avatar btw
David DeLaney
ADH&D the Movie
clif
Dhdnsh = Didn’t Hate the Disney New Shows. (AKA Mandelorian et al.)
IntangibleMatter
Joyce out here summarizing why I don’t talk to certain friends of mine who are religious anymore.
Question everything, unconditionally.
And as such, I’m questioning why Dorothy is asking about this.
True Survivor
She has spent her life in fanatical pursuit of the political power, believing that it is the way she can best help others and make her life meaningful – much in the same way that Joyce believed that being a good Christian was the path to a life of beneficence and purpose. Like, Joyce, Dorothy has had to face the fact that maybe what she believed about the Presidency, and thus herself and the dreams she defined herself by, is not the mythic power or good she thought – a fact which has thrown her into depression and self-doubt.
Adam Black
This is true.
But what broke her was facing how she was sacrificing living her life, being her true self and being able to do the good things she wanted. All for mostly illusory goal where she would have to betray her beliefs.
Bad means, bad end.
Dante
She’s been prodding at how wrong she was… About herself. And her goals, and the way the world works. In a way, Dorothy was very naive too.
How do you cope with a complete update of your concept of Self?
Coatl
The fact of believing that you are now officially an adult implies that you must behave as one should. But it’s not like that.
In the case of Dorothy, she thought that if she had a serious and realistic vision she would do things correctly without mistakes, but no, in life it will always be like a roller coaster, ups and downs, but the important thing here is that we must move forward and From those moments gain true experience.
I feel that this is where Dorothy will tell the truth to Joyce, but she is afraid of her reaction, in fact, I think that previously she was already terrified that if she declined from her goals everyone would condemn her, but fortunately her parents, Becky and Walky They have proven the opposite. It has been seen that Dorothy’s feeling of helping is genuine, I trust that she will be able to find something where she can do it without the need to add unnecessary weight.
Let’s just hope that Joyce listens as she should (I say this because of how the alcohol will react in her system)
Alongcameaspider
Well she herself is reckoning with her own crisis of faith, not religious faith but faith in herself
Imogen
Yeah, Dorothy believed that her only limits were determination, and that if she just worked harder, harder, harder, she could do anything. Recently she’s realized that not only is that not really true, she kind of… isn’t happy doing that.
Jeremiah
Because she’s been questioning if everything she thought she wanted was wrong for a few days now and doesn’t know how to deal with it?
Reltzik
… can I start by questioning the principle of “question everything”? Because there’s just too many things and not enough time to get to them all. ;p
IntangibleMatter
Did I stutter when saying to question everything? Question everything
Ellegos
Why?
BarerMender
Because the world is full of people who will lie to you, starting with parents, preachers, teachers, politicians, and professors, and ending with reporters, dumbass friends who sound smart, and smart people who aren’t as smart as they think they are.
Reltzik
I didn’t get further than “because I’m a contrarian and that paradox is just to meta to pass up”.
clif
Same.
David DeLaney
because that is the way of SCIENCE!!1! *krakaTHOOM*
eh, whatever
It is.
James
Technically yes, with the corollary that once you’ve received an answer for something that holds up, you typically move onto the next question until something actually casts doubt on an existing answer.
David DeLaney
but ALWAYS write down the answers that are WRONG
so you can shove them in the face of the next generation and say
“no no, we already tried that, and it did NOT catch fire correctly”
eh, whatever
Because otherwise you’ll learn nothing.
Stanistani
Yes, exactly! Why against everything! Burn it all down and build it up again, this time as an adult, instead of as a child spoon-fed what they want you to be.
LiamKav
But “question everything” is also the attitude that leads to believing that vaccines a a plot by the NWO to depopulate the Earth and that chemtrails are used to control birthrates and also that there’s a secret paedophile ring operating out of a pizza restaurant etc etc.
Daibhid C
It’s not, really. If you actually question those things you discover they’re all nonsense. If you question the ideas that vaccines are good, chemtrails aren’t real, and the pizzeria didn’t even have a basement, on the other hand, you’ll find they’re pretty solid.
Questioning something does not mean “deciding the opposite is true”, it means actually looking into them. (And, to avoid doubt, finding a website that confirms your beliefs and deciding to believe it unconditionally is not actually “doing your own research”.)
Miri
Yes!!! Question it as in interrogate the notion and examine the facts available; not just doubt it because somebody has asserted it, without applying any brainpower!!
Mark
That’s exactly the problem here: some use “question (vt)” when they mean “deny without thought”. I am not pointing at anyone here, but we’ve all been exposed to this meaning and it’s natural to apply it to see if it decodes the proverb well.
thejeff
There’s definitely a level at which people learn “You need to question what you were taught” and then only apply that to what they were originally formally taught. And this applies not just to the blatantly obvious conspiracy theories on the right, but also to the leftist “Everything is the fault of America/capitalism” version.
fridge_logic
Disagree.
Conspiracists may tout a mantra of question everything but they put little effort into questioning their deeply held beliefs about conspiracy. Question everything, if the questions are sincere means being ready to learn you’re wrong about anything.
Perhaps, the problem is nuance, or the lack of nuance in catchy phrases like “question everything.”
Miri
“Question everything” and “live your life as a paranoid conspiracy theorist” don’t need to be synonymous… One of those questions you should be asking is “how credible is this source?” and if you understand anything about science, hopefully you then rate e.g. the WHO and epidemiologists as more reliable than anti-vaxxers…
zee
Nah cuz those people were absolutely not question Facebook and Fox news. Question everything is basically another way to say “think critically, forehead”
James
Sadly, even when they do -or make an approximate attempt at doing so- at a certain point a lack of evidence becomes evidence of a coverup.
C.T. Phipps
Dorothy is an excellent organizer and leader but her exposure to Robin the Politician, the dirty nature of politics, and the horrific nature of violence (seeing Amazi-Girl stab that jerkass horribly) has her realize that being President will probably involve advocating it as well as making a lot of nasty deals.
And she doesn’t WANT to do any of that.
She doesn’t even want to profit off her tragic story, which is some basic social networking.
Mark
One question she should ask: who do I trust with this, more than I trust me? Someone is going to take the job.
clif
Who do I trust to operate the gas chamber more than I trust me? Someone is going to take the job.
HueSatLight
Is she an excellent organizer and leader, though?
Needfuldoer
Sometimes you don’t even recognize the people you thought you knew.
clif
Is that you, Fred?
Luminous Lead
She’s dealing with a lot of things, but one is probably her unspoken attraction to Joyce, hence the “coming out” query.
Nono
If you ever reached the point to go ‘well, no need to learn anything anymore’, life would be pretty boring.
I might regret that when I’m 70 and I have to learn how to use the iPhone 7294.
butting
Learning how to use the iPhone 7294? Trivial.
Figuring out how to make it behave like an iPhone 6 like Steve Jobs and the Cheese intended? That’s going to be the challenge.
David DeLaney
firast of all, how DARE you see me and Windows 98 and slrn and Notepad so accurately
hedgie
Were Usenet more alive, I’d probably still be using slrn, albeit now as one pane of a tmux session on a Mac.
Hof1991
I’m 70 and I’m learning Lightworks now. Long way from 16mm films and my Viewmaster. But fortunately it’s a lot like Premiere Pro.
At some point you can stop learning but I’m not looking forward to that.
clif
At 75 I just learned there’s a newish C++ with move semantics and I’m pretty bitter about it.
clif
On the other hand, learning to navigate Large Language Models is kind of fun.
Schpoonman
I was wrong about Star Wars movies. I once thought the Sequel Trilogy was going to turn out well.
Goddamn you, Jar Jar Abrams. And the other execs who okayed production without a remotely coherent plot, but mostly Jar Jar.
Schpoonman
BullSHIT we see Danny entirely too much.
Schpoonman
Also: Accept that if you were wrong before you will be wrong again. No one is perfect, we all make mistakes every day, and there is always something new to learn.
True Survivor
I agree, and find Jar Jar Abrahams a hilarious moniker (even if I largely like the character maybe mor than I should and enjoyed the director’s other works). I do fear that I am now just the adult hating the new Star Wars because it is not the Star Wars I grew up with – like how people hated the Prequels when I was a kid. However, given that I have largely liked the rest of Disney Star Wars, and the plots just seem so widely erratic and meandering, I maintain hope that the writing in the sequels is just objectively bad and I won’t look like a fool in 15 years with kids growing and pointing out how awesome they really were (as to be honest, I never saw the last one – I heard it was bad and the plot was nonsense, looked it up the summary, agreed with that assessment, and could not bear to make myself watch them just butcher their finally).
Also, what is this about Danny?
Schpoonman
The Last Jedi has maybe the single greatest theme ever put to art, “It doesn’t matter what your origins are, only that you get up and try,” and Rise said “Ha ha, jklol, only the chosen few matter. Some people are just more important. Deal with it, peasants.” I have not watched a single iota of Star Wars since the end of 2019, but I understand I’m just not a fan anymore. There’s a lot of excellent art being made in that sphere, I just am completely disinterested.
I do wonder what ranks as the worst movie, though: Attack or Rise.
Bittersweet
Omg someone with praise for TLJ, thank you. That’s my favorite movie of the sequels and I always feel anxiety when I see someone mention it because I get tired of defending it and Rian Johnson from whatever random pettiness people throw at it because… idfk. It wasn’t a perfect movie by any means, but having just watched a genuinely bad movie it sometimes feels like people just hate anything which isn’t perfect.
Schpoonman
Adults who never matured who wanted something that never existed in the first place are responsible for 98% of TLJ criticisms. The remaining 2% wish Rose had a better conclusion after the single-best character introduction in the Sequel Trilogy: Tazing Finn.
Mano308gts
The Last Jedi had the single worst plot, worst abandonment of prior established plot & lore, and was a pointless exercise in futility from beginning to end. It is an irredeemable movie, and solely the cause of Rise of Skywalker’s failure, considering that it tore down literally everything that existed before, but failed to provide anything new to build off of.
With that being said, this topic is very far from both the spirit and topic of the comic, so while we can make spurious connections to Jennifer’s love of Kitt Fisto, it is still not a reasonable association to make the claim that we are on topic. I suggest we keep the debate of ‘which movie ruined the sequels’ for other spheres.
Schpoonman
Okay boomer.
Woop de doop
OK ZOOMER
clif
I would suggest Mano308gts read the alt text.
The Rise of Skywalker wasn’t the best movie ever, but it could easily have gone wrong in so many bad ways that it threatened and then didn’t, and remains a powerful statement of the importance of choice and the rejection of genetics as destiny.
Schpoonman
I had to come back to this, actually, because 1) Your little “I’m going to get the last word by shutting down any further discussion on the matter after I’ve said my piece” bit was tired yet done better by my little sister 15 years ago, and 2) The above comic is two characters asking themselves “What choice do I make now?” The dichotomy of TLJ saying “Your destiny is what you make it,” and Rise saying “Hope you mattered before you were born,” is a wonderful example to explore.
Before Joyce’s character growth, she would lean heavily toward Rise. After all, God already made the choice for her. She had a “choice” in whether or not to believe, but as someone who grew up effectively forced to be a Christian until I was out enough from under my parents’ thumbs to freely be an apostate, no she didn’t. Conversely, Rise tried to portray Rey as constantly feeling the pull of the Dark Side to reinforce its theme that there are the elites and there are the rest of us, but nowhere in the film is that backed up. Yes, she gets angry, because she’s fighting for her life against someone who understands her intimately yet deeply betrayed her in the prior film.
On a related note, the reprisal of “I know what I must do but I don’t know if I have the strength to do it,” was one of the most beautiful moments I have ever seen in a film (beauty is in the eye of the beholder, don’t judge me) which makes it all the more criminal and the movie as a whole that much worse that it was completely unearned. It doesn’t clash as badly while watching the movie itself (or maybe how fantastic the moment is blinded me to its fatal problem) because Kylo gets emotionally reset roughly to where he is at the end of TFA at the start of Rise, but 30 seconds after it happened I went “Wait, and just like that he’s a good guy? No other questions? Are you serious?”
Meanwhile, in TLJ Kylo’s choice to betray both Snoke and Rey are all his. After realizing that Luke was fallible, Rey made the choice to both keep some of the Sacred Texts but leave to confront Kylo anyway. Also her Grey Jedi outfit (and hair <3) are fucking incredible so Jar Jar Abrams apparently hates good fashion as well as coherent plots. Rose sees Finn prepping an escape pod and chooses to stop him, that it doesn't matter if he's one of the heroes of the Resistance, (she thinks) he's doing the wrong thing right now and he needs to be stopped.
The movie absolutely has its problems. I've dabbled in my feelings about Luke further down the page, the Poe subplot was a writing travesty on all sides from front to back*, we needed a movie where all three leads can actually play off each other for any length of time, and the casino planet needed to be reworked into a much smaller segment that better emphasized the war profiteering and didn't waste Gwendolin Christie. Sure, she's the Boba Fett faceless elite mook who doesn't actually do anything, but Rian, you're not supposed to copy the mistakes the OT made! For all Jar Jar's flaws, TFA is a wonderful remake of ANH that fixes the big flaw of Mark Hamill not being the best in live action. All of Daisy Ridley, John Boyega, and Oscar Isaac were oozing charisma out their every pore.
*: All I will say about it is that they don’t get away in the first place if that Destroyer isn’t bombed, so a reprimand for losing an entire fighter wing? Okay. But it started with him getting slapped and demoted, and he refused to let that chip off his shoulder for the rest of the movie and it was a cluster until the objectively stunning light speed crash, which is another matter I will also not pursue right now.
Taffy
It’s almost cute that you think a Star War conversation can be stopped by saying “But we’re getting off-topic”.
zee
My hot take is that the sequals lore wise were a dumb idea to begin with bc effectively the og squad toppled an evil empire and another took it’s place in like 5 minutes. It’s hilarious. Any sequels should have taken place much farther in the future. At best the sequels could have only been a rehash of old material for that sweet sweet nerd nostalgia money. Therefore any serious indepth critique of any of the sequel movies like this take down of the last Jedi, is pee pee poo poo and a waste of time. I rest my case ur honor, loveubye
Schpoonman
The Sal magnet was unlocked on KS, there’s a mock-up under the comic with the reference.
John Campbell
They were objectively bad. Episode 7 was just the AbramsTrek remake of Episode 4. You could almost chop Episode 8 out of the series entirely without affecting anything of note. Rey was the only one of the protagonists who did anything that wasn’t somewhere between “pointless” and “actively counterproductive”, and even she didn’t do very damn much. And then Episode 9 retconned, rendered irrelevant, or just straight-out ignored everything that did happen. It was nice seeing all the old hardware flying again in 9, though. Not just for nostalgia, but because, seriously, these guys are the
RebellionResistance against the evilEmpireFirst Order, they absolutely should be flying leftover rustbuckets from the ’70s, not brand new sleeker-and-cooler X-Wing models.The prequels were objectively bad, too. For Star Wars Day a couple years ago, I binge-watched the entire series, and holy shit. When I first watched them — I hadn’t seen Episode 1 since the first week it was in theaters — I was too distracted by all the other shit that was wrong with it to notice the acting, but I seriously cannot think of another movie where I’ve seen talented actors give such stilted and wooden performances. I mean, I know Natalie Portman can act. I’ve seen her do it. She sure as hell wasn’t in those movies, though. I have to assume that George’s direction was along the lines of, “Okay, try again, but slower and with less emotion this time. Try not to make it sound like something a human being might ever say.”
I’m increasingly convinced that the only reason the original trilogy was as good as it was (and take that as you will) is because Harrison Ford is a far better ad-libber than George Lucas is a dialogue writer, and George wasn’t yet so big that no one could tell him to fuck off.
Adam Black
There more ( why original series was good )
Lucas was only Director on new hope. His wife was editor of Godfather.
Empire strikes back was based on a script from one of the best ( female) writers in science fiction. He assembled top talent and let them make decisions.
I think the sequel could have been excellent if Lucas was involved as producer, script editor, contuity guy, mise en scene. Just banned from Dialogue rewrites, dialogue coaching and final editing . Or cringe stereotype characters.
Schpoonman
“It’s like poetry, it rhymes.”
RassilonTDavros