Two Pioneer probes and the New Horizons Pluto probe are all past Neptune, but only the Voyagers and New Horizons are still “talking”.
Rycan
Then again, we’ve had transistor radio receivers for over half a century, so one could argue that “transradio” is incredibly widespread. Especially when you consider the spectacular failure that is cismission radio – it’s really good at producing a feedback loop, and not much else.
A5PECT
Am I really the only one here that picked up on this incredibly nerdy joke?
Why, because they’re black? Because racism only stands out to racial minorities? I’m uncomfortable with this.
lordofkonrad
I think racism stands out more to racial minorities than to white europeans/north americans. Not that white people wouldn’t react. It’s easy for some to ignore or simply miss out on social injustices or things like racist undertones if they don’t affect you directly.
ajm5007
>>Why, because they’re black?<> Because racism only stands out to racial minorities?<> I’m uncomfortable with this.<<
Good. Facts about racism should make everyone uncomfortable.
ajm5007
Ugh! I have to learn not to use angle brackets as quotation marks in HTML forums:
“Why, because they’re black?”
Yes.
“Because racism only stands out to racial minorities?”
Not only, but it does tend to stand out to us more since we’re generally the ones who are terribly harmed by it on a regular basis.
“I’m uncomfortable with this.”
Good. Facts about racism should make everyone uncomfortable.
Rycan
Probably because they encounter racism more often. It’s a lot harder to ignore racism when you’re a favorite target.
The song lyrics seem to be using “colored” as a synonym for “sinners.” They’re saying that everyone (regardless of skin color) is a “colored person,” because all people are sinners. That’s my interpretation.
Skorpeyon
Personally, I don’t think that’s the intention at all. It’s literally talking about skin color, but essentially saying that it doesn’t matter. The one portion that I think is confusing (Ignorance has wronged some races / And vengeance is the Lord’s / If we aspire to share this space / Repentance is the cure) is actually being heavily critical of racism. It’s saying the people were looked down upon for their skin color, and that’s wrong.
I’m not saying the song is good, and it certainly has some horrible lyrics that can easily be taken the wrong way, but I don’t think it was meant as anything more than what it literally is. It’s saying people, as a whole, should be colorblind and ignore skin color. The irony is that when people hear “colored people” they assume it’s derogatory and in the context of the song it’s intended to include every race regardless of skin color.
Basically, it was a really stupid way to say something that’s not really a bad message.
QD
I mean, instead of “thank God racism is over!” it says “wow you guys you REALLY need to acknowledge this huge sin committed by an entire civilization before any progress here can be made”
which obvs does not excuse the awful language used to make that point
Z2
I could swear that song was trying to deconstruct the term ‘Colored People’ with both the fact that ‘White’ is also a color and the statement that what really ‘colors’ us is our actions…
Like:
Band: “Guys, this is kind of a stupid concept as it stands.”
EVERYBODY: “HAW HAW/Yikes, they’re singing about a stupid concept!”
Geo
Yeah the whole point of the song is turning a term that has bad history into a point about said bad history.
Also its hardly the most offensive term ever. I mean one of the largest civil rights group in America is called the “National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.”
Dan
Thank you. I’m glad some people get what the song is about. lol. The terminology is weird, but it’s supposed to be because they are using it to make a point.
They were actually a really good group. They do have a few songs here and there that are kind of cringe-inducing now (which even they have acknowledged), but they also have a number of really good ones.
Oh hell they even used red and yellow, how antiquated is that? Pretty sure my skin is a medium copper, not red like the bloody Cleveland Indian.
Chris Phoenix
“Jesus loves the little children, all the children of the world. Red and yellow, black and white, we are precious in His sight. Jesus loves the little children of the world.”
I grew up singing this. I’m sure the usage here is a tribute to that song.
Rycan
*groan* Next you’re going to tell me you sang songs about Negros in Sunday School (Spanish Sunday School doesn’t count).
Dallium
One of their songs on “Free at last” consists solely of the three of them singing “We’re just two honks and a negro serving the lord.” Things were just different twenty years ago
Beachfox
I was a functioning near-adult twenty years ago. Things weren’t -that- different. Not when it comes to -this-.
Dan
I don’t really see the problem with that line, honestly. It’s obviously a general catigorization, the same kind that almost literally EVERYONE uses. Sure, there are different shades of skin, but most people refer to categories like Black people (who are never actually black) or White people (who are never actually white). Do you really want them to list the entire color spectrum? The song would last for 20 mintues. At least.
As a black man…I’m not sure how to feel about this song. Having just finished reading the lyrics, it’s…awkward. Really, REALLY awkward. At first, it seems to imply that the colored races need to repent for THEIR sins, and that they only exist because of the Grace of God. But, it later mentions that some races have been wronged, and “white” is included in the colors listed later. So…OK?
I think the intended message is “We all are human, and should treat each other equally as such. Also since we are all human we all are sinful beings who have fallen short of the glory that is God.” I found the lyrics really cringeworthy though. Like I’m not sure if they understand the historical context of the phrase Colored people.
…Wow…that may be the worst typo I’ve ever typed. For this, I greatly apologize.
MeghanTheWorldEater
If it makes you feel any better it took me about an hour to figure out what your typo was.
Jason
Still trying…
No Name
Look at the apostrophes.
marianne
Since it made you sound like an old-timey grizzled gold prospector in my head, I’m gonna have to disagree and say that that’s surely the best typo you’ve ever typed!
Rycan
That’s it, five minutes in the penalty box for misuse of an apostrophe.
Yes, of course they know. They’re trying to reclaim the phrase as their own. (I’m not letting DC Talk off the hook for offending people; I’m just offering a songwriter’s perspective.)
Derek
“Like I’m not sure if they understand the historical context of the phrase Colored people.”
It’s pretty clear that they do. The chorus has “We’re colored people and they call us the human race”. They are subverting the normal meaning of the word (black people) and using it to refer to all people instead. Basically they’re way of saying “all people are equal”. This wouldn’t work with other ethnic or racial terms, and it wouldn’t work without understanding the associations that go along with “colored people”.
Lurlock
I think they’re trying to follow the “Hey, white’s a color too, right?” line of reasoning. So yeah, their intentions are good, I suppose; they just didn’t think it through thoroughly…
Eolirin
There’s a certain amount of erasure going on there, and there’s a lot of stuff that basically eliminates the need to actually address the systemic nature of white power, so I wouldn’t feel too good; it’s feels a bit like someone who has a sense that racism is real and a bad thing, but doesn’t actually know anyone affected by it or how it actually works in the real world.
Or, alternately, someone that recognizes that racism is real, bad, understands how it works, but knows it’s audience isn’t actually willing to hear it so they have to make it much more palatable to them by dissembling and drawing false equivalency.
And it’s ambiguous enough that if you’re a white supremacist, you can listen to the song and think it’s talking about how minority groups need to stop being uppity and repent instead of agitating for equality (“vengeance is the lord’s, not yours, so sit down and shut up”). Being able to both seem inoffensive, if not a bit misguided, when listened to by a not crazy person, and still being open to that interpretation is actually kind of impressive, in a rather depressing sort of way.
Yeah, I think the first explanation is the best bet. Either way, any song that warrants the statement “white supremacists can listen to it and agree with it” probably shouldn’t exist.
Eolirin
Yeahhh. It’s kind of awful, really, intentional or not.
Also, just a note, I was legitimately surprised that one of the band members is African-American. He’s actually one of the main singers of the song “Colored people.” Now I’m a different kind of confused.
Eolirin
It’s not terribly difficult to miss the implications of what you’re saying or doing, especially in a broader historical or cultural context. Not everyone’s life experiences are the same, and not everyone has the ability to step back far enough to look at things from multiple perspectives.
Just cause he’s black doesn’t mean he’s going to automatically get what’s wrong with it.
pumpkincat
Actually met the band back in my misspent youth. The way they explained the song was the notion that in God’s eyes, we are all different colors, and the different shades of skin are all part of the beauty of God’s plan, etc.
Or to put it another way, the outside isn’t what matters to God but rather following the plan, etc. The eighties and nineties were … different, and, uh, well. Religion.
Eolirin
Yeah, that sounds like an utter cluelessness about the broader cultural context they’re operating in. Jeeze.
Khrene
“Yeah, that sounds like an utter cluelessness about the broader cultural context they’re operating in. Jeeze.”
Even though this song may not deal with systematic oppression directly, it tries to break the stigma that many White people still had thanks to things like blockbusting and shitty portrayls of PoC’s in the media and news, which is important because people cannot stop systematic oppression if they have bias and prejudice against the oppressed ingraned into them.
383 thoughts on “Truce”
Jen Aside
off to a smashing start
Jen Aside
*Dorothy gets kicked out for bringing Sierra Mist*
Nono
Or just Sierra.
Jen Aside
*double entendre where “mist” is German for “manure”*
thebombzen
Mount Whitney mist. You know, Sierra Nevada Mist.
AustKyzor
Well, Sierra shouldn’t be poopin in people’s rooms
David Herbert
I think Sierra would be invited since they’re church buddies.
Wait, is Becky still going to go to church?
Smiling Cat
She’s specifically stated that her sexuality doesn’t impact her faith.
Leorale
I’m not sure she’s had a Sunday since the whole Anderson fiasco in which it could come up directly.
I don’t know how Becky felt about church before her life exploded, but if I was her, I’d be scared to go to church, in case of other ToeDads.
timemonkey
I believe tomorrow will be Sunday. I assume the issue will be raised then.
Rycan
Will Becky feel compelled to out herself there next? Stay tuned!
Rycan
Err, ‘there’ being ‘at that church with the music’.
lightsabermario
And by tomorrow, we mean three months from now.
LiaHansen
these references were not designed for the general public
sps48
Wouldn’t Sarah just say “regular radio”?
cisradio?
thebombzen
The only transradio is from the Voyager probes. Afaik they’re the only human-made transneptunian objects
CptNerd
Two Pioneer probes and the New Horizons Pluto probe are all past Neptune, but only the Voyagers and New Horizons are still “talking”.
Rycan
Then again, we’ve had transistor radio receivers for over half a century, so one could argue that “transradio” is incredibly widespread. Especially when you consider the spectacular failure that is cismission radio – it’s really good at producing a feedback loop, and not much else.
A5PECT
Am I really the only one here that picked up on this incredibly nerdy joke?
Rycan
Better that getting nothing but blank stares.
Kate
Honestly she’s probably quoting Joyce there.
Though she’s also enough of an intellectual that I wouldn’t be surprised if she said “secular radio” anyway when discussing Christian music.
leadsynth
As a lawyer (in training), Sarah’s allowed to overcomplicate things
Vree
An opportunity to learn, then! 🙂
AnvilPro
So far, Sarah’s the life of the party
Bagge
I like how she and Walky bonded as kinda sane people
timemonkey
Of course the racist undertones are going to stand out to them.
Cobragardens
Why, because they’re black? Because racism only stands out to racial minorities? I’m uncomfortable with this.
lordofkonrad
I think racism stands out more to racial minorities than to white europeans/north americans. Not that white people wouldn’t react. It’s easy for some to ignore or simply miss out on social injustices or things like racist undertones if they don’t affect you directly.
ajm5007
>>Why, because they’re black?<> Because racism only stands out to racial minorities?<> I’m uncomfortable with this.<<
Good. Facts about racism should make everyone uncomfortable.
ajm5007
Ugh! I have to learn not to use angle brackets as quotation marks in HTML forums:
“Why, because they’re black?”
Yes.
“Because racism only stands out to racial minorities?”
Not only, but it does tend to stand out to us more since we’re generally the ones who are terribly harmed by it on a regular basis.
“I’m uncomfortable with this.”
Good. Facts about racism should make everyone uncomfortable.
Rycan
Probably because they encounter racism more often. It’s a lot harder to ignore racism when you’re a favorite target.
otusasio451
“Colored people.”
…Yeah, that doesn’t surprise me as much as it should.
Plasma Mongoose
Is that song as bad as I think it could be?
Heatth
Surprisingly, no. It is really weird and kinda off putting, but the message is alright.
MeghanTheWorldEater
http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/dctalk/coloredpeople.html
It’s an unusually roundabout way of saying “Racism isn’t cool.”
otusasio451
Wait…that wasn’t a joke? IT’S REAL??? OH DEAR HELL, I DIDN’T THINK IT WAS REAL!
Regalli
When in doubt, assume Willis is pretty much never exaggerating. If only because there’s a Youtube link in the hover text.
*Looks the band up* Sweet merciful flamey-os, they formed in 1987, HOW DID THEY MISS WHAT THEY WERE WRITING?
leadsynth
The song lyrics seem to be using “colored” as a synonym for “sinners.” They’re saying that everyone (regardless of skin color) is a “colored person,” because all people are sinners. That’s my interpretation.
Skorpeyon
Personally, I don’t think that’s the intention at all. It’s literally talking about skin color, but essentially saying that it doesn’t matter. The one portion that I think is confusing (Ignorance has wronged some races / And vengeance is the Lord’s / If we aspire to share this space / Repentance is the cure) is actually being heavily critical of racism. It’s saying the people were looked down upon for their skin color, and that’s wrong.
I’m not saying the song is good, and it certainly has some horrible lyrics that can easily be taken the wrong way, but I don’t think it was meant as anything more than what it literally is. It’s saying people, as a whole, should be colorblind and ignore skin color. The irony is that when people hear “colored people” they assume it’s derogatory and in the context of the song it’s intended to include every race regardless of skin color.
Basically, it was a really stupid way to say something that’s not really a bad message.
QD
I mean, instead of “thank God racism is over!” it says “wow you guys you REALLY need to acknowledge this huge sin committed by an entire civilization before any progress here can be made”
which obvs does not excuse the awful language used to make that point
Z2
I could swear that song was trying to deconstruct the term ‘Colored People’ with both the fact that ‘White’ is also a color and the statement that what really ‘colors’ us is our actions…
Like:
Band: “Guys, this is kind of a stupid concept as it stands.”
EVERYBODY: “HAW HAW/Yikes, they’re singing about a stupid concept!”
Geo
Yeah the whole point of the song is turning a term that has bad history into a point about said bad history.
Also its hardly the most offensive term ever. I mean one of the largest civil rights group in America is called the “National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.”
Dan
Thank you. I’m glad some people get what the song is about. lol. The terminology is weird, but it’s supposed to be because they are using it to make a point.
They were actually a really good group. They do have a few songs here and there that are kind of cringe-inducing now (which even they have acknowledged), but they also have a number of really good ones.
thebombzen
Is that Hazel’s mom in your Gravatar?
MeghanTheWorldEater
Nope Nathan Mint.
http://portsidestories.tumblr.com/post/112504550864/bless-his-heart-hes-got-that-name-down-pat
Yu'Karaya
“Red and yellow, black and white”
Oh hell they even used red and yellow, how antiquated is that? Pretty sure my skin is a medium copper, not red like the bloody Cleveland Indian.
Chris Phoenix
“Jesus loves the little children, all the children of the world. Red and yellow, black and white, we are precious in His sight. Jesus loves the little children of the world.”
I grew up singing this. I’m sure the usage here is a tribute to that song.
Rycan
*groan* Next you’re going to tell me you sang songs about Negros in Sunday School (Spanish Sunday School doesn’t count).
Dallium
One of their songs on “Free at last” consists solely of the three of them singing “We’re just two honks and a negro serving the lord.” Things were just different twenty years ago
Beachfox
I was a functioning near-adult twenty years ago. Things weren’t -that- different. Not when it comes to -this-.
Dan
I don’t really see the problem with that line, honestly. It’s obviously a general catigorization, the same kind that almost literally EVERYONE uses. Sure, there are different shades of skin, but most people refer to categories like Black people (who are never actually black) or White people (who are never actually white). Do you really want them to list the entire color spectrum? The song would last for 20 mintues. At least.
otusasio451
As a black man…I’m not sure how to feel about this song. Having just finished reading the lyrics, it’s…awkward. Really, REALLY awkward. At first, it seems to imply that the colored races need to repent for THEIR sins, and that they only exist because of the Grace of God. But, it later mentions that some races have been wronged, and “white” is included in the colors listed later. So…OK?
Seriously, I do not know how to feel here.
Lord Stoneheart
I think the intended message is “We all are human, and should treat each other equally as such. Also since we are all human we all are sinful beings who have fallen short of the glory that is God.” I found the lyrics really cringeworthy though. Like I’m not sure if they understand the historical context of the phrase Colored people.
otusasio451
They…they HAVE to know, right? They’re’s no way they couldn’t know, right?
otusasio451
…Wow…that may be the worst typo I’ve ever typed. For this, I greatly apologize.
MeghanTheWorldEater
If it makes you feel any better it took me about an hour to figure out what your typo was.
Jason
Still trying…
No Name
Look at the apostrophes.
marianne
Since it made you sound like an old-timey grizzled gold prospector in my head, I’m gonna have to disagree and say that that’s surely the best typo you’ve ever typed!
Rycan
That’s it, five minutes in the penalty box for misuse of an apostrophe.
Tbone Jenkins
I basically assumed that you were so horrified by the lyrics that it temporarily discombobulated the grammar portion of your brain…
Kate
Given that one of the members of DC Talk was a black man, I sure hope so.
Rebecca
Just about to say this. Yeah, there’s no way at least one of them DIDN’T know the historical context of “colored people.”
Regalli
And it formed in 1987 in Lynchburg, Virginia. If they missed that, I have no idea how.
JohnnyO
“There’s no way they didn’t know”
I think you’re overestimating homeschool and private religious education.
leadsynth
Yes, of course they know. They’re trying to reclaim the phrase as their own. (I’m not letting DC Talk off the hook for offending people; I’m just offering a songwriter’s perspective.)
Derek
“Like I’m not sure if they understand the historical context of the phrase Colored people.”
It’s pretty clear that they do. The chorus has “We’re colored people and they call us the human race”. They are subverting the normal meaning of the word (black people) and using it to refer to all people instead. Basically they’re way of saying “all people are equal”. This wouldn’t work with other ethnic or racial terms, and it wouldn’t work without understanding the associations that go along with “colored people”.
Lurlock
I think they’re trying to follow the “Hey, white’s a color too, right?” line of reasoning. So yeah, their intentions are good, I suppose; they just didn’t think it through thoroughly…
Eolirin
There’s a certain amount of erasure going on there, and there’s a lot of stuff that basically eliminates the need to actually address the systemic nature of white power, so I wouldn’t feel too good; it’s feels a bit like someone who has a sense that racism is real and a bad thing, but doesn’t actually know anyone affected by it or how it actually works in the real world.
Or, alternately, someone that recognizes that racism is real, bad, understands how it works, but knows it’s audience isn’t actually willing to hear it so they have to make it much more palatable to them by dissembling and drawing false equivalency.
And it’s ambiguous enough that if you’re a white supremacist, you can listen to the song and think it’s talking about how minority groups need to stop being uppity and repent instead of agitating for equality (“vengeance is the lord’s, not yours, so sit down and shut up”). Being able to both seem inoffensive, if not a bit misguided, when listened to by a not crazy person, and still being open to that interpretation is actually kind of impressive, in a rather depressing sort of way.
otusasio451
Yeah, I think the first explanation is the best bet. Either way, any song that warrants the statement “white supremacists can listen to it and agree with it” probably shouldn’t exist.
Eolirin
Yeahhh. It’s kind of awful, really, intentional or not.
otusasio451
Also, just a note, I was legitimately surprised that one of the band members is African-American. He’s actually one of the main singers of the song “Colored people.” Now I’m a different kind of confused.
Eolirin
It’s not terribly difficult to miss the implications of what you’re saying or doing, especially in a broader historical or cultural context. Not everyone’s life experiences are the same, and not everyone has the ability to step back far enough to look at things from multiple perspectives.
Just cause he’s black doesn’t mean he’s going to automatically get what’s wrong with it.
pumpkincat
Actually met the band back in my misspent youth. The way they explained the song was the notion that in God’s eyes, we are all different colors, and the different shades of skin are all part of the beauty of God’s plan, etc.
Or to put it another way, the outside isn’t what matters to God but rather following the plan, etc. The eighties and nineties were … different, and, uh, well. Religion.
Eolirin
Yeah, that sounds like an utter cluelessness about the broader cultural context they’re operating in. Jeeze.
Khrene
“Yeah, that sounds like an utter cluelessness about the broader cultural context they’re operating in. Jeeze.”
I gotta contest with you man, the 70’s and 80’s still had a lot of overt racism due to Black and colored neighborhoods being disproportionately effected by drugs and poverty due to systematic failures* and active systematic disenfranchisement that directly target people of color directly. or active systematic disenfrachisement targeted poor people, but had greater impacts to people of color , needless to saw law enforcement did their best to alleviate the problem
Even though this song may not deal with systematic oppression directly, it tries to break the stigma that many White people still had thanks to things like blockbusting and shitty portrayls of PoC’s in the media and news, which is important because people cannot stop systematic oppression if they have bias and prejudice against the oppressed ingraned into them.