I don’t want to be one of those people who falls into evil from carelessness or convenience. I want to be the one chooses evil, who embraces it with my whole blackened heart.
You missed a part. But those lemons in a bag, in slices, along with some broken glass, thumb tacks, or razor blades. You really want your enemies to FEEL it when you bludgeon them with them. Thumb tacks are best, if you can get them, because they don’t destroy the bag as fast.
P.S. Sorry for flagging you. I missed with the mouse.
spriteless aunty
Look the point of hitting someone with a bag of lemons is to cause a lot of pain without visible and lawsuitable bruises.
SeanR
This only causes shallow scratches. Very shallow. Very painful scratches, but still very shallow.
I feel like those last three options (narcissism, stubbornness, evil) are very different from each other and it says a lot about Dorothy that she’s put them all in a row like that.
makes me wonder if there are ‘good’ narcissists. maybe ‘parasocial influencers’ that don’t cause scandals/ones that do makeup/makeover and modelling, tho considering there’s a whole subreddit, ideal that parents woujldnt’ be one
AKP
I mean in terms of the mental health thing, yes. If you set up a narcissist so that the best way to get praise and attention is to engage in constructive pro-social behavior, you get good narcissists. Not necessarily ones you want to be friends with, but good for the world.
Pilgrim
The theme of the 13th Federalist Paper can be summed up as “pit ambition against ambition for the general good” so the theory of beneficial narcissism is literally baked into U.S. governance from the beginning. Hamilton, Madison and Jay recognized the danger of politicians acting from pure self interest but theorized enough of them would come to some sort of equilibrium.
Schpoonman
…God that’s cute in its naivete.
thejeff
Given they were basically (re)inventing democracy, I think they can be cut some slack. It’s also not like anyone’s really come up with a better solution since them.
Some tweaks on different ways to balance, but that’s about it.
S.R.
True narcissism is a mental illness, so, yes, there are in fact narcissists who try not to hurt people. No mental illness in the world makes everyone who has it into a monster.
That’s ableist to say. Plenty of evil people weren’t narcissistic. Frankly, a lot of people who are labeled that way don’t fall under clinical criteria, whereas there’s good people out there who do.
I think the Narc label is simply what abusive parents are often labeled with. I prefer the term “abusive.”
zee
I mean, not every use of the word “narcissistic” is referring to the personality disorder. Its still a personality trait based on the story of the guy who turned into a weird flower cuz he liked his face so much. Also a pattern of abuse, I’m not sure if narcissistic abusers always have NPD but it’s still a recognizable pattern.
You could say that in itself is ableist and the word should be used exclusively in a clinical context, i personally think it’s a useful word for the public vocabulary so I’d disagree. Just like how i think “psychopathic” is a useful word even though it’s not literally diagnosing someone with aspd
not someone else
Powersliding between definitions- which people do regularly and then pretend they didn’t- is ableist as hell. The idea of “narcissistic abuse” is also very much based on demonizing NPD and broadening it into a pop armchair diagnosis and is not cool.
Narcissism the regular word is fine but it needs to be clarified more often what someone means due to bad actors, sort of like how you can totally be depressed without actually having Major Depressive Disorder but if you start talking to the public about how you dealt with and treated your depression you should probably specify whether you’re actually talking about the clinical, usually-chronic thing or “yo this celebrity I never met died and I was super bummed for a week until I did yoga about it”.
To me, narcissism is just a facet of Pride, which is one of the Sins. I don’t know how stubbornness got in there.
HueSatLight
Sin is when you do something or are something that some dude claims has somehow injured an omnipotent being, but really it’s about that dude’s ability to control others.
Yup. She didn’t know as much as she does now, hence the point of going to college, a transformative experience. She must acknowledge that she only ever held unto her original goal under false pretenses, and learn not to frame her more fundamental goal too tightly. Instead of trying to solve “how to I become President”, instead she should solve “how do I help as many people as I can?”
Hey if Ruth is sufficiently conservative or left-wing she just runs for the other party and bam! that’s a win in an election where the base cares more about hurting the other side than bettering the country on common ground. Plus the “no value voters” – she has those on lock:
Was gonna say that she would sadly be ineligible because of that pesky natural-born-citizen clause, but then I remembered her Gramps was American, so she might have had dual citizenship from birth.
According to Google, Ruth MIGHT be a US Citizen if her grandfather maintains a residence in the US. If not, then she’s not, even if he is.
I learned something today about the weird rules concerning citizenship.
Fay
Her grandfather definitely lives in the US- that’s why Ruth is there now, after all. She lived in Canada until her parents died, after which she went to live with her grandpa that lives in the US.
Needfuldoer
If either of her parents was American, Ruth could have birthright citizenship.
Well, if Clint is an American citizen, that would make Ruth’s mother an American citizen, which would make Ruth an American citizen as well, wouldn’t it?
Needfuldoer
That’s what I was trying to get at, yeah.
Sometimes people forget the US immigration and naturalization system was designed to build a nation of immigrants.
Yeah, unless there’s something we don’t know, by far the most likely case is that she’s a dual citizen.
Clint could have moved from Canada to the US, rather than Ruth’s mom moving to Canada, but there’s no hint of that. Ruth’s mom could have renounced her US citizenship before Ruth was born, but there’s no reason to think that.
Otherwise, she’s the daughter of an American citizen born abroad who’s lived in the US since she was 16. She’s a citizen.
SillyGoose
I love the amount of work you all put into determining whether a fictional character who doesn’t want to be President would be allowed to.
Jamie
You know, when I made the joke, I thought about this for five seconds and decided Ruth was probably ineligible and to ignore it for the joke’s sake.
I appreciate that people worked it out better than I could have.
Canada is in America by any sensible definition of the word
UrsulaDavina
Don’t call Candians Americans they don’t like that.
Dragonfire
Those’re fighting words.
Dana
I’d say “Under the jurisdiction of the United States of America” is a sensible definition by which it is not.
june gloom
I hate this semantic game so much.
Taffy
It’s a stupid game. There are two entire continents with “America” in the name, and I don’t think my guildmates from Brazil would take kindly to being called Americans. Because connotations exist.
(There’s no SA data center for FF14, so they usually play on NA servers. I see as much Portuguese as I do English, at some RP venues.)
Yumi
I’ve known some people from various countries who are annoyed at the idea that “American” should/does refer to people from the US precisely because there are two entire continents with “America” in the name. (Also, the Americas aren’t always separate in some continental division.)
Mark
I’ve been a US citizen since birth, and I’m annoyed by it. This confusion makes it hard to talk about two entire continents.
Taffy
It’s silly that they’re literally named North and South, but people wanna remove those helpful qualifiers. If you wanna refer to every single person from both by the same name, be ready to clarify a lot.
I do wish the USA had a snappier title for its citizens than “Americans” that a layperson is gonna know about, though. I think it’s more practical for these stupid ambiguities to be removed, but “United States Ian” doesn’t really roll off the tongue.
Taffy
Thank you, phone, for putting that extra space there an attosecond before my finger hit the Post button, despite me checking twice to make sure you hadn’t.
Also no american has ever been named Ian. Ian, like Gemma and Liam, is a British word used by writers as shorthand for “this is happening in UK”
zee
My country is in north America and i *despise* that “oh you’re technically American too!” Game. It’s a semantic argument that exists wholely and entirely to be annoying because it has 0 practical use.
Taffy
What, you don’t think it’s practical to have to specify “No, I’m not from that shithole just because I happen to live on the same continent”?
maybe the rules will change by then, given how many immigrants are in the US, and maybe ppl going outside of the country to give birth/get healthcare/etc, i wouldn’t be surprised if there was a decade where not many candidates would be born within the us , like even going to like the ‘best’ hospital in the world for birth care or even growing a baby in some kinda lab
211 thoughts on “Persevere”
Ana Chronistic
Choose Evil
the opposite of Live
…wait no?? 😮
Dana
So Lone Star, Now you see that Evil will always triumph, because Good is dumb.
JA
The evil ones always seem to live practically forever, so choose evil.
Except Jimmy Carter. He’s one of the good ones who lived practically forever.
Or…oh. Oh no…
Wizard
Why settle for the lesser of two evils? Vote the Elder Party! Cthulu in ’24!
milu
Oh that is a wicked slogan
Tan
I don’t want to be one of those people who falls into evil from carelessness or convenience. I want to be the one chooses evil, who embraces it with my whole blackened heart.
porthos9438
Dear Lord, lead us not into temptation. We can find the way on our own.
newlland(Henryvolt)
Congratulations, you have grasped the concept of true pure irredeemable evil. Not may can do that.
shadowcell
Dumbing of Age Book 13: I Can Choose Evil
Sombrero
DoA Book 13: Maybe This Has Been a Sunk Cost Fallacy for Too Long.
SillyGoose
DoA Book 13: Evil I’d really like.
Ana Chronistic
DoAB13: Is My Brain Lying Again?
Schpoonman
Yeah, Ruth, I love lemons, too.
UrsulaDavina
Ruth’s motto when life gives you lemons put them in a bag and bludgeon your enemies with them.
The Wellerman
“Make life rue the day it thought it could give Dorothy Keener lemons!!!” XD
UrsulaDavina
SHE IS THE WOMAN WHO IS GOING TO BURN YOUR HOUSE DOWN, WITH THE LEMONS!
Bryy
She is the one who knocks.
SeanR
You missed a part. But those lemons in a bag, in slices, along with some broken glass, thumb tacks, or razor blades. You really want your enemies to FEEL it when you bludgeon them with them. Thumb tacks are best, if you can get them, because they don’t destroy the bag as fast.
P.S. Sorry for flagging you. I missed with the mouse.
spriteless aunty
Look the point of hitting someone with a bag of lemons is to cause a lot of pain without visible and lawsuitable bruises.
SeanR
This only causes shallow scratches. Very shallow. Very painful scratches, but still very shallow.
not someone else
I feel like those last three options (narcissism, stubbornness, evil) are very different from each other and it says a lot about Dorothy that she’s put them all in a row like that.
Ryan
Narcissism and evil are not synonymous but are closely related and frequently intertwined.
anon
makes me wonder if there are ‘good’ narcissists. maybe ‘parasocial influencers’ that don’t cause scandals/ones that do makeup/makeover and modelling, tho considering there’s a whole subreddit, ideal that parents woujldnt’ be one
AKP
I mean in terms of the mental health thing, yes. If you set up a narcissist so that the best way to get praise and attention is to engage in constructive pro-social behavior, you get good narcissists. Not necessarily ones you want to be friends with, but good for the world.
Pilgrim
The theme of the 13th Federalist Paper can be summed up as “pit ambition against ambition for the general good” so the theory of beneficial narcissism is literally baked into U.S. governance from the beginning. Hamilton, Madison and Jay recognized the danger of politicians acting from pure self interest but theorized enough of them would come to some sort of equilibrium.
Schpoonman
…God that’s cute in its naivete.
thejeff
Given they were basically (re)inventing democracy, I think they can be cut some slack. It’s also not like anyone’s really come up with a better solution since them.
Some tweaks on different ways to balance, but that’s about it.
S.R.
True narcissism is a mental illness, so, yes, there are in fact narcissists who try not to hurt people. No mental illness in the world makes everyone who has it into a monster.
not someone else
Thank you jfc
Joy
That’s ableist to say. Plenty of evil people weren’t narcissistic. Frankly, a lot of people who are labeled that way don’t fall under clinical criteria, whereas there’s good people out there who do.
I think the Narc label is simply what abusive parents are often labeled with. I prefer the term “abusive.”
zee
I mean, not every use of the word “narcissistic” is referring to the personality disorder. Its still a personality trait based on the story of the guy who turned into a weird flower cuz he liked his face so much. Also a pattern of abuse, I’m not sure if narcissistic abusers always have NPD but it’s still a recognizable pattern.
You could say that in itself is ableist and the word should be used exclusively in a clinical context, i personally think it’s a useful word for the public vocabulary so I’d disagree. Just like how i think “psychopathic” is a useful word even though it’s not literally diagnosing someone with aspd
not someone else
Powersliding between definitions- which people do regularly and then pretend they didn’t- is ableist as hell. The idea of “narcissistic abuse” is also very much based on demonizing NPD and broadening it into a pop armchair diagnosis and is not cool.
Narcissism the regular word is fine but it needs to be clarified more often what someone means due to bad actors, sort of like how you can totally be depressed without actually having Major Depressive Disorder but if you start talking to the public about how you dealt with and treated your depression you should probably specify whether you’re actually talking about the clinical, usually-chronic thing or “yo this celebrity I never met died and I was super bummed for a week until I did yoga about it”.
SeanR
To me, narcissism is just a facet of Pride, which is one of the Sins. I don’t know how stubbornness got in there.
HueSatLight
Sin is when you do something or are something that some dude claims has somehow injured an omnipotent being, but really it’s about that dude’s ability to control others.
Nicoleandmaggie
I assume she’s more often accused of being narcissistic or stubborn than evil— the evil thing is new to her.
Joy
Those things are often compared to each other in the environments she’s spent her life in.
Bryy
Oh, Dorothy. We’ve all been there.
Trying to reconcile our new feelings through the lens of our old feelings.
The Wellerman
Yup. She didn’t know as much as she does now, hence the point of going to college, a transformative experience. She must acknowledge that she only ever held unto her original goal under false pretenses, and learn not to frame her more fundamental goal too tightly. Instead of trying to solve “how to I become President”, instead she should solve “how do I help as many people as I can?”
Jamie
Ruth for President. Clearly.
True Survivor
Hey if Ruth is sufficiently conservative or left-wing she just runs for the other party and bam! that’s a win in an election where the base cares more about hurting the other side than bettering the country on common ground. Plus the “no value voters” – she has those on lock:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QWdN4hA-rB0
RassilonTDavros
Was gonna say that she would sadly be ineligible because of that pesky natural-born-citizen clause, but then I remembered her Gramps was American, so she might have had dual citizenship from birth.
UrsulaDavina
Probably not her Parents were probably Canadian
Rose by Any Other Name
According to Google, Ruth MIGHT be a US Citizen if her grandfather maintains a residence in the US. If not, then she’s not, even if he is.
I learned something today about the weird rules concerning citizenship.
Fay
Her grandfather definitely lives in the US- that’s why Ruth is there now, after all. She lived in Canada until her parents died, after which she went to live with her grandpa that lives in the US.
Needfuldoer
If either of her parents was American, Ruth could have birthright citizenship.
https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/legal/travel-legal-considerations/us-citizenship/Acquisition-US-Citizenship-Child-Born-Abroad.html
JBento
Well, if Clint is an American citizen, that would make Ruth’s mother an American citizen, which would make Ruth an American citizen as well, wouldn’t it?
Needfuldoer
That’s what I was trying to get at, yeah.
Sometimes people forget the US immigration and naturalization system was designed to build a nation of immigrants.
JBento
*And then the Racist Nation attacked…*
thejeff
Yeah, unless there’s something we don’t know, by far the most likely case is that she’s a dual citizen.
Clint could have moved from Canada to the US, rather than Ruth’s mom moving to Canada, but there’s no hint of that. Ruth’s mom could have renounced her US citizenship before Ruth was born, but there’s no reason to think that.
Otherwise, she’s the daughter of an American citizen born abroad who’s lived in the US since she was 16. She’s a citizen.
SillyGoose
I love the amount of work you all put into determining whether a fictional character who doesn’t want to be President would be allowed to.
Jamie
You know, when I made the joke, I thought about this for five seconds and decided Ruth was probably ineligible and to ignore it for the joke’s sake.
I appreciate that people worked it out better than I could have.
thejeff
It’s come up before in other contexts
UrsulaDavina
Ruth is Canadian and can’t run for president but Dotty can in theory be Prime Minister of Canada
BarerMender
Forget it. Doesn’t qualify. Not born American.
jflb96
Canada is in America by any sensible definition of the word
UrsulaDavina
Don’t call Candians Americans they don’t like that.
Dragonfire
Those’re fighting words.
Dana
I’d say “Under the jurisdiction of the United States of America” is a sensible definition by which it is not.
june gloom
I hate this semantic game so much.
Taffy
It’s a stupid game. There are two entire continents with “America” in the name, and I don’t think my guildmates from Brazil would take kindly to being called Americans. Because connotations exist.
(There’s no SA data center for FF14, so they usually play on NA servers. I see as much Portuguese as I do English, at some RP venues.)
Yumi
I’ve known some people from various countries who are annoyed at the idea that “American” should/does refer to people from the US precisely because there are two entire continents with “America” in the name. (Also, the Americas aren’t always separate in some continental division.)
Mark
I’ve been a US citizen since birth, and I’m annoyed by it. This confusion makes it hard to talk about two entire continents.
Taffy
It’s silly that they’re literally named North and South, but people wanna remove those helpful qualifiers. If you wanna refer to every single person from both by the same name, be ready to clarify a lot.
I do wish the USA had a snappier title for its citizens than “Americans” that a layperson is gonna know about, though. I think it’s more practical for these stupid ambiguities to be removed, but “United States Ian” doesn’t really roll off the tongue.
Taffy
Thank you, phone, for putting that extra space there an attosecond before my finger hit the Post button, despite me checking twice to make sure you hadn’t.
United States Ian, I ask you.
milu
Its true, that is truly bizarre way to specify the nationality of Ian
milu
Also no american has ever been named Ian. Ian, like Gemma and Liam, is a British word used by writers as shorthand for “this is happening in UK”
zee
My country is in north America and i *despise* that “oh you’re technically American too!” Game. It’s a semantic argument that exists wholely and entirely to be annoying because it has 0 practical use.
Taffy
What, you don’t think it’s practical to have to specify “No, I’m not from that shithole just because I happen to live on the same continent”?
milu
or off the same continent, as the case may be
Taffy
No. It’s in North America. The continent. Just saying “American” is shorthand for “from the United States of America”. The country. You know that.
anon
maybe the rules will change by then, given how many immigrants are in the US, and maybe ppl going outside of the country to give birth/get healthcare/etc, i wouldn’t be surprised if there was a decade where not many candidates would be born within the us , like even going to like the ‘best’ hospital in the world for birth care or even growing a baby in some kinda lab
Thag Simmons
Pretty sure Ruth would be ineligible, I don’t think she’s a natural-born citizen
Dana