At least for now. I kind of doubt this is the final development in either Sarah’s character or her relationship with Jacob.
Needfuldoer
I think he’s running out of patience with her, though.
Li
I don’t agree. I think a lot of us have run out of patience for her, and understandably want the catharsis of seeing Jacob tell her to go screw herself and leave him alone, but I think Jacob, in-universe, would agree with the people who say it was really hard for Sarah to ask and that these strips have represented progress. Look at his face in Panel 2, then her face in Panel 3, then his face in Panel 5.
He would be well within his rights to decide this isn’t worth the effort, but do you really think he even looks frustrated with her in the last panel? Especially after how hopeful he was in Panel 4 and how close he got to a more honest response from her?
I don’t know that I see dating in their future, but at least for now I do see Jacob continuing to try to be an actual friend to her — the kind of person with whom she can let her walls down.
Again: not saying Jacob has any obligation to do that, not saying Sarah necessarily deserves it. Just saying I don’t think he’s giving up, or even discouraged.
Li
*how hopeful he was in Panel 2, ugh
Devin
I couldn’t agree with you more. I know that I personally am getting frustrated with Sarah, but I really don’t see that reflected in Jacob. I think he wants a connection of some sort with her and isn’t done trying to find ways to make that happen.
I feel like in that last panel he looks almost impressed with how ornery she is. But yeah, not frustrated. I like your analysis .
Li
Thanks 🙂
Felian
yeah, for some reason he does not give up yet. he does not seem too frustrated. Is he interested in dating her (or a version of her that can open up, at least) or just motivated to help her character development? i’m not even sure which of these i’d prefer.
Li
I think he’s at least interested in being friends with her. More than that, I couldn’t say. I mean, I’m still surprised he wasn’t done with her after he last walked away in frustration — but apparently I’m forgetting a lot of interactions.
Like here, which admittedly had her fantasizing about him more privately in the strip before it; or this, a little bit more recently, where he was clearly charmed by her tsun(dere). Most relevantly, this and this and this and this.
I was distracted by the vaudevillian hijinx of Sarah going door to door in her humorously futile quest to find someone to break up Joyce and Joe, but everything from that short conversation in September is highly relevant to this conversation.
1. Jacob tells Sarah that Joyce told him she likes him. Sarah denies this, extremely unconvincingly.
2. Jacob prods Sarah about liking him a tiny bit, teasingly, and Sarah insists she not only doesn’t like him, she actually hates humanity in general! But then admits to caring a lot about Joyce, something she was previously unwilling to cop to.
3. Jacob tells Sarah he wants to be treated like a person, not a prop, and asks for honesty and openness from her. He also says that, if she can give him those things, he’d be happy to spend more time with her. (Sarah pouts and then hisses at the closed door.)
Like, all supremely relevant to this conversation. No wonder Jacob isn’t looking hugely discouraged; he already made progress with Sarah the last time they spoke (she admitted to caring about at least some people and was very transparently lying about not being into him), and this time he made even more progress.
Mark
Obligation is not the only reason for doing a thing.
Honestly, that’s pretty much par for the course for priest-types, in my experience.
(I have been exorcised often enough that I couldn’t tell you how many times I’ve been exorcised.)
Kimi
While I hope that you were being exercised for something fun, like the ability to climb walls, I have a feeling that it was probably more something due to their skewed “moral standards”. I’m sorry that it happened.
Nah, it was fun. When I was in high school, our Friday night entertainment was going downtown and hassling the street preachers who’d come in from the ungodless wastes surrounding our blue town in the Bible Belt to convert the heathens.
My favorite was, when they approach and start to put their hand out, you grab it in that two-handed clasp-shake and say, as sincerely as you can manage, “Hi, my name’s John. Have you been saved?” And then while they’re trying to recalibrate because you stole their opening line, you inform them that if they don’t accept Eris Discordia into their hearts, or possibly other parts of their anatomy, when they die they’ll go to Thud, which is just like Cary, except somehow even more boring.
(If your name is not John, you can substitute your own if you prefer. Or just use mine. It may be even more confusing for them, particularly if you’re a girl.)
So, yeah, this kind of thing got me exorcised a lot.
One time we exorcised them. We had a whole thing with candles and a big pentacle we drew on the sidewalk with a piece of bark from a planter and a chant that we just made up. They left, so I guess our gods were better than theirs.
I can’t find the film online any more, I’ve got a copy somewhere, maybe I’ll upload it someday if I can find it.
Mturtle7
@VicMortimer That was an AMAZING read, thank you. Just. Absolutely legendary. The characters! The background, and world-building! The drama! The plot twists and turns! I mean, I’m sure it was very serious business for some of the people involved, but holy crud reading this feels like it’s straight out of fiction.
eh, whatever
o hai!
*stealing “ungodless wastes”*
kthxbai
filler text to distract the spam filter; more filler text to distract the spam filter; yet more filler text to distract the spam filter
Full disclosure: I stole “ungodless” from King Luca in Nukees years ago.
McNitz
My exorcism drives all the priests off the streets
And they’re like, it’s better than ours
Damn right it’s better than yours
I can’t teach you, you’re a bunch of bores
thejeff
Kallisti!
Regret
What is it with Discordians that makes them the most fun people to be around while also leaving you less stable than you were before, without being able to pinpoint the exact reason? And yes, I know that’s all Nancy’s fault, but you won’t hear me admitting that, she gets miffed when she gets worshipped and that never ends well. Or worse, she takes an interest! And then you’re totall screwed.
Felian
that sounds amazing af. 😀 if you can’t convince them, at least CONFUSE THEM.
It doesn’t have to be childhood specific. We know Sarah’s history at IU. We’ve seen her being even slightly social backfire on her hard. Just knowing the Raidah situation I think this all tracks.
You know speaking of the Raidah situation I wonder if that specifically is impacting her interactions with Jacob. She knows he dated Raidah, so as far as she knows he knows Raidahs version of what happened so she’s not sure how to handle him not being hostile to her because in her experience everyone who hears Raidahs version is hostile towards her.
We also know from Liz that as far back junior high/early high school Sarah was cold and standoffish enough that her boyfriend went to Liz for advice on her.
okay, got reminded way further down that the first part is not in fact true. sorry! we do know there’s a separation or divorce involved & Liz is a half-sister?
–Dave, if I read ALL the comments before commenting I’d have too many stored up by the end and they’d come out even more tangled
eh, whatever
Or they’d not come out at all and wouldn’t duplicate things that’ve already been said.
And why do you sign your comments when your name’s already on them?
Li
This is a little rude?
Also obviously because Dave likes doing that. Why else?
some people just ARE. It’s fashionable NOW to compare your traumas for credit, but there was actually a time when we didn’t want to relive them for vicarious thrills or to ‘win’ a contest of ‘whose life was shittier’. I know, hard to believe, isn’t it? Sarah is the way Sarah is, much the way Benedict and Beatrice are in That one Play by that Shakesperare fellah. *(I think it’s “Much Ado about Nothing”). she’s seen other people ruin their lives and doesn’t want to be one of them. She doesn’t have to be flashing a trauma sign, she might just be observant-young romance has nasty side effects, after all.
Maybe she’s just shy, or maybe she’s got a voice in her head saying “no, you don’t want to end up like Desdemona in “Othello”!!”
Or it could be that like a lot of us from that older generation, she first learned to compartmentalize her feelings so they didn’t get in the way and wreck her future. There are actual benefits to Denial and Repression, like saving a shit ton of money and not getting your other plans derailed because you caught Moonbeams in your brain and let your gonads do your thinking.
Just sayin’. she looks comical now, but when she’s rocking the six figure income while the kids who listened to their FEELINGS are trying to pay off six figure student loans with degrees that, plus a coffee machine, let you be a part time barista?
Hey now, don’t conflate compartimentalisation with denial and repression. Those are very different concepts. You can compartimentalize while still being sane as long as your life has parts of it where you can let those feelings out, preferably people. (Humans tend to function better if they have honest and deep social connections.)
Denial is when you refuse to notice that you have an issue, and when combined with compartimentalisation that never ends well since you then never air out those compartments and they will ferment and eventually pop in one way or another. If you’re lucky they will pop once, get everything out at once, and then you’ll be fine after a lot of re-integrating with the parts of you that were closed off before.
Repression is just an external attempt to keep such a compartment closed, which can be a short term solution, but it isn’t going to last and it will make the fermentation inside the compartment speed up like a pressure cooker.
As someone who literally never opened up until my 30s, I get the compartmentalization, I get the benefits.
Not sure I’d send anyone down that road though.
Money is nice. I enjoy mine, but it seriously messes with your head in a lot of other ways.
I don’t think any of this has anything to do with “comparing your traumas for credits”, whatever that means.
This is fiction. Fiction often – though not always as in the example you gave, digs into character’s pasts to explain their present behaviors and to help them grow. This particular fiction often does that. It seems likely that Sarah will go down that path and we’ll see some of it. Our interest in that as readers has nothing to do with the characters themselves comparing traumas for credits.
Even if Sarah’s attitude isn’t explained by a traumatic backstory (beyond what we already know with Dana), it’s pretty obvious she’s not happy with where she is emotionally, however much she might deny it. That seems a place for a growth arc, not a “No, it’s good to not be able to approach people you’re attracted to because maybe somehow you’ll make more money later.”
Blah blah blah, all you’re saying is “Okay, but maybe she’ll be isolated and rich”, as if that matters.
Daniel M Ball
mmaybe it does? It’s a lot easier to survive opening up if you’re wealthy, than being open when you’re broke.
Li
Not actually true. It’s easier to survive everything if you’re financially comfortable, but wealthy people are demonstrably lonelier and more paranoid. You start seeing everyone around you as greedy takers, and you stop being able to trust that anyone actually likes you as a person.
I see it more like he’s giving her an extra chance to do better. Alternatively it’s going, “you want even power, here, take it”, like very politely calling her on her bullshit.
HueSatLight
His naivete is his overconfidence in his ability to do what you’re saying. He’s apparently missed that she asked him something in yesterday’s strip, and that she’s shown more than 0 percent vulnerability.
He is patient, and he is trying, but he’s just an ordinary guy, he’s not the feelings whisperer.
I think it makes him more interesting than super-hunky-guy-who-is-an-emotional-guru-perfect-in-every-way.
Bogeywoman
I’m honestly not getting “over confident” from him here. It’s totally subjective, of course, so your reading isn’t wrong, I just read it as him trying to de-escalate/figure out exactly what Sarah is trying to ask, because he doesn’t know. I think he is self-assured and has confidence in himself, but to a much healthier and realistic degree than Dorothy.
Aside from reading his tone differently, I totally agree that he is a normal (well adjusted, emotionally mature) guy doing his best. My favourite thing about DoA is that all the characters are so developmentally realistic.
HueSatLight
not arguing, just something I thought of and wanted to add.
I don’t think he understands being introverted. https://www.dumbingofage.com/barbell/ in this strip, she’s basically set up to fail. She’s not going to be able to come up with something to talk about, and she even says that. But her job as a spotter is to watch him, so she’s going to end up staring at him unable to think of anything to say.
He could have asked her what her least favorite song was. That’s a relatively safe question to answer, but it still gets her to talk about personal things.
Jacob’s an extrovert, it feels like he thinks “just jump in the deep end and start swimming laps” should work.
Lumino
Hard disagree.
Jacob is demanding that Sarah act like an adult, because if she can’t make herself vulnerable, then a relationship is doomed to failure. She HAS to be willing to take the chance.
He can hold open his arms to catch her, but if she’s not willing to take that step forward then it’s not going to be healthy.
Nah, he isn’t misunderstanding her here- he is standing his ground. He has made his terms clear and is willing to abide by them. That his terms are openness and honesty makes them no less his terms.
That’s why he is willing to repeatedly allow her the opportunity to meet his terms, but he really doesn’t seem especially put back that she isn’t able to meet them.
340 thoughts on “Permission”
Ana Chronistic
“Who asks that?”
“Uh, I do. I just did.”
“VULNERABILITY IS FOR THE WEAK”
M!a
I so friggin called it.
Straight back to the Sarah we all know and… well, roll our eyes at.
Li
At least for now. I kind of doubt this is the final development in either Sarah’s character or her relationship with Jacob.
Needfuldoer
I think he’s running out of patience with her, though.
Li
I don’t agree. I think a lot of us have run out of patience for her, and understandably want the catharsis of seeing Jacob tell her to go screw herself and leave him alone, but I think Jacob, in-universe, would agree with the people who say it was really hard for Sarah to ask and that these strips have represented progress. Look at his face in Panel 2, then her face in Panel 3, then his face in Panel 5.
He would be well within his rights to decide this isn’t worth the effort, but do you really think he even looks frustrated with her in the last panel? Especially after how hopeful he was in Panel 4 and how close he got to a more honest response from her?
I don’t know that I see dating in their future, but at least for now I do see Jacob continuing to try to be an actual friend to her — the kind of person with whom she can let her walls down.
Again: not saying Jacob has any obligation to do that, not saying Sarah necessarily deserves it. Just saying I don’t think he’s giving up, or even discouraged.
Li
*how hopeful he was in Panel 2, ugh
Devin
I couldn’t agree with you more. I know that I personally am getting frustrated with Sarah, but I really don’t see that reflected in Jacob. I think he wants a connection of some sort with her and isn’t done trying to find ways to make that happen.
Li
? Thank you.
Freezer
Looked to me like he called her bluff. And not only did she fold, she flipped the table on the way out.
Li
Okay? You’re certainly welcome to that interpretation.
Nathan
I feel like in that last panel he looks almost impressed with how ornery she is. But yeah, not frustrated. I like your analysis .
Li
Thanks 🙂
Felian
yeah, for some reason he does not give up yet. he does not seem too frustrated. Is he interested in dating her (or a version of her that can open up, at least) or just motivated to help her character development? i’m not even sure which of these i’d prefer.
Li
I think he’s at least interested in being friends with her. More than that, I couldn’t say. I mean, I’m still surprised he wasn’t done with her after he last walked away in frustration — but apparently I’m forgetting a lot of interactions.
Like here, which admittedly had her fantasizing about him more privately in the strip before it; or this, a little bit more recently, where he was clearly charmed by her tsun(dere). Most relevantly, this and this and this and this.
I was distracted by the vaudevillian hijinx of Sarah going door to door in her humorously futile quest to find someone to break up Joyce and Joe, but everything from that short conversation in September is highly relevant to this conversation.
1. Jacob tells Sarah that Joyce told him she likes him. Sarah denies this, extremely unconvincingly.
2. Jacob prods Sarah about liking him a tiny bit, teasingly, and Sarah insists she not only doesn’t like him, she actually hates humanity in general! But then admits to caring a lot about Joyce, something she was previously unwilling to cop to.
3. Jacob tells Sarah he wants to be treated like a person, not a prop, and asks for honesty and openness from her. He also says that, if she can give him those things, he’d be happy to spend more time with her. (Sarah pouts and then hisses at the closed door.)
Like, all supremely relevant to this conversation. No wonder Jacob isn’t looking hugely discouraged; he already made progress with Sarah the last time they spoke (she admitted to caring about at least some people and was very transparently lying about not being into him), and this time he made even more progress.
Mark
Obligation is not the only reason for doing a thing.
anon
it reminds me of that kelly monologue from the office “what kinda person doesn’t play any games?” (paraphrasing)
thejeff
I read “who asks that?” as about the question that she was thinking of asking.
Animedingo
8 steps back
Doctor_Who
I wouldn’t be surprised if she’s literally backing away. While hissing.
“SSSSSincerity! My one weaknessss!”
Wraithy2773
Onto a bus.
Headed to the airport.
So she can fly as far away from vulnerability as possible.
(no, *your* metaphor got a little out of hand!)
David DeLaney
a bird, flying out of your hand, is worth …
–Dave, … okay, this metaphor about hands and bushes isn’t going ANYWHERE safe for work
M!a
… isn’t worth the birdshit it left behind?
Steelbright
This comment made my night haha
anon
the only way it could’ve gone worse if if she slammed a door on him and almost breaking his nose
https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2563 tho, it seemed to have worked for them but they had a bit more romantic tension to begin with lol
M!a
Or headbutted him in the junk and then threw up all over it.
I’m far too lazy to look up the QC episode, though.
Needfuldoer
That’s the roommate initiation rite.
(I miss old QC.)
Nathan
“I’ll see you in Hell!” really works as a way to end pretty much every conversation, huh.
Doctor_Who
Not great for medical diagnoses, admittedly.
Proxiehunter
Not when it’s coming from a priest in a confessional either.
John Campbell
Honestly, that’s pretty much par for the course for priest-types, in my experience.
(I have been exorcised often enough that I couldn’t tell you how many times I’ve been exorcised.)
Kimi
While I hope that you were being exercised for something fun, like the ability to climb walls, I have a feeling that it was probably more something due to their skewed “moral standards”. I’m sorry that it happened.
John Campbell
Nah, it was fun. When I was in high school, our Friday night entertainment was going downtown and hassling the street preachers who’d come in from the ungodless wastes surrounding our blue town in the Bible Belt to convert the heathens.
My favorite was, when they approach and start to put their hand out, you grab it in that two-handed clasp-shake and say, as sincerely as you can manage, “Hi, my name’s John. Have you been saved?” And then while they’re trying to recalibrate because you stole their opening line, you inform them that if they don’t accept Eris Discordia into their hearts, or possibly other parts of their anatomy, when they die they’ll go to Thud, which is just like Cary, except somehow even more boring.
(If your name is not John, you can substitute your own if you prefer. Or just use mine. It may be even more confusing for them, particularly if you’re a girl.)
So, yeah, this kind of thing got me exorcised a lot.
One time we exorcised them. We had a whole thing with candles and a big pentacle we drew on the sidewalk with a piece of bark from a planter and a chant that we just made up. They left, so I guess our gods were better than theirs.
David DeLaney
this. whole. SUBTHREAD. has just made my night.
–Dave, thank y’all from the bottom of my alleged
VicMortimer
Here, this is what happened in my town a few decades ago: https://monkeyfire.com/mpol/dir_zine/dir_2000/1032/t_gamut.html
I can’t find the film online any more, I’ve got a copy somewhere, maybe I’ll upload it someday if I can find it.
Mturtle7
@VicMortimer That was an AMAZING read, thank you. Just. Absolutely legendary. The characters! The background, and world-building! The drama! The plot twists and turns! I mean, I’m sure it was very serious business for some of the people involved, but holy crud reading this feels like it’s straight out of fiction.
eh, whatever
o hai!
*stealing “ungodless wastes”*
kthxbai
filler text to distract the spam filter; more filler text to distract the spam filter; yet more filler text to distract the spam filter
John Campbell
Full disclosure: I stole “ungodless” from King Luca in Nukees years ago.
McNitz
My exorcism drives all the priests off the streets
And they’re like, it’s better than ours
Damn right it’s better than yours
I can’t teach you, you’re a bunch of bores
thejeff
Kallisti!
Regret
What is it with Discordians that makes them the most fun people to be around while also leaving you less stable than you were before, without being able to pinpoint the exact reason? And yes, I know that’s all Nancy’s fault, but you won’t hear me admitting that, she gets miffed when she gets worshipped and that never ends well. Or worse, she takes an interest! And then you’re totall screwed.
Felian
that sounds amazing af. 😀 if you can’t convince them, at least CONFUSE THEM.
Amós Batista
If you’re a pirate.
Mark
Now throw a toy at him, Sarah!
Mr. Random
I’m genuinely starting to wonder what Sarah’s childhood was like to makeher THIS level of closed off.
Laura
Sad.
Sirksome
It doesn’t have to be childhood specific. We know Sarah’s history at IU. We’ve seen her being even slightly social backfire on her hard. Just knowing the Raidah situation I think this all tracks.
HueSatLight
Dana described her as lonely and withdrawn, before the Raidah stuff. I expect Raidah et al turning on her wasn’t a new experience.
Alongcameaspider
You know speaking of the Raidah situation I wonder if that specifically is impacting her interactions with Jacob. She knows he dated Raidah, so as far as she knows he knows Raidahs version of what happened so she’s not sure how to handle him not being hostile to her because in her experience everyone who hears Raidahs version is hostile towards her.
Li
Good point.
thejeff
We also know from Liz that as far back junior high/early high school Sarah was cold and standoffish enough that her boyfriend went to Liz for advice on her.
David DeLaney
we haven’t yet met HER parents…
–Dave, because she’s a sophomore so that Parents’ Day wasn’t for her?
David DeLaney
okay, got reminded way further down that the first part is not in fact true. sorry! we do know there’s a separation or divorce involved & Liz is a half-sister?
–Dave, if I read ALL the comments before commenting I’d have too many stored up by the end and they’d come out even more tangled
eh, whatever
Or they’d not come out at all and wouldn’t duplicate things that’ve already been said.
And why do you sign your comments when your name’s already on them?
Li
This is a little rude?
Also obviously because Dave likes doing that. Why else?
Daniel M Ball
some people just ARE. It’s fashionable NOW to compare your traumas for credit, but there was actually a time when we didn’t want to relive them for vicarious thrills or to ‘win’ a contest of ‘whose life was shittier’. I know, hard to believe, isn’t it? Sarah is the way Sarah is, much the way Benedict and Beatrice are in That one Play by that Shakesperare fellah. *(I think it’s “Much Ado about Nothing”). she’s seen other people ruin their lives and doesn’t want to be one of them. She doesn’t have to be flashing a trauma sign, she might just be observant-young romance has nasty side effects, after all.
Maybe she’s just shy, or maybe she’s got a voice in her head saying “no, you don’t want to end up like Desdemona in “Othello”!!”
Or it could be that like a lot of us from that older generation, she first learned to compartmentalize her feelings so they didn’t get in the way and wreck her future. There are actual benefits to Denial and Repression, like saving a shit ton of money and not getting your other plans derailed because you caught Moonbeams in your brain and let your gonads do your thinking.
Just sayin’. she looks comical now, but when she’s rocking the six figure income while the kids who listened to their FEELINGS are trying to pay off six figure student loans with degrees that, plus a coffee machine, let you be a part time barista?
She might be the only one doing the smart thing.
Li
These are such interesting thoughts.
Like. Not fair or good or correct, but interesting!
Regret
Hey now, don’t conflate compartimentalisation with denial and repression. Those are very different concepts. You can compartimentalize while still being sane as long as your life has parts of it where you can let those feelings out, preferably people. (Humans tend to function better if they have honest and deep social connections.)
Denial is when you refuse to notice that you have an issue, and when combined with compartimentalisation that never ends well since you then never air out those compartments and they will ferment and eventually pop in one way or another. If you’re lucky they will pop once, get everything out at once, and then you’ll be fine after a lot of re-integrating with the parts of you that were closed off before.
Repression is just an external attempt to keep such a compartment closed, which can be a short term solution, but it isn’t going to last and it will make the fermentation inside the compartment speed up like a pressure cooker.
Mr. Random
As someone who literally never opened up until my 30s, I get the compartmentalization, I get the benefits.
Not sure I’d send anyone down that road though.
Money is nice. I enjoy mine, but it seriously messes with your head in a lot of other ways.
thejeff
I don’t think any of this has anything to do with “comparing your traumas for credits”, whatever that means.
This is fiction. Fiction often – though not always as in the example you gave, digs into character’s pasts to explain their present behaviors and to help them grow. This particular fiction often does that. It seems likely that Sarah will go down that path and we’ll see some of it. Our interest in that as readers has nothing to do with the characters themselves comparing traumas for credits.
Even if Sarah’s attitude isn’t explained by a traumatic backstory (beyond what we already know with Dana), it’s pretty obvious she’s not happy with where she is emotionally, however much she might deny it. That seems a place for a growth arc, not a “No, it’s good to not be able to approach people you’re attracted to because maybe somehow you’ll make more money later.”
Taffy
Blah blah blah, all you’re saying is “Okay, but maybe she’ll be isolated and rich”, as if that matters.
Daniel M Ball
mmaybe it does? It’s a lot easier to survive opening up if you’re wealthy, than being open when you’re broke.
Li
Not actually true. It’s easier to survive everything if you’re financially comfortable, but wealthy people are demonstrably lonelier and more paranoid. You start seeing everyone around you as greedy takers, and you stop being able to trust that anyone actually likes you as a person.
Sirksome
I feel like Jacob should know Sarah’s deal by now. He might be expecting too much.
HueSatLight
He means well, but he kind of has a naivete that reminds me of Dorothy’s.
Bogeywoman
I see it more like he’s giving her an extra chance to do better. Alternatively it’s going, “you want even power, here, take it”, like very politely calling her on her bullshit.
HueSatLight
His naivete is his overconfidence in his ability to do what you’re saying. He’s apparently missed that she asked him something in yesterday’s strip, and that she’s shown more than 0 percent vulnerability.
He is patient, and he is trying, but he’s just an ordinary guy, he’s not the feelings whisperer.
I think it makes him more interesting than super-hunky-guy-who-is-an-emotional-guru-perfect-in-every-way.
Bogeywoman
I’m honestly not getting “over confident” from him here. It’s totally subjective, of course, so your reading isn’t wrong, I just read it as him trying to de-escalate/figure out exactly what Sarah is trying to ask, because he doesn’t know. I think he is self-assured and has confidence in himself, but to a much healthier and realistic degree than Dorothy.
Aside from reading his tone differently, I totally agree that he is a normal (well adjusted, emotionally mature) guy doing his best. My favourite thing about DoA is that all the characters are so developmentally realistic.
HueSatLight
not arguing, just something I thought of and wanted to add.
I don’t think he understands being introverted. https://www.dumbingofage.com/barbell/ in this strip, she’s basically set up to fail. She’s not going to be able to come up with something to talk about, and she even says that. But her job as a spotter is to watch him, so she’s going to end up staring at him unable to think of anything to say.
He could have asked her what her least favorite song was. That’s a relatively safe question to answer, but it still gets her to talk about personal things.
Jacob’s an extrovert, it feels like he thinks “just jump in the deep end and start swimming laps” should work.
Lumino
Hard disagree.
Jacob is demanding that Sarah act like an adult, because if she can’t make herself vulnerable, then a relationship is doomed to failure. She HAS to be willing to take the chance.
He can hold open his arms to catch her, but if she’s not willing to take that step forward then it’s not going to be healthy.
Mano308gts
Nah, he isn’t misunderstanding her here- he is standing his ground. He has made his terms clear and is willing to abide by them. That his terms are openness and honesty makes them no less his terms.
That’s why he is willing to repeatedly allow her the opportunity to meet his terms, but he really doesn’t seem especially put back that she isn’t able to meet them.
Bogeywoman
This ^
Yes. A+ wording. You get a trophy for saying what my brain couldn’t ?
Li
+1 here too.
I have spent more time kinda defending Sarah today, but I don’t understand people trying to say JACOB is being “the real jerk” either.
thejeff
Because in any conflict between characters, some have to choose one to be the villain and one the victim. No nuance is allowed.