Part of me wants to be defensive of Joe here, but she knew him for years in a very… proto- state. It’s going to take time for her to get to see his growth.
I think she sees his growth somewhat, but it’s also gonna take time for her to trust it, not to mention unlearn associating him with the kinds of ick that he used to give her. Which like. Valid.
I do think that, yeah, she has noticed changes, but yeah, it’s going to take time and consistency for her to become a believer. She also has just not seen as much as some of the others have with him, like Dina and Becky, Joyce obviously, Danny, and to an extent Sal and probably Amber.
Charles Phipps
Dorothy also may know Joe has grown but still hate him because she doesn’t like him.
It’s not a crime after all.
Needfuldoer
True, but Jocelyn doesn’t know Dorothy’s a biased source.
thejeff
I wouldn’t even say she’s biased. She has good reason to distrust Joe.
GreyICE
“He used to be very vocal about objectifying women. But I think he got better.”
“When did he get better?”
“After he got caught…”
DailyBrad
It’s not, but Dorothy is very low on the list of the cast who would want to have a grudge over incomplete or flawed information. That’s anathema to Dorothy.
She also just independently has a prickly relationship with Joe. If this was about his relationship to someone other than Joyce she’d probably be more aggressive about his worse qualities, not less.
I vaguely recall Sarah warned Joyce that Dorothy would lose faith in her if she learned she tried to “fix” him while they dated. Is this shoe about to drop?
There’s a non-zero chance Ethan and Jocelyn talk still, though I dunno if Ethan just keeps abreast of her writing. At the very least, yeah, they are acquainted and in a way that’d likely stick with both of them, not the least of which reason being they had what seemed to be mutual attraction.
The Do List was outed in early October (specifically Book 7 Chapter 4, aptly titled “The Do List”). It is currently the end of January, so roughly 4 months
That’s not a retcon, a retcon would be pretending he was always the way he is now. Which isn’t happening here just because Dotty is choosing her words diplomatically. It’s painfully obvious she’s trying her best to not spill the truth without outright lying.
Nah, he was pretty bad (and Dorothy knew him during that time) and now he’s trying to be good (and mostly succeeding), and that’s almost entirely due to Joyce.
Retconning is not when a character does not mention the prior shitty behavior of somebody who is trying to better himself for somebody else as not to discredit him in front of said person’s sibling. That’s called being tactful, nothing has changed about the way Joe was prior, it was just not mentioned.
147 thoughts on “Read on”
Sirksome
Joyce also brings out the gay in everyone.
NGPZ
is her superpower ^^
Stephen Nedland
In everyone, but herself. Step out of that closet, young lady, everything is going to be just fine.
DailyBrad
Part of me wants to be defensive of Joe here, but she knew him for years in a very… proto- state. It’s going to take time for her to get to see his growth.
AK
I think she sees his growth somewhat, but it’s also gonna take time for her to trust it, not to mention unlearn associating him with the kinds of ick that he used to give her. Which like. Valid.
DailyBrad
I do think that, yeah, she has noticed changes, but yeah, it’s going to take time and consistency for her to become a believer. She also has just not seen as much as some of the others have with him, like Dina and Becky, Joyce obviously, Danny, and to an extent Sal and probably Amber.
Charles Phipps
Dorothy also may know Joe has grown but still hate him because she doesn’t like him.
It’s not a crime after all.
Needfuldoer
True, but Jocelyn doesn’t know Dorothy’s a biased source.
thejeff
I wouldn’t even say she’s biased. She has good reason to distrust Joe.
GreyICE
“He used to be very vocal about objectifying women. But I think he got better.”
“When did he get better?”
“After he got caught…”
DailyBrad
It’s not, but Dorothy is very low on the list of the cast who would want to have a grudge over incomplete or flawed information. That’s anathema to Dorothy.
Decidedly Orthogonal
Dorothy seeing Joe’s “growth” may or may not lead to interesting feelings from Joyce, and a hell of a NSFW comic.
Michael Steamweed
There’s an AO3 on that. 🙂
Miri
Rule 34 means “of course there is” ?
Michael Steamweed
Really should be “Law 34”.
Freezer
No Joe/Dorothy that I could find (yet). Plenty of Joe/Joyce and Dorothy/Joyce, though.
thejeff
Someone here wrote a very cute Joe/Joyce/Dorothy story a little while back.
Mark
That’s certainly fair. Joe himself is surprised to find that there’s more to him than his past behavior, and unable to fully believe it.
Michael Steamweed
Plus Dorothy is slightly competitive about having Joyce. Yeah, Dotty is a bit biased.
darkoneko
For now.
Dara
Yeah I was gonna say. “For now.“
Icalasari
Ooo I hope this doesn’t lead to bad things
Nono
Look let my dreams of Bi Joe stay alive okay
Freemage
I choose to read this in your avatar’s voice.
Da Boy
Asher wants to monopolize all the tall bad boys
Andy
They can still be, just interpret Dorothy’s Joyce brings out the best in them as bi-Joe.
Disastroid
B I Joe, A Real American Hero
Thag Simmons
This is very diplomatic of Dorothy.
HueSatLight
Dorothy’s going to try to kiss Jocelyne before the weekend’s over.
Sirksome
It’s what she deserves.
ktbear
Who is “she” in this sentence?
Thag Simmons
Dealer’s choice
Taffy
Why make a distinction at all?
NGPZ
Right? both of them have had it rough and could use some sugar T_T <3
Decidedly Orthogonal
Because of the Ambiguous reference. But indeed it does not really matter.
JA
Yes.
Cattleprod
Ha, I totally forgot that could be her biggest concern about Joe.
BBCC
Men are our of his purview so FAR!
jeffepp
Dottie’s totally not jelling. or anything.
Thag Simmons
She also just independently has a prickly relationship with Joe. If this was about his relationship to someone other than Joyce she’d probably be more aggressive about his worse qualities, not less.
thejeff
Well, she’s more protective of Joyce than of most others, so maybe not.
Random832
oops accidentally reported
it’d be really nice if there was, like, a confirmation popup or something
Thag Simmons
It requires multiple flags to actually trip, so an accidental report isn’t really an issue
JessWitt
Ah, so Jocelyne remembers Ethan.
I vaguely recall Sarah warned Joyce that Dorothy would lose faith in her if she learned she tried to “fix” him while they dated. Is this shoe about to drop?
Thag Simmons
That shoe dropped a while ago, but it somewhat predictably wasn’t nearly as bad as Sarah projected it to be.
thejeff
At least partly because it dropped after they broke up
Thag Simmons
To be pedantic it dropped while they were in the process of breaking up
DailyBrad
There’s a non-zero chance Ethan and Jocelyn talk still, though I dunno if Ethan just keeps abreast of her writing. At the very least, yeah, they are acquainted and in a way that’d likely stick with both of them, not the least of which reason being they had what seemed to be mutual attraction.
Charles Phipps
Ethan has forgotten Joyce ever existed.
“We dated?”
“Huh? I’m sorry, I don’t remember that.”
“You can remember what Soundwave’s cassettes are named but not me.”
“Okay, that’s just common knowledge.”
Thag Simmons
My assumption would be that they were mutuals on social media but Ethan hadn’t really engaged with her after Mike died
IntangibleMatter
How many months in-universe has it been since his ratings list got leaked? I feel like it hasn’t actually been that long
Clif
It was so last semester.
Leorale
Plus Dorothy knew him through highschool, as he was Danny’s bestie. Dorothy is being super cool, given how many years she had to tolerate proto-Joe.
Leorale
— that wasn’t really what you asked, I got a bit distracted
Decidedly Orthogonal
September¹ 2010, to January² 2024. So ¿fiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiìiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiive? months?
[1] coincidentally
[2] also coincidentally
Tan
The Do List was outed in early October (specifically Book 7 Chapter 4, aptly titled “The Do List”). It is currently the end of January, so roughly 4 months
HueSatLight
Oct 9th and Jan 27th, “un”-officially. https://walkypedia.fandom.com/wiki/Dumbing_of_Age_Timeline
Charles Phipps
Dorothy: I hate Joe with the fiber of my being and am being supportive. None of this is influenced by jealousy toward Joyce.
Jocelyn: Uh huh.
Taffy
This is reconning Joe’s original sleazy behavior and I’m going to tell everyone. ?
Taffy
Retconning*. Retroactive continuity. Joe used to be sleaze, now he’s certified Good Boys™
Ike
What? This is very clearly Dorothy trying not to say bad things about Joe even though she really wants to.
Taffy
Nope. Telling everyone.
Shade
That’s not a retcon, a retcon would be pretending he was always the way he is now. Which isn’t happening here just because Dotty is choosing her words diplomatically. It’s painfully obvious she’s trying her best to not spill the truth without outright lying.
Taffy
It’s fine, actually.
Da Boy
Are you familiar with the term Character Development?
Taffy
Are you familiar with oxygen?
StClair
Nah, he was pretty bad (and Dorothy knew him during that time) and now he’s trying to be good (and mostly succeeding), and that’s almost entirely due to Joyce.
Scruffy looking nerfherder
Retconning is not when a character does not mention the prior shitty behavior of somebody who is trying to better himself for somebody else as not to discredit him in front of said person’s sibling. That’s called being tactful, nothing has changed about the way Joe was prior, it was just not mentioned.
Taffy
No.
Icalasari
Just because you say no doesn’t mean you’re right. His behaviour isn’t being retconned
Taffy
We will disagree, whether you agree to or not. You don’t have a choice.