7. taking the opportunity to publicly humiliate him for cheating on Alice or something (terrible idea and timing but that’s who she is)
Rose by Any other Name
Given his hand position in panel 6, your option number 6 might be spot on.
Axel
idk if it fits the previous panel where she balls her fist, but on the other hand, if we combine 6 and 7, she could have known it was coming and been waiting for him to try something
Axel
(and that’s a real ‘idk’, I can’t tell from their position/the angle)
Rose by Any other Name
Right now, given only this, I feel like your ass grab theory is the best one based on the evidence.
MINE was based on her expression, and my mind went some much darker places. So I’m kinda hoping it’s only a sleezy assgrab and not something way more fucky.
Axel
yeah I had similar thoughts (as did my partner), but Alice’s attitude threw me off. my brain got stuck on the Heathers quote; “Football season is over, Veronica. Kurt and Ram had nothing left to offer the school except date rapes and AIDS jokes.”
Axel
more charitable to Billie than “he was stealing her attention” or “felt like punching” I mean
HueSatLight
8. There’s a scorpion on his abdomen, she’s saving him.
BarerMender
The position of his hand is suggestive, but Billie is looking the wrong way. It isn’t him she’s mad at.
JBento
It’s not an assgrab, or at least, not here. He has the hand on her side raised in panel 2, and in panel 4 he’s substantially AHEAD of her.
Arianod
Panel 2, his right arm is raised. Panel 4 shows he’s one or two steps ahead of Billie, an ass grab would be incredibly awkward and impossible to hide from everyone. I think we can rule it out.
Well it looks from flashbacks like Billie and Alice had a past sexual relationship that ended with Billie’s car crash at prom. So straight-up jealousy, could be.
Billie also previously mentioned that the head cheerleader’s job was to help take teammates for secret abortions when necessary. So maybe Alice was quicker to forgive Chester than Billie was.
oh god I forgot that, Jennifer literally said she “sneaked friends into abortion clinics” ?
Bryy
WELP.
Adept
That fits. I think she loathes him for a reason.
thejeff
But this is a weird time and place to act on something like that, since she would have known it all along.
Unless it was the ass grab suggested above, the only possibly new piece of info would be Alice calling him her boyfriend.
Yumi
I don’t think it has to be “new” information– it could be that information combined with anger at seeing him be celebrated like this. That could go for if he had done something bad before or she was jealous of his official status with Alice. Emotions are heightened overall, she hates the guy under normal circumstances, now here he is getting his name cheered along with hers? Yeah, I can see Billie snapping a bit.
Michael Steamweed
Plus she’s been drinking.
thejeff
I mean, this is Billie, so it’s likely, but Billie’s also good at handling her booze. There are no real signs she’s drunk now. We know she will be later for the DUI, but it’s early yet. That could even follow an after-prom party.
Even more telling is IMO the scene when Alice first showed up, Billie was quite focused on re-establishing contact to her, and Alice rebuked her. In particular, the wording Alice used here https://www.dumbingofage.com/2014/comic/book-4/04-the-whiteboard-dong-bandit/dramahurricane/ – “For the longest time, I thought I loved you”. It could be platonic, sure, but in retrospect, I suspect it was indeed romantic.
thejeff
And in that same strip Walky says being a drama hurricane can be sexually transmitted, making it pretty clear they had a sexual relationship.
My long term theory was that Jennifer didn’t acknowledge a romantic relationship with Alice in her “straight but has sex with girls sometimes like everyone does” stage. They basically had one, especially on Alice’s part, but not officially, and both dated boys (or just had drunken sex at parties) because that fit the popular cheerleader image.
well i didn’t expect that, but yeah unless she was secretly/unconsciously crushing on alice (in the strip with her saying ‘i loved you but you’re a danger to yourself/others’ or so), i would’ve also expected him to either secretly be a scumbag or alice shit talking him the same way you would with when you’er annoyed with a partner but maybe exaggerated some things?
He sexually assaulted someone is my guess. We never really have seen why Billy said in the beginning of the comic a million years ago that she went after bad men and protected other girls. I think we are about to humanize Billy.
Jealousy, maybe. Or that’s really an eldritch creature that has temporarily taken on the appearance of Chester Phillips, and Jennifer clocked it instantly.
I’m not completely discounting your theory, but for now I’m assuming she had sex with him in recent days and just now found out he was cheating on Alice with her.
She thought he was infected with one of those parasites from the movie Alien, and wanted to punch it before it burst out of his stomach and started attacking people.
She very consciously developed a thing for Chester and made a play for him, but he refused her (perhaps rather cruelly). Maybe she thinks Alice knows about this and is feeling publically humiliated.
Can’t swear to it as I can’t see the future, but that right there? That’s the punch of a girl who knows something about a guy and can’t hold it in any longer.
So my call is the idea of her leaving him unused is a joke that ties into rumours about her, which themselves were spread by him and his team because she turned him down when he came to her behind his girlfriend’s back.
She’s sober, and that’s good, but she’s also so emotionally constipated in a way that’s rapidly breaking down, she’s passive aggressive as fuck, and she’s keeping really toxic company. Yes, more toxic than Billie/Jennifer on her worst days.
Charles Phipps
Raidah is an ass but I think people overstate things. After all, she didn’t send someone to break up her relationship like Sarah did. Sadly, she needed to get away from her past to recover as she whatever Walky’s personal merits, he brought about the worst in her.
Decidedly Orthogonal
Yeah naw bruh. Unless we get a more directly linking explantion, then laying her behaviour at Walky’s feet is a WWII scale bridge too far.
Charles Phipps
I’m not saying it’s Walky’s fault. I’m saying that Billy’s issues get triggered by them and whatever behavior she’s trying to get past. We don’t know why in-universe. He is seemingly blameless of anything in their relationship.
Sirksome
I understand what you meant. For whatever reason when it comes to Jennifer people choose to see her in the worst light. You’re not saying Walky is at fault just that interacting with him upsets Jen and she needed space from that. I was saying the same when they had that group date. For whatever reason people don’t like hearing that because Walky cares about Jennifer. But he annoys her, sometimes even on purpose. It’s not on Jen to just tolerate that. But everyone interprets her needing space from him as her shunning him and by extension the rest of her friends even though she still spends time with everyone pretty regularly.
Jeremiah
I think the issue might be that you stubbornly refuses to see all the ways on which Jennifer has demonstrably gotten worse. Also making some kind of distinction between “Billie” and “Jennifer” doesn’t really work because again, they are not different people, they are the same trying pretend otherwise.
Sirksome
@Jeremiah. I’m not trying to argue. You don’t like Jennifer, a lot of readers don’t. That’s fine. I don’t want to change anyone’s mind or ruin their interpretation of the comic. I just like to converse about it and offer my own perspective and interpretation.
I also don’t designate between “Jennifer” and “Billie” I just choose to respect the name the admittedly fictional character chooses to be called.
Like I would never intentionally dead name Jocelyne or call Booster by the pronouns they don’t like. It doesn’t really mean anything because they’re not real. I just find it good practice.
Jeremiah
And I don’t dislike Jennifer, she is actually one of my favorites characters specifically because of all the things about her I mentioned, because it make her interesting, which is why it annoys me when those things get dismissed. And also when I redder to the name thing I don’t mean the act of calling her what she wants to be called, I mean acting like the two names actually represent a change in personality and she should “ho back” to being Billie, when she is already that. Also, also I think considering how we been told and seen how she treats Walky I think she can actually take being annoyed by him occasionally.
Jennifer isn’t engaged in domestic violence, not part of a suicide pact, not drinking alcohol (I may be biased here because I’ve had close relatives die of alcoholism related incidents), and was seemingly happy until she tried to create some fun drama that destroyed her relationship with Asher.
Thag Simmons
That she self-destructed her relationship with Asher for petty reasons is maybe a sign that she wasn’t actually doing better
Charles Phipps
I mean, compared to the nonstop violence and insults of her previous relationships?
Thag Simmons
Considering that the relationship disintegrated in part because Jennifer missed the violence and insults, yeah, I don’t think it’s a sign that she had actually fixed the underlying problems
Jeremiah
They actually didn’t engaged in much violence after they started their relationship? Like at all. They did insult each other but like, not with any actual bite or malice.
thejeff
They did fight. At first to keep up the pretense for the rest of the floor, but also because it turned them on.
jmsr7
I’m not sure she actually knows her relationship with Asher is over.
Charles Phipps
I mean she didn’t want to break up with him. She was trying to drive him to do something romantic.
Sadly, negging only works if you’re a scummy pick up artist or Bugs Bunny.
Bryy
I’m pretty sure she thinks it is over in the context that it’s “over”.
258 thoughts on “Chester”
NGPZ
aaaaaaah here it goooooooes :0
*plays “Hydrogen” by M.O.O.N. on dance floor speakers*
Animedingo
Ok but why tho
Alongcameaspider
A few options I can think of
1: he was stealing attention she felt was hers
2: she subconsciously had a crush on Alice and was acting on jealousy
3: she just felt like punching someone
4: all of the above
Doctor_Who
5) This is just how she dances.
No wonder she and Ruth got along.
Proxiehunter
6: She’s aware of him doing something that he deserves it for.
Thag Simmons
That’d make sense
Blackdrazon
This one’s my bet.
Adept
I assume he’s an abusive arsehole, possibly a rapist.
Banana Slamma
Wow, that’s a hell of an assumption based on literally nothing. Kind of sad when you think about it.
Liliet
It’s not based on litearlly nothing, it’s based on Billie’s reaction. We know she used to protect her cheerleaders from stuff like that.
Chrissy
This comment really rubs me the wrong way.
“Kind of sad when you think about it.” What?
Are you trying to “not all men” this? Did it hurt your feelings that someone was able to use context clues?
Roe
it’s based on this being Dumbing of Age and the last 12 years of storylines
ElderlyMarxist
honestly my assumption was that he’d done something shitty to her that pre-empted her issues w/ substances & ‘downfall’
captainrex7675
Winner Winner
captainrex7675
Winner, winner, good call
Rose by Any other Name
Option 1 and 3 are out – her fist is already balled in panel 4. This was a premeditated punch, not spontaneous.
Plus that look – I’m guessing there’s some preexisting beef here. Possibly to do with Alice, possibly not.
Devin
1 isn’t out based on that timing. He first started grabbing significant attention in Panel 2, which leaves stolen attention very much on the table.
I’d also like to add that I’m guessing she’s a li’l drunk right now, lowering the work any reason would have to do to get the fist in motion.
TerribleTransit
No boozles around her head, which makes being drunk unlikely (though not impossible)
Devin
That’s a good point. I was going on the flushed cheeks, but I forgot about the boozies.
Needfuldoer
We all know Beef exists, but he’s presumably at IU already at this point.
Aura
Can we add the white tux? 😛
BarerMender
Can we add “Football rules”? I already strongly dislike him.
Mark
Yeah, in Indiana? Basketball or nothing!
Shadowsnail
The only football that’s allowed to rule is San Dimas High School football.
Axel
(slightly) more charitable options
6. he grabbed her ass
7. taking the opportunity to publicly humiliate him for cheating on Alice or something (terrible idea and timing but that’s who she is)
Rose by Any other Name
Given his hand position in panel 6, your option number 6 might be spot on.
Axel
idk if it fits the previous panel where she balls her fist, but on the other hand, if we combine 6 and 7, she could have known it was coming and been waiting for him to try something
Axel
(and that’s a real ‘idk’, I can’t tell from their position/the angle)
Rose by Any other Name
Right now, given only this, I feel like your ass grab theory is the best one based on the evidence.
MINE was based on her expression, and my mind went some much darker places. So I’m kinda hoping it’s only a sleezy assgrab and not something way more fucky.
Axel
yeah I had similar thoughts (as did my partner), but Alice’s attitude threw me off. my brain got stuck on the Heathers quote; “Football season is over, Veronica. Kurt and Ram had nothing left to offer the school except date rapes and AIDS jokes.”
Axel
more charitable to Billie than “he was stealing her attention” or “felt like punching” I mean
HueSatLight
8. There’s a scorpion on his abdomen, she’s saving him.
BarerMender
The position of his hand is suggestive, but Billie is looking the wrong way. It isn’t him she’s mad at.
JBento
It’s not an assgrab, or at least, not here. He has the hand on her side raised in panel 2, and in panel 4 he’s substantially AHEAD of her.
Arianod
Panel 2, his right arm is raised. Panel 4 shows he’s one or two steps ahead of Billie, an ass grab would be incredibly awkward and impossible to hide from everyone. I think we can rule it out.
Laura
Well it looks from flashbacks like Billie and Alice had a past sexual relationship that ended with Billie’s car crash at prom. So straight-up jealousy, could be.
Billie also previously mentioned that the head cheerleader’s job was to help take teammates for secret abortions when necessary. So maybe Alice was quicker to forgive Chester than Billie was.
NGPZ
oh god I forgot that, Jennifer literally said she “sneaked friends into abortion clinics” ?
Bryy
WELP.
Adept
That fits. I think she loathes him for a reason.
thejeff
But this is a weird time and place to act on something like that, since she would have known it all along.
Unless it was the ass grab suggested above, the only possibly new piece of info would be Alice calling him her boyfriend.
Yumi
I don’t think it has to be “new” information– it could be that information combined with anger at seeing him be celebrated like this. That could go for if he had done something bad before or she was jealous of his official status with Alice. Emotions are heightened overall, she hates the guy under normal circumstances, now here he is getting his name cheered along with hers? Yeah, I can see Billie snapping a bit.
Michael Steamweed
Plus she’s been drinking.
thejeff
I mean, this is Billie, so it’s likely, but Billie’s also good at handling her booze. There are no real signs she’s drunk now. We know she will be later for the DUI, but it’s early yet. That could even follow an after-prom party.
Callid13
I think #2 is correct, though likely a lot more than a “subconscious crush”. Others have already pointed out that in panel #8 in https://www.dumbingofage.com/2022/comic/book-12/04-dont-stop-billie-ving/billie/, Alice seems to be touching Billie’s naked shoulder.
Even more telling is IMO the scene when Alice first showed up, Billie was quite focused on re-establishing contact to her, and Alice rebuked her. In particular, the wording Alice used here https://www.dumbingofage.com/2014/comic/book-4/04-the-whiteboard-dong-bandit/dramahurricane/ – “For the longest time, I thought I loved you”. It could be platonic, sure, but in retrospect, I suspect it was indeed romantic.
thejeff
And in that same strip Walky says being a drama hurricane can be sexually transmitted, making it pretty clear they had a sexual relationship.
My long term theory was that Jennifer didn’t acknowledge a romantic relationship with Alice in her “straight but has sex with girls sometimes like everyone does” stage. They basically had one, especially on Alice’s part, but not officially, and both dated boys (or just had drunken sex at parties) because that fit the popular cheerleader image.
We’ll see how that holds up. 🙂
anon
well i didn’t expect that, but yeah unless she was secretly/unconsciously crushing on alice (in the strip with her saying ‘i loved you but you’re a danger to yourself/others’ or so), i would’ve also expected him to either secretly be a scumbag or alice shit talking him the same way you would with when you’er annoyed with a partner but maybe exaggerated some things?
Bajja
He sexually assaulted someone is my guess. We never really have seen why Billy said in the beginning of the comic a million years ago that she went after bad men and protected other girls. I think we are about to humanize Billy.
Yumi
Jealousy, maybe. Or that’s really an eldritch creature that has temporarily taken on the appearance of Chester Phillips, and Jennifer clocked it instantly.
Clif
I’m not completely discounting your theory, but for now I’m assuming she had sex with him in recent days and just now found out he was cheating on Alice with her.
Dana
She’s just bad at following instructions.
Queen Anthai
Maybe Chester did something shitty and she just took the opportunity? Who knows. We’ll probably find out soon enough.
Frelance
she maybe knows about him not being a fine upstanding citizen, in the contexts that she developed her addiction
segnosaur
She thought he was infected with one of those parasites from the movie Alien, and wanted to punch it before it burst out of his stomach and started attacking people.
Mark
She very consciously developed a thing for Chester and made a play for him, but he refused her (perhaps rather cruelly). Maybe she thinks Alice knows about this and is feeling publically humiliated.
But I’m usually wrong….
Furie
Can’t swear to it as I can’t see the future, but that right there? That’s the punch of a girl who knows something about a guy and can’t hold it in any longer.
So my call is the idea of her leaving him unused is a joke that ties into rumours about her, which themselves were spread by him and his team because she turned him down when he came to her behind his girlfriend’s back.
GUIGUI
She probably know he cheated on his girlfriend. Maybe with her. while telling her he didn’t have a girlfriend.
Charles Phipps
Jennifer is an improvement over Billie in every possible way but I will miss these sudden displays of violence.
aeromechanicalace
You’re going to have to elaborate on what makes Jennifer better. From my perspective, she’s been pretty much constantly awful.
DailyBrad
She’s sober, and that’s good, but she’s also so emotionally constipated in a way that’s rapidly breaking down, she’s passive aggressive as fuck, and she’s keeping really toxic company. Yes, more toxic than Billie/Jennifer on her worst days.
Charles Phipps
Raidah is an ass but I think people overstate things. After all, she didn’t send someone to break up her relationship like Sarah did. Sadly, she needed to get away from her past to recover as she whatever Walky’s personal merits, he brought about the worst in her.
Decidedly Orthogonal
Yeah naw bruh. Unless we get a more directly linking explantion, then laying her behaviour at Walky’s feet is a WWII scale bridge too far.
Charles Phipps
I’m not saying it’s Walky’s fault. I’m saying that Billy’s issues get triggered by them and whatever behavior she’s trying to get past. We don’t know why in-universe. He is seemingly blameless of anything in their relationship.
Sirksome
I understand what you meant. For whatever reason when it comes to Jennifer people choose to see her in the worst light. You’re not saying Walky is at fault just that interacting with him upsets Jen and she needed space from that. I was saying the same when they had that group date. For whatever reason people don’t like hearing that because Walky cares about Jennifer. But he annoys her, sometimes even on purpose. It’s not on Jen to just tolerate that. But everyone interprets her needing space from him as her shunning him and by extension the rest of her friends even though she still spends time with everyone pretty regularly.
Jeremiah
I think the issue might be that you stubbornly refuses to see all the ways on which Jennifer has demonstrably gotten worse. Also making some kind of distinction between “Billie” and “Jennifer” doesn’t really work because again, they are not different people, they are the same trying pretend otherwise.
Sirksome
@Jeremiah. I’m not trying to argue. You don’t like Jennifer, a lot of readers don’t. That’s fine. I don’t want to change anyone’s mind or ruin their interpretation of the comic. I just like to converse about it and offer my own perspective and interpretation.
I also don’t designate between “Jennifer” and “Billie” I just choose to respect the name the admittedly fictional character chooses to be called.
https://www.dumbingofage.com/2020/comic/book-11/02-look-straight-ahead/soundlike/
Like I would never intentionally dead name Jocelyne or call Booster by the pronouns they don’t like. It doesn’t really mean anything because they’re not real. I just find it good practice.
Jeremiah
And I don’t dislike Jennifer, she is actually one of my favorites characters specifically because of all the things about her I mentioned, because it make her interesting, which is why it annoys me when those things get dismissed. And also when I redder to the name thing I don’t mean the act of calling her what she wants to be called, I mean acting like the two names actually represent a change in personality and she should “ho back” to being Billie, when she is already that. Also, also I think considering how we been told and seen how she treats Walky I think she can actually take being annoyed by him occasionally.
Yumi
Oh, you’re not going to get an elaboration that makes sense.
Charles Phipps
Jennifer isn’t engaged in domestic violence, not part of a suicide pact, not drinking alcohol (I may be biased here because I’ve had close relatives die of alcoholism related incidents), and was seemingly happy until she tried to create some fun drama that destroyed her relationship with Asher.
Thag Simmons
That she self-destructed her relationship with Asher for petty reasons is maybe a sign that she wasn’t actually doing better
Charles Phipps
I mean, compared to the nonstop violence and insults of her previous relationships?
Thag Simmons
Considering that the relationship disintegrated in part because Jennifer missed the violence and insults, yeah, I don’t think it’s a sign that she had actually fixed the underlying problems
Jeremiah
They actually didn’t engaged in much violence after they started their relationship? Like at all. They did insult each other but like, not with any actual bite or malice.
thejeff
They did fight. At first to keep up the pretense for the rest of the floor, but also because it turned them on.
jmsr7
I’m not sure she actually knows her relationship with Asher is over.
Charles Phipps
I mean she didn’t want to break up with him. She was trying to drive him to do something romantic.
Sadly, negging only works if you’re a scummy pick up artist or Bugs Bunny.
Bryy
I’m pretty sure she thinks it is over in the context that it’s “over”.